Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

It's a business, and so like an animal that has been wounded. It fights back and defends itself. Like an animal.

That's the thing that surprises me. The leaders of a listed company have every incentive to only look at short-term effects on shareholder value. But you'd think that the church leaders would take the long view, and look at the long-term effects: after all, the RCC exists already nearly 2,000 years and they surely want to extend that at least another 2,000 years? Don't they see the damaging effects of this to their "moral authority", or even just the financial damages? You'd think they'd want to prevent that to re-occur.

They got away with this in the 1950s because (most) people could be pressured into not going to the police, or if they did the police wouldn't believe that that nice pastor had done such nasty things. But that has changed: most people will file charges for child sexual abuse wherever and whenever it occurs, and the police and the prosecutor will take them serious, not to mention that the general population will believe any charge mentioned in the news.
 
That's the thing that surprises me. The leaders of a listed company have every incentive to only look at short-term effects on shareholder value. But you'd think that the church leaders would take the long view, and look at the long-term effects: after all, the RCC exists already nearly 2,000 years and they surely want to extend that at least another 2,000 years? Don't they see the damaging effects of this to their "moral authority", or even just the financial damages? You'd think they'd want to prevent that to re-occur.
You need to factor in the arrogance that comes from working directly for God.
 
Strongly disagree. The church is doing what the many reports have shown it has been doing for decades and that is trying to minimize any harm to the church itself.

So the billions being paid to victims of abuse, the news coverage of defrocked priests being led off to jail, the poisoned public perception of the RCC as evidenced in this very thread... these are not "harmful" to the Church?

To be clear, I am in no way defending pedophilia, pedophiles, or the actions and inactions of the Church hierarchy on this issue. I do, however, take issue with the contention that nothing is being done to stop it or prevent it in the future.
 
So the billions being paid to victims of abuse, the news coverage of defrocked priests being led off to jail, the poisoned public perception of the RCC as evidenced in this very thread... these are not "harmful" to the Church?
After centuries of abuse we're finally getting things done, but the Church is fighting hard to continue doing nothing wherever they can. As long as they could sweep it all under the rug they did nothing.

To be clear, I am in no way defending pedophilia, pedophiles, or the actions and inactions of the Church hierarchy on this issue. I do, however, take issue with the contention that nothing is being done to stop it or prevent it in the future.

Obstructionism continues.

If I were a Catholic parent I would never ever leave my kids alone with a priest.
 
Using the statistics cited earlier in this thread, 2 in 1,000 priests are pedophiles. I'd bet that if you picked 1,000 names of men out of the phone book, you'd get three pedophiles. Granted, any abuse is too much.

None of the kids at my church, over the whole 25+ years that my wife has been there, has ever been molested by a priest. Even when the story broke, and huge settlements were being paid, no one from our parish came forward. As ddt said, the culture has changed from the 1950's or even the 1970's. People do talk about this stuff now, they do come forward when abuse occurs, and they do go to the cops. I think it's probably safer to leave your kids with a priest than it is to leave them in a day-care center.
 
Using the statistics cited earlier in this thread, 2 in 1,000 priests are pedophiles. I'd bet that if you picked 1,000 names of men out of the phone book, you'd get three pedophiles. Granted, any abuse is too much.

None of the kids at my church, over the whole 25+ years that my wife has been there, has ever been molested by a priest. Even when the story broke, and huge settlements were being paid, no one from our parish came forward. As ddt said, the culture has changed from the 1950's or even the 1970's. People do talk about this stuff now, they do come forward when abuse occurs, and they do go to the cops. I think it's probably safer to leave your kids with a priest than it is to leave them in a day-care center.

You guarantee none of them have been molested?
 
I mentioned the pedophilia scandal on another forum and got some angry replies that I was "insulting all Catholics everywhere" by even mentioning it. I'm fairly certain I'm not insulting the little old lady down the street by mentioning that her priest shouldn't be left alone with small children, but I may be wrong, (first time for anything, I guess :D ). So what do you think? Is even mentioning the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof an insult to "all Catholics everywhere"?

Yes.
 
Using the statistics cited earlier in this thread, 2 in 1,000 priests are pedophiles. I'd bet that if you picked 1,000 names of men out of the phone book, you'd get three pedophiles. Granted, any abuse is too much.
Those statistics are misleading. We could have a separate discussion on it, but I have the definite feeling that especially DOC, but also Trakar, only cited these numbers to score and not have an honest discussion.

The bottom line is: the John Jay report had tallied allegations against 5% of the US priests in the 1950-2002 period. That number agrees, IIRC, with numbers from other countries. So you have a 1 in 20 chance that your priest fiddles kids.

The second point is that the second John Jay report said that only 5% of those accused exhibited pedophile tendencies. What the motivation is of the other 95%, I don't know - we could have a separate discussion on that - but whatever the motivation, the result is that your kid is abused.

Arguing from those numbers that RCC priests are better than the average population doesn't work. Trakar himself cited numbers from a general paper on paedophilia that estimates are that around 5% of males have paedophile tendencies, but that most of them don't act on them. IOW: there are lots of priests with paedophile tendencies that haven't acted on them.

So, we could have another discussion on correlation between child sexual abuse and paedophilia, but in the end, what matters is how many priests abuse. And that is 5%.


None of the kids at my church, over the whole 25+ years that my wife has been there, has ever been molested by a priest. Even when the story broke, and huge settlements were being paid, no one from our parish came forward. As ddt said, the culture has changed from the 1950's or even the 1970's. People do talk about this stuff now, they do come forward when abuse occurs, and they do go to the cops. I think it's probably safer to leave your kids with a priest than it is to leave them in a day-care center.
Because day care centers are infiltrated with satanists who initiate the toddles with black masses? :p

Seriously, no, I don't agree. We "just" (well, 2010) had a huge sexual abuse scandal at a daycare center in the Netherlands. The owner of the center instantly went bankrupt. I don't see that happen with the RCC, or with any church for that matter. The other night, a news show revealed that the government inspection agency often announces their inspections of daycare centers beforehand, with the message: don't do that, it doesn't work. The minister promised to look into this and take action.

Daycare centers are, or can be, regulated by law and inspected on their safety measures in all kinds of ways, including proper screening of their employees. The church cannot easily be regulated to do that, and even if the government has that power, the religion aspect means that they're loathe to do that. YMMV, but I think those are general points which apply to any (western) society, be it the Netherlands, the US or any other.
 
Last edited:
Does the 5% statistic of allegations specify allegations of abuse against children? Consider the possibility of these "abuse" cases being, for example, priests becoming involved with adult women (or men) under their pastoral care, which is certainly inappropriate and can be seen as an abuse of trust. Or priests using the confessional as a blackmail/extortion tool. Either of which are reprehensible in the extreme.
 
Overtly supporting it or not, going to the church and sitting on your hands is supporting the institution of pedophilia. I know you don't like that, but reality tends to be rude.

No, that's not reality, that's your arbitrarily severe standard for "collective guilt". By this standard I'm pretty certain you'd be guilty of an abundance of crimes against humanity.
 
Here's your problem. If this is you "mentioning" the sex abuse in the Catholic Church, then you stand a pretty good chance of offending most Catholics. Yeah, false assertions will do that.

Let's see, here's an organization that has enabled pedophiles, you're supporting it therefore you're supporting an organization that enables pedophiles. If that offends people then all they have to do is quit supporting it.
 
But the Church is trying to end the institutional protection. And joesixpack is right; nobody I know supports pedophilia. Hell, my wife's son was an altar boy for 11 years, and if she ever thought one of the priests had tried to molest him, she'd have killed the guy with her bare hands.

If you support the church then you most certainly do support pedophilia. How many of your dollars has gone to buy off victims? Did she ever ask her son?
 
If you support the church then you most certainly do support pedophilia. How many of your dollars has gone to buy off victims? Did she ever ask her son?

This is an absolutely ridiculous assertion. It's difficult to take anyone seriously who makes such a stupid claim. I'm not even going to dignify the rest of your post with a reply.
 
So the billions being paid to victims of abuse, the news coverage of defrocked priests being led off to jail, the poisoned public perception of the RCC as evidenced in this very thread... these are not "harmful" to the Church?

To be clear, I am in no way defending pedophilia, pedophiles, or the actions and inactions of the Church hierarchy on this issue. I do, however, take issue with the contention that nothing is being done to stop it or prevent it in the future.

Lesser of evils explains the actions of the he church so far. The motive for this comes from the harm to the church not from of morality of the church. There is hardly any evidence that such a change has happened for any other reasons. We see plenty of evidence that without exterior pressure there would have been no changes in the church. The RCC first and foremost seeks to protect itself, regardless of the harm that causes to others.
 
This is an absolutely ridiculous assertion. It's difficult to take anyone seriously who makes such a stupid claim. I'm not even going to dignify the rest of your post with a reply.

Are you denying that the church has supported and enabled pedophiles?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom