Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

Lesser of evils explains the actions of the he church so far. The motive for this comes from the harm to the church not from of morality of the church. There is hardly any evidence that such a change has happened for any other reasons. We see plenty of evidence that without exterior pressure there would have been no changes in the church. The RCC first and foremost seeks to protect itself, regardless of the harm that causes to others.

But pedophilia has always been against the morality of the church (not to mention of everyone else). There hasn't been a shift because it's always been considered wrong. The change has happened because of publicity, yes; and that is, to my mind, a very good thing. Sunlight is the best of all disinfectants, as they say. What the church did in the past, covering up the problem, was clearly wrong. That's not in dispute. But to say that it's business as usual in the church (especially in the US) after everything that's happened just isn't true. Maybe it's because Americans are more litigious and the church is looking to prevent future huge payouts. Maybe they're trying to insulate themselves from criminal liability. Whatever the cause, there are major changes being made in the church, and anything that makes kids safer I'm all for. Even one pedophile is one too many.
 
Are you denying that the church has supported and enabled pedophiles?

The church is more than priests, or the Pope and cardinals, or bishops. The church is the 1.3 billion people who practice the faith, and I'm quite sure that 99.44% of those people find pedophilia utterly revolting and support imprisonment for those priests guilty of it. I don't even subscribe to the faith and I find it utterly revolting. But your broad-brush tactics are equally revolting.
 
If you can, why don't you?

Because there's no point.

It's trivially obvious why an insult to the Catholic Church is an insult to all Catholics. If it has to be explained, there's no point explaining it.


ETA: Out of curiousity, why do you care whether or not you are insulting all Catholics?
 
Last edited:
ETA: Out of curiousity, why do you care whether or not you are insulting all Catholics?

I think the real question he wants answered is "Are all catholics everywhere offended by mention of the institutional pedophilia of their organization, and if not, how can I reword that so that they will be?"
 
Does the 5% statistic of allegations specify allegations of abuse against children? Consider the possibility of these "abuse" cases being, for example, priests becoming involved with adult women (or men) under their pastoral care, which is certainly inappropriate and can be seen as an abuse of trust. Or priests using the confessional as a blackmail/extortion tool. Either of which are reprehensible in the extreme.

Yes, it's only about abuse against children.
 
The church is more than priests, or the Pope and cardinals, or bishops. The church is the 1.3 billion people who practice the faith, and I'm quite sure that 99.44% of those people find pedophilia utterly revolting and support imprisonment for those priests guilty of it. I don't even subscribe to the faith and I find it utterly revolting. But your broad-brush tactics are equally revolting.

But they still keep supporting it. If you find an organization is doing something you find revolting then you should quit that organization otherwise your mouth is talking but your actions are talking louder.
 
I think the real question he wants answered is "Are all catholics everywhere offended by mention of the institutional pedophilia of their organization, and if not, how can I reword that so that they will be?"


So Catholics aren't offended by pedophilia?
 
Because there's no point.

It's trivially obvious why an insult to the Catholic Church is an insult to all Catholics. If it has to be explained, there's no point explaining it.
If you can't explain it, why should we think it exists. Outside of your own mind, that is.
ETA: Out of curiousity, why do you care whether or not you are insulting all Catholics?
My point here is that this righteous and rather bogus indignation is being used to try to silence anyone who brings up the topic. You'd have read that if you had read the thread.
 
This again. I don't think the little old lady down the street condones pedophilia. That was the point of the OP and that is the knee-jerk reaction I get to even mentioning the topic to some folks.

Well that's odd, because I've mentioned the topic of sexual abuse among priests to some people, including some Catholics, and I've never gotten that knee jerk reaction, and I've never been told that I've insulted all Catholics everywhere.

I guess you've just had bad luck.

Of course, I've never insisted that


the Catholic Church has an organized and willful culture of pedophilia and the enabling thereof
 
I think the real question he wants answered is "Are all catholics everywhere offended by mention of the institutional pedophilia of their organization, and if not, how can I reword that so that they will be?"

I think you're out of your depth trying to think of what my "real question" would be. You do a good job of proving that the Shout Them Down Squad is alive and kicking, however.
 
I think you're out of your depth trying to think of what my "real question" would be. You do a good job of proving that the Shout Them Down Squad is alive and kicking, however.

You presume to understand something about me which you clearly don't. If you think I am a defender of the Catholic Church then you are sadly mistaken.

What I take exception with is not that you would discuss sexual abuse by priests and the ensuing coverup by some of the churches leaders, I take issue with the presumption that all catholics grant tacit approval for the same by their continued faith.

What I take exception with is the pretense of a question in the original post. When it has been pointed out to you that many if not most Catholics don't take offense at the mention of sexual abuse you argue that they do, and that perhaps I should not suggest otherwise because I "wasn't there" wherever the **** "there" was.

What I take exception to is your arbitrarily strict standards for collective guilt which seems to serve no other purpose other than to justify self righteous moralizing.

Reality is something you seem to be ignoring in your rush to condemn Catholics. The response to the sexual abuse scandal by Catholics has taken many forms. Many doicese felt a drop in donations. Some Catholics stopped attending mass (my parents, for example. For them this was one of many issues that drove them away from the Church, though they still self identify as Catholics), others (like my sister and brother-in-law) became more involved in parish and diocecian activities in the hopes of pushing the church in a more progressive direction. I'm certain if you brought up the issue with them you'd get an earfull. I'm also certain that if you accused them of being an accessory after the fact you'd probably offend them. But that's because they don't condone, approve, or wish to cover up sexual abuse by priests.
 
Yea they only support those who aide and abed things they supposedly hate. And anyway according to catholic psychologists these teen boys had a hole that they desperately needed a father figure to fill and seduced the priests in a totally heterosexual way. The way young boys are want to.

Great typo, unless you actually meant to say that! :p
 
People, please! It's "aid and abet!" Not "abed" or "abbed" or anything else. "Abet" means to encourage someone to commit a criminal act, so I'm not sure it's even applicable here, although "aid" may be (at least in the sense of helping someone get away with it).

Sorry, I'm not usually a grammar/spelling nazi, but I just couldn't handle this one any more!:mad:
After twice I thought it wasn't a typo. ymmv. :D

I'd say regarding the hierarchy 'aid and abet' is spot on.
 
You presume to understand something about me which you clearly don't. If you think I am a defender of the Catholic Church then you are sadly mistaken.

What I take exception with is not that you would discuss sexual abuse by priests and the ensuing coverup by some of the churches leaders, I take issue with the presumption that all catholics grant tacit approval for the same by their continued faith.

What I take exception with is the pretense of a question in the original post. When it has been pointed out to you that many if not most Catholics don't take offense at the mention of sexual abuse you argue that they do, and that perhaps I should not suggest otherwise because I "wasn't there" wherever the **** "there" was.

What I take exception to is your arbitrarily strict standards for collective guilt which seems to serve no other purpose other than to justify self righteous moralizing.

Reality is something you seem to be ignoring in your rush to condemn Catholics. The response to the sexual abuse scandal by Catholics has taken many forms. Many doicese felt a drop in donations. Some Catholics stopped attending mass (my parents, for example. For them this was one of many issues that drove them away from the Church, though they still self identify as Catholics), others (like my sister and brother-in-law) became more involved in parish and diocecian activities in the hopes of pushing the church in a more progressive direction. I'm certain if you brought up the issue with them you'd get an earfull. I'm also certain that if you accused them of being an accessory after the fact you'd probably offend them. But that's because they don't condone, approve, or wish to cover up sexual abuse by priests.

So they don't condone, approve, or wish to cover up sexual abuse by priests by becoming more involved in parish and diocecian activities in the hopes of pushing the church in a more progressive direction.

I'd say that by becoming more involved they're certainly approving the organization by example.
 
If you can't explain it, why should we think it exists. Outside of your own mind, that is.

My point here is that this righteous and rather bogus indignation is being used to try to silence anyone who brings up the topic. You'd have read that if you had read the thread.

It's the same tactics used to shut down any criticism no matter how heinous the acts we can never blame the beliefs and the organizations that preach the beliefs and enable the acts.

Mention suicide bombings and "Broad Brush" and 'bigot" are the verbal bombs thrown, criticize the BoA and your an anti-Mormon persecutor and here there seems to be a boiling up of indignation that people might actually be held accountable for what the church they belong to is doing.
 
So if you could explain how pedophilia is an "institution" I would understand how what you're saying is "reality". Saying that there was institutional misconduct in covering up the crime and that perpetrators were sheltered from punishment and arrest by members of an institution does not make the crime "institutional" except in the most equivocal sense. Members of the church do not condone child rape, and I have yet to meet a Catholic who would try to defend it or the actions of the many Bishops who covered it up.

I suspect you don't know many Catholics in real life.

And yet never they never try to help investigations or release documents with out years of court battles. Of course there is no one or organisation in the church with the power to change policy for the whole church in such a way. That is the problem with non hierarchical organizations.
 
This is an absolutely ridiculous assertion. It's difficult to take anyone seriously who makes such a stupid claim. I'm not even going to dignify the rest of your post with a reply.

Yea it is like saying everyone who went to a nice party in New York or Massachusetts that raised money for the IRA supported terrorism.
 
The church is more than priests, or the Pope and cardinals, or bishops. The church is the 1.3 billion people who practice the faith, and I'm quite sure that 99.44% of those people find pedophilia utterly revolting and support imprisonment for those priests guilty of it. I don't even subscribe to the faith and I find it utterly revolting. But your broad-brush tactics are equally revolting.

So you can't hold people responsible for the actions of the people they support?

If I gave money to an organization that provided help to some people but also supported terrorism, am I supporting terrorism even if I don't agree with it and find it immoral?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom