Another Vaccination Scare?

I'm not asking to outlaw medical consulting and treatment. I'm asking to train people in the schools on the subject of medicine.

Well, in the current climate of Pharmaceutical Marketing (count the hits) where ordinary, normal, harmless and natural conditions and variations are advertised as being dangerous diseases and syndroms that need to be treated, it does have its dangers. But the problem certainly isn't that doctors would be helpful in keeping this in check, they are the #1 target of pharmaceutical marketing anyways, and more billions are spent for direct end consumer marketing, trying to induce hypochondry while inventing new diseases.
 
I'm not asking to outlaw medical consulting and treatment. I'm asking to train people in the schools on the subject of medicine.

Well, in the current climate of Pharmaceutical Marketing (count the hits) where ordinary, normal, harmless and natural conditions and variations are advertised as being dangerous diseases and syndroms that need to be treated, it does have its dangers. But the problem certainly isn't that doctors would be helpful in keeping this in check, they are the #1 target of pharmaceutical marketing anyways, and more billions are spent for direct end consumer marketing, trying to induce hypochondry while inventing new diseases.

But opening up the gates to let people self-diagnose and order whatever meds they think they need would make that worse, not better.

Can you imagine if Merck was allowed to not only direct-to-consumer advertise, but also sell something like morphine???

I can see the commercial now:

Are you sad?
:( :( :( :(

Sometimes feel anxious?
:eek: :eek: :eek: :eek:

Angry?
:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

You might have Opioid Uptake Disorder, a serious condition that affects one in five Americans. Fortunately, it's treatable.

:) :) :) :) :)

Call 1-800-OPIOIDS for a free information booklet and sample of Opitrex.
 
I'm asking to train people in the schools on the subject of medicine.

We do. We call the people who have trained "doctors" (and nurses and various other things of course). Since it takes the best part of six years to get even a basic working knowledge of things, it's not all that practical to teach everyone.
 
We do. We call the people who have trained "doctors" (and nurses and various other things of course). Since it takes the best part of six years to get even a basic working knowledge of things, it's not all that practical to teach everyone.

Perhaps your idea of "basic" and mine are different? Many old-style medical courses teach the basics (i.e. anatomy, physiology, etc.) in 2 years full-time study at the start of the course.

There is nothing stopping anyone learning about medicine except their level of enthusiasm for the subject and ability to understand the information and concepts involved. Obviously, learning to "do" the clinical and surgical aspects of medicine requires lots of practical experience and tuition.

Perhaps if children were taught about how their bodies and medicine worked more of them would treat them better when they were older and be less easily persuaded by quacks?
 
in the current climate of Pharmaceutical Marketing (count the hits) where ordinary, normal, harmless and natural conditions and variations are advertised as being dangerous diseases and syndroms that need to be treated, it does have its dangers. But the problem certainly isn't that doctors would be helpful in keeping this in check, they are the #1 target of pharmaceutical marketing anyways, and more billions are spent for direct end consumer marketing, trying to induce hypochondry while inventing new diseases.

As opposed to SCAM marketing? For example, look at how those flogging 'colon therapy' products and procedures redefine a whole range of normal habits as pathological...
 
As opposed to SCAM marketing? For example, look at how those flogging 'colon therapy' products and procedures redefine a whole range of normal habits as pathological...

Oh Noes!!!1!!1!!
Therez poopz in ur colonz!
 
Perhaps your idea of "basic" and mine are different? Many old-style medical courses teach the basics (i.e. anatomy, physiology, etc.) in 2 years full-time study at the start of the course.

I meant "basic" in the sense that I certainly wouldn't want a newly hatched junior doctor let loose on the world with no supervision. Even after all the time spent in medical school (and I am not even counting the time in school before that), doctors still need years of experience on the job, and are still learning by the time they retire. We're not just talking about knowing a bit about anatomy, Dabljuh wants us to teach everyone how to diagnose and treat all illness.

Perhaps if children were taught about how their bodies and medicine worked more of them would treat them better when they were older and be less easily persuaded by quacks?

But what lessons will we replace? There is only so much time available for education, and it's generally quite full. I'm all for teaching people as much as possible, but there is a big difference between teaching them enough to recognise quackery and teaching them enough to be able to act as doctors.
 
I meant "basic" in the sense that I certainly wouldn't want a newly hatched junior doctor let loose on the world with no supervision. Even after all the time spent in medical school (and I am not even counting the time in school before that), doctors still need years of experience on the job, and are still learning by the time they retire. We're not just talking about knowing a bit about anatomy, Dabljuh wants us to teach everyone how to diagnose and treat all illness.

Ok, I misunderstood what you meant by "basic".

But what lessons will we replace? There is only so much time available for education, and it's generally quite full. I'm all for teaching people as much as possible, but there is a big difference between teaching them enough to recognise quackery and teaching them enough to be able to act as doctors.

Geography:D
 
You're getting them mixed up there. The Salk vaccine was the killed vaccine. When it was really dead, it was perfectly safe. (initially...enhancement effects aside).

It was the Sabin vaccine that eliminated polio, though.

I did not know that. I grew up knowing that Salk was the one who rid the world of Polio, the great scourge of mankind. Everybody knew it. Now you are pointing out that this is something I was taught that is not true.
 
But opening up the gates to let people self-diagnose and order whatever meds they think they need would make that worse, not better.

Can you imagine if Merck was allowed to not only direct-to-consumer advertise, but also sell something like morphine???
You prefer the mafia to sell the stuff? Well I prefer sicilians doing it over doctors, but those sicilians don't pay taxes.
I can see the commercial now:

Are you sad?
:( :( :( :(

Sometimes feel anxious?
:eek: :eek: :eek: :eek:

Angry?
:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

You might have Opioid Uptake Disorder, a serious condition that affects one in five Americans. Fortunately, it's treatable.

:) :) :) :) :)

Call 1-800-OPIOIDS for a free information booklet and sample of Opitrex.
You gotta be kidding me. That's exactly the way it works right now, except that you're asked to go to your doctor instead of receiving a free sample. Who himself is going to be subject to even more and individualized PR. Remember the "Hey if you have erectile dysfunction, you should probably talk to your doctor" ads? Read any end-consumer zine for females lately and noted the calls to have yourself checked for depressions, chronic fatigue syndrome and other stuff? Of course not only the school medicine is doing this, but also lots of the alternative medicine industry. But the later one simply doesn't have nearly as much money for marketing.

Dabljuh wants us to teach everyone how to diagnose and treat all illness.
Wrong. I want everyone to be able to diagnose and treat THEIR OWN illnesses. Because most people don't really have to know about the 40'000 or so conditions that supposedly afflict the human race. Right now, PR is driving the masses to become hypochondriacs, which is easy as they are depending on doctors and the pharmaceutical industry. Having people self-diagnose may or may not alleviate the problem of Disease Mongering as medical literacy and confidence increases, but in any case it'd help to reduce health costs.

Why? Because you can teach people what's normal and doesn't need treatment.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

Wrong. I want everyone to be able to diagnose and treat THEIR OWN illnesses. Because most people don't really have to know about the 40'000 or so conditions that supposedly afflict the human race. Right now, PR is driving the masses to become hypochondriacs, which is easy as they are depending on doctors and the pharmaceutical industry. Having people self-diagnose may or may not alleviate the problem of Disease Mongering as medical literacy and confidence increases, but in any case it'd help to reduce health costs.

Why? Because you can teach people what's normal and doesn't need treatment.

But you'd have to teach them about all 40,000 because you don't know which one any individual is going to get:confused:
 
And the vast majority of medical problems are not chronic, long-term conditions. They come and go. How are they going to decide if they have a bacterial infection or a viral infection when they get the sniffles? Mis-use of anti-biotics is a problem now, and that's with trained people giving out specific instructions on how they're to be used. People get new illnesses, and these are generally the ones they go to the doctor for. My father, for example, has had diabetes for years. After the initial bit when they found it, he has no further need for diagnosis. Your statements are nonsensical on the face of it:

Duhbljuh: We need to teach people to self-diagnos! Most people know their medical problems already, they don't need a doctor!

Diagnose: to determine the identity of (a disease, illness, etc.) by a medical examination: The doctor diagnosed the illness as influenza.

Translation of Duh's statement:

We need to teach people how to determine the identity of a disease they have for themselves! Most people already know the identity of the disease they have!

Not to mentiuon that your model completely ignores continuing education. Medicine today is a different animal than it was even 10 years ago. New findings, new treatments, more effective measures with fewer side effects...you expect each person to keep up (accurately) with all of this info?

And I'm sorry, but the VAST MAJORITY of the hypocondriac type of people are self-diagnosers. And again, the majority of these are not because of advertisements, but because of google-fu. They read webmd or wrongdiagnosis anbd start thinking they know more than their doctor (and ignore the fact that the doctor has not only the symptoms, but blood tests, cultures, X-rays, and other information).

No, your idea would result in a huge increase in mis-diagnosis, including infectious diseases that would put the rest of the sane people at risk. You'd lower the standard of care to almost nothing, either increase school time or remove the teaching of other useful subjects (maybe science, so few seem to understand that anyway, Duh included), and end up with a lot more dead, crippled, and ill people...and likely with more anti-biotic resistent bacterial strains. As well as losing a major indicator of possible epidemics or geograhpically, economically, or culturally isolated medical problems.

This was, essentially, the standard used a couple hundred years ago...when doctors were self-taught as much as anything. Yeah, let's go back to those kinds of life-expectancies, please.
 
Having people self-diagnose may or may not alleviate the problem of Disease Mongering as medical literacy and confidence increases, but in any case it'd help to reduce health costs.

Why? Because you can teach people what's normal and doesn't need treatment.

That is actually a good point. Most people actually do practice self diagnosis once they are free of the Parents influence. You have to be able to tell enough about your body to know when to go to a Doctor, or an Emergency room. The lack of knowledge about skin cancer right now, leads to thousands of deaths a year, because people can't tell what should be looked at by a specialist, or at least tested. I almost lost a friend a few years ago, because nobody knew the basics of what skin cancer looks like! Insanity.

You get a thousand commercials for drugs, but none show you what skin cancer looks like.
 
W said:
You gotta be kidding me. That's exactly the way it works right now, except that you're asked to go to your doctor instead of receiving a free sample.
Right...and it's the physicians who are having to act as barriers to people being medicated for illnesses thay don't even have.
 
That is actually a good point. Most people actually do practice self diagnosis once they are free of the Parents influence. You have to be able to tell enough about your body to know when to go to a Doctor, or an Emergency room. The lack of knowledge about skin cancer right now, leads to thousands of deaths a year, because people can't tell what should be looked at by a specialist, or at least tested. I almost lost a friend a few years ago, because nobody knew the basics of what skin cancer looks like! Insanity.

You get a thousand commercials for drugs, but none show you what skin cancer looks like.

This I agree with, but I don't believe this is what Dabljuh is talking about. This is not self-diagnosing, but basic triage. Doctors would refer to this as "patient education", and there's usually dozens of flyers and pamphlets in the waiting room, as well as postors, those little plastic anatomy models, and other things for you to read, look at, and/or take home. Most doctors would love to see patients take this advice, so they don't spend time in office hours (which are typically already stuffed full) with patients who need nothing more than a couple aspirin and a good night's sleep.

I do agree there aren't many comercials for this, but that's frankly because we're a capitolist country. There are public health commercials to raise awareness of some diseases, and numerous non-profit organizations who have education as a major goal. But the drug companies are there to sell drugs. Just because they're motivated by profit doesn't necessarily make it a bad thing; there's pluses and minuses to every option. I agree we should have more education, btu the question will be who should pay for it? And that, I think, is where we would differ. No one forces you to watch drug commercials. No one cuts your Internet connection or revokes your library card because you want to do research on particulat conditions or something similar. And skin cancer, in particular, has recieved a lot of publicity in the not-too-distant past. Not to mention every doctors office I've ever been in having one of those posters with the pictures of wierd-looking moles :). Even if you don't know what skin cancer looks like, a strange lesion should be enough to make sometone think "maybe I should look into this a bit" and pop up some sort of research tool. But I would NOT go so far as to allow that person to then schedule surgery and proscribe themselves chemotherapy based on what they found using Google.

There's a balance. Typically, the more information you give a person on a particular condition, the more likely they are to imagine they have it...or to notice what might be unrelated symptoims just because they are similar to the ones taught (even if unrelated). I think we need to teach people enough to know that "this is not normal", but it takes a LOT more than that to determine "I need ampicillan 25mg QID for ten days to clear this up".
 
Typically, the more information you give a person on a particular condition, the more likely they are to imagine they have it...or to notice what might be unrelated symptoms just because they are similar to the ones taught (even if unrelated).

I don't get this at all. Is there any evidence at all to support the theory/claim that explaining health issues, symptoms, conditions, that explaining them, educating people, leads to MORE problems, rather than less? Taking a basic first aid course, a CPR class, or reading a book on simple medicine and medical procedures, seems to reduce the ignorance and fear about stuff.

Many years ago, when I used to spend time in the wilderness, way before cell phones and such, "Being your own Wilderness Doctor" was a must have, because of the chance of having to actually be your own Doctor when days away from any help. It never led my humble self to imagine I had any of the medical problems, and saved me a lot of suffering several times.

A working knowledge of common health issues, and emergency treatment for the serious ones, is just common sense. And does save time and money.

A good example is a stingray injury. If you are hours out on a boat and get stung, it is vital that you know that hot water, as hot as you can stand it without burning the skin, is the treatment that neutralizes the toxin that is causing the extreme pain. Sure you go the ER as soon as you can, but using hot water stops the swelling, pain, and blood poisoning immediately. If you are days away from medical care, such simple information is just common sense to spread.

Same goes for a lot of stuff.

Medical knowledge isn't ultra hard to learn. The posters in the Doctors office, as well as the pamphlets and stuff, are about education. It's a concept.
 
{snip} Medical knowledge isn't ultra hard to learn. {snip}
Sure- if you see someone collapse, you know to get a doctor. That is easy to learn.

Your example of wilderness emergencies is a tiny subset of medicine. If someone suddenly becomes incapacitated by heart attack, appendicitis, brain tumor, or whatever; you don't need to diagnose it because you can't do anything about it beyond getting that person out to medical care. In the woods, you will doubtless not encounter a sudden case of skin cancer, tuberculosis, or multiple sclerosis. If someone develops a sore throat, you won't have to distinguish infection, allergy, or leukemia.

A little knowledge, such as you possess, is a dangerous thing.
 
Sure- if you see someone collapse, you know to get a doctor. That is easy to learn.

Your example of wilderness emergencies is a tiny subset of medicine. If someone suddenly becomes incapacitated by heart attack, appendicitis, brain tumor, or whatever; you don't need to diagnose it because you can't do anything about it beyond getting that person out to medical care. In the woods, you will doubtless not encounter a sudden case of skin cancer, tuberculosis, or multiple sclerosis. If someone develops a sore throat, you won't have to distinguish infection, allergy, or leukemia.

A little knowledge, such as you possess, is a dangerous thing.

Wow! The ego has landed.:D

So you would recommend as few people as possible take a first aid course or know how to perform mouth to mouth?

What robinson said was perfectly sensible and could probably save someone's life. He did not say anything about not getting professional help at the first available opportunity.
 
Last edited:
robinson:

The first aid course is not what I'm talking about, and that's not the issue that dubljuh has brought up.

First aid is a very specific subset dealing with immediate, acute problems that must be dealt with right away.

However, start giving people a list of symptoms for various chronic and hard-to-diagnos conditions. Chronic fatigue syndrome, for example. IBS. A lot of these non-life threatening, chronic conditions. There are a large subset of people that, given access to (as Dabljuh suggests) internet databases to search their symptoms will identify with these types of illnesses. Even things like bronchitis (which can linger for weeks even under antibiotic therapy) will get people believing they have something else when you simply (as Dabljuh suggested, again) will often lead to people believing they have something more serious.

I realize I was not clear...I'm not against teaching emergency techniques and triage techniques...but frankly, these techniques are NOT about diagnosis. They are about treating symptoms. Period. I'm not against teaching treatment.

I am against trying to teach diagnosis to everyone. I think we're violently agreeing, here :)
 
Let me add a simple statement that may help clarify, I'm finding it hard to get everything down into a few sentences and remain clear.

I'm not against teaching first aid, and how to recognize an emergency. That's all good, and can be taught easily and quickly. In fact, when I worked in the medical field, teaching such things was a large part of my job.

That is NOT what Dabljuh has been arguing for, however. He has ben arguing for self-diagnosis and self-prescription. Essentially, no doctors (except, I presume, as somehting akin to contractors).

Teaching someone how to diagnose the large range of possible conditions they might get, and the proper treatmetns for those, and drug interactions and dosages, and all the other bits and pieces is a LOT more than a simpel first aid course. And giving someone the knowledge without teaching (like an internet database, for example) will lead to more of the "hypochondriac" type of thinking.

The teaching, though, is going to be long and expensive. You're essentially talking about giving everyone the equivalent of pre-med and PA school, at least. It's not a feasible option.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom