Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

Explaining why a crime took place is generally construed as a defense for that crime.

Generally construed by whom? People who can't tell the difference between an explanation (saying why something happened) and a defense (saying either that it didn't happen, or that it did happen but it was ok)?
 
Why priests abused kids isn't the question, why it was covered up is.

post 116?

Demonstrated defense of pedophiles.

We all know why it was covered up. ANTpogo answered that question quite well (without defending it, I apparently must add).

And I'm wondering what "demonstrated defense of pedophiles" you could possibly mean. I've reread that post several times and am completely confused as to how it could possibly be read in that way without a total suspension of critical thought.

ETA; After reading it over again I can only conclude that you didn't even read my post or the post to which I was responding. You need to follow that thread of conversation back to the beginning and read it again.

Of course, even giving you the benefit of the doubt and assuming that you didn't read the post before mine, it stretches all credibility that you could ever twist my post into a defense of child abuse. You are either deliberately endeavoring to deceive other readers of this thread as to my position, or you are incapable of understanding straightforward written language.
 
Last edited:
IOW, holding individuals accountable for their actions, is appropriate, holding the entire organization and all of its members accountable for the actions of a miniscule number of the organization's membership acting independently of the organization is inappropriate.
When Morgan Stanley committed investor fraud, the organization was held responsible and fined. When HSBC laundered money, the company was held responsible and fined. And on and on. Only a miniscule number of employees were involved in the crimes.

Tell me why the RCC should be treated any differently.
 
Last edited:
And according to the study cited only 6% of those accused (6,700 x .06 =) 402 were convicted or roughly (402/109,694) 0.4% of all priests in the US have actually been found guilty of the sexual abuse of a child (admittedly this gives a pass to some 3000 priests who had died before they could be investigated. ....
It also gives a bye to the uncountable number where it was too late to prosecute.
 
No person with a normal sex drive takes a vow of abstinence. It's an oxymoron.

Oh they actually do, believe it or not. But it takes years of being shamed for their own very natural desires that leads them try and suppress them and to take a vow of abstinence.
 
When Morgan Stanley committed investor fraud, the organization was held responsible and fined. When HSBC laundered money, the company was held responsible and fined. And on and on. Only a miniscule number of employees were involved in the crimes.

Tell me why the RCC should be treated any differently.

Because there is no similarity or reasonable comparison between the events.
 
Supported pedophiles by your presence.

How so? I don't see how that follows, at all. I was required to go to this training in order to sing in the choir. Nothing to do with supporting pedophiles, at all; in fact, the whole point of the training was to teach us to identify signs of abuse and abusers and who to report same to.

And no, I don't tithe; I'm actually an atheist. I go because (1) I like to sing and (2) Mrs. JHunter1163 is a cradle Catholic and insists we go. It keeps peace in the house.
 
How so? I don't see how that follows, at all. I was required to go to this training in order to sing in the choir. Nothing to do with supporting pedophiles, at all; in fact, the whole point of the training was to teach us to identify signs of abuse and abusers and who to report same to.

And no, I don't tithe; I'm actually an atheist. I go because (1) I like to sing and (2) Mrs. JHunter1163 is a cradle Catholic and insists we go. It keeps peace in the house.

You kind of miss the point there. Attending a church that as pedophilia as an institution is implied support of that church.

I think this is why Defender of the Faith get so obstreperous. They're trying to reconcile their faith with the awful things done under the cover of that faith.
 
You kind of miss the point there. Attending a church that as pedophilia as an institution is implied support of that church.

I think this is why Defender of the Faith get so obstreperous. They're trying to reconcile their faith with the awful things done under the cover of that faith.

Here's your problem. If this is you "mentioning" the sex abuse in the Catholic Church, then you stand a pretty good chance of offending most Catholics. Yeah, false assertions will do that.
 
So if you could explain how pedophilia is an "institution" I would understand how what you're saying is "reality". Saying that there was institutional misconduct in covering up the crime and that perpetrators were sheltered from punishment and arrest by members of an institution does not make the crime "institutional" except in the most equivocal sense. Members of the church do not condone child rape, and I have yet to meet a Catholic who would try to defend it or the actions of the many Bishops who covered it up.

I suspect you don't know many Catholics in real life.
 
So if you could explain how pedophilia is an "institution" I would understand how what you're saying is "reality". Saying that there was institutional misconduct in covering up the crime and that perpetrators were sheltered from punishment and arrest by members of an institution does not make the crime "institutional" except in the most equivocal sense. Members of the church do not condone child rape, and I have yet to meet a Catholic who would try to defend it or the actions of the many Bishops who covered it up.

I suspect you don't know many Catholics in real life.

If you mean "it's not written down in the bylaws", you're right. But the number of cases on the books shows the problem is endemic and institutional. And you do condone child rape if you're not actively trying to end the Church's institutional protectionism. Ignoring the problem isn't making it better, it's just what the pedo expect from church members.
 
But the Church is trying to end the institutional protection. And joesixpack is right; nobody I know supports pedophilia. Hell, my wife's son was an altar boy for 11 years, and if she ever thought one of the priests had tried to molest him, she'd have killed the guy with her bare hands.
 
But the Church is trying to end the institutional protection. And joesixpack is right; nobody I know supports pedophilia. Hell, my wife's son was an altar boy for 11 years, and if she ever thought one of the priests had tried to molest him, she'd have killed the guy with her bare hands.

Overtly supporting it or not, going to the church and sitting on your hands is supporting the institution of pedophilia. I know you don't like that, but reality tends to be rude.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom