I think I have a problem with all of this. It is “define abuse”.
I think most of us would agree that a thirty year old of either sex becoming sexually involved with a ten year old of the same (or other) sex would constitute abuse. Catholic priest or not.
But, at the other end of the spectrum, suppose we have two seven year olds playing “I’ll show you mine if you show me yours”. Is this abuse? Or two eleven year olds doing the same? Or a sixteen year old and an eleven year old. Or a seventeen year old and a fourteen year old groping each other behind the (proverbial) bike shed? In all cases of either (or same) sex and who was older.
What about a 40 year old mother of three propositioning a 19 year old male? Who would have been a lucky boy? I really regret I had move away to go back to work. I could have had some real fun for a few weeks. Assault? Abuse? Use your imagination.
The point I am trying to make is that at the extremes we all are likely to agree. It’s just that there is a large area in the middle – mainly the teenage years and below – where it is not so clear.
OK, sexual assault, like sexual harassment, is different. But even so, it’s still often not what happened, but who did it.
Incidentally, paedophile is spelt thus: pedophile is someone who is sexually attracted to feet. I’m not too sure that is what people mean. If you are, there are good treatments for athletes’ … But I digress.
I think most of us would agree that a thirty year old of either sex becoming sexually involved with a ten year old of the same (or other) sex would constitute abuse. Catholic priest or not.
But, at the other end of the spectrum, suppose we have two seven year olds playing “I’ll show you mine if you show me yours”. Is this abuse? Or two eleven year olds doing the same? Or a sixteen year old and an eleven year old. Or a seventeen year old and a fourteen year old groping each other behind the (proverbial) bike shed? In all cases of either (or same) sex and who was older.
What about a 40 year old mother of three propositioning a 19 year old male? Who would have been a lucky boy? I really regret I had move away to go back to work. I could have had some real fun for a few weeks. Assault? Abuse? Use your imagination.
The point I am trying to make is that at the extremes we all are likely to agree. It’s just that there is a large area in the middle – mainly the teenage years and below – where it is not so clear.
OK, sexual assault, like sexual harassment, is different. But even so, it’s still often not what happened, but who did it.
Incidentally, paedophile is spelt thus: pedophile is someone who is sexually attracted to feet. I’m not too sure that is what people mean. If you are, there are good treatments for athletes’ … But I digress.
Last edited: