Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

So it wasn't bad math, just completely irrelevent to the topic of discussion?

Sex abuse is irrelevant to the topic of Pedophelia?:confused:

ETA:
Perhaps you missed my response.
I was simply speaking of the sexual abuse accusations, which is 5% or 1 in 20.

Is it me, but isn't that an insanely high figure for a population who supposedly took a vow of abstinence?


If we look at just pedophile accusations, it would be 1 in 500. Still a crazy high statistic in my book.
 
Last edited:
Yup. This is why it was a hanging offense in the theocracy of colonial Massachusetts merely to be a Quaker. The church elders couldn't abide the idea of someone going around suggesting that people could get their own ideas about religion.

Even to this day! Laughably (in a sardonic fashion), Quaker groups were among the groups targeted by CoIntelPro.
 
Or perhaps it points to a problem with requiring a vow of abstinence.
It is a very telling issue and one that we shouldn't brush away.

I think it is interesting in considering catholic supported "abstinence only" approach to birth control.
we must ask several questions:
1.) how can the catholic church advocate a practice that clearly fails for their own leaders? (one in 50 is a failure in my book)
2.) How could they claim that god advocates a practice that is so clearly doomed to fail?


ETA:
Noticed I said several questions and then only asked two.
So here's one more:
3.) what is the rate of sex abuse in churches that don't rely on celibacy for religious leaders?
 
Last edited:
It is a very telling issue and one that we shouldn't brush away.

I think it is interesting in considering catholic supported "abstinence only" approach to birth control.
we must ask several questions:
1.) how can the catholic church advocate a practice that clearly fails for their own leaders? (one in 50 is a failure in my book)
2.) How could they claim that god advocates a practice that is so clearly doomed to fail?

I'm not certain who's crazier, dogmatic religious institutions, or those who would try to use logic to argue against their dogma?
 
That's how I read that quote too, but the blogger seems to be lying (*). From the wiki page on the report:

So the substantiated percentage of sexual abusers in the American RCC is hardly lower than the estimated percentage of sexual abusers in the population at large.

ETA2: sorry, read that wrong. Substantiated allegations, not substantiated abuse.

(*) IMHO, this is the only mathematically correct way of reading that phrase. If the blogger had been interested in honesty, he would have worded it more carefully. The combination with "very small percentage" supports this reading.

ETA: with some posters, better check their sources before drawing conclusions from it.

And according to the study cited only 6% of those accused (6,700 x .06 =) 402 were convicted or roughly (402/109,694) 0.4% of all priests in the US have actually been found guilty of the sexual abuse of a child (admittedly this gives a pass to some 3000 priests who had died before they could be investigated. but even if the ratios were the same for those priests as it was for the priests who were investigated by roughly doubling these considerations, that would have yeilded (804/109,694) 0.7% of the priests in the US over the 50 years of the study period, or about 7 out of every 1000 priests. Still a very small percentage and much lower than the general population numbers for adult males which varies according to study from 1 in 20 to 1 in 5 depending upon definitions applied.
 
The Church routinely moves priests to avoid their having to face pedophilia charges.

"The Church" doesn't move priests, individual bishops and archbishops are generally the deciders of when and where to move specific individual priests.
 
Yeah, whatever. I do nothing but talk, you know that, you've followed my life enough to see that I'm all talk and no action. Right? RIGHT? Or are you just making bald assertions?

I would never presume to venture into your apparent field of expertise.
 
See the pattern here? The OP asked: "Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?"

All of the answers, even the most vehement ones, argue about what the Catholic Churth did, not what it is doing now.

Imagine someone saying, "Don't use Loss Leader as your attorney, he is not even toilet trained." Yes, there was a time in the past when I was not toilet trained, but that was forty years ago. The statement is not true about me today.

I believe that if you want to accuse the Church of having an ongoing issue, one should have at least some evidence that the issue is still going on. Instead, I think that the evidence shows that the Church (at least in western nations) is now addressing the matter.

And all of that is before we even discuss whether the past behavior of Church officials constituted a "culture".

Yes, the past history is the past history. I'm not arguing about past history. I am saying that it is logically irresponsible to claim that the past history is still going on unless one has present evidence. The past history of the USA includes slavery. It is not a fair statement to say that the US currently has a culture of slavery. Germany does not have a culture of trying to take over the world. France does not have a culture of invading England.

Your parallel of being potty trained is fallacious. Everyone (nearly everyone) gets potty trained in their early childhood. However: once a thief, always a thief as the saying goes. The enablers in the RCC hierarchy - the (arch)bishops and cardinals that covered up the abuse - are still there, and there still are that try to cover it up:
George Pell, Cardinal-Archbishop of Sydney, stated that he hoped the Royal Commission will stop a "smear campaign" against the Catholic Church.
Check out the high rates of abuse in the diocese of Maitland-Newcastle, part of the archdiocese of Sydney, for contrast. And as you can see from the Australian example, not even every western country has had a comprehensive investigation into the abuse.

I think people have every right to speak of the abuse in the present tense as long as there is little to no proof positive that policies actually have changed; for instance, policies as jhunter mentioned, or press reports of priests being prosecuted for abuse after the church had reported them. And I emphatically don't mean by that just words (by the same people that had been covering up just a couple of years ago), but actual actions.

Suppose you had been censured a couple of times by the bar. let's say for overbilling. A client confronts you with that, and asks you how he can trust you. How do you convince him that the leopard has changed its spots?
 
Actually since they knew these decisions would lead to that probable consequence, I think it's easy enough to conclude that this is what they wanted. Maybe they saw it as the lesser evil (in their minds a lesser evil than the PR nightmare that reporting these cases would have caused), but your position relies on their having the power to do something, knowing what the consequence of their decisions would be, yet somehow that consequence not being their intention. I don't think you can make that case.



I think in fact that's exactly what they wanted since they knew with a high degree of confidence that that's what their decisions had led to in the past and would likely do in the future. I don't see how they can claim that hushing up victims with settlements and relocating suspected pedophiles to places that would result in new victims isn't what they intended to do.

It's sort of like saying that a farmer only creates all the conditions for a plant to grow knowing the likely result is for the plant to grow but doesn't intend the plant to grow.

[ETA: At best, your case would depend on believing the people who made these decisions to be completely naive as to one of the primary purposes of bringing criminals to the criminal justice system: to prevent their being able to repeat their offense. In the case of crimes with victims like this, that purpose is to prevent more kids from being abused. But all of the men in authority who made these decisions are educated administrators who are not naive to the secular world. Knowing that their decisions protected suspects from prosecution and insulated them from past accusers was certainly done for the primary purpose of protecting the Church from bad PR, but it had to have been their intention for more kids to be victimized since this was the easily foreseeable consequence of their decisions. ]

The strongest case you can make (which you recognize is itself pretty damning) is that they deemed the intention to allow more children to be abused as the lesser evil.

The bottom line is they were concealing a crime every time they did it, why the immunity from prosecution?
 
Sex abuse is irrelevant to the topic of Pedophelia?:confused:

ETA:
Perhaps you missed my response.

When the topic is pedophelia, quoting or commenting upon a statistic regarding more general sexual abuse, is largely irrelevent to the specific discussion.
 
When the topic is pedophelia, quoting or commenting upon a statistic regarding more general sexual abuse, is largely irrelevent to the specific discussion.
Only if you think the issue is simply a matter of pedophilia rates.
That isn't my problem with this issue. My problem is with the assumed moral authority the position of priest holds. We expect more from that position than any other. So when I hear a rate of 5% accused of sexual abuse, it really brings into stark relief the problem that is at hand.
 
"The Church" doesn't move priests, individual bishops and archbishops are generally the deciders of when and where to move specific individual priests.


You're hiding behind semantics but when defending pedophiles and enablers there isn't much to use.
 
You're hiding behind semantics but when defending pedophiles and enablers there isn't much to use.

Please indicate anywhere that I have defended those who have committed the sexual abuse of minors, or those who acted inappropriately with regards to those abusers. Your accusations with regards to myself and my arguments are inaccurate and libelous.
 
And according to the study cited only 6% of those accused (6,700 x .06 =) 402 were convicted or roughly (402/109,694) 0.4% of all priests in the US have actually been found guilty of the sexual abuse of a child (admittedly this gives a pass to some 3000 priests who had died before they could be investigated. but even if the ratios were the same for those priests as it was for the priests who were investigated by roughly doubling these considerations, that would have yeilded (804/109,694) 0.7% of the priests in the US over the 50 years of the study period, or about 7 out of every 1000 priests. Still a very small percentage and much lower than the general population numbers for adult males which varies according to study from 1 in 20 to 1 in 5 depending upon definitions applied.

You're fiddling with numbers. First of all: the download page for both John Jay reports.

Second, the numbers that were cited by Father Fader's blog were actually from the FIRST John Jay report, and concerned the period 1950-2002, not until 2010.

Third, the 6,700 number is the number of allegations, not the number of priests. From the First John Jay report, page 4:
The total number of priests with allegations of abuse in our survey is 4,392.
[...]
We asked each diocese, eparchy and community for their total number of active priests in this time period. Adding up all their r esponses, there were 109,694 priests reported by dioceses, eparchies and religious communities to have served in their ecclesiastical ministr y from 1950-2002. Using this number, 4.0% of all priests active between 1950 and 2002 had allegations of abuse.
(I haven't found the 6,700 number yet).

Fourth, to the number of criminal investigations, it says on page 7:
To date, the police have been contacted about 1,021 priests with allegations of abuse, or 24% of our total. Nearly all of these reports have led to investigations, and 384 instances have led to criminal charges. Of those priests for whom information about dispositions is available, 252 were convicted and at least 100 of those served time in prison. Thus, 6% of all priests against whom allegations were made were convicted and about 2% received prison sentences to date.

Fifth: could you cite the relevant portions where the numbers you claim are mentioned?

And as you note, many priests had already died. For other allegations the statute of limitations had run out. So the percentage of priests convicted says very little. You should even be wary drawing conclusions from the number of convictions related to the number of police reports, methinks: proof is not easy when it happened years ago and in a one-on-one situation.

But to conclude, let's go back to Father Flader's blog, what he wrote and what DOC cited:
The second report of the John Jay College of Criminal Justice into sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in the U.S. reported that in the period 1950-2010 there had been accusations of sexual abuse against only 5% of priests, and that less than 4% of these involved paedophilia.
This is what the SECOND John Jay report writes about that, on page 3:
Less than 5 percent of the priests with allegations of abuse exhibited behavior consistent with a diagnosis of pedophilia (a psychiatric disorder that is characterized by recurrent fantasies, urges, and behaviors about prepubescent children). Thus, it is inaccurate to refer to abusers as “pedophile priests.”
I'm mighty puzzled, then, why the hell the 95% other priests then couldn't keep their hands off their altar boys, when they weren't pedophiles. And frankly, the reason why they did doesn't matter for the question why the abuse was covered up by the hierarchy. It does matter, on the other hand, for the question how to prevent abuse.
 
"The Church" doesn't move priests, individual bishops and archbishops are generally the deciders of when and where to move specific individual priests.

So what you're saying is that the church hierarchy consists of a basket of apples (the (arch)bishops) and there is the odd good apple in the basket? Because the moving of abusing priests has been done by nearly all of them. Moving priests, BTW, also occurs between dioceses - both with "good" and "bad" priests, so then there are TWO bishops to blame.
 
Only if you think the issue is simply a matter of pedophilia rates.
That isn't my problem with this issue. My problem is with the assumed moral authority the position of priest holds. We expect more from that position than any other. So when I hear a rate of 5% accused of sexual abuse, it really brings into stark relief the problem that is at hand.

Considering that the standard population percentage estimations for adult males runs 4-5 (or more) times higher than 5%, the rate you see exhibits much higher moral regard and consideration. If you expect perfection from human beings, it is your expectations that are too high, not the comparatively low rates of moral turpitude exhibited among the Catholic clergy.
 
Considering that the standard population percentage estimations for adult males runs 4-5 (or more) times higher than 5%, the rate you see exhibits much higher moral regard and consideration. If you expect perfection from human beings, it is your expectations that are too high, not the comparatively low rates of moral turpitude exhibited among the Catholic clergy.
I understand. So there is a rate of pedophelia and sexual abuse that we should accept and we shouldn't be concerned that elements within the church have in the past concealed these occurrences?
 
So what you're saying is that the church hierarchy consists of a basket of apples (the (arch)bishops) and there is the odd good apple in the basket?

Until demonstrated otherwise, the apples should be presumed good (eg "until individual inspection reveals rot").

Because the moving of abusing priests has been done by nearly all of them. Moving priests, BTW, also occurs between dioceses - both with "good" and "bad" priests, so then there are TWO bishops to blame.


Not to say that such has never happened, but this presumes that the dioceses receiving priests are always or usually aware of any ulterior motivations for moving specific priests. I know of no information that clearly supports this in any significant manner. Priests are often shifted around for any number of legitimate reasons, that there may occassionally be an improper reason for a particular transfer does not mean that there is a Church-wide conspiracy of silence. If nothing else, the multiple convictions of priests guilty of this behavior should expose the distortion of such assertions.
 
I understand. So there is a rate of pedophelia and sexual abuse that we should accept and we shouldn't be concerned that elements within the church have in the past concealed these occurrences?

Not at all. Concern about the improper and illegal activities of particular individuals is and should always be of concern, most particularly to Catholic parishioners. But the focus should remain upon the individuals who have actually committed those acts, not broadbrushed into some sort of blanket condemnation of the Church and all the members that make up that church. Nor should it be blown out of proportion with respect to the incidence of these same improper behaviors at a much greater scale throughout broad swaths of our nation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom