Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

Not at all. Concern about the improper and illegal activities of particular individuals is and should always be of concern, most particularly to Catholic parishioners. But the focus should remain upon the individuals who have actually committed those acts, not broadbrushed into some sort of blanket condemnation of the Church and all the members that make up that church. Nor should it be blown out of proportion with respect to the incidence of these same improper behaviors at a much greater scale throughout broad swaths of our nation.

I condemn the actions of a group which acts with presumed moral authority.
They individuals were representatives of the church and therefore their actions reflect the actions of the church.

This condemnation does not extend, however to the church members. Merely leadership.

ETA: if a priest decides to run a soup kitchen. Does he get credit for the good deed, or does the church, or both?
 
Last edited:
Only if you think the issue is simply a matter of pedophilia rates.
That isn't my problem with this issue. My problem is with the assumed moral authority the position of priest holds. We expect more from that position than any other. So when I hear a rate of 5% accused of sexual abuse, it really brings into stark relief the problem that is at hand.

See my post from yesterday.

Remember, the catholic church, as well as the individuals, claim the priests are "called by God" to the priesthood. They are the ones who call it their "calling."

You'd think God would be a little more discriminating against child molestors.

Their "it's no different from the regular population" claims are extremely damaging to their claim of moral authority, as you say, and to their claims of being called by God.
 
I condemn the actions of a group which acts with presumed moral authority.

Your blanket condemnation seems to presume a personal consideration of ultimate moral authority.


They individuals were representatives of the church and therefore their actions reflect the actions of the church.

This condemnation does not extend, however to the church members. Merely leadership.

ETA: if a priest decides to run a soup kitchen. Does he get credit for the good deed, or does the church, or both?

Generally if a priest starts and runs a soup kitchen it is that priest who is considered to be providing a good example of christian kindness and out reach, likewise, when a priest acts on his own to indulge in personal vices or crimes it is that priest who should be held to account for his display counter to good christian values.

When a leader fails it is his to own, unless you can demonstrate official RCC doctrine and tradition that directs actions with regard to such activities, you are merely presuming a conspiracy to act counter to expressed church values and civil law.

Blaming individuals for their indivdual flaws is the appropriate course, until there is evidence that compellingly indicates otherwise.
 
Last edited:
Considering that the standard population percentage estimations for adult males runs 4-5 (or more) times higher than 5%, the rate you see exhibits much higher moral regard and consideration. If you expect perfection from human beings, it is your expectations that are too high, not the comparatively low rates of moral turpitude exhibited among the Catholic clergy.

When the topic is pedophelia, quoting or commenting upon a statistic regarding more general sexual abuse, is largely irrelevent to the specific discussion.

"The Church" doesn't move priests, individual bishops and archbishops are generally the deciders of when and where to move specific individual priests.

Please indicate anywhere that I have defended those who have committed the sexual abuse of minors, or those who acted inappropriately with regards to those abusers. Your accusations with regards to myself and my arguments are inaccurate and libelous.

Hilited.
 

Are you able to read with any sort of comprehension? Could you please defend your assertion that the hilited quotes could be construed as a defense of " those who have committed the sexual abuse of minors" ?

And I still hear crickets chirping as your answer to the last question put to you. Are you avoiding it for a reason?
 
Until demonstrated otherwise, the apples should be presumed good (eg "until individual inspection reveals rot").
Name one good apple in this case. :rolleyes:

Furthermore, that's a nice legal principle for a criminal case, but the fact that the overwhelming majority of bishops did this, does establish it as church policy. Moreover, you conveniently overlook the role of the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith which actively stalled investigation of those few cases it learned of.

Not to say that such has never happened, but this presumes that the dioceses receiving priests are always or usually aware of any ulterior motivations for moving specific priests. I know of no information that clearly supports this in any significant manner. Priests are often shifted around for any number of legitimate reasons, that there may occassionally be an improper reason for a particular transfer does not mean that there is a Church-wide conspiracy of silence.
The receiving bishop, in this case, is responsible for not asking about abuse by the priest that is shifted to his diocese.

If nothing else, the multiple convictions of priests guilty of this behavior should expose the distortion of such assertions.
:confused: We've just seen, going over (part of) the John Jay reports, that there has been a distinctive lack of convictions. You said yourself that there were some 3,000 priests in the USA that had already died without an investigation.
 
Considering that the standard population percentage estimations for adult males runs 4-5 (or more) times higher than 5%, the rate you see exhibits much higher moral regard and consideration. If you expect perfection from human beings, it is your expectations that are too high, not the comparatively low rates of moral turpitude exhibited among the Catholic clergy.

[ citation needed ]
 
See my post from yesterday.

Remember, the catholic church, as well as the individuals, claim the priests are "called by God" to the priesthood. They are the ones who call it their "calling."

You'd think God would be a little more discriminating against child molestors.

Their "it's no different from the regular population" claims are extremely damaging to their claim of moral authority, as you say, and to their claims of being called by God.

if they're no different than the regular population then they need to take off their collars and quit being called "father". No more parking in the "clergy" spaces too.
 
So what you're saying is that the church hierarchy consists of a basket of apples (the (arch)bishops) and there is the odd good apple in the basket? Because the moving of abusing priests has been done by nearly all of them. Moving priests, BTW, also occurs between dioceses - both with "good" and "bad" priests, so then there are TWO bishops to blame.

Moreover, the vatican was aware of what the bishops were doing and didn't put a stop to it.
 
Last edited:
Are you able to read with any sort of comprehension? Could you please defend your assertion that the hilited quotes could be construed as a defense of " those who have committed the sexual abuse of minors" ?

And I still hear crickets chirping as your answer to the last question put to you. Are you avoiding it for a reason?


An insult right out of the gate.

Explaining why a crime took place is generally construed as a defense for that crime.

I certainly hope I haven't come to the "last question" but if you have a specific one then you might repost it as I've looked up this page and haven't seen one.
 
Last edited:
Moreover, the vatican was aware of what the bishops were doing and didn't put a stop to it.

Yeah, I mentioned them in my followup post: the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith. They used to have effective methods, back when they were still called the Inquisition. :rolleyes:
 
The Church, like I said. The lower-level guys eventually make to the upper levels, so saying the lower-level are doing the cover-ups now just means the upper-levels did them 20 years ago. The rot goes to the top.

Exactly, the pope and every level of the hierarchy below him actively engaged in covering up pedophilia but somehow "the Church" wasn't involved.
 
Explaining why a crime took place is generally construed as a defense for that crime.
Firstly, no. Even presuming that this were so there still remains the question of
how any of those hilited quotes explain why some priests sexually abused minors?
I certainly hope I haven't come to the "last question" but if you have a specific one then you might repost it as I've looked up this page and haven't seen one.

Please see post #116
 
There's one what?

Firstly, no. Even presuming that this were so there still remains the question of
how any of those hilited quotes explain why some priests sexually abused minors?


Please see post #116

Why priests abused kids isn't the question, why it was covered up is.

post 116?

Demonstrated defense of pedophiles.
 
Generally if a priest starts and runs a soup kitchen it is that priest who is considered to be providing a good example of christian kindness and out reach, likewise, when a priest acts on his own to indulge in personal vices or crimes it is that priest who should be held to account for his display counter to good christian values.
Do you not see the double standard here?
If his good actions are examples of christian goodness wouldn't he bad actions be an example of christian badness?
You've over extended yourself on this one. You can't possibly believe that a priest's actions doesn't represent the actions of the organization he represents.

That organization attempts to sell moral authority as it's primary product. An immoral action by a leader (that is doubled upon by coverups of other leaders) must represent a rather significant failing of that organizations product.

Let's put it another way. what would the public reaction be if
a Weight loss company branch was selling products that actually were high in fat and made people gain weight? What would the backlash be if it was also discovered that a regional manager knew of this but tried to hide it?
Wouldn't it reflect negatively on the organization as a whole?


When a leader fails it is his to own, unless you can demonstrate official RCC doctrine and tradition that directs actions with regard to such activities, you are merely presuming a conspiracy to act counter to expressed church values and civil law.
I do not need to presume conspiracy. there was cover ups done. It need not reach all the way up to the pope to be a problem for the church.
But, I will say this, The fact that this has happened in multiple parts throughout the world is a rather strong problem for the church.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom