Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

Yes. And? Remember, what we're arguing about is the constitutionality of the law, not whether or not it would be a good thing.

Ok, but it certainly seems to be a special situation where everyone is "forced" into participation in the health care system by preventing a hospital from letting someone die if they can't prove that they're able to pay for treatment. How are you proposing the government would force someone into participation in the broccoli market in order to then force them to purchase broccoli? I don't see a slippery slope here, but maybe I'm missing something.

The government is forcing me to pay taxes. What they do with those taxes is a different question. That's the way the system works. But this mandate isn't a tax. Nor is it the equivalent of a tax.

You aren't forced to purchase health insurance. The penalty is a tax.

-Bri
 
Some things I have to buy or pay a penalty for not doing so:

Safety belts
Gun lock
IRS Form 6969 (although, if I hadn't waited so long, I could have gotten it free from the IRS)
Checking account/credit card/money order/cashiers check to pay my taxes
Social Security Insurance
Funeral (well, my heirs -- they can't simply put my body in the trash)
Trash pickup
Lawn care -- or get cited for "blight"

Arguably, I could opt out of some of these.


Most of these are covered at the state or local level and, as far I as know, none of them are regulated under the Interstate Commerce Clause. Here the federal government is arguing that one's act of not doing something (buying insurance from a private company) is substantially related to interstate commerce and thus subject to federal regulation.
 
Ok, but it certainly seems to be a special situation where everyone is "forced" into participation in the health care system by preventing a hospital from letting someone die if they can't prove that they're able to pay for treatment. How are you proposing the government would force someone into participation in the broccoli market in order to then force them to purchase broccoli? I don't see a slippery slope here, but maybe I'm missing something.

I don't see any likely scenario in which the government would try to do that with broccoli specifically, but the relevant problem is whether or not it could. And I can imagine all sorts of ways that could happen. For example, the government could force grocery stores to provide free samples of broccoli.

You aren't forced to purchase health insurance. The penalty is a tax.

Not according to Congress or Obama. And the penalty IS intended to force you to purchase health insurance. That's its explicit justification.
 
For example, the government could force grocery stores to provide free samples of broccoli.


A merely funny comment online. Sad to hear it as relevant in the SCOTUS.

Not according to Congress or Obama. And the penalty IS intended to force you to purchase health insurance. That's its explicit justification.


Live with the penalty if you break the rules of being responsible for yourself within a world at large.

Or call the waaaambulance. Oh, I forgot... you're not covered :D
 
How does this differ from medicare?

Medicare is funded by a tax on income. Suppose I offered a tax credit to someone who purchases private health insurance and simply raise the taxes to pay for an expanded form of government-funded healthcare/medicare? Wouldn't that accomplish the same thing?

Is the entire issue one of universality and an inability to opt out? Why should this matter? Everyone who is a US citizen is required (I think) to get a social security card. We are required to answer the census. We are required to produce proof of citizenship in order to work. Universality shouldn't be the main issue.

If money is the main issue, then it could be done as a tax -- except wouldn't that just do the opposite of privatized health insurance and be fought against by the small government/socialism crowd?

Isn't the purpose of this to kill the idea and not any particular provision?
 
How does this differ from medicare?

Medicare is funded by a tax on income. Suppose I offered a tax credit to someone who purchases private health insurance and simply raise the taxes to pay for an expanded form of government-funded healthcare/medicare? Wouldn't that accomplish the same thing?

Perhaps it would accomplish the same desired task. But the method isn't the same. Process matters.

Is the entire issue one of universality and an inability to opt out?[] Why should this matter? Everyone who is a US citizen is required (I think) to get a social security card. We are required to answer the census. We are required to produce proof of citizenship in order to work. Universality shouldn't be the main issue.

The government requires interactions with the government. Required commerce with non-government entities is not the same, and it's new.

If money is the main issue, then it could be done as a tax

Yes, it could be. But it isn't in the current legislation.

except wouldn't that just do the opposite of privatized health insurance and be fought against by the small government/socialism crowd?

That's an issue of political preference, not of constitutionality.

Isn't the purpose of this to kill the idea and not any particular provision?

Depends who exactly you're referring to. But if this particular legislation gets killed right now, then even if direct government single-payer health care is perfectly constitutional, that doesn't mean it will ever pass. Opponents are probably hoping that this was the only window of opportunity. And proponents are scared that they're right.
 
Reminder: 'Obamacare' is based on a conservative idea

Why the Right Turned Its Back on the Individual Mandate

The roadmap for what was then the signature Republican approach to health-care reform was provided by the once quintessentially Reaganaut think tank, the Heritage Foundation, which now denounces “the cancer of Obamacare.” The offending document was written in 1989, at the dawn of the first Bush presidency, and its rationale for the individual mandate was as follows:

“There is an implicit contract between households in society, based on the notion that health insurance is not like other forms of insurance protection. If a young man wrecks his Porsche and does not have the foresight to obtain insurance, we may commiserate but society feels no obligation to repair his car. Healthcare is different. If a man is struck down by a heart attack in the street, Americans will care for him whether or not he has insurance. If we find that he has spent his money on other things rather than insurance, we may be angry but we will not deny him services – even if that means more prudent citizens end up paying the tab … A mandate on individuals recognizes this implicit contract.”

This is, of course, almost precisely the argument made by both the Obama administration and Governor Romney when he was preparing his signature legislative accomplishment in Massachusetts. Namely, that we have a hole in the social contract, where a lack of individual responsibility causes great financial costs for society as a whole in the realm of health care, which everyone will need at some point in their lives. The solution, reiterated several times by Heritage in policy papers leading up to the fight over Hillarycare, was to put an end to fiscally irresponsible freeloaders by advancing the principle of individual responsibility.

Now those same conservatives that came up with this idea and even used it in Massachusetts under Romney, hate the idea because it has become associated with Obama.

Just one particularly relevant example of why it is irresponsible to not have health insurance if you can afford it because it imposes costs on others:
Obamacare critic leaves us holding her hospital bills

Brown was outspoken in her belief that Congress had gone beyond what the U.S. Constitution allows when it included in the reform law a requirement that, beginning in 2014, most Americans will have to obtain health insurance or pay a fine to the IRS. She said she was uninsured and was that way by choice.

"She firmly believes that no one should have the right to tell her she has to use her own money to pay for health insurance," Karen Harned, executive director of the NFIB legal center, said when the NFIB filed its lawsuit in 2010.

She turned out not to be such a perfect choice after all.

Last year Brown shuttered her business and filed for personal bankruptcy. Among her debts: nearly $4,500 in medical bills. More than $2,000 of that was owed to Bay Medical Center in Panama City. The rest was to doctors in Florida, Alabama and Mississippi.

Because she filed bankruptcy at least in part because of debt due to medical costs, her case actually becomes an argument for the Affordable Care Act, not against it.

This is what opponents of the Affordable Care Act are arguing for, in essence: That people should be free to gamble by not buying health insurance, keep the winnings in the form of savings if their gamble pays off and they manage to stay healthy, and stick doctors, other health care consumers and taxpayers with the bill if their gamble does not pay off.
 
This is what opponents of the Affordable Care Act are arguing for, in essence: That people should be free to gamble by not buying health insurance, keep the winnings in the form of savings if their gamble pays off and they manage to stay healthy, and stick doctors, other health care consumers and taxpayers with the bill if their gamble does not pay off.

Yeah, 2008 Obama was such a heartless bastard.
 
Perhaps it would accomplish the same desired task. But the method isn't the same. Process matters.

Sure, thing - can you demonstrate that the method matters? That it is not a distinction without a difference in this instance?


The government requires interactions with the government. Required commerce with non-government entities is not the same, and it's new.

So? Not all government interactions are equivalent. If government is laying the rules by which non-governmental entities operate, and as such they are merely proxies for governmental requirements, why does the provider in-and-o-itself matter?
 
Just finished. Verrilli was not good, neither was Carver. Verrilli, i thought, had several opportunities to really make solid, cogent points and failed to do so. A big one was his response to Scalia's request to articulate the limiting principle to the mandate vis a his the commerce clause as succinctly as possible. Took him a few pages and several studders to make it happen.

Calvin was easily the most articulate, and seemingly the most prepared, of the three.
 
Last edited:
Did you forget what Obama said in 2008?

OK fine, but that doesn't invalidate my argument.

Can't watch the videos now anyway, but I take it that Obama didn't support an individual mandate during the campaign. The Affordable Care Act was written by congress and Obama didn't get everything he wanted in there, particularly the Public Option.
 
Last edited:
Not according to Congress or Obama.
So what? Whatever label Obama or Congress uses for political reasons should be irrelevant to Constitutional analysis, a point that was specifically made in the argument.

And the penalty IS intended to force you to purchase health insurance. That's its explicit justification.
Again, so what? We use taxes all the time to influence behavior. The tax credit for mortgage payments is intended to encourage home ownership. The tax deduction for charitable contribution is intended to encourage charitable giving.

The "penalty" is a flat tax, which is waived by the federal government if you purchase health insurance.
 
Dumb idea - instead of making it a tax added on if you fail to have insurance, why not apply the tax across the board on everyone, and then provide tax credits for those who have insurance?
 
That's what the law does do. Except, because the word "tax" is unpopular, they call it a "fine" for not buying insurance. But functionally it's a tax.
 
No other nation on earth has implemented UHC in such a mindless, stupid way. If this kills the ACA at least maybe we can look at what other countries are doing and formulate a program that borrows the best ideas.

Does any other country, for example, have seperate health care systems for the elderly, the poor, military veterans, and government employees? It's stupidity in the highest order and it's bankrupting the country.
The "mindless, stupid way" at issue in this litigation is not the main point. The tenor of some of the questioning is that universal health care cannot be implemented in the United States of America on a national basis in ANY way, even if the plan for doing so is highly intelligent. If the Court is not careful with its rationale, it could end up trashing everything, assuming that rationale and stare decisis still have meaning (which is a debatable assumption).

I am of the view, by the way, that the plan "chosen" in the USA is not a very good one. There are a lot of different approaches around the world directed to health care, and the USA could have the advantage of picking and choosing the best from competing systems, taking the good and discarding or guarding against the bad. The US could have developed a hybrid system that would literally be the envy of the world.
I watch the US health care discussions with interest. Personally, I'd like to see the US adopt a system that is NOT like Canada's but that is BETTER THAN Canada's. It can be done, and the US is in a position to do it; but the US has to get past the ignorance and fear that seems to grip a significant number of citizens.
When I moved to Canada three years ago, I found that Canadians looked at the US system and thought that it was insane. Not unwise, not poor policy, not in need of fixing, but insane.

And why? Primarily because health care in the States is deemed to be a luxury, and if you can't afford a luxury, you do without. That's the American Way.

In Canada (and other nations), basic health care is deemed a human right. Not a luxury, not a privilege, not even a statutory right, but a HUMAN right, a right that people have just by being people. There was a time when the USA set the world standard for natural rights of people--Freedom of Expression being a well-known right that did not come from King or legislature, and could not be taken away by either--but in recent years, the USA has been retarded.

I do not use that term as a slur. I use it literally. After World War II, the USA slowed down as a leader in human rights, and other nations passed it. (The current view in the USA is that that the highest form of rights are constitutional rights, and if it ain't in the Constitution, or if it wasn't contemplated by the Framers some 230 years ago, it ain't a right and never will be.)

Canadians cannot understand how the US could see health care in any way other than as a human right, and it shocks them to learn that, in the US, people can be denied care that they NEED.

In Canada, we pay high taxes for our health care. The health care ain't free. But Canadians DON'T pay high monthly premiums for basic health care. Those that are too poor to pay taxes get the care just the same, and this does not swamp the system. Canadian businesses DON'T have to devote a huge portion of their benefits package to health care. Canadian workers DON'T hold on to jobs they despise merely out of fear (in the US, a well-supported fear) of losing their health care. Huge money lawsuits DON'T turn on the question of who is going to be responsible for future medical bills resulting from an accident. Businesses DON'T keep unproductive employees out of fear that they will be liable for cutting off health care. Canadians who suffer a catastrophic illness AREN'T at risk of losing their homes or their life savings, nor ar they at risk of having their premiums for basic health care raised.

(It does not take much imagination to realize that health care might be deemed, quite literally, a right-to-life issue; and that businesses in general and small businesses in particular stand to benefit enormously from freeing themselves from supplying health care and the agony of dealing with for-profit insurers. In other words, it seems exceptionally strange that some of the people who ought to be in favor of universal health care on moral and/or economic grounds are the most adamantly opposed to it. But when can you expect rationality from people who are insane?)

This is not to say that the Canadian system is perfect (my preference, for what it is worth, would have been for the USA to adopt a hybrid system that combines the best of both the US and Canadian systems). Nor is it to say that the Canadian approach is the only approach. But the USA lags every other advanced nation in this area, and for no good reason, as best I can tell.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom