Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

44% have changed religions, 9% of the population is Catholics who have changed religion. But they should trust their religion and learn to not question their moral superiors in the church.

Why be so mad at people who know better than you but not question the part that gives your the belief of them knowing better?

Of course 9% when it is only out of 25% is still nearly 40% of catholics.

What on earth are you talking about there? Who is mad and who knows better than I and what is it that they know better than I? What is it you think I believe anyway?

And back to your statistics, it's pretty evident that Catholics convert at a much lower rate than Protestants, which was the point made by myself and jhunter.
 
From the Wiki article on Catholicism:

The Latin and Eastern Catholic Churches together form the "Catholic Church",[22] or "Roman Catholic Church",[23] the world's largest single religious body and the largest Christian church, comprising over half of all Christians (1.1 billion Christians of 2.1 billion) and nearly one-sixth of the world's population.

The OP better get busy if he's going to insult all 1.1 billion of them.
 
You're forgetting that the RCC isn't a democracy. Priests aren't voted in or out; they are assigned. The congregation has no say whatsoever in which priest is assigned to which parish.

The idea that Catholic congregations "put up with" pedophiles is simply wrong. There's no denying that the hierarchy covered it up; but there is literally nothing that the congregations at large could have done about it.

Really? They can't throw the bums out? Why not? Because the Church says they have to keep a pedophile around their children? Does that make any sense at all to you?
 
What on earth are you talking about there? Who is mad and who knows better than I and what is it that they know better than I? What is it you think I believe anyway?

And back to your statistics, it's pretty evident that Catholics convert at a much lower rate than Protestants, which was the point made by myself and jhunter.

And your evidence for that is what? A lower percent of the population doesn't prove that until we compare it to total percentages.
 
Really? They can't throw the bums out? Why not? Because the Church says they have to keep a pedophile around their children? Does that make any sense at all to you?

Really, they can't, because the Church assigns a priest to a parish. Typically, the assignment will last five to ten years, although it can be more or less. So people may not have suspected that particular priests were pedophiles, because it's not really unusual for priests to be moved from place to place.

That makes absolutely no difference, though, regarding the reprehensible pattern of moving pedophiles from place to place. People in the hierarchy knew and did nothing. That's what needed (and needs) to be stopped.
 
In a larger city, a protestant won't even have to switch denominations, he or she can simply find another pastor at another church that they like more. The RCC is much more hierarchical. Regularly attending a church in a different parish is frowned upon.

There are vanishingly few non-Catholic denominations to which a Catholic could go. I can think of only one (Episcopalian, or "Catholic-Lite" as they're also known).

Oh, there are plenty of breakaway groups who maintain catholic traditions and beliefs, but most of them are pretty small. I mentioned one just above in this thread: the Old Catholic Church, which originated around 1700 in the Netherlands when the Pope accused the apolostic vicar of Utrecht of being a Jansenist and deposed him. They're pretty liberal: ordain women, no celibacy and have no problems with gays. If Latin is more your style (and optionally, Holocaust denial) you could go to the Society of St. Pius X. And there are plenty more groups claiming catholic tradition and apostolic succession:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedevacantist_Roman_Catholic
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakaway_Catholic_Churches
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_Catholic_churches
 
Oh, there are plenty of breakaway groups who maintain catholic traditions and beliefs, but most of them are pretty small. I mentioned one just above in this thread: the Old Catholic Church, which originated around 1700 in the Netherlands when the Pope accused the apolostic vicar of Utrecht of being a Jansenist and deposed him. They're pretty liberal: ordain women, no celibacy and have no problems with gays. If Latin is more your style (and optionally, Holocaust denial) you could go to the Society of St. Pius X. And there are plenty more groups claiming catholic tradition and apostolic succession:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedevacantist_Roman_Catholic
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakaway_Catholic_Churches
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_Catholic_churches

Yeah, plenty of options there for the wandering Catholic, but a couple of problems, not the least of which is there isn't one within a three hours drive of most people. Secondly is the fact that these are schismatic groups who generally have a faith at odds with conventional Catholic doctrine. But this is really not the issue.

Really, the assertion that anyone who self identifies as a Catholic is aiding and abetting pedophile priests is, as I have stated earlier, an arbitrarily severe standard of collective guilt. It's fine to apply that standard with your atheistic supercilious righteous indignation, but that's not what people are like. Many of them are outraged by the scandal, many have and will call the police if they think the parish priest is a pedo, and they're still going to be at mass on Sunday. Get over it. People are not going to play by your rules.
 
That's not what that grid says. It says that 9% of people raised Catholic (not 9% of the US population) have converted to other faiths during their lifetimes. So it's not something that happens a lot, despite your effort to spin it otherwise. To look at it the other way, 91% of people who were born Catholic still identify as Catholic.

ETA: My mistake; it does say that. However, I notice that the sample size isn't exactly vast (less that 1,000 recontact interviews) and many of the people (four in ten) leaving the faith did so because they stopped believing in any God, not just the Catholic one. *raises hand*

There's also this page at Pew which has a larger sample size, 10,545. 32% of Catholics have left: 15% to protestant, 14% to to unaffiliated, 3% to other. So yes, it is quite possible for a catholic to vote with their feet. And frankly, I don't think the average catholic is so high on the finesses of dogma, like what happens at the Eucharist, that that aspect is overriding in their decision to stay in the RCC (or undecision to leave).
 
The ones that put up with this abuse are giving their tacit approval. That's not really hard to figure out, guy.

So, when you bring this up, you are deliberately insulting them, but you take umbrage when they act insulted.
 
Really, they can't, because the Church assigns a priest to a parish. Typically, the assignment will last five to ten years, although it can be more or less. So people may not have suspected that particular priests were pedophiles, because it's not really unusual for priests to be moved from place to place.

That makes absolutely no difference, though, regarding the reprehensible pattern of moving pedophiles from place to place. People in the hierarchy knew and did nothing. That's what needed (and needs) to be stopped.

They could vote with their feet if nothing else.
 
So, you're fine with continuing to support the Church that won't get rid of its pedos and the people who can't figure out what to do about it? Them idiots.

I don't actually support the church, so clearly I'm not "fine" with it. But I'm confused, are Catholics idiots because they take offense or because they don't take offense at your mention of sex abuse? Or are they just all idiots because they still believe in God?

It's funny, and I suppose it's more a reflection of my total lack of brains, but I've met quite a few Catholics (and Protestants, Jews, and Muslims) in my time who didn't impress me as idiots in any way. In fact, I haven't seen a correlation between faith (or its lack) and anything I would consider "intelligence". Or for that matter, "ethics".
 
I don't actually support the church, so clearly I'm not "fine" with it. But I'm confused, are Catholics idiots because they take offense or because they don't take offense at your mention of sex abuse? Or are they just all idiots because they still believe in God?
Is that the best you can do?
It's funny, and I suppose it's more a reflection of my total lack of brains, but I've met quite a few Catholics (and Protestants, Jews, and Muslims) in my time who didn't impress me as idiots in any way. In fact, I haven't seen a correlation between faith (or its lack) and anything I would consider "intelligence". Or for that matter, "ethics".
Does that include the ones that can't figure out that leaving their kids with pedos is not a good idea? Your standards are very low.
 
Is that the best you can do?

Does that include the ones that can't figure out that leaving their kids with pedos is not a good idea? Your standards are very low.

So wait, are all Catholic priests pedophiles? This is news to me. I went to a parochial school and I never got molested. Neither did my brother or sister. Perhaps the risk of sexual abuse in the Catholic schools is no greater than in public schools. You have yet to present any evidence to the contrary.

As far as "the best I could do", I don't actually understand what you're saying there. I asked a question. Do you have an answer?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom