Another Vaccination Scare?

Gosh darn, what a concept. Or, people could do their own research, and find out for themselves, and I don't have to do your homework for you.

Hmmm.... tough choice there ...

So you're saying you could not find any?

I did in fact do a google search:
http://www.google.com/search?q=dangers+vaccines&hl=en&safe=off&start=10&sa=N
And found only woo sites promoting homeopathy that "said" vaccines are dangerous. No evidence. No study results. Nothing.

The only non-woo thing in the whole 15 pages of results were a few links to a veterinarian study for dogs about potential dangers in using a live virus vaccine over a dead one. That's the closest I could come.

Can you come closer?
 
In Europe, a batch release certificate is issued before a vaccine can be administered to the public. This certificate is issued after further rigorous safety testing has been done in addition to those already performed by the manufacturer. In the UK this testing is done by the National Institute for Biological Standards and Control. Why would governments invest in such places if they were not concerned about vaccine safety and public health?
 
Evidence that vaccines are safe, and effective, should be abundant and easy to obtain. Any substance that is injected into very young children should meet the highest of standards for safety and be tested and retested, and the results available in their entirety.

This is just common sense.

You would expect, a company that manufactures and sells vaccines for children would face huge amounts of legal and medical burden of proof.

Correct? And the onus is completely on the Doctors, researchers and CEOs that are responsible for the vaccines. There is no question that the person or persons insisting you inject or spray something into a newborn must meet the highest level of scrutiny and proof of safety.
 
Evidence that vaccines are safe, and effective, should be abundant and easy to obtain. Any substance that is injected into very young children should meet the highest of standards for safety and be tested and retested, and the results available in their entirety.

This is just common sense.

You would expect, a company that manufactures and sells vaccines for children would face huge amounts of legal and medical burden of proof.

Correct? And the onus is completely on the Doctors, researchers and CEOs that are responsible for the vaccines. There is no question that the person or persons insisting you inject or spray something into a newborn must meet the highest level of scrutiny and proof of safety.

Most of the time that happens now. The only exception I can think of in very recent years is when the ACIP expanded the recommendation for inactivated influeza vaccines to include babies and children without doing any safety or effectiveness studies in that age group first, sans one effectivness study which found that they works "similar to placebo" in them. Then there was a bit of a backlash and a hoohaa over that, so the CDC mass vaccinated a bunch of kids in one city, and then looked for a cluster of kids turning up at the ERs and clinics with reactions, and then called it a "safety study" and declared it "safe".
That's the deal with individual vaccines, at least. Looking at the effects of lots of them being given at once, or over the first year of life is a whole 'nother creature.
 
...so the CDC mass vaccinated a bunch of kids in one city, and then looked for a cluster of kids turning up at the ERs and clinics with reactions, and then called it a "safety study" and declared it "safe".

I know. It is unbelievable that there are no animal studies on vaccines. Or the obvious study where you compare populations that received the full gamut of vaccines, with a population that didn't. Both are obvious science, medical studies that we know how to do, and would put the issue to rest. This entire topic would be stopped, every time it comes up, if there was any evidence to show that current vaccination procedures are safe.

That's the deal with individual vaccines, at least. Looking at the effects of lots of them being given at once, or over the first year of life is a whole 'nother creature.

Yeah, and the creature that worried parents would like to have a look at. Especially when their kid has a lifetime disability, and it starts after the vaccination.
 
robinson said:
I know. It is unbelievable that there are no animal studies on vaccines.
They do some animal studies, but not toxicology.
There's an interesting logic behind that:

http://www.fda.gov/cber/minutes/tox120202.htm

Historically, the non-clinical safety assessment for preventive vaccines has often not included toxicity studies in animal models. This is because vaccines have not been viewed as inherently toxic, and vaccines are generally administered in limited dosages over months or even years
 
They do some animal studies, but not toxicology.

I'm not interested in toxicology really, but the real picture, what actually happens. The obvious solution, as I said many times in many threads, is to do a scientific study.

Giving a bunch of kids vaccines then waiting to see what happens is not good medicine. Nor scientific. In fact, it is horrible science.

What you do, is study people, over a lifetime, and separate them into two groups. The ones that got all the vaccines, and the ones that didn't get any vaccines at all. Then you do all that cool scientific stuff and compare the two groups. From the resistance to this idea, as well as the ignoring of it, you might think somebody doesn't want this to be done.
 
I'm not interested in toxicology really, but the real picture, what actually happens. The obvious solution, as I said many times in many threads, is to do a scientific study.

Giving a bunch of kids vaccines then waiting to see what happens is not good medicine. Nor scientific. In fact, it is horrible science.

What you do, is study people, over a lifetime, and separate them into two groups. The ones that got all the vaccines, and the ones that didn't get any vaccines at all. Then you do all that cool scientific stuff and compare the two groups. From the resistance to this idea, as well as the ignoring of it, you might think somebody doesn't want this to be done.


It's considered unethical to not vaccinate kids, though. So there's no way to get that kind of control group.
 
But you can always look at disease morbidity and mortality before and after vaccine introduction.
 
Last edited:
But you can always look at disease morbidity and mortality before and after vaccine introduction.

That'll usually tell you the effectiveness of the various individual vaccines, but not much about the possible health effects of "the vaccination program" as a whole.
And even when you look for the effectiveness of individual vaccines via mortality, even that's not entirely reliable. Like with flu shots in the elderly, it *looks* like influenza vaccination doesn't decrease influenza mortality at all, but the counter argumant is that maybe it does in reality, but doesn't show up in studies because antibiotic resistance has increased at the same time, skewing the data.
And overall morbidity is even less reliable, because there's a lot more observer bias in there, too.
 
It's considered unethical to not vaccinate kids, though. So there's no way to get that kind of control group.

Nonsense. There are two large populations in the US alone that don't receive vaccines. And remember, most of the world never received the Polio vaccines.

... Like with flu shots in the elderly, it *looks* like influenza vaccination doesn't decrease influenza mortality at all, ....
And overall morbidity is even less reliable, because there's a lot more observer bias in there, too.

Deaths from Influenza each year, in people without any vaccine, are very very small, with most of them occurring in the elderly with other health problems. Flu shots are a scam, always have been.

Nevermind.

OK. I usually do anyway. :wackywink:
 
Deaths from Influenza each year, in people without any vaccine, are very very small, with most of them occurring in the elderly with other health problems. Flu shots are a scam, always have been.



.
Oy, do you ever check statistics? Flu shots save lives. Not only that, the economy benefits when thousands aren't off sick for weeks every year to get healthy again.
Average winter respiratory deaths attributed to influenza in children 1 month–14 years were 22 and to RSV 28; and all cause deaths to influenza 78 and to RSV 79. All cause RSV attributed deaths in infants 1–12 months exceeded those for influenza every year except 1989/90; the average RSV and influenza attributed death rates were 8.4 and 6.7 per 100 000 population respectively. Corresponding rates for children 1–4 years were 0.9 and 0.8 and for older children all rates were 0.2 or less, except for an influenza rate of 0.4 in children 10–14 years.
-for UK http://jech.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/59/7/586

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2007/08/03/1995865.htm -kids die from the flu

Your post also indicates you don't believe in herd immunity to protect infants and ederly people either. Don't you think that is selfish?

Not only that, but supressing the spread of the virus can help keep it from mutating into a strain that will get us an overdue pandemic.
 
Oy, do you ever check statistics? ...

Of course. That is why I made that statement. The CDCs own numbers show that it is a scam. If you read the reports, you can see it for yourself.

Your post also indicates you don't believe in herd immunity to protect infants and ederly[sic] people either. Don't you think that is selfish?
Actually, I do believe in protecting peoples health, it is absurd to suggest I don't. And insulting. There is a foolproof way to prevent Flu, and Flu pandemics. Vaccines are not it.

Not only that, but supressing[sic] the spread of the virus can help keep it from mutating into a strain that will get us an overdue pandemic.

I agree. In fact, stopping the spread of any deadly virus is very important. And we should do just that when we know there is a deadly disease that is contagious. It would also be good to stop all infectious diseases from spreading as well.
 
Of course. That is why I made that statement. The CDCs own numbers show that it is a scam. If you read the reports, you can see it for yourself.

Let me guess, you got CDC stats from Mercola's site again? Please.
Try looking up stats on the WHO too.

Actually, I do believe in protecting peoples health, it is absurd to suggest I don't. And insulting. There is a foolproof way to prevent Flu, and Flu pandemics. Vaccines are not it.

Oh what, stop ingesting milk products or something, as Mercola suggests? I'd LOVE to hear what you figure is a foolproof way to prevent flu.



I agree. In fact, stopping the spread of any deadly virus is very important. And we should do just that when we know there is a deadly disease that is contagious. It would also be good to stop all infectious diseases from spreading as well.

Exactly why we have vaccines in the first place. Sheesh.

CDC stats for a flu season death rate in children:
During October 2, 2005 through June 24, 2006, 41 pediatric deaths have been reported to CDC from 14 states (Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Kansas, Michigan, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, and Wyoming) and New York City. Four of the deaths reported during this time period occurred prior to the 2005-06 influenza season.

You don't think 41 families would prefer that their children be alive?
http://www.cdc.gov/flu/weekly/weeklyarchives2005-2006/05-06summary.htm

That is one country. ONE. Is 41 too small a number for you to not care about?
 
Last edited:
Eos said:
Flu shots save lives. Not only that, the economy benefits when thousands aren't off sick for weeks every year to get healthy again.
Why do you think it's not working in Canada?

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=dff483b52e3bd6e744c44120bdc690e6

The purpose of this study was to determine whether the incidence of influenza in Ontario, Canada has decreased following the introduction of the Universal Influenza Immunization Campaign (UIIC) in 2000. All laboratory-confirmed influenza cases in Ontario, from January 1990 to August 2005 were analyzed using multitaper time series analysis. We found that there has not been a decrease in the mean monthly influenza rate following the introduction of the UIIC (109.5 (S.D. 20) versus 160 (S.D. 50.3) p > 0.1). Despite increased vaccine distribution and financial resources towards promotion, the incidence of influenza in Ontario has not decreased following the introduction of the UIIC.



Eos said:
Not only that, but supressing the spread of the virus can help keep it from mutating into a strain that will get us an overdue pandemic.
I think most of the pandemic fear center around avian influenza crossing over into humans, not out presently circulating strains mutating.
 
Last edited:
They are comparing one way/process of vaccination & coverage to another. Those aren't comparisions for no vaccination. If there was a lack of vaccination at all you would see far more deaths. It's quite a leap to say no vaccination is working in Canada. Nice try.

Current misinformation spread around about vaccines is not helping the uptake rate amongst the population for which there is no coverage. If the vaccine was free for everyone then we'd get better herd immunity for everyone. Right now though, that would be way too costly. They are more concerned about getting the vaccine to people who are most likely to die from complications when they get the flu. Some people care enough to save some of those most at risk, and try to make sure healthcare folks that come into contact with susceptible populations are getting their shots.

You really don't think a pandemic strain could come from a strain of any flu circulating? Really? Now you're showing your ignorance about viruses.
 
Last edited:
They are comparing one way of vaccination to another
.
What do you mean?
Vaccine coverage more than doubled during that time.
http://www.ama-assn.org/ama1/pub/upload/mm/36/2004_flu_kurji.pdf

Why didn't the program, and the doubling in influenza coverage reduce influenza?

You really don't think a pandemic strain could come from a strain of any flu circulating? Really? Now you're showing your ignorance about viruses.

This might depend on how you're defining "pandemic" since technically, every year we have a influenza pandemic of sorts. But when you hear people talking about "the impending influenza pandemic" they're usually referring to an influenza virus from an animal (and they start with birds) gaining the ability to transmit between humans.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom