Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

There we have it, folks, Yeahbutism at its best. This is why I have no respect for Catholics who aren't trying to get rid of their local pedos.

So this is an argument you're making here? Is this critical thinking? No wonder I suck at it, I've been trying to construct arguments based on fact.

Oh, just out of curiosity (I know, another question you'll likely ignore but I'll give it a shot anyway), since most priests aren't pedos, then most parishes don't actually need to get rid of them, are they still idiots if they don't try?
 
Last edited:
Oh, just out of curiosity (I know, another question you'll likely ignore but I'll give it a shot anyway), since most priests aren't pedos, then most parishes don't actually need to get rid of them, are they still idiots if they don't try?

It's looking that way, isn't it.
Very strange thinking
 
There we have it, folks, Yeahbutism at its best. This is why I have no respect for Catholics who aren't trying to get rid of their local pedos.

So, could you name any Catholics anywhere who aren't trying to get rid of their local pedos? Can you point to any instance of any Catholics anywhere who say that it's ok that their priests are pedophiles?

And, more directly to the point of the OP, you are calling people idiots if they support the Catholic Church. You are also saying that by supporting the church they are partially responsible* for the abuse. Surely you acknowledge that this is insulting them. So, the answer to your question from the OP is "yes". There's no need for me or anyone else to explain it to you, you have explained it to us.


*In your exact words, they are "giving their tacit approval".
 
Last edited:
So, could you name any Catholics anywhere who aren't trying to get rid of their local pedos? Can you point to any instance of any Catholics anywhere who say that it's ok that their priests are pedophiles?

And, more directly to the point of the OP, you are calling people idiots if they support the Catholic Church. You are also saying that by supporting the church they are partially responsible* for the abuse. Surely you acknowledge that this is insulting them. So, the answer to your question from the OP is "yes". There's no need for me or anyone else to explain it to you, you have explained it to us.


*In your exact words, they are "giving their tacit approval".

And they are. They don't care enough to shake up the church, the church is trying to get away with doing the absolute least it can do and they support that. Because they actually offer support to the church.

They have a choice and they choose to support the church, so therefor they are partially responsible for its actions.
 
And they are. They don't care enough to shake up the church, the church is trying to get away with doing the absolute least it can do and they support that. Because they actually offer support to the church.

They have a choice and they choose to support the church, so therefor they are partially responsible for its actions.

I don't disagree.
 
I don't disagree.

Why is being responsible for something ongoing and giving tacit approval of it so different? They know what the church does and choose to not leave over this, so we assume some degree of apathy over these actions.
 
They could vote with their feet if nothing else.

I know several posters have mentioned that walking away is not the same for a Catholic as a Protestant, but I suspect that those who don't quite see the the difference don't understand the source of the difference. To oversimplify in what I hope is a useful way, Protestants and Catholics have completely different views of what Jesus' fundamental legacy was. To a Protestant, it's the New Testament; that seems to be easy for modern types to get. To a Catholic (and the Orthodox churches), it's the institution of the church itself in all its parts, including its teachings, but particularly including the laity.

This idea of the church as at the core has interesting results. For instance, it's perfectly possible to be an anticlerical Catholic. Central America had lots of that. Also. there's a long history of Catholics thinking that constant activism by the laity is necessary to keep corruption from getting entrenched at the top. It also explains how a modern person can be a heretical Catholic, and not simply be an apostate.

Personally, I think the reforming types are fighting a losing battle. What has occurred in the Catholic Church is something that could occur in any rigid hierarchy. Religious hierarchies are surely particularly prone to this though, with the near-reverence given the anointed class. Judaism as whole is largely decentralized. I know that there have been sporadic instances of child-molesting Rabbis throughout all the divisions of Judaism. The centralized and hierarchical Hasidic sects seem to be the ones with institutional concealment issues. (I know that the situation with Hasidim is not completely comparable, but it does have some parallels.)

(I'm probably posting and running today. I still think it's worth pointing out that many atheists have unconsciously absorbed a Protestant, and often specifically fundamentalist, view of what christianity is supposed to look like.)
 
I know several posters have mentioned that walking away is not the same for a Catholic as a Protestant, but I suspect that those who don't quite see the the difference don't understand the source of the difference. To oversimplify in what I hope is a useful way, Protestants and Catholics have completely different views of what Jesus' fundamental legacy was.

The Lutheran church in the area where I grew up didn't at all. In fact, when we were in the Boy Scouts, we had a church weekend, where we attended both a catholic mass and then the Lutheran service. They were very similar in lots of ways. They typically had the same readings, even!

The biggest difference was in how they viewed communion, with the Lutheran church not taking the "body and blood of christ" thing literally. Also, the Lutherans didn't have the stringent rules, like the no contraception and you have to attend services every week. It was basically a more liberal version of catholicism.
 
Why is being responsible for something ongoing and giving tacit approval of it so different? They know what the church does and choose to not leave over this, so we assume some degree of apathy over these actions.

Which part of "I don't disagree" did you fail to comprehend?
 
So you agree that they do give tacit approval then?

Yes.




There's a bit of an asterisk involved, because there has been some question begging in some of the previous posts, going all the way back to the OP. The people of the Catholic Church give their tacit approval to the activities of the Catholic Church. That doesn't mean they give their tacit approval to everything done by every priest, nor even to everything done by every Pope.

For example, in the case of sexual abuse by priests, I don't think anyone in the Church gives tacit approval to sexual abuse by priests. However, I think the sexual abuse by priests, rare as it may be, is a symptom of the Catholic Church's teachings on sexuality and the institution of priestly celibacy. Those teachings are things that the laity do give their tacit, and sometimes explicit, approval, and to the extent that those teaching contribute to the problem, the laity must take some responsibility.

Put slightly differently, I think there are a lot of teachings of the Catholic Church that are just moonbat crazy. In saying that, I have insulted each and every Catholic in the world, and I would never deny doing it. When it comes to sexual abuse by priests, I think those moonbat crazy teachings create, unintentionally, an environment where sexual abuse is practically guaranteed. In saying that, I am, once again, insulting every Catholic in the world.

Recognizing that I am doing so, I generally keep my mouth shut about those opinions unless I'm in a place where ridiculing religion is considered acceptable. I would never spout off like that around ordinary citizens. Here on JREF, though, I feel much safer insulting Catholics.

And please don't tell my mother I said this. She's Catholic, and in my opinion, a fairly nice, intelligent, person. Like most Catholics.
 
Yes.




There's a bit of an asterisk involved, because there has been some question begging in some of the previous posts, going all the way back to the OP. The people of the Catholic Church give their tacit approval to the activities of the Catholic Church. That doesn't mean they give their tacit approval to everything done by every priest, nor even to everything done by every Pope.

For example, in the case of sexual abuse by priests, I don't think anyone in the Church gives tacit approval to sexual abuse by priests. However, I think the sexual abuse by priests, rare as it may be, is a symptom of the Catholic Church's teachings on sexuality and the institution of priestly celibacy. Those teachings are things that the laity do give their tacit, and sometimes explicit, approval, and to the extent that those teaching contribute to the problem, the laity must take some responsibility.

Put slightly differently, I think there are a lot of teachings of the Catholic Church that are just moonbat crazy. In saying that, I have insulted each and every Catholic in the world, and I would never deny doing it. When it comes to sexual abuse by priests, I think those moonbat crazy teachings create, unintentionally, an environment where sexual abuse is practically guaranteed. In saying that, I am, once again, insulting every Catholic in the world.

Recognizing that I am doing so, I generally keep my mouth shut about those opinions unless I'm in a place where ridiculing religion is considered acceptable. I would never spout off like that around ordinary citizens. Here on JREF, though, I feel much safer insulting Catholics.

And please don't tell my mother I said this. She's Catholic, and in my opinion, a fairly nice, intelligent, person. Like most Catholics.

So, you support your Mother, that makes you a Pedophile apologist![/tsig]
 
Yes.




There's a bit of an asterisk involved, because there has been some question begging in some of the previous posts, going all the way back to the OP. The people of the Catholic Church give their tacit approval to the activities of the Catholic Church. That doesn't mean they give their tacit approval to everything done by every priest, nor even to everything done by every Pope.

For example, in the case of sexual abuse by priests, I don't think anyone in the Church gives tacit approval to sexual abuse by priests. However, I think the sexual abuse by priests, rare as it may be, is a symptom of the Catholic Church's teachings on sexuality and the institution of priestly celibacy. Those teachings are things that the laity do give their tacit, and sometimes explicit, approval, and to the extent that those teaching contribute to the problem, the laity must take some responsibility.

Put slightly differently, I think there are a lot of teachings of the Catholic Church that are just moonbat crazy. In saying that, I have insulted each and every Catholic in the world, and I would never deny doing it. When it comes to sexual abuse by priests, I think those moonbat crazy teachings create, unintentionally, an environment where sexual abuse is practically guaranteed. In saying that, I am, once again, insulting every Catholic in the world.

Recognizing that I am doing so, I generally keep my mouth shut about those opinions unless I'm in a place where ridiculing religion is considered acceptable. I would never spout off like that around ordinary citizens. Here on JREF, though, I feel much safer insulting Catholics.

And please don't tell my mother I said this. She's Catholic, and in my opinion, a fairly nice, intelligent, person. Like most Catholics.

Then why take issue with the statement about their tacit approval?
 
Yes.




There's a bit of an asterisk involved, because there has been some question begging in some of the previous posts, going all the way back to the OP. The people of the Catholic Church give their tacit approval to the activities of the Catholic Church. That doesn't mean they give their tacit approval to everything done by every priest, nor even to everything done by every Pope.

For example, in the case of sexual abuse by priests, I don't think anyone in the Church gives tacit approval to sexual abuse by priests. However, I think the sexual abuse by priests, rare as it may be, is a symptom of the Catholic Church's teachings on sexuality and the institution of priestly celibacy. Those teachings are things that the laity do give their tacit, and sometimes explicit, approval, and to the extent that those teaching contribute to the problem, the laity must take some responsibility.

Put slightly differently, I think there are a lot of teachings of the Catholic Church that are just moonbat crazy. In saying that, I have insulted each and every Catholic in the world, and I would never deny doing it. When it comes to sexual abuse by priests, I think those moonbat crazy teachings create, unintentionally, an environment where sexual abuse is practically guaranteed. In saying that, I am, once again, insulting every Catholic in the world.

Recognizing that I am doing so, I generally keep my mouth shut about those opinions unless I'm in a place where ridiculing religion is considered acceptable. I would never spout off like that around ordinary citizens. Here on JREF, though, I feel much safer insulting Catholics.

And please don't tell my mother I said this. She's Catholic, and in my opinion, a fairly nice, intelligent, person. Like most Catholics.

I've been trying to follow this thread and I may have missed this point, but the quoted post from Meadmaker reminded me that what we're dealing with regarding the Catholic church is a few thousand years of confession and the sacredness of that.

So, I can easily see that, according to church doctrine and habit and legal protection, all a priest has to do is to go to confession and follow the rites of contrition that the confessor gives. The church would see that the steps of saving one's immortal soul outweighs any legalities so BAM! instant literal get-out-of-jail-free card. The laity probably sees this differently -- though perhaps not enough to go picket churches or write mass emailings calling for temporal justice to be done in protecting children.

According to this following Catholic website,
http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/religion/re0059.html

"The sacramental seal is inviolable. Quoting Canon 983.1 of the Code of Canon Law, the Catechism states, "...It is a crime for a confessor in any way to betray a penitent by word or in any other manner or for any reason" (No. 2490). A priest, therefore, cannot break the seal to save his own life, to protect his good name, to refute a false accusation, to save the life of another, to aid the course of justice (like reporting a crime), or to avert a public calamity. He cannot be compelled by law to disclose a person's confession or be bound by any oath he takes, e.g. as a witness in a court trial. A priest cannot reveal the contents of a confession either directly, by repeating the substance of what has been said, or indirectly, by some sign, suggestion, or action. A Decree from the Holy Office (Nov. 18, 1682) mandated that confessors are forbidden, even where there would be no revelation direct or indirect, to make any use of the knowledge obtained in the confession that would "displease" the penitent or reveal his identity."​

It may not necessarily be easy to perform the rites of contrition, but I think anyone would be a fool to think they'd be harder than 10 years in prison and a record for life.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom