Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

Here is part of a blog from a Catholic priest who at the beginning of it acknowledges a grave evil is committed whenever a child is abused, especially by a member of the clergy.

From fatherfladerblog

...we should never forget that it is a very small percentage of priests who have abused their ministry. The second report of the John Jay College of Criminal Justice into sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in the U.S. reported that in the period 1950-2010 there had been accusations of sexual abuse against only 5% of priests, and that less than 4% of these involved paedophilia. The report acknowledged that the rate of abuse by clergy is lower than that in comparable professions... Fifth, at the time that most of the offences occurred, many years ago, neither the Church nor people in secular society understood, as we do today, the seriousness of paedophilia as a mental condition that is not easily treated. The tendency then was to regard it as an isolated case of sexual weakness, for which the perpetrator had repented and was resolved not to commit it again, and so the priest was simply moved to a different parish where he could begin his new life of chastity in different surroundings. This was gravely mistaken but those who responded in that way were usually acting in good faith and cannot be judged by standards that have changed in the light of new findings.

http://fatherfladerblog.wordpress.com/2013/01/26/the-clergy-sexual-abuse-scandal/

Accusations against priests. This doesn't account for those that kept mum like a childhood neighbor of mine who kept mum until it came out when he was in his thirties, married, with children. His allegation came in the form of a note he left behind before hanging himself.

I wouldn't blame his suicide on the abuse, not entirely.
 
Here is part of a blog from a Catholic priest who at the beginning of it acknowledges a grave evil is committed whenever a child is abused, especially by a member of the clergy.

From fatherfladerblog

...we should never forget that it is a very small percentage of priests who have abused their ministry. The second report of the John Jay College of Criminal Justice into sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in the U.S. reported that in the period 1950-2010 there had been accusations of sexual abuse against only 5% of priests, and that less than 4% of these involved paedophilia. The report acknowledged that the rate of abuse by clergy is lower than that in comparable professions... Fifth, at the time that most of the offences occurred, many years ago, neither the Church nor people in secular society understood, as we do today, the seriousness of paedophilia as a mental condition that is not easily treated. The tendency then was to regard it as an isolated case of sexual weakness, for which the perpetrator had repented and was resolved not to commit it again, and so the priest was simply moved to a different parish where he could begin his new life of chastity in different surroundings. This was gravely mistaken but those who responded in that way were usually acting in good faith and cannot be judged by standards that have changed in the light of new findings.

http://fatherfladerblog.wordpress.com/2013/01/26/the-clergy-sexual-abuse-scandal/

That might explain the first case or even the second but by the time the sixth and seventh case came along even the dullest might think that it wasn't working.
 
Yes, the church considered it's public image, how it looked to people, more important than the heinous crime of molesting children. That is a fact. Do you have some information that tells us what all the catholic churches are doing today, this hour about that? Please share.


You have the burden of proof backwards. I am not the one making the positive claim. Nor have I ever said that "all" catholic chuches are doing anything. The OP made the positive claim that there is a current culture of pedophilia in the church - that is the claim that requires evidence.



If I find out you were a dirty lawyer before, it is definitely going to influence my choosing you to represent me. That is a fact.


That is a fact that has nothing to do with the hypothetical I posed. My hypo had to do with someone arguing that I currently mess my pants with nothing other than evidence that I did so as a baby.



Please present that evidence.


Not my claim, not my burden. I'm not arguing that there is a current culture of pedophilia anywhere.



The past history of the catholic church has more bloodshed, crime, greed, avarice, coveteousness, than most histories I know. And that is a fact everybody here knows. That information is freely available.


Yes, the past history is the past history. I'm not arguing about past history. I am saying that it is logically irresponsible to claim that the past history is still going on unless one has present evidence. The past history of the USA includes slavery. It is not a fair statement to say that the US currently has a culture of slavery. Germany does not have a culture of trying to take over the world. France does not have a culture of invading England.
 
Here is part of a blog from a Catholic priest who at the beginning of it acknowledges a grave evil is committed whenever a child is abused, especially by a member of the clergy.

From fatherfladerblog

...we should never forget that it is a very small percentage of priests who have abused their ministry. The second report of the John Jay College of Criminal Justice into sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in the U.S. reported that in the period 1950-2010 there had been accusations of sexual abuse against only 5% of priests, and that less than 4% of these involved paedophilia. The report acknowledged that the rate of abuse by clergy is lower than that in comparable professions... Fifth, at the time that most of the offences occurred, many years ago, neither the Church nor people in secular society understood, as we do today, the seriousness of paedophilia as a mental condition that is not easily treated. The tendency then was to regard it as an isolated case of sexual weakness, for which the perpetrator had repented and was resolved not to commit it again, and so the priest was simply moved to a different parish where he could begin his new life of chastity in different surroundings. This was gravely mistaken but those who responded in that way were usually acting in good faith and cannot be judged by standards that have changed in the light of new findings.

http://fatherfladerblog.wordpress.com/2013/01/26/the-clergy-sexual-abuse-scandal/

Presuming that study is meritorious and valid, and we accept that accusation = guilt, we are talking about less than (.05 x .04 = .0020) 00.2% of priests have been accused of sexual assault upon children. In the general population, Seto (2009)1 gives an estimate of something a bit less than 5% of the adult male population is liable to commit some form of pedophilia. This would seem to suggest that the likelihood of sexual assault upon children by general population adult males is 25x higher than among priests. However, this is probably misleading as most males with pedophilic tendancies control their predilections, and presumably a priest's spiritual alignment and devotion to moral considerations would enhance their "control" attributes. It may not be that priests are any different than the regular adult male population of our species with regards to pedophilia, except that they are better at controlling and resisting their pedophilic behavior. I certainly would not consider the mixing of two very different studies in this manner to be a rigorous analysis of the issue, but it certainly seems to indicate a situation dramatically different from the one that some individuals seem determined to portray.

1 - "Pedophilia," Annual Review of Clinical Psychology. Vol. 5: 391-407 (Volume publication date April 2009). DOI: 10.1146/annurev.clinpsy.032408.153618
 
Yes, the past history is the past history. I'm not arguing about past history. I am saying that it is logically irresponsible to claim that the past history is still going on unless one has present evidence. The past history of the USA includes slavery. It is not a fair statement to say that the US currently has a culture of slavery. Germany does not have a culture of trying to take over the world. France does not have a culture of invading England.
The insinuation that the abuse is ancient history is just plain funny, and very, very disheartening.

The current scandal in Ireland, you should check it out. Same with the issues in the US, those being the two countries I'm most familiar with. The evidence is there, but only if you can see it. That takes some courage in many cases. And there is absolute refusal to see it in far too many cases.
 
by your report, 1 in 20 priests are accused of sexual abuse.
Man, that's worse than I thought.

What form of mathematical manipulation produces a figure of 1 in 20 from a calculation that involves figuring out what 4% of 5% equals?
 
The argument that priests are either less likely (or more likely) to molest than the general population is a red herring.

The scandal here, the whole problem with the Church and its hierarchy, is what they did with those molesting priests, however many there were.
 
The argument that priests are either less likely (or more likely) to molest than the general population is a red herring.

The scandal here, the whole problem with the Church and its hierarchy, is what they did with those molesting priests, however many there were.

Yep, bottom-line, did the God Squad condone pedophilia, abet the offenders and block efforts to stop them, get them out of areas where they were in trouble with the authorities, browbeat any possible witnesses and the victims, and allow them to go on doing child rape in new places when they've escaped justice in their current location.

And these deeds are done by men and women who claim to be doing God's work.
 
Is Cardinal Bernard Law still hiding out in the Vatican?

If so, that seems like a continuing cover-up to me.
 
Are all Americans offended when someone suggests that the invasion of Iraq was wrong and based on lies? Do Americans who remain in the US, continue to vote and pay taxes, tacitly condone the invasion, the continued occupation, and Abu Gareb? No.

Why would you imagine that you "insult all Catholics everywhere" by mentioning the sex abuse and cover-up? Has it been your experience in face to face conversations with your catholic friends or family or is this something that happens in the online world where people often "mention" things in loaded and provocative ways? What exactly was the wording of your "mention"? And why would you presume that some stranger-to-you speaks for "all Catholics everywhere"? In my experience, not even the Pope manages to do this.

Honestly, if the true culture of the Catholic church was willfully pro-pedophilia then what Catholic would be offended? Tell a Catholic that they are willfully pro-Eucharist and they'll nod in agreement. Tell a Catholic that by remaining a member of the church they endorse child rape and you will get a denial.
 
Last edited:
Are all Americans offended when someone suggests that the invasion of Iraq was wrong and based on lies? Do Americans who remain in the US, continue to vote and pay taxes, tacitly condone the invasion, the continued occupation, and Abu Gareb? No.

Why would you imagine that you "insult all Catholics everywhere" by mentioning the sex abuse and cover-up? Has it been your experience in face to face conversations with your catholic friends or family or is this something that happens in the online world where people often "mention" things in loaded and provocative ways? What exactly was the wording of your "mention"? And why would you presume that some stranger-to-you speaks for "all Catholics everywhere"? In my experience, not even the Pope manages to do this.

Honestly, if the true culture of the Catholic church was willfully pro-pedophilia then what Catholic would be offended? Tell a Catholic that they are willfully pro-Eucharist and they'll nod in agreement. Tell a Catholic that by remaining a member of the church they endorse child rape and you will get a denial.

I don't imagine it, I'm constantly being told that I am insulting all Catholics everywhere by even mentioning it.
 
I don't imagine it, I'm constantly being told that I am insulting all Catholics everywhere by even mentioning it.

I doubt your assertion. It has the ring of hyperbole. Is one person repeating this over and over again for the hearing of it to be "constant" for you, or has every Catholic to whom you've ever mentioned the sex abuse scandal expressed umbrage? Is it your actual experience that "all Catholics everywhere" have been insulted? I can tell you that I've had conversations with other Catholics and have found them quite willing to speak about it without taking offense. Many (the overwhelming majority, in my experience) of them have been highly critical of the Church's response to the revelations of sexual abuse.

I think you DO imagine it, or you have restricted your interactions with Catholics to a very small and non-representative sample.
 
I doubt your assertion. It has the ring of hyperbole. Is one person repeating this over and over again for the hearing of it to be "constant" for you, or has every Catholic to whom you've ever mentioned the sex abuse scandal expressed umbrage? Is it your actual experience that "all Catholics everywhere" have been insulted? I can tell you that I've had conversations with other Catholics and have found them quite willing to speak about it without taking offense. Many (the overwhelming majority, in my experience) of them have been highly critical of the Church's response to the revelations of sexual abuse.

I think you DO imagine it, or you have restricted your interactions with Catholics to a very small and non-representative sample.

Yeah, okay. Were you there?
 
I don't imagine it, I'm constantly being told that I am insulting all Catholics everywhere by even mentioning it.

There is a big difference between acting in an insulting manner (which is how I would qualify the manner in which you seem to frame your discussion of the sexual crimes issue involving a few priests and the mishandling of those issues by some church officials), and all Catholics feeling insulted by any reasonable discussion of the general topic and issue.
 
There is a big difference between acting in an insulting manner (which is how I would qualify the manner in which you seem to frame your discussion of the sexual crimes issue involving a few priests and the mishandling of those issues by some church officials), and all Catholics feeling insulted by any reasonable discussion of the general topic and issue.

I only insult people when I find it useful. It's is NOT insulting to point out that criminal activities are being condoned and covered up. Feigning being insulted to protect oneself from having to confront a problem is insulting, to the victims.
 
Yeah, okay. Were you there?

You mean sequestered in a bubble with a non-representative sampling of self-identifying Catholics? No. I live in a larger world and encounter a wider range of humanity. This is why I don't extrapolate isolated experiences into sweeping generalizations. I like to see a greater sample size before I pass judgment.
 
You mean sequestered in a bubble with a non-representative sampling of self-identifying Catholics? No. I live in a larger world and encounter a wider range of humanity. This is why I don't extrapolate isolated experiences into sweeping generalizations. I like to see a greater sample size before I pass judgment.

Ah, I see, you're part of the problem.
 
Perhaps LA is not addressing it, but I can assure you that my diocese (the diocese of Bridgeport, CT) is. Anyone who so much as volunteers in the church, in any capacity whatsoever, is required to take four hours of training re: child abuse, watching for signs of child abuse, how to report child abuse, who to report it to in the diocese after notifying the police, yada yada yada. All I do is sing in the damn church choir, and I had to take the training.

Shame you are obligated to pass money up the ladder to the criminals.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom