Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

I think I have a problem with all of this. It is “define abuse”.

I think most of us would agree that a thirty year old of either sex becoming sexually involved with a ten year old of the same (or other) sex would constitute abuse. Catholic priest or not.

But, at the other end of the spectrum, suppose we have two seven year olds playing “I’ll show you mine if you show me yours”. Is this abuse? Or two eleven year olds doing the same? Or a sixteen year old and an eleven year old. Or a seventeen year old and a fourteen year old groping each other behind the (proverbial) bike shed? In all cases of either (or same) sex and who was older.

What about a 40 year old mother of three propositioning a 19 year old male? Who would have been a lucky boy? I really regret I had move away to go back to work. I could have had some real fun for a few weeks. Assault? Abuse? Use your imagination.

The point I am trying to make is that at the extremes we all are likely to agree. It’s just that there is a large area in the middle – mainly the teenage years and below – where it is not so clear.

OK, sexual assault, like sexual harassment, is different. But even so, it’s still often not what happened, but who did it.

Incidentally, paedophile is spelt thus: pedophile is someone who is sexually attracted to feet. I’m not too sure that is what people mean. If you are, there are good treatments for athletes’ … But I digress.
 
Last edited:
That's like saying Penn State didn't care one way or the other if molestation was occurring or not.
Yes. And? At least the managers of Penn State had the decency to step down in shame. And various Penn State officials are being prosecuted.

Which bishop has stepped down? Or has been prosecuted? I really hope some DA in a European country has the balls to put out a European arrest warrant for Ratzi; the Italian police know exactly when he's leaving the Vatican.

And the Penn State scandal occurred "after" all the priest scandal publicity.
Lying for Jeebus again?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penn_State_child_sex_abuse_scandal:
Based on an extensive grand jury investigation, Sandusky was indicted in 2011 on 52 counts of child molestation dating from 1994 to 2009, though the abuse may have dated as far back as the 1970.
 
I think I have a problem with all of this. It is “define abuse”.

In some countries/states (including Canada), where there is a power imbalance, any sexual activity is considered to be abuse until proven otherwise. And most countries have laws that draw lines to answer your questions about youngsters of various ages 11-19. That, of course, is only the legalistic answer. The moral dimension of the issue is separate.

Incidentally, paedophile is spelt thus: pedophile is someone who is sexually attracted to feet.

British vs. North American spelling.

And, of course, it is not a criminal offense to be a p(a)edophile. It is a criminal offense to act on p(a)edophilic impulses.
 
The St. Louis Archdiocese had a special fund for settling cases out of court and had a practice of simply re-assigning the alleged perps to other parishes. This of course was going on long before the issue was in the news.
They had standard practices in place that had the effect of encouraging pedophiles to go unreported and unpunished.
...
That's exactly what they did for as long as they could.


See the pattern here? The OP asked: "Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?"

All of the answers, even the most vehement ones, argue about what the Catholic Churth did, not what it is doing now.

Imagine someone saying, "Don't use Loss Leader as your attorney, he is not even toilet trained." Yes, there was a time in the past when I was not toilet trained, but that was forty years ago. The statement is not true about me today.

I believe that if you want to accuse the Church of having an ongoing issue, one should have at least some evidence that the issue is still going on. Instead, I think that the evidence shows that the Church (at least in western nations) is now addressing the matter.

And all of that is before we even discuss whether the past behavior of Church officials constituted a "culture".
 
It all depends on context. If you are telling this to a little old lady referring to a person who she is friends with, and of whom you have zero knowledge of other than the fact the he is a priest, then yes that would be considered an insult. Most priests are not pedophiles. Pretending that all priests are, and that Catholics find child molestation acceptable is going to be insulting to most Catholics.
My personal belief is that any priest who isn't involved directly or indirectly is a very rare bird. The ones that helped cover it up are accessories after the fact, if not simple accessories.
Mentioning the pedophilia scandal might make some Catholics feel uncomfortable. That's too bad.
Silence permits abuse. Insisting it not be talked about helps the pedophiles.
 
My personal belief is that any priest who isn't involved directly or indirectly is a very rare bird. The ones that helped cover it up are accessories after the fact, if not simple accessories.

What do you base this belief on other than a general mistrust of the clergy?


Silence permits abuse. Insisting it not be talked about helps the pedophiles.

In my experience, most catholics don't insist on not talking about it.
 
Last edited:
See the pattern here? The OP asked: "Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?"

The only way to know if the statement offends all catholics, is if you ask all catholics.

All of the answers, even the most vehement ones, argue about what the Catholic Churth did, not what it is doing now.

Yes, the church considered it's public image, how it looked to people, more important than the heinous crime of molesting children. That is a fact. Do you have some information that tells us what all the catholic churches are doing today, this hour about that? Please share.

Imagine someone saying, "Don't use Loss Leader as your attorney, he is not even toilet trained." Yes, there was a time in the past when I was not toilet trained, but that was forty years ago. The statement is not true about me today.

If I find out you were a dirty lawyer before, it is definitely going to influence my choosing you to represent me. That is a fact.

I believe that if you want to accuse the Church of having an ongoing issue, one should have at least some evidence that the issue is still going on. Instead, I think that the evidence shows that the Church (at least in western nations) is now addressing the matter.

Please present that evidence.

And all of that is before we even discuss whether the past behavior of Church officials constituted a "culture".

The past history of the catholic church has more bloodshed, crime, greed, avarice, coveteousness, than most histories I know. And that is a fact everybody here knows. That information is freely available.
 
Last edited:
I mentioned the pedophilia scandal on another forum and got some angry replies that I was "insulting all Catholics everywhere" by even mentioning it. I'm fairly certain I'm not insulting the little old lady down the street by mentioning that her priest shouldn't be left alone with small children, but I may be wrong, (first time for anything, I guess :D ). So what do you think? Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?

The "circle-the-wagons" mentality exists in every organization.

Throw in religious faith and you get a constituency ready to fight at the drop of a hat.

I don't believe you've insulted anyone in a wholesale fashion.
 
They want to be able to ignore their support for an organization that aids and abeds child rape. You are making that difficult by pointing this out. Shame on you for making them feel guilty.

oh the irony! Someone outside the church is making them feel guilt.
 
I mentioned the pedophilia scandal on another forum and got some angry replies that I was "insulting all Catholics everywhere" by even mentioning it. I'm fairly certain I'm not insulting the little old lady down the street by mentioning that her priest shouldn't be left alone with small children, but I may be wrong, (first time for anything, I guess :D ). So what do you think? Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?

Yes, because it assumes that all, most or many Catholic priests are pedophiles and that there is a widespread organized practice of protecting and shielding such activities from legal authorities and parishioners by all church officials and hierarchy.

This quite simply is inaccurate and without evidenciary support. I have not seen any evidence that indicates that pedophilia among priests even rises to the level that such exists among the general population, yet alone that it exceeds that rate.

Personally, I usually take little offense at such, because I understand that in general such statements are usually borne of ignorance, prejudice and/or simple-minded disconnect from reasoned consideration.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like Penn State.
DOC, I agree. Penn State, like the catholic church, is guilty of protecting a child molester. That is evil and unacceptable.

Such a betrayal of trust is not to be taken lightly. Society should not accept it from anyone. Perhaps if people responded with more consistent outrage with the catholic church, Penn State would not have made the decisions they made.
 
Yes, because it assumes that all, most or many Catholic priests are pedophiles and that there is a widespread organized practice of protecting and shielding such activities from legal authorities and parishioners by all church officials and hierarchy.

This quite simply is inaccurate and without evidenciary support. I have not seen any evidence that indicates that pedophilia among priests even rises to the level that such exists among the general population, yet alone that it exceeds that rate.

Personally, I usually take little offense at such, because I understand that in general such statements are usually borne of ignorance, prejudice and/or simple-minded disconnect from reasoned consideration.

Don't you find it strange that we are even having a conversation about a church, it's priests, and child molestation. You would think there would be no such conection at all.

The actual reality is sad.
 
I
Incidentally, paedophile is spelt thus: pedophile is someone who is sexually attracted to feet. I’m not too sure that is what people mean. If you are, there are good treatments for athletes’ … But I digress.

That is simply the difference between Brit. and U.S. English - pedophile and paedophile are the same. The foot thing is podophile --think pediatrition (children doctor) v. podiatrist (foot doctor). And for first (and only I am giving): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foot_fetishism
 
Don't you find it strange that we are even having a conversation about a church, it's priests, and child molestation. You would think there would be no such conection at all.

The actual reality is sad.

It is sad that the affliction is prevalent enough throughout our species as to have a commonly recognized set of terms to describe the behavior, but it is a part of the human condition and regardless of the spiritual devotion of those who attempt to dedicate their lives to the promotion of principles of Christianity (or any other spiritual system of moral guidance and support) priests, like all the rest of us, are human, and subject to human weaknesses and frailties. As stated before, I would be surprised if there were a significantly higher proportion of pedophiles in the priesthood than there is in the general US population, but I would be surprised if any human behavioral misfunction was completely absent expression within the what, half million (give or take) priests in the world.
 
I believe that if you want to accuse the Church of having an ongoing issue, one should have at least some evidence that the issue is still going on. Instead, I think that the evidence shows that the Church (at least in western nations) is now addressing the matter.
I don't know about the "Church" but the LA diocese does not appear to be addressing the problem:

Files for 122 priests were made public last month by court order after priests fought for five years to keep them sealed.
Mahoney, the archbishop, recently retired and is living the life of Riley with no punishment at all ... well, ok, the current archbishop says he can't say mass anymore. Big freakin' deal. One of his chief aides and the overseer of the churches in my home town retired a week or so ago and has suffered no punishment at all.

Yeah, yeah, there's been a lot of publicity about old cases. But at least locally I see no real engagement in changing organizational behavior. To be blunt, a manhole cover may have been lifted but there's still a lot of **** down in the sewer.
 
Perhaps LA is not addressing it, but I can assure you that my diocese (the diocese of Bridgeport, CT) is. Anyone who so much as volunteers in the church, in any capacity whatsoever, is required to take four hours of training re: child abuse, watching for signs of child abuse, how to report child abuse, who to report it to in the diocese after notifying the police, yada yada yada. All I do is sing in the damn church choir, and I had to take the training.
 
If one wants to say that the higher reaches of the church knew there were abuses and did not act upon them appropriately, then say that. Implying that the problem is ongoing and that it is somehow ingrained in the "culture" of the church is a conclusion - and an insulting one.

This is what I'm talking about. You have the right to feel insulted. So do the rest of us. Insulted that this has been condoned for hundreds of years.
 
My personal belief is that any priest who isn't involved directly or indirectly is a very rare bird...
Here is part of a blog from a Catholic priest who at the beginning of it acknowledges a grave evil is committed whenever a child is abused, especially by a member of the clergy.

From fatherfladerblog

...we should never forget that it is a very small percentage of priests who have abused their ministry. The second report of the John Jay College of Criminal Justice into sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in the U.S. reported that in the period 1950-2010 there had been accusations of sexual abuse against only 5% of priests, and that less than 4% of these involved paedophilia. The report acknowledged that the rate of abuse by clergy is lower than that in comparable professions... Fifth, at the time that most of the offences occurred, many years ago, neither the Church nor people in secular society understood, as we do today, the seriousness of paedophilia as a mental condition that is not easily treated. The tendency then was to regard it as an isolated case of sexual weakness, for which the perpetrator had repented and was resolved not to commit it again, and so the priest was simply moved to a different parish where he could begin his new life of chastity in different surroundings. This was gravely mistaken but those who responded in that way were usually acting in good faith and cannot be judged by standards that have changed in the light of new findings.

http://fatherfladerblog.wordpress.com/2013/01/26/the-clergy-sexual-abuse-scandal/
 
Last edited:
Here is part of a blog from a Catholic priest who at the beginning of it acknowledges a grave evil is committed whenever a child is abused, especially by a member of the clergy.

From fatherfladerblog

...we should never forget that it is a very small percentage of priests who have abused their ministry. The second report of the John Jay College of Criminal Justice into sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in the U.S. reported that in the period 1950-2010 there had been accusations of sexual abuse against only 5% of priests, and that less than 4% of these involved paedophilia. The report acknowledged that the rate of abuse by clergy is lower than that in comparable professions... Fifth, at the time that most of the offences occurred, many years ago, neither the Church nor people in secular society understood, as we do today, the seriousness of paedophilia as a mental condition that is not easily treated. The tendency then was to regard it as an isolated case of sexual weakness, for which the perpetrator had repented and was resolved not to commit it again, and so the priest was simply moved to a different parish where he could begin his new life of chastity in different surroundings. This was gravely mistaken but those who responded in that way were usually acting in good faith and cannot be judged by standards that have changed in the light of new findings.

http://fatherfladerblog.wordpress.com/2013/01/26/the-clergy-sexual-abuse-scandal/

Ah, a disinterested and objective source. Thanks for that. :rolleyes:
 
The second report of the John Jay College of Criminal Justice into sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in the U.S. reported that in the period 1950-2010 there had been accusations of sexual abuse against only 5% of priests, and that less than 4% of these involved paedophilia.
by your report, 1 in 20 priests are accused of sexual abuse.
Man, that's worse than I thought.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom