Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

again

That's not the point.

The point is that the Catholic church protected their pedophiles from the police and from public scrutiny, and often sent them to new parishes full of new victims.

Sure, there's pedophiles amongst the teachers, the boy scout leaders, the librarians, the parents, the doctors, and the rest of us. But most of these groups would turn in a pedophile at the first accusation.
And you are basing your accusations and imagined statistical information on repeat offenders who you believe are more present in the Catholic priesthood?
 
Most of the Catholics I know are pretty mad about the coverup. I don't think they typically take umbrage when it gets brought up unless you ask them to defend the Church's practice of shielding criminals.
 
I wonder if there is statistical evidence of the percentage of pedophiliacs in the general population to those found in any religious denomination.

It doesn't matter, because that is not the source of the problem.

1) First, there is the betrayal - these folks are not among the "general population." They have been "called by God" to serve the church. Remember, that is THEIR language, that this is their "calling." What does it say that they are no different from the general population? All of a sudden, their standing up in front of the congregation as teachers means nothing. They are especially ordained to say mass, and it is by their words that the bread and wine are turned into the body and blood of Christ. But they are just normal people? You can't have it both ways. If priests are not special, then why are they the only ones who are able to consecrate in mass? But this is the position of the Roman Catholic Church. It is the Church who sets them up as special. Until, of course, they are found diddling boys, at which point they are just men who are no different from anyone else...

2) Second, priests molesting boys is bad enough, but the problem goes beyond individuals, but to the institutions. When they discovered that illegal crap was happening, which happened as a result of the public discovering it and taking action, their response was not to turn the matter over to the law enforcement, nor even to defrock the priest (talk about behavior unbecoming of a priest!), but to move them into a new location where the locals were not aware of what this beast had done, which allowed them to start over and do it again. And, not surprisingly, that is what happened. And knowledge of it went up to very high levels in the church authority, even in the Vatican (indeed, the current Pope was among those aware of the things that were known to be going on, and how it was being improperly handled)

I don't know that the extent of child molestors among priests is higher than that for Boy Scout leaders or teachers, but then again, when a teacher is caught molesting students, it's not like the superintendent just assigns them to a different school. Or if they did, they would be criticized just as much as the RCC has been.
 
No, you aren't, but I've run into this attitude as well. Any criticism of any church official or policy is, in some people's minds, an insult to all believers.

It's a useful way to shield your ideas and behavior from criticism.
 
slap on wrist

Pedophile teachers got it easy. But another unknown fact of unreported pedophilia is unknown. Or just ask all the actors who come forth with their childhood stories of abuse...
 
So what do you think? Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?


Yes. Do you have any evidence that such a culture still exists right now on this day? If the answer is anything but yes, you're drawing a hasty conclusion and implying an insult.
 
Most of the Catholics I know are pretty mad about the coverup. I don't think they typically take umbrage when it gets brought up unless you ask them to defend the Church's practice of shielding criminals.

Not mad enough to stop supporting those who aid and abbed child rape. So really not all that made about it given that they still give them financial support.
 
Not mad enough to stop supporting those who aid and abbed child rape. So really not all that mad about it given that they still give them financial support.

Indeed. Talk is pretty cheap. Are they mad enough to insist on accountability? No, they can tell you how unhappy it makes them, but ask them to do something about it? Doesn't happen.
 
Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?

Just mentioning that the scandal exists and that the Church hierarchy has long tried to cover up pedophilia when it happens? I'd say no, it isn't. Neither is actively and directly criticising the hierarchy (collectively or individually) for that coverup.

Saying something like "Well, obviously you're okay with that, since you still go to Mass", though, is pretty borderline because it's more directly personal, unless attempting to get the other person riled up about it for whatever reason is your goal.

Saying the whole Church has "an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof" seems deliberately inflammatory to me, because it's basically saying that the Church wants pedophilia to happen, rather than merely being an insular organization whose leaders are more than happy to place protection of that organization over all other concerns, even pedophilia occurring within its ranks.

Because, really, even if the particular organization in question wasn't presenting itself as a moral authority, that's plenty bad all on its own and doesn't need any kind of punching-up to make it sound worse.
 
Yes. Do you have any evidence that such a culture still exists right now on this day? If the answer is anything but yes, you're drawing a hasty conclusion and implying an insult.

Given how recently they were doing this and we don't see any cases of them calling in the authorities why should we expect them to have changed in the last 6 months?
 
Not mad enough to stop supporting those who aid and abbed child rape. So really not all that made about it given that they still give them financial support.

Paterno covering up for Sandusky doesn't mean you have to stop being a Penn State Football fan, or even a supporter of the school.
 
Okay, I've had enough!

People, please! It's "aid and abet!" Not "abed" or "abbed" or anything else. "Abet" means to encourage someone to commit a criminal act, so I'm not sure it's even applicable here, although "aid" may be (at least in the sense of helping someone get away with it).

Sorry, I'm not usually a grammar/spelling nazi, but I just couldn't handle this one any more!:mad:
 
Just mentioning that the scandal exists and that the Church hierarchy has long tried to cover up pedophilia when it happens? I'd say no, it isn't. Neither is actively and directly criticising the hierarchy (collectively or individually) for that coverup.

Saying something like "Well, obviously you're okay with that, since you still go to Mass", though, is pretty borderline because it's more directly personal, unless attempting to get the other person riled up about it for whatever reason is your goal.

Saying the whole Church has "an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof" seems deliberately inflammatory to me, because it's basically saying that the Church wants pedophilia to happen, rather than merely being an insular organization whose leaders are more than happy to place protection of that organization over all other concerns, even pedophilia occurring within its ranks.

Because, really, even if the particular organization in question wasn't presenting itself as a moral authority, that's plenty bad all on its own and doesn't need any kind of punching-up to make it sound worse.

Yes to all this, but especially the bolded part.
 
Paterno covering up for Sandusky doesn't mean you have to stop being a Penn State Football fan, or even a supporter of the school.

Or stop giving them your money. That would be too much like a punishment for their criminal activity.
 
Many peoples first response to being shown the facts of a matter, especially when it disagrees with their point of view, is to get upset.

I would rather be an emissary of facts, than a believer in illusionary truths.

You are not insulting. You are simply speaking the facts.
 
People, please! It's "aid and abet!" Not "abed" or "abbed" or anything else. "Abet" means to encourage someone to commit a criminal act, so I'm not sure it's even applicable here, although "aid" may be (at least in the sense of helping someone get away with it).

Sorry, I'm not usually a grammar/spelling nazi, but I just couldn't handle this one any more!:mad:

It's much easier to read if you assume that it is just a pun that got out of hand.
 
My father's side of the family is Catholic and they'll be the first to tell you that the hx of the church covering up for pedophiles is horrendous. (To be fair I think most of them are Christmas and Easter Catholics, but they got the holy water sprinkled on them as babies, so I guess that's what matters.)

The history of the church is shameful, and I don't know a single Catholic who supports it. I also personally know family members that can't stand the current pope as a result of what they see as his personal responsibility for the scandal.

No, acknowledging a church-wide wrong is not insulting to anyone with a conscience.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom