Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

You are not insulting. You are simply speaking the facts.


How is a "willful culture of pedophilia" a fact and not a conclusion?

I doubt you could find two people who even agree on what "culture" means in that context. Is pedophilia mandatory? Is it encouraged? Is it considered by the church to somehow be a ritual that all holy people must perform?

And what does the word "willful" mean when it modifies "culture"? How do we know the difference between a willful culture and a willingless one?

If one wants to say that the higher reaches of the church knew there were abuses and did not act upon them appropriately, then say that. Implying that the problem is ongoing and that it is somehow ingrained in the "culture" of the church is a conclusion - and an insulting one.
 
How is a "willful culture of pedophilia" a fact and not a conclusion?

I doubt you could find two people who even agree on what "culture" means in that context. Is pedophilia mandatory? Is it encouraged? Is it considered by the church to somehow be a ritual that all holy people must perform?

And what does the word "willful" mean when it modifies "culture"? How do we know the difference between a willful culture and a willingless one?

If one wants to say that the higher reaches of the church knew there were abuses and did not act upon them appropriately, then say that. Implying that the problem is ongoing and that it is somehow ingrained in the "culture" of the church is a conclusion - and an insulting one.

Yea it isn't like senior catholic psychologists argue that the boy seduced the priests because they had a hole that needed filling in a totally heterosexual way. Well appart from that one...

A great number of them are accomplices to child rape.
 
Yea it isn't like senior catholic psychologists argue that the boy seduced the priests because they had a hole that needed filling in a totally heterosexual way. Well appart from that one...

Which, again, is because their main priority is finding a way to absolve and protect the organization at any cost, not because the Church's "culture" is all about promoting and practicing pedophilia.

What the Church hierarchy has done (and is still doing) in the service of that priority is horrific and blameworthy enough as it is, without having to make stuff up about it.
 
Last edited:
If one wants to say that the higher reaches of the church knew there were abuses and did not act upon them appropriately, then say that. Implying that the problem is ongoing and that it is somehow ingrained in the "culture" of the church is a conclusion - and an insulting one.

The higher reaches of the church knew there were abuses and did not act upon them appropriately!

Happy?

Is it insulting to say you have a booger on your face?

If I find out someone is sexually molesting someone, and I don't say anything, and in fact try to hide that blemish, I am in fact guilty of aiding the perpetrator.

It is not just. It is not right. It is a fact.

I myself, was abused.
 
If I find out someone is sexually molesting someone, and I don't say anything, and in fact try to hide that blemish, I am in fact guilty of aiding the perpetrator.

And if you do that, are you doing it because you're really all about promoting and encouraging sexual molestation in general in the group you both belong to, or are you doing it because you want to protect the group you both belong to from potential PR and legal liabilities if what that person did is exposed?

Is it insulting to say you have a booger on your face?

It probably is if you're accusing the person with the booger on their face of putting it there on purpose because they belong to a culture that promotes and enables facial-booger-wearing.
 
Last edited:
I mentioned the pedophilia scandal on another forum and got some angry replies that I was "insulting all Catholics everywhere" by even mentioning it. I'm fairly certain I'm not insulting the little old lady down the street by mentioning that her priest shouldn't be left alone with small children, but I may be wrong, (first time for anything, I guess :D ). So what do you think? Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?


I think just the opposite: the actions of bishops and others in the church hierarchy to hide and shelter its pedophiles should be considered insulting to Catholics everywhere.

I consider how hard my parents worked to make their contributions to the Church and the millions of dollars that went to settling claims in order to keep pedophiles in the dark and thus away from criminal prosecution. I find it somewhat amazing that so many Catholics are still willing to trust these evil people with their money.
 
Last edited:
And if you do that, are you doing it because you're really all about promoting and encouraging sexual molestation in general in the group you both belong to, or are you doing it because you want to protect the group you both belong to from potential PR and legal liabilities if what that person did is exposed?

I do it because my conscience tells me it's wrong to do otherwise.

I don't want people hurt, or to have to deal with the shame and guilt such things inevitably bring with them.

Can you understand where I am coming from?
 
I do it because my conscience tells me it's wrong to do otherwise.

I don't want people hurt, or to have to deal with the shame and guilt such things inevitably bring with them.

Yes, and the fact that the Catholic hierarchy is apparently dedicated to putting the "good name" and legal inviolability of the Church and its clergy over and above those things is more than enough reason to excoriate it.

There's no need to accuse them of doing what they're doing because they have an "organized and willful culture of pedophilia" and want to promote and enable pedophilia on top of that.
 
The higher reaches of the church knew there were abuses and did not act upon them appropriately!

Indeed. The St. Louis Archdiocese had a special fund for settling cases out of court and had a practice of simply re-assigning the alleged perps to other parishes. This of course was going on long before the issue was in the news.
 
There's no need to accuse them of doing what they're doing because they have an "organized and willful culture of pedophilia" and want to promote and enable pedophilia on top of that.

So the controversy here is over whether or not that particular phrase is justified?

It's not one I'd use, but it's certainly defensible. They had standard practices in place that had the effect of encouraging pedophiles to go unreported and unpunished. I'm not sure what else a "willful culture of" something is other than knowingly and intentionally establishing conditions under your control that encourage the continuation of that something.

That's exactly what they did for as long as they could.
 
So the controversy here is over whether or not that particular phrase is justified?

If the overall question is whether it's insulting to Catholics (potentially up to the "all Catholics everywhere" criteria), yes. It's the difference between "members of the Church let kids get abused because they were more concerned with the reputation of the Church than crimes against children" and "members of the Church let kids get abused because they deliberately wanted kids to get abused."

One is a harsh truth that will probably provoke a defensive reaction but isn't actually an insult. The other is intentionally insulting and inflammatory.

I'm not sure what else a "willful culture of" something is other than knowingly and intentionally establishing conditions under your control that encourage the continuation of that something.

Because the Church was not establishing those conditions because they wanted priests to keep molesting children. They apparently didn't care whether the priests kept doing, or stopped doing it. All they cared about was that word of what those priests were doing did not get out in order to protect the Church as a whole. That what those priests were doing was child molestation and rape was completely irrelevant to the Church - all the hierarchy cared about was that the Church didn't look bad in public and have secular legal authorities breathing down its neck.

And that's plenty evil enough for me.

[EDIT: As I said, if you want to be deliberately insulting, that's one thing. What the hierarchy is doing certainly merits that kind of angry response. I just think that you should be aware that that's what you are doing, because I'm pretty sure that using the phrasing "the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof" is not going to be very conducive to a reasonable and productive discussion about the Church abuse scandal, especially a discussion involving members of the Church (lay or otherwise).
 
Last edited:
That's not the point.

The point is that the Catholic church protected their pedophiles from the police and from public scrutiny, and often sent them to new parishes full of new victims.

Sure, there's pedophiles amongst the teachers, the boy scout leaders, the librarians, the parents, the doctors, and the rest of us. But most of these groups would turn in a pedophile at the first accusation.

Maybe after the priest scandal they would (with Penn State being an exception), but I certainly don't believe that was the case before the scandal.

http://www.startribune.com/local/minneapolis/169053916.html?refer=y

And although the scandal was very bad, I think the media had a feeding frenzy with it while hypocritically at the same time they said very little about the "overall" national teacher sex abuse problem. Sure they might play up an individual case or two that has a very attractive teacher or a Joe Paterno, but I've heard almost nothing about it as an overall national problem when in fact it was a very serious problem.

http://archive.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2004/4/5/01552.shtml
 
Last edited:
Because the Church was not establishing those conditions because they wanted priests to keep molesting children. They apparently didn't care whether the priests kept doing, or stopped doing it. All they cared about was that word of what those priests were doing did not get out in order to protect the Church as a whole. That what those priests were doing was child molestation and rape was completely irrelevant to the Church - all the hierarchy cared about was that the Church didn't look bad in public and have secular legal authorities breathing down its neck.
I think it's a bit worse than that. I won't say the RCC wanted priests to molest children. But they didn't care one iota about the molest - except for their own reputation. As far as I'm aware, each and every molesting priest was relocated to another parish, and let loose on an unknown and unsuspecting new set of future victims. No-one at the new parish knew, and no-one kept any measure of oversight. If the RCC hierarchy had cared one bit for the children in their flock, they'd have put these priests simply on non-active, or they'd have relocated them to a desk job at the episcopal palace or some such, where they could do no harm. But instead, they facilitated the molest by giving the offenders new targets. An notorious example is that of Peter Hullermann, where Ratzinger carries personal responsibility for implementing this policy.
 
I think it's a bit worse than that. I won't say the RCC wanted priests to molest children. But they didn't care one iota about the molest - except for their own reputation.

Exactly. As long as what was happening could be kept from putting the reputation of the Church in danger and the secular authorities kept out of Church affairs, the hierarchy was entirely indifferent to what was happening. They simply did not care one way or the other if molestation was occurring or not.
 
I mentioned the pedophilia scandal on another forum and got some angry replies that I was "insulting all Catholics everywhere" by even mentioning it. I'm fairly certain I'm not insulting the little old lady down the street by mentioning that her priest shouldn't be left alone with small children, but I may be wrong, (first time for anything, I guess :D ). So what do you think? Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?

Not as long as they don't support the pedos - if they do, then you are but they richly deserve it.........
 
They simply did not care one way or the other if molestation was occurring or not.
That's like saying Penn State didn't care one way or the other if molestation was occurring or not. And the Penn State scandal occurred "after" all the priest scandal publicity.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom