And according to the study cited only 6% of those accused (6,700 x .06 =) 402 were convicted or roughly (402/109,694) 0.4% of all priests in the US have actually been found guilty of the sexual abuse of a child (admittedly this gives a pass to some 3000 priests who had died before they could be investigated. but even if the ratios were the same for those priests as it was for the priests who were investigated by roughly doubling these considerations, that would have yeilded (804/109,694) 0.7% of the priests in the US over the 50 years of the study period, or about 7 out of every 1000 priests. Still a very small percentage and much lower than the general population numbers for adult males which varies according to study from 1 in 20 to 1 in 5 depending upon definitions applied.
You're fiddling with numbers. First of all:
the download page for both John Jay reports.
Second, the numbers that were cited by
Father Fader's blog were actually from the FIRST John Jay report, and concerned the period 1950-2002, not until 2010.
Third, the 6,700 number is the number of
allegations, not the number of
priests. From the First John Jay report, page 4:
The total number of priests with allegations of abuse in our survey is 4,392.
[...]
We asked each diocese, eparchy and community for their total number of active priests in this time period. Adding up all their r esponses, there were 109,694 priests reported by dioceses, eparchies and religious communities to have served in their ecclesiastical ministr y from 1950-2002. Using this number, 4.0% of all priests active between 1950 and 2002 had allegations of abuse.
(I haven't found the 6,700 number yet).
Fourth, to the number of criminal investigations, it says on page 7:
To date, the police have been contacted about 1,021 priests with allegations of abuse, or 24% of our total. Nearly all of these reports have led to investigations, and 384 instances have led to criminal charges. Of those priests for whom information about dispositions is available, 252 were convicted and at least 100 of those served time in prison. Thus, 6% of all priests against whom allegations were made were convicted and about 2% received prison sentences to date.
Fifth: could you cite the relevant portions where the numbers you claim are mentioned?
And as you note, many priests had already died. For other allegations the statute of limitations had run out. So the percentage of priests convicted says very little. You should even be wary drawing conclusions from the number of convictions related to the number of police reports, methinks: proof is not easy when it happened years ago and in a one-on-one situation.
But to conclude, let's go back to Father Flader's blog, what he wrote and what DOC cited:
The second report of the John Jay College of Criminal Justice into sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in the U.S. reported that in the period 1950-2010 there had been accusations of sexual abuse against only 5% of priests, and that less than 4% of these involved paedophilia.
This is what the SECOND John Jay report writes about that, on page 3:
Less than 5 percent of the priests with allegations of abuse exhibited behavior consistent with a diagnosis of pedophilia (a psychiatric disorder that is characterized by recurrent fantasies, urges, and behaviors about prepubescent children). Thus, it is inaccurate to refer to abusers as “pedophile priests.”
I'm mighty puzzled, then, why the hell the 95% other priests then couldn't keep their hands off their altar boys, when they weren't pedophiles. And frankly, the reason why they did doesn't matter for the question why the abuse was covered up by the hierarchy. It does matter, on the other hand, for the question how to prevent abuse.