Another Vaccination Scare?

Ivor the Engineer

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Feb 18, 2006
Messages
11,103
This on MSN UK homepage today:

...And now another doctor, Dr Richard Halvorsen, raises his concerns - warning that the Government "misleads us about vaccines". Author of a new book, The Truth About Vaccines, he claims that UK children are being used as "guinea pigs" and given "unnecessary" jabs for illnesses such as mumps, and a vaccine for whooping cough which has been "ineffective" in stamping out the illness.

Halvorsen is a GP who's spent five years researching vaccination and he says: "Vaccine programmes are not the magic bullet cure that they are claimed to be, and bombarding children with a cocktail of vaccines could be causing some serious health problems, with hundreds if not thousands of children adversely affected every year."

Comments?
 
I was baffled by his statements about the HPV vaccine, first of all.

In trials it has only prevented the pre-cancerous changes to cells rather than cancer itself, and it only protects against the two types of HPV that cause 70% of this cancer...


That first part is particularly odd. Is he suggesting that preventing pre-cancerous changes has no impact on preventing cancer?

Also, he seems to try to suggest that the vaccine isn't terribly effective. Yes, the vaccine protects against two types of HPV that cause 70% of cancers of the cervix, vagina, and vulva, but it also protects against two other types that cause 90% of genital warts. At the end of the day, I think that that's pretty darned good.

...HIS VERDICT: Some women in trials of the vaccine developed potential auto-immune disorders - mainly arthritis-related. This vaccine looks promising but it is too early to introduce it on a national scale.


And? Some women outside of trials develop auto-immune disorders. This offers no information about whether the rate among vaccinated females was any different from non-vaccinated females. I have seen no indication that that's the case.

I have other thoughts, but these were among my first.
 
I'd say pretty much all the comment this deserves is contained in the quoted snippet:

"Author of a new book, The Truth About Vaccines..."
 
Why would a vaccine against mumps be unnecessary?
Facts about mumps:

Cases: 200,000 per year before vaccine became available, currently 3,000-5,000 per year
gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Encephalitis: 2 in 100,000[/FONT]
gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Testicular swelling: 1 in 5 adults[/FONT]
gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Deafness: 1 in 20,000[/FONT]

gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Death: 1 in 3,000 to 1 in 10,000[/FONT]
http://www.metrokc.gov/health/immunization/compare.htm

The whooping cough vaccine is around to save the lives of those too young to tolerate it (prevents them from dying because of whooping cough), and it's not meant to stamp pertussis/whooping cough out.
Facts about Pertussis/Whooping Cough:
(Whooping Cough): Prior to vaccine, 200,000 cases and 8,000 deaths per year in U.S. Over 400 confirmed cases in King County, WA in 1999. 69% of all U.S cases less than 5 years old, and almost half of these were younger than 12 months old.
gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Pneumonia: 1 in 8[/FONT]
gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Convulsions/seizures: 1 in 100[/FONT]
gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Death: 1 in 500[/FONT]

The usual lies about diseases being supposedly benign and strawmen as to a vaccine's purpose.

What the article does not tell you is that Dr Richard Halvorsen is a supplier of single vaccines at a private clinic, and that his publications seem to consist solely of articles in the Daily Express and Daily Mail. A literature search reveals no peer-reviewed papers on the subject of vaccines or vaccine safety. If you find any, please feel free to contact me and enlighten me on his expertise.
http://www.blacktriangle.org/blog/?p=1383
Yeah, scare parents into buying YOUR product. Uh huh. That's real ethical :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Here is my email to the columnist.

[email protected]

Ms Fagan,

Why is it that any crackpot with a credential is considered credible by reporters such as yourself? The information in your column from July 31, 07, The Truth About Vaccinations, couldn't be further from the truth. Yet once again, we have some supposed "expert" ranting the anti-vaccination crowd rhetoric. Despite how many times the information vomited out by this group of quacks has been discredited, all it takes is another book, or another person with an ax to grind and here we go again.

There is no controversy about childhood vaccines. There is science, and there are people who fail to convince their peers by valid scientific research so they appeal to the public who are more easily hoodwinked. The myth the scientific community isn't open to any and all valid research leads people like yourself to buy this line of garbage.

Do you believe scientists with valid concerns about childhood vaccinations are simply brushed off by a stodgy medical community making it necessary for appeals directly to the public? Or did you somehow think you were getting a variety of opinions from a medical community undecided about the benefits of childhood vaccinations? How many times does the medical community have to debunk this nonsense?

And in the meantime, yet another parent is misled into forgoing their child's vaccinations putting their child at grave risk. Why? Because yet another reporter or columnist thinks letting crackpots have a public forum for their nonsense is somehow covering "the controversy".


I'm not in the mood to sign up and post it. Maybe I will later.
 
There is science, and there are people who fail to convince their peers by valid scientific research so they appeal to the public who are more easily hoodwinked.

I would think you may want to write something like: "There is science that convinces peers, and then there are people who fail to convince their peers (because they don't actually have any valid scientific research), so they appeal to the public who are more easily hoodwinked instead."

Just to clarify that these idiots like Halvorsen are full of sheeeet.
 
To those with more vaccine-specific knowledge than I:

Is there any merit to his criticisms of the lack of information regarding the safety of the COMBINED vaccines and the way that even separate vaccines for different things may interact?

I know that medications, vaccines, etc. are studied individually for safety and efficacy, but, vaccines have been added over time, and kids are getting a large number over a relatively short period of time. For example, there is overlap in the timing of the Hep B, DTaP, Hib, inactivated polio, influenza, MMR, and varicella. All are given between 6-18 months. You could add Pneumococcus and Hep A for certain risk groups. Then there is Rotavirus between 2-6 months and Meningococcus at, I guess, two years, too.

When I was a kid, all I got was the polio, DTaP, and MMR over that same period of time. So things have changed a bit.

Are there studies that have examined not just the individual but the combined effects/side effects of these vaccines both in the short- and the long-term?

DON'T GET ME WRONG!
I think that this guy is largely full of BS, and I'm inclined as many of you are to think that they do more good than harm.

It was on this one point that I had some questions and hoped to tap into the wealth of knowledge here on this subject.
 
I'm not an expert on this, but I can't see why the combinations should be a problem. The main reason vaccines are separated is because the different components require different buffers, or antibacterial precautions, that kind of thing. Oh, and of course they may be separated because they're best given at different times.

One of the great advances in vaccine technology has been the introduction of subunit vaccines, so that instead of a cocktail of the entire inactivated pathogen, the patient is given only the purified antigens which stimulate the most effective immune responses. As a result, although the number of diseases protected against is always going up, the number of actual antigens injected has actually come down.

Nowadays, a dose of one of the combined vaccines contains fewer antigens than a single bacterium a child would be exposed to in the "wild state", say a Streptococcus. And of course children are being exposed to these organisms all the time.

The immune system is being presented with a myriad antigens every day, and deciding what to do with them. By far the biggest job it has is deciding when "do nothing" is the appropriate response. (That is porobaly the next field of advance - find out how to educate the immune system more cleverly so that it's better at not reacting to things it shouldn't react to.)

Handling the relatively small number of antigens in even the most complex multivalent vaccine is all in a day's work.

Rolfe.
 
We should all bombard her with emails.
I think I may fire a salvo. However, I had a tangle with my local NPR station broadcasting anti-vax stuff from a chiropractor. The station manager said they gave equal time to a public health official. so they were clear. They consider themselves conduits of information, not evaluators of said info. After a little more discussion, I gave up.

The station manager (not the guy I talked to) often notes that when providing a contrasting opinion, a reporter can insert bias by selecting a poor spokesman for the opposition.
 
To those with more vaccine-specific knowledge than I:

Is there any merit to his criticisms of the lack of information regarding the safety of the COMBINED vaccines and the way that even separate vaccines for different things may interact?

Looked into this a lot when I first had kids. There is some, disputed and by no means conclusive evidence, that combination vaccines (and vaccinating too early in life*) may not be the safest or most efficient (in terms of preventing disease) way of vaccinating. Australia seemed to lead in this type of research for some reason. There is a significant (though admittedly small in percentage terms) subset of Doctors that question the current accepted wisdom on vaccination - they don't claim it as all bad, just that the medical fraternity has got a bit carried away with it all and that for some childhood illnesses that are relatively harmless (in the developed world) it's a bit over the top to routinely vaccinate (chicken pox, mumps etc - measles is a bit more borderline).

I honestly can't remember all the theories, arguments, science and anyway, each parent should do their own research and make up their own minds. Muddying the waters in the UK is that Doctors are actually paid more if they get more kids vaccinated which could be construed as a conflict of interest. Unfortunately we have also had cases of predictions of measles epidemics co-inciding with batches of vaccine getting close to their use by date which also gets the conspiracy theorists going.

As with all these things, the nutters in any particular corner get more of the attention which detracts from the reasonable argument.

*I believe there have been outbreaks of measles amongst college kids in America who had all been vaccinated as babies and part of the argument is that as they were vaccinated whilst their immune system was still developing, it did not confer the liefe-long protection promised.

Apologies that this is all anecdotal and based on 12 year old memories. I won't say what decision we reached for our own children because I really think everyone should make up their own mind. I will say it was one of the toughest decisions I've ever had to make as it was one that affected my kids not me.
 
Skeptigirl; your email raised a "huzzah!" from me; stirring stuff. If it was only the people that bought this BS being affected by it, you could put it down to a function of natural selection; people that deny themselves effective treatments are asking for it. But this affects people who aren't in a position to decide - very young children. I know you can't really equate it with child abuse, but the media + quacks = degraded public health, and I think that's terrible.
 
Factual sources will let you know that the vaccines that are actual combinations are no less effective or less safe than individual. These people making them are NOT STUPID or morons, they actually do know what they are doing.

http://www.vaccinesafety.edu/Testimony-O99.htm

Questions have been raised about the benefits and problems associated with administering several vaccines at the same time or combining vaccines in the same syringe. There are factors that can limit the ability to combine vaccines and there are theoretical concerns that have been reviewed in detail in a workshop sponsored by the FDA, the National Vaccine Program Office, CDC and NIH2. These factors are taken into account in the FDA review of combination products. Numerous studies have been conducted to evaluate the safety and effectiveness of vaccines administered simultaneously or in the same syringe.
Several efforts to produce new combined vaccines have not been successful, but those vaccines that have been approved by the FDA have been carefully evaluated and found to be safe and effective. Experts serving on advisory committees for the CDC and the AAP review the data from these studies prior to making recommendations for general use.
Children benefit from combined vaccines because they are protected against several different diseases with a single injection, thereby reducing pain and discomfort from multiple injections. If we did not have combined vaccines, children would need to be brought to physician's offices or clinics far more often, perhaps even weekly during the first few months of life in order to protect them against serious infections. The use of combined vaccines can simplify the immunization process and record keeping for parents, physicians and public health officials.3

To say they are not studied in combination is ridiculous. Of course studies are/were done, and of course they have been used long enough to know as well.

Anyone who subjects children to the single vaccines are the ones putting them through unnecessary extra pain for no good reason.
 
Last edited:
I was asked to comment on three issues: the number of vaccines children receive, combination vaccines and diabetes. I am not concerned about the number of vaccines children receive, and I look forward to the availability of several other vaccines that will help us prevent serious infections and cancer. The human immune system is remarkable in its capacity to respond to millions of different antigens. Children are exposed to many thousands of bacteria, fungi and viruses beginning at the moment of birth. In the first few months of life the human immune system responds to many foreign antigens from these organisms. Each bacterium contains hundreds of different antigens including carbohydrates, fatty substances, proteins, RNA and DNA. Children develop antibodies to 17 different proteins in one common bacterium (Moraxella catarrhalis) and a strep throat infection results in immune responses to 25-50 different antigens.1 Some new highly effective vaccines are made using only one or two bacterial antigens. For example, Haemophilus influenzae type b vaccines, or Hib as they are commonly called, contain only a single bacterial antigen attached to a protein. Children immunized with these vaccines are protected against meningitis and sepsis caused by the Haemophilus influenzae type b organism. Therefore, the immune systems of children who receive this vaccine are exposed to far fewer antigens than children naturally infected with the bacterium. Since all children would be exposed to the bacterium if they were not immunized, the use of the Hib vaccine actually reduces the burden on the immune system.

-Just backs up what Rolfe said at the same link I quoted above.
 
Factual sources will let you know that the vaccines that are actual combinations are no less effective or less safe than individual. These people making them are NOT STUPID or morons, they actually do know what they are doing.

http://www.vaccinesafety.edu/Testimony-O99.htm



To say they are not studied in combination is ridiculous. Of course studies are/were done, and of course they have been used long enough to know as well.


Thanks for the info.

I do hope that you weren't suggesting that anyone here was saying that they were stupid or morons, by the way.
 
I believe you can get a free copy of the 2004 IOM Vaccine Safety Review via this link:
http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=10997

Six Common Misperceptions about vaccination:
http://www.cdc.gov/nip/publications/6mishome.htm
Giving a child multiple vaccinations for different diseases at the same time increases the risk of harmful side effects and can overload the immune system.
Children are exposed to many foreign antigens every day. Eating food introduces new bacteria into the body, and numerous bacteria live in the mouth and nose, exposing the immune system to still more antigens. An upper respiratory viral infection exposes a child to 4 - 10 antigens, and a case of "strep throat" to 25 - 50. According to Adverse Events Associated with Childhood Vaccines, a 1994 report from the Institute of Medicine, "In the face of these normal events, it seems unlikely that the number of separate antigens contained in childhood vaccines . . . would represent an appreciable added burden on the immune system that would be immunosuppressive." And, indeed, available scientific data show that simultaneous vaccination with multiple vaccines has no adverse effect on the normal childhood immune system.
A number of studies have been conducted to examine the effects of giving various combinations of vaccines simultaneously. In fact, neither the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) nor the AmericanAcademy of Pediatrics (AAP) would recommend the simultaneous administration of any vaccines until such studies showed the combinations to be both safe and effective. These studies have shown that the recommended vaccines are as effective in combination as they are individually, and that such combinations carry no greater risk for adverse side effects. Consequently, both the ACIP and AAP recommend simultaneous administration of all routine childhood vaccines when appropriate. Research is under way to find ways to combine more antigens in a single vaccine injection (for example, MMR and chickenpox). This will provide all the advantages of the individual vaccines, but will require fewer shots.
There are two practical factors in favor of giving a child several vaccinations during the same visit. First, we want to immunize children as early as possible to give them protection during the vulnerable early months of their lives. This generally means giving inactivated vaccines beginning at 2 months and live vaccines at 12 months. The various vaccine doses thus tend to fall due at the same time. Second, giving several vaccinations at the same time will mean fewer office visits for vaccinations, which saves parents both time and money and may be less traumatic for the child.
This confirms a post (above).


I just saw this and have not read it yet:
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2007/08/when_antivaccination_pseudoscience_turns.php#more
The author has many posts on the topic.
 
Ever heard a homeopath say "Pain killers don't work" ?

I didn't (Not like I listen to homeopaths, other alternative health guys, or doctors in general)

And there's plenty of alternative / herbal crap that works to relieve pain. I mean, even acupuncture kinda works (you poke someone with needles 'till he shuts up about whatever other pain he had)

Yes, pain killers aren't healthy. I mean, heroin's a popular pain killer. Homoepaths and other woo's are in sync with doctors when they say that taking pain killers all the time isn't healthy.

Why would anyone attack something that works? What's the motive?

Isn't vaccination basically the same idea as homeopathy (giving someone a minute/inert dose of something that would make him sick to cure/immunize him)

And just like homeopathy it had one success on its track record (chickenpox to immunize vs smallpox) which was then used to generalize an entire idea of treatment? (Except that you sell vaccination to healthy people, especially infants that are too young to refuse)

Why would the alternative health scene attack vaccinations, if they actually were safe and worked?
 
Last edited:
...
Isn't vaccination basically the same idea as homeopathy (giving someone a minute/inert dose of something that would make him sick to cure/immunize him)
...

Absolutely not. First of all, homeopathy uses dilutions that are chemically and physically impossible to contain even a molecule of the stated "substance". Some that is 30C would have one molecule of the substance contained in all the water not just of the oceans on this planet, but several other planets full of water.

Second of all... the very first vaccine was essentially the virus of a different disease, cow pox, which provided immunity for smallpox. This was not diluted in any sense.

Other vaccines are the actual pathogens that have been weakened through various processes. More modern vaccines are actually various parts of the proteins derived from the pathogen that help activate the immune system. The point is that vaccines actually contain measurable doses of active ingredients.

Some selected history reading on the subject:
Vaccine by Arthur Allen
Vaccinated by Paul Offit

The latter is a biography of Maurice Hilleman... the man responsible for the MMR that is part of the controversy. It also includes extensive background into basic vaccine development history (like certain animal tissues are not good for pathogen growth, etc). That MMR was approved for use in the USA in 1971, and only started to be used in the UK in 1988. Most Americans under the age of 37 have had at least one dose of that MMR.

If you don't have time to get to the library for either of those books (and they are both very good reads, I even had to keep reading the biography one on the bus even though I am prone to motion sickness while reading in moving vehicles!).... then try reading the chapters in the Pink Book. It includes chapters on the principles of vaccination, vaccine safety and descriptions of each disease, including the history of the disease, the risks of both the disease and vaccine... plus a description of the vaccine (like the fact the "MMR and MMRV are supplied as a lyophylized (freeze-dried) powder and are reconstituted with sterile, preservative-free water. The vaccines contain a small amount of human albumin, neomycin, sorbitol, and gelatin." (quoted from the Measles chapter, page 10)
 
By the way, it's cowpox that's given to immunize against smallpox.

As to vaccine interaction, if there were any common problems, I'd be dead. Being in the militayr, with frequent overseas travel and in the medical field, I had many, many vaccinations. Somehow, the Army seemed excessively adept at losing my medical records. At least three seperate times, I've recieved close to a dozen vaccines in one day. These have included Yellow Fever, Thyphus, Diptheria, Tetanus, Polio, Smallpox, Anthrax, Measles, Mumps, Rubella, TB Tine test, Hepatitis A, Hepatitis B, IG, Influenza, and Plague.

So far, *twitch* I've had *twitch* no problems at *twitch* all *twitch twitch*

:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom