Am I insulting all Catholics everywhere?

So you can't hold people responsible for the actions of the people they support?

If I gave money to an organization that provided help to some people but also supported terrorism, am I supporting terrorism even if I don't agree with it and find it immoral?

Well, we can't blame the Church so I guess the only one left to blame is the victims. If they'd just kept quiet the innocent, childlike faith of the pew people would not have been disturbed.:(
 
What I take exception with is not that you would discuss sexual abuse by priests and the ensuing coverup by some of the churches leaders, I take issue with the presumption that all catholics grant tacit approval for the same by their continued faith.

The ones that put up with this abuse are giving their tacit approval. That's not really hard to figure out, guy.
 
The ones that put up with this abuse are giving their tacit approval. That's not really hard to figure out, guy.

Which, going by what you've stated so far, would be any and every one who self identifies themselves as a Catholic.

Got it, guy.
 
The ones that put up with this abuse are giving their tacit approval. That's not really hard to figure out, guy.

You're forgetting that the RCC isn't a democracy. Priests aren't voted in or out; they are assigned. The congregation has no say whatsoever in which priest is assigned to which parish.

The idea that Catholic congregations "put up with" pedophiles is simply wrong. There's no denying that the hierarchy covered it up; but there is literally nothing that the congregations at large could have done about it.
 
You're forgetting that the RCC isn't a democracy. Priests aren't voted in or out; they are assigned. The congregation has no say whatsoever in which priest is assigned to which parish.

The idea that Catholic congregations "put up with" pedophiles is simply wrong. There's no denying that the hierarchy covered it up; but there is literally nothing that the congregations at large could have done about it.

Yep not a thing. They couldn't stop donating money and find a more transparent church, that would be silly.
 
Yep not a thing. They couldn't stop donating money and find a more transparent church, that would be silly.

Christians can't switch from one sect to another. That's not how it works. Certainly from an atheist perspective it won't matter because it's all mythological anyway, but we're not talking about atheists are we? For the faithful, switching from one tradition to another isn't quite the same as switching between brands of beer.
 
Yep not a thing. They couldn't stop donating money and find a more transparent church, that would be silly.

PT, I've seen enough of your posts around this forum to know that you're not as stupid as this post makes you appear. For believers (which, again, I emphasize that I am not) religion is instilled early in life. A believer doesn't just switch denominations like they might switch cell phone companies or cable providers. This is especially true of Catholics, since there are deep doctrinal differences between Catholicism and Protestantism (divinity of Mary, transsubstantiation, intercession of saints, etc.)

ETA: Ninja'ed by joesixpack.
 
So they don't condone, approve, or wish to cover up sexual abuse by priests by becoming more involved in parish and diocecian activities in the hopes of pushing the church in a more progressive direction.
I've followed your line of thought in this thread with some understanding so far. But this post is as upside down as it can get. Look at the highlighted parts that you are responding to. joesixpack is citing people who are getting MORE involved to stop this travesty which is what every catholic who gives a damn should be doing and you're ripping them. Step back, tsig, and get some perspective.
 
Last edited:
Christians can't switch from one sect to another. That's not how it works. Certainly from an atheist perspective it won't matter because it's all mythological anyway, but we're not talking about atheists are we? For the faithful, switching from one tradition to another isn't quite the same as switching between brands of beer.

Really? Here is a simplified (*) scheme of the various churches in the Netherlands, with the major splits and reunions.

(*) I see at least the Old Catholics, the Anabaptists and the Remonstrants are missing.
 
I've followed your line of thought in this thread with some understanding so far. But this post is as upside down as it can get. Look at the highlighted parts that you are responding to. joesixpack is citing people who are getting MORE involved to stop this travesty which is what every catholic who gives a damn should be doing and you're ripping them. Step back, tsig, and get some perspective.


This is more an effort by tsig to get me mad by insulting my family than it is a demonstration of his unsteady grasp of logic.
 
PT, I've seen enough of your posts around this forum to know that you're not as stupid as this post makes you appear. For believers (which, again, I emphasize that I am not) religion is instilled early in life. A believer doesn't just switch denominations like they might switch cell phone companies or cable providers. This is especially true of Catholics, since there are deep doctrinal differences between Catholicism and Protestantism (divinity of Mary, transsubstantiation, intercession of saints, etc.)

ETA: Ninja'ed by joesixpack.

It's actually quite common among protestants to walk out of their denomination if the parish and the minister agree on this; see my previous post. But your objection that, if I may rephrase, catholics don't have a choice, is not right either: there are other, non-RCC catholic denominations that share the basic doctrine with the RCC.
 
It's actually quite common among protestants to walk out of their denomination if the parish and the minister agree on this; see my previous post. But your objection that, if I may rephrase, catholics don't have a choice, is not right either: there are other, non-RCC catholic denominations that share the basic doctrine with the RCC.

True enough, but in the real world, lay Catholics aren't going to renounce their faith because of this. They are appalled, as they should be, and they should (and have) demanded action from the church leadership. And changes are being made. Not as quickly as they should be, and they didn't start anywhere near soon enough in my book, but there is progress being made.
 
It's actually quite common among protestants to walk out of their denomination if the parish and the minister agree on this; see my previous post. But your objection that, if I may rephrase, catholics don't have a choice, is not right either: there are other, non-RCC catholic denominations that share the basic doctrine with the RCC.

In a larger city, a protestant won't even have to switch denominations, he or she can simply find another pastor at another church that they like more. The RCC is much more hierarchical. Regularly attending a church in a different parish is frowned upon.

There are vanishingly few non-Catholic denominations to which a Catholic could go. I can think of only one (Episcopalian, or "Catholic-Lite" as they're also known).
 
It's actually quite common among protestants to walk out of their denomination if the parish and the minister agree on this; see my previous post. But your objection that, if I may rephrase, catholics don't have a choice, is not right either: there are other, non-RCC catholic denominations that share the basic doctrine with the RCC.

See: Lutherans

I know in fact quite a few catholics who converted to Lutheran because they couldn't accept some of the lunacy of the RCC. I can't say the child molestation scandal specifically, and it has been more things like the abortion and contraception and other sexist policies.
 
PT, I've seen enough of your posts around this forum to know that you're not as stupid as this post makes you appear. For believers (which, again, I emphasize that I am not) religion is instilled early in life. A believer doesn't just switch denominations like they might switch cell phone companies or cable providers. This is especially true of Catholics, since there are deep doctrinal differences between Catholicism and Protestantism (divinity of Mary, transsubstantiation, intercession of saints, etc.)

ETA: Ninja'ed by joesixpack.

Except all those who do exactly that.

44% of the US population

link

But hey I guess they don't count for some reason as you can't do that.
 
True enough, but in the real world, lay Catholics aren't going to renounce their faith because of this. They are appalled, as they should be, and they should (and have) demanded action from the church leadership. And changes are being made. Not as quickly as they should be, and they didn't start anywhere near soon enough in my book, but there is progress being made.

9% of the US population are Catholics who have done exactly that. So as only 25% are catholic that is a pretty good percent of people raised catholic who who are not.
 
9% of the US population are Catholics who have done exactly that. So as only 25% are catholic that is a pretty good percent of people raised catholic who who are not.

That's not what that grid says. It says that 9% of people raised Catholic (not 9% of the US population) have converted to other faiths during their lifetimes. So it's not something that happens a lot, despite your effort to spin it otherwise. To look at it the other way, 91% of people who were born Catholic still identify as Catholic.

ETA: My mistake; it does say that. However, I notice that the sample size isn't exactly vast (less that 1,000 recontact interviews) and many of the people (four in ten) leaving the faith did so because they stopped believing in any God, not just the Catholic one. *raises hand*
 
Last edited:
Did you read that? It's actually a whopping 9%

44% have changed religions, 9% of the population is Catholics who have changed religion. But they should trust their religion and learn to not question their moral superiors in the church.

Why be so mad at people who know better than you but not question the part that gives your the belief of them knowing better?

Of course 9% when it is only out of 25% is still nearly 40% of catholics.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom