Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

The argument that priests are either less likely (or more likely) to molest than the general population is a red herring.

The scandal here, the whole problem with the Church and its hierarchy, is what they did with those molesting priests, however many there were.

The assertion that the Church and its hierarchy acted improperly, as opposed to some church representatives acting improperly in their handling of the issue when they encountered it, is not, to my understandings, compellingly supported.

IOW, holding individuals accountable for their actions, is appropriate, holding the entire organization and all of its members accountable for the actions of a miniscule number of the organization's membership acting independently of the organization is inappropriate.
 
Presuming that study is meritorious and valid, and we accept that accusation = guilt, we are talking about less than (.05 x .04 = .0020) 00.2% of priests have been accused of sexual assault upon children.
That's how I read that quote too, but the blogger seems to be lying (*). From the wiki page on the report:
The Report determined that, during the period from 1950 to 2002, a total of 10,667 individuals had made allegations of child sexual abuse. Of these, the dioceses had been able to substantiate 6,700 accusations against 4,392 priests in the USA, about 4% of all 109,694 priests who served during the time covered by the study
So the substantiated percentage of sexual abusers in the American RCC is hardly lower than the estimated percentage of sexual abusers in the population at large.

ETA2: sorry, read that wrong. Substantiated allegations, not substantiated abuse.

(*) IMHO, this is the only mathematically correct way of reading that phrase. If the blogger had been interested in honesty, he would have worded it more carefully. The combination with "very small percentage" supports this reading.

ETA: with some posters, better check their sources before drawing conclusions from it.
 
Last edited:
The assertion that the Church and its hierarchy acted improperly, as opposed to some church representatives acting improperly in their handling of the issue when they encountered it, is not, to my understandings, compellingly supported.

IOW, holding individuals accountable for their actions, is appropriate, holding the entire organization and all of its members accountable for the actions of a miniscule number of the organization's membership acting independently of the organization is inappropriate.

The Church routinely moves priests to avoid their having to face pedophilia charges.
 
IOW, holding individuals accountable for their actions, is appropriate, holding the entire organization and all of its members accountable for the actions of a miniscule number of the organization's membership acting independently of the organization is inappropriate.

This again. I don't think the little old lady down the street condones pedophilia. That was the point of the OP and that is the knee-jerk reaction I get to even mentioning the topic to some folks.
 
I only insult people when I find it useful. It's is NOT insulting to point out that criminal activities are being condoned and covered up. Feigning being insulted to protect oneself from having to confront a problem is insulting, to the victims.

So is treating their pain and suffering as a debate talking point exaggerated and broadbrushed to the point that it serves as nothing more than hyperbolic rhetoric rather than a reasoned and considered discussion of the actual issues.
 
If the overall question is whether it's insulting to Catholics (potentially up to the "all Catholics everywhere" criteria), yes. It's the difference between "members of the Church let kids get abused because they were more concerned with the reputation of the Church than crimes against children" and "members of the Church let kids get abused because they deliberately wanted kids to get abused."

Actually since they knew these decisions would lead to that probable consequence, I think it's easy enough to conclude that this is what they wanted. Maybe they saw it as the lesser evil (in their minds a lesser evil than the PR nightmare that reporting these cases would have caused), but your position relies on their having the power to do something, knowing what the consequence of their decisions would be, yet somehow that consequence not being their intention. I don't think you can make that case.

Because the Church was not establishing those conditions because they wanted priests to keep molesting children.

I think in fact that's exactly what they wanted since they knew with a high degree of confidence that that's what their decisions had led to in the past and would likely do in the future. I don't see how they can claim that hushing up victims with settlements and relocating suspected pedophiles to places that would result in new victims isn't what they intended to do.

It's sort of like saying that a farmer only creates all the conditions for a plant to grow knowing the likely result is for the plant to grow but doesn't intend the plant to grow.

[ETA: At best, your case would depend on believing the people who made these decisions to be completely naive as to one of the primary purposes of bringing criminals to the criminal justice system: to prevent their being able to repeat their offense. In the case of crimes with victims like this, that purpose is to prevent more kids from being abused. But all of the men in authority who made these decisions are educated administrators who are not naive to the secular world. Knowing that their decisions protected suspects from prosecution and insulated them from past accusers was certainly done for the primary purpose of protecting the Church from bad PR, but it had to have been their intention for more kids to be victimized since this was the easily foreseeable consequence of their decisions. ]

The strongest case you can make (which you recognize is itself pretty damning) is that they deemed the intention to allow more children to be abused as the lesser evil.
 
Last edited:
This again. I don't think the little old lady down the street condones pedophilia. That was the point of the OP and that is the knee-jerk reaction I get to even mentioning the topic to some folks.

When you talk about priests in general, the church hierarchy and the Church, you are speaking in broadbrush terms that include all Catholics, if you wish to talk about specific violators who happen to be Catholic, do so in those terms and you will not be insulting Catholics. That, however, seems to be more specific and accurate than you desire to be.
 
What form of mathematical manipulation produces a figure of 1 in 20 from a calculation that involves figuring out what 4% of 5% equals?

I was simply speaking of the sexual abuse accusations, which is 5% or 1 in 20.

Is it me, but isn't that an insanely high figure for a population who supposedly took a vow of abstinence?


If we look at just pedophile accusations, it would be 1 in 500. Still a crazy high statistic in my book.
 
So is treating their pain and suffering as a debate talking point exaggerated and broadbrushed to the point that it serves as nothing more than hyperbolic rhetoric rather than a reasoned and considered discussion of the actual issues.

Yeah, whatever. I do nothing but talk, you know that, you've followed my life enough to see that I'm all talk and no action. Right? RIGHT? Or are you just making bald assertions?
 
You have the burden of proof backwards. I am not the one making the positive claim. Nor have I ever said that "all" catholic chuches are doing anything. The OP made the positive claim that there is a current culture of pedophilia in the church - that is the claim that requires evidence.






That is a fact that has nothing to do with the hypothetical I posed. My hypo had to do with someone arguing that I currently mess my pants with nothing other than evidence that I did so as a baby.






Not my claim, not my burden. I'm not arguing that there is a current culture of pedophilia anywhere.






Yes, the past history is the past history. I'm not arguing about past history. I am saying that it is logically irresponsible to claim that the past history is still going on unless one has present evidence. The past history of the USA includes slavery. It is not a fair statement to say that the US currently has a culture of slavery. Germany does not have a culture of trying to take over the world. France does not have a culture of invading England.

I doubt your assertion. It has the ring of hyperbole. Is one person repeating this over and over again for the hearing of it to be "constant" for you, or has every Catholic to whom you've ever mentioned the sex abuse scandal expressed umbrage? Is it your actual experience that "all Catholics everywhere" have been insulted? I can tell you that I've had conversations with other Catholics and have found them quite willing to speak about it without taking offense. Many (the overwhelming majority, in my experience) of them have been highly critical of the Church's response to the revelations of sexual abuse.

I think you DO imagine it, or you have restricted your interactions with Catholics to a very small and non-representative sample.

There's one.
 
When you talk about priests in general, the church hierarchy and the Church, you are speaking in broadbrush terms that include all Catholics, if you wish to talk about specific violators who happen to be Catholic, do so in those terms and you will not be insulting Catholics. That, however, seems to be more specific and accurate than you desire to be.

If that's the way you want to try and shut me up, fine. Try it. However, if it takes insulting all Catholics to get them to get their house in order, I'm okay with that. Maybe some few of them will have the balls to face the issue and do something about it.
 
So is treating their pain and suffering as a debate talking point exaggerated and broadbrushed to the point that it serves as nothing more than hyperbolic rhetoric rather than a reasoned and considered discussion of the actual issues.

Wait a second--someone has exaggerated the pain and suffering caused by the decisions of Church authorities? Evidence please?

As for the issue of the effect of this kind of rhetoric: I think when something is outrageous expressions of outrage are reasonable and might even help frame the discussion as it ought be.

See my last--this nonsense that it's unreasonable to speak of people's decisions to protect child abusers and to allow them to abuse subsequent victims as "unintentional" as a way of somehow avoiding unpleasant language is absurd.
 
Last edited:
Is it me, but isn't that an insanely high figure for a population who supposedly took a vow of abstinence?

Or perhaps it points to a problem with requiring a vow of abstinence.

There could be some other factor that leads people predisposed to pedophilia to become priests, or it could be that something about being a priest leads to the development of pedophilia at higher than normal rates. I dunno.

Either way wouldn't surprise me.
 
Or perhaps it points to a problem with requiring a vow of abstinence.
I think if a person with normal sexual drives were to violate his vow of abstinence he'd drive somewhere outside his parish and hire an "escort" or enter into an affair with an adult woman. The only two instances I know of personally of a priest violating his vows involved adult women (not prostitutes, by the way), one of which resulted in his leaving the priesthood in order to marry.
There could be some other factor that leads people predisposed to pedophilia to become priests, or it could be that something about being a priest leads to the development of pedophilia at higher than normal rates. I dunno.

I strongly suspect this. I have no real data to support it though.
 
Actually since they knew these decisions would lead to that probable consequence, I think it's easy enough to conclude that this is what they wanted. Maybe they saw it as the lesser evil (in their minds a lesser evil than the PR nightmare that reporting these cases would have caused), but your position relies on their having the power to do something, knowing what the consequence of their decisions would be, yet somehow that consequence not being their intention. I don't think you can make that case.

No, I said they didn't care about whether their actions would result in more molestations or not, as long as it avoided that "PR nightmare". There are plenty of instances of moved priests getting token scolding or some kind of "don't do this again" counseling, but that was always more of an afterthought compared to their main reason for doing what they did, which was to make sure none of that got out.

It's like someone who knows his friend has too much to drink and still lets him take his car keys and drive home without doing or saying anything. He bears responsibility for his inaction if that drunk driver kills someone, but it's not legitimate to say that he wants his intoxicated friend to kill someone, rather than just hoping nothing bad will happen and everything will blow over.
 
Yesterday, on Diane Rehm, they interviewed a fellow, Gary Willis, who was evidently a devout but radical Catholic. His solution to the church's problems? No priests.
"A failed tradition" he says.
Pointed out that the priesthood as such had no antecedents in the early church, and that the idea of the priest as a conduit to God only arose later.
He quoted a lot of Greek...

I think the Quakers took that approach.


Yup. This is why it was a hanging offense in the theocracy of colonial Massachusetts merely to be a Quaker. The church elders couldn't abide the idea of someone going around suggesting that people could get their own ideas about religion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom