Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

Gawdzilla Sama

TImeToSweepTheLeg
Joined
Nov 25, 2009
Messages
45,010
Location
Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
I mentioned the pedophilia scandal on another forum and got some angry replies that I was "insulting all Catholics everywhere" by even mentioning it. I'm fairly certain I'm not insulting the little old lady down the street by mentioning that her priest shouldn't be left alone with small children, but I may be wrong, (first time for anything, I guess :D ). So what do you think? Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?
 
I would say that the pedophilia scandal, and its coverup should have insulted catholics far more deeply than commentary on said scandal.

They haven't cleaned it all up yet, preferring to concentrate on things like denying gay rights and railing against birth control in the 21st century.

I was raised catholic: altar boy, considered seminary, all that stuff. Then clarity happened.
 
They want to be able to ignore their support for an organization that aids and abeds child rape. You are making that difficult by pointing this out. Shame on you for making them feel guilty.
 
I'm fairly certain I'm not insulting the little old lady down the street by mentioning that her priest shouldn't be left alone with small children, but I may be wrong, (first time for anything, I guess :D ).

Given today's social climate, no adult authority figure should be left alone with small children. I wouldn't want to be put in that situation and risk being thrown in jail by the testimony of a confused three-year-old.
 
Given today's social climate, no adult authority figure should be left alone with small children. I wouldn't want to be put in that situation and risk being thrown in jail by the testimony of a confused three-year-old.

Besides, that three-year-old totally WANTED it!! ;)
 
Yesterday, on Diane Rehm, they interviewed a fellow, Gary Willis, who was evidently a devout but radical Catholic. His solution to the church's problems? No priests.
"A failed tradition" he says.
Pointed out that the priesthood as such had no antecedents in the early church, and that the idea of the priest as a conduit to God only arose later.
He quoted a lot of Greek...
 
Yesterday, on Diane Rehm, they interviewed a fellow, Gary Willis, who was evidently a devout but radical Catholic. His solution to the church's problems? No priests.
"A failed tradition" he says.
Pointed out that the priesthood as such had no antecedents in the early church, and that the idea of the priest as a conduit to God only arose later.
He quoted a lot of Greek...

I think the Quakers took that approach.
 
I mentioned the pedophilia scandal on another forum and got some angry replies that I was "insulting all Catholics everywhere" by even mentioning it. I'm fairly certain I'm not insulting the little old lady down the street by mentioning that her priest shouldn't be left alone with small children, but I may be wrong, (first time for anything, I guess :D ). So what do you think? Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?

It all depends on context. If you are telling this to a little old lady referring to a person who she is friends with, and of whom you have zero knowledge of other than the fact the he is a priest, then yes that would be considered an insult. Most priests are not pedophiles. Pretending that all priests are, and that Catholics find child molestation acceptable is going to be insulting to most Catholics.

Mentioning the pedophilia scandal might make some Catholics feel uncomfortable. That's too bad.
 
Last edited:
It all depends on context. If you are telling this to a little old lady referring to a person who she is friends with, and of whom you have zero knowledge of other than the fact the he is a priest, then yes that would be considered an insult. Most priests are not pedophiles. Pretending that all priests are, and that Catholics find child molestation acceptable is going to insulting to most Catholics.

Mentioning the pedophilia scandal might make some Catholics feel uncomfortable. That's too bad.

Yea they only support those who aide and abed things they supposedly hate. And anyway according to catholic psychologists these teen boys had a hole that they desperately needed a father figure to fill and seduced the priests in a totally heterosexual way. The way young boys are want to.
 
I mentioned the pedophilia scandal on another forum and got some angry replies that I was "insulting all Catholics everywhere" by even mentioning it. I'm fairly certain I'm not insulting the little old lady down the street by mentioning that her priest shouldn't be left alone with small children, but I may be wrong, (first time for anything, I guess :D ). So what do you think? Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?

Well, technically I'm a catholic (though a really bad one:D), and I'm not offended. I am, however, offended and disgusted by these priests and their enablers within the church.
 
It all depends on context. If you are telling this to a little old lady referring to a person who she is friends with, and of whom you have zero knowledge of other than the fact the he is a priest, then yes that would be considered an insult. Most priests are not pedophiles. Pretending that all priests are, and that Catholics find child molestation acceptable is going to insulting to most Catholics.

Mentioning the pedophilia scandal might make some Catholics feel uncomfortable. That's too bad.


They keep supporting the pedophiles and their enablers.
 
Ask them if they really feel more insulted by you mentioning the scandal than by the pope and his friends trying to cover it up.
 
results

I wonder if there is statistical evidence of the percentage of pedophiliacs in the general population to those found in any religious denomination.
 
I wonder if there is statistical evidence of the percentage of pedophiliacs in the general population to those found in any religious denomination.

Again, the primary issue is not about pedophilia among the priesthood, however disturbing that is. It is about the concerted efforts by the church to protect the accused.
 
I wonder if there is statistical evidence of the percentage of pedophiliacs in the general population to those found in any religious denomination.
That's not the point.

The point is that the Catholic church protected their pedophiles from the police and from public scrutiny, and often sent them to new parishes full of new victims.

Sure, there's pedophiles amongst the teachers, the boy scout leaders, the librarians, the parents, the doctors, and the rest of us. But most of these groups would turn in a pedophile at the first accusation.
 
That's not the point.

The point is that the Catholic church protected their pedophiles from the police and from public scrutiny, and often sent them to new parishes full of new victims.

Sure, there's pedophiles amongst the teachers, the boy scout leaders, the librarians, the parents, the doctors, and the rest of us. But most of these groups would turn in a pedophile at the first accusation.

Well not the boy scouts. Though at least they tried to prevent them getting more victims.
 
Sounds like you're dealing with people who go out of their way to be offended and insulted. Since you're simply providing them with what they crave, you are in fact acting kindly toward them. The baby Jesus smiles upon you for it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom