Another Vaccination Scare?

The big advantage humans have over computers at the moment is Content Addressable Memory and massive parallel processing. It will be interesting to see how the gap narrows between computer programs and human experts in tasks such as diagnosis when computers start to have this hardware functionality in significant amounts.

Physicians may become glorified typists in my lifetime:D
 
Since we're totally off topic, do you docs think it's better when people try to do a bit of self diagnosis troubleshooting before showing up, or does that just make it harder for you guys?
There's a new book out called "How Doctors Think", and the author (a physician) actually advocates people troubleshooting things on their own a bit when possible to know potentially relevant information to give their physician.

Seems like a fine line to walk since so many people want to fixate on what *they* think is wrong with them, and will almost demand that their doc give them the exact diagnosis they've decided on at home...

There is a difference between providing better information to your doctor - a more detailed description of your pain, a list that includes OTC meds/supplements, the exact cause of your sister's early death - and stating the information in terms of a diagnosis. Knowing things isn't a problem. It's the patient that doesn't realize what they don't know that is a pain in the butt. :)

Linda
 
Just for the record, I've never implicitly or explicitly called Ivor an anti-semite.

Linda

No, you only mentioned my "intolerance" when I and others were talking with LossLeader about ritual Jewish circumcision.

When I asked for clarification you grouped me in with people who had been warned by mods. about anti-Semitic comments.

Therefore you implied I was being anti-Semitic.

ETA: The tense of your above denial makes it clear that it is more for the benefit of your public image than mine. Doesn't the reality of what you did fit with your self-concept? Or don't you "do" apologies?
 
Last edited:
I did not realize that you would read anti-semitism into what I said. I'm sorry that I did not do more to prevent that interpretation.

Linda
 
I did not realize that you would read anti-semitism into what I said. I'm sorry that I did not do more to prevent that interpretation.

Linda

Thank you for your apology, which I fully accept. That is the end of the matter as far as I am concerned.
 
The NHS does not "sell" vaccines. It has one ulterior motive - to promote the continued good health of the population in the UK. Products that do not do what they are meant to do soon get discarded. vaccines prevent huge amounts of future illness which would burden the NHS/the taxpayer considerably. It is in the best interests of the NHS to promote safe and effective remedies..

Unfortunately, as I mentioned in my post, they effectively do sell vaccines. GPs receive an additional (and quite significant) payment if they get over a certain percentage of their patients vaccinated. I even know GPs who have calculated it as part of their wage for Mortgage purposes. It was also disappointing that when we wished to discuss vaccination with our health visitor, we knew more about it than she did. She simply waved a leaflet in our faces (which said nothing by the way - just here are the ages at which your child will receive xyz vaccination) and said 'Everyone gets their kids vaccinated - it's compulsory!'. Which it most certainly is not...yet. She wasn't even aware that there was any controversy (which was probably at its height at the time).

All this undermines confidence - especially if the 'other side' are shouting loud enough.

The conspiracy theorists also have a field day with the amount of influence the drug companies have and that is unfortunately fuelled by the jollies GPs receive (indeed expect to receive) from them. I'm speaking from the experience of two close friends here, one a GP and one a drugs rep. It amazes me that as a public servant myself, I have to declare any gratuity from suppliers (even a pub lunch for £4:60) as it could affect my judgement but my GP friend can go on an all expenses paid trip overseas (so far there's been Denmark, France, Holland, Belgium) for a weekend to attend a 1 hour drugs conference to promote some new offering or other. As my friend the rep says - we wouldn't spend the money if it didn't influence their decision...
 
Wasn't that Google?

No. Google managed 58% correct.

I'm trying to find where I got these figures from...

ETA: Here's the google study.

ETA2: http://www.answers.com/topic/differential-diagnosis?cat=health

A recent study by Tang and Ng (BMJ 2006;333:1143-5) examined the effectiveness of Google searches in diagnosing extremely hard and/or unusual cases that are featured in the New England Journal of Medicine's case reports. These are cases that are challenging enough to merit publication in this leading journal. A quick search on 3 to 5 main words or phrases regarding the case found a correct diagnosis 58 % of the time. One responder (Wentz) replicated the study using the PUBMED database, and found the correct diagnosis to these challengingly difficult cases 88% of the time. (Groves T. 2007. "Can Google help you to diagnose patients' problems" sBMJ. Jan. Vol 15. p. 20-21.)
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, as I mentioned in my post, they effectively do sell vaccines. GPs receive an additional (and quite significant) payment if they get over a certain percentage of their patients vaccinated. I even know GPs who have calculated it as part of their wage for Mortgage purposes.

Check with your GP friend again. GPs are actually distinct from the NHS proper - they act as independent contractors. So GPs may see a financial gain if they meet vaccination targets, but the NHS itself does not make money out of the vaccines and in fact it would benefit the NHS Primary Care Trusts if GPs did not meet their targets - they would have to pay GPs less money through the GP contracts!

It was also disappointing that when we wished to discuss vaccination with our health visitor, we knew more about it than she did. She simply waved a leaflet in our faces (which said nothing by the way - just here are the ages at which your child will receive xyz vaccination) and said 'Everyone gets their kids vaccinated - it's compulsory!'. Which it most certainly is not...yet. She wasn't even aware that there was any controversy (which was probably at its height at the time).

All this undermines confidence - especially if the 'other side' are shouting loud enough.

Maybe so. But this is just an isolated example of ignorance in your health visitor, rather than being symptomatic of a vast NHS conspiracy to make money out of vaccines

The conspiracy theorists also have a field day with the amount of influence the drug companies have and that is unfortunately fuelled by the jollies GPs receive (indeed expect to receive) from them. I'm speaking from the experience of two close friends here, one a GP and one a drugs rep. It amazes me that as a public servant myself, I have to declare any gratuity from suppliers (even a pub lunch for £4:60) as it could affect my judgement but my GP friend can go on an all expenses paid trip overseas (so far there's been Denmark, France, Holland, Belgium) for a weekend to attend a 1 hour drugs conference to promote some new offering or other. As my friend the rep says - we wouldn't spend the money if it didn't influence their decision...

The APBI have very stricy rules regarding these "freebies". Doctors are not meant to accept a gift (eg calculators etc) worth more than £5 and have to declare all gratuities to their employing NHS Trusts. Of course there will be conference meetings, but I very much doubt you can give a real example of an overseas trip for a GP for a "one hour drug conference". Have you evidence for this?

I am not denying that trips and "inducements" take place - of course they do. This usually applies to newly-licensed drugs like the l"atest statin". But regarding vaccines there is little margin for trying to persuade GPs to prescribe one vaccine over another since much of the time there is only one option. Ask your GP friend how many visits he/she has had from a vaccine manufacturer in the last year, and for which products. And then let us know, because I'd be very surprised if there was even one.

Also, as was pointed out, vaccines on the current infant immunisation schedule are not very profitable.
The exceptions are vaccines like Gardasil (more of a lifestyle choice?)

ETA - Are you Sinope's sock puppet? Why the name change?
 
Last edited:
However, it drove me nuts when I'd be screening sick call, and I'd ask "What's wrong" and they'd tell me "Strep throat" or "flu". While I understand why they say that, not every sore throat is strep and not every cough is the flu.

What I find annoying about this is that it biases doctors against people who really do know what's wrong with them. For every 99 people who have no idea what they're talking about there's one who actually does, but all the people who do diagnosis by Google mean the others get ignored.

For example, when I was younger I was seriously asthmatic, but by hte time I left school it had just about gone. However, while I was at university I got a chest infection that brought my asthma back. When I went to see a GP I was completely ignored and just given cough medicine. I'm sure there are lots of people that get a slight cough and claim to have asthma, and so this is the appropriate reponse in most cases, but in my case I really do know what asthma is and the GP being constantly inundated with people trying to self-diagnose meant I had an extra week of not being able to breathe before finally getting diagnosed properly.

Self-diagnosis doesn't just irritate the doctors, it also causes problems for people who genuinely do know what is wrong with themselves.
 
I disagree with your assessment. First, you cannot formulate a strategy based on that.

The problem is people not being individually responsible for their health, that instead expect the doctor to magically solve their problems.

Doctors can be good and bad as well. But having a third person diagnose you has a larger margin for abuse (financial, pharmaceutical) and misdiagnosis.

Most people don't need to know the 100's of diseases and conditions a doctor knows. Most people only have a small number of problems, like a vulnerability to asthma, or frequent back pain. It is simply inefficient in terms of information distribution to centralize the diagnosis competence in few.

I say, teach kids how to diagnose & medicate themselves. Give them the rights to prescribe themselves with drugs. That's what most people do, anyways, but without education.

Turn doctors into teachers and empower the people. Self-Diagnosis must become the standard practice, and doctors should not be more than consultants, second opinions. The current system that places all power to decide upon the health of a patient is ripe with abuse of financial nature, and this is systemic. If you have the people do this themselves...

Searching for diseases by google is just the beginning. There's pages like WrongDiagnosis that may work better than a pubmed text search as well, although I'm not sure if that site also has a complete list of medication side effects.

But well, that's kind of my 0.02$
 
I have to admit that it is tempting to consider giving evolution a chance.

Linda
 
Companies finance studies to investigate their products. Companies design studies to favor their products. Companies provide the spin on the data that favors their product. In the commercial sector, where most investigators are more concerned with reimbursement than with authorship, industry can easily control clinical-trial data. Still: Over 10% of clinical trials publish simply fictional data

Peer review in journals has three purposes:
- Making sure an article is spell checked
- Making sure unpopular opinions are silenced
- On this forum, being some sort of magic bullet that one should immediately turn off critical thinking and accept anything published in a peer reviewed journal as absolute and definite truth, that only a madman would disagree with.
 
I disagree with your assessment. First, you cannot formulate a strategy based on that.

The problem is people not being individually responsible for their health, that instead expect the doctor to magically solve their problems.

Doctors can be good and bad as well. But having a third person diagnose you has a larger margin for abuse (financial, pharmaceutical) and misdiagnosis.

Most people don't need to know the 100's of diseases and conditions a doctor knows. Most people only have a small number of problems, like a vulnerability to asthma, or frequent back pain. It is simply inefficient in terms of information distribution to centralize the diagnosis competence in few.

I say, teach kids how to diagnose & medicate themselves. Give them the rights to prescribe themselves with drugs. That's what most people do, anyways, but without education.

Turn doctors into teachers and empower the people. Self-Diagnosis must become the standard practice, and doctors should not be more than consultants, second opinions. The current system that places all power to decide upon the health of a patient is ripe with abuse of financial nature, and this is systemic. If you have the people do this themselves...

Searching for diseases by google is just the beginning. There's pages like WrongDiagnosis that may work better than a pubmed text search as well, although I'm not sure if that site also has a complete list of medication side effects.

But well, that's kind of my 0.02$

:jaw-dropp
 
self diagnosis? that would cetainly solve the overpopulation problem. so dubjuh you reckon you could be your own oncologist? i hear enemas are just the thing for curing cancer. how about neurology? fancy attempting to remove a brain tumour yourself? maybe use some of that super placebo homeopathy you sell ( by the way, does that make you a shill for complementary therapy? oh, i forget, CAM is all free isnt it? not a huge multi million dollar unregulated industry) or maybe, just maybe, underneath all that bluster you do actually realise that so-called alternative therapies only seem to work for people that arent really ill. in my experience ( and unfortunately i have the misfortune of knowing a lot of health woos) when the **** hits the fan and they get a real illness that has serious, life threatening implications they run straight to the nearest real doctor for some of that nasty allopathic evidence based treatment you so deride. that is the luxery of living in a medically advanced first world country, access to decent healthcare. perhaps you should have a browse of the infant mortality rates in countries that dont have that luxury and do a little comparison.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom