Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

Nobody is being forced to buy anything from any private company. Anyone can pay a tax penalty and not purchase health insurance.
Ah the old, "it's not really forcing anybody to do anything". Like when someone holds a gun to your head and demands a wallet. It's not really force-- you could always refuse and choose the bullet to the head instead.

And indeed the law itself doesn't say minimum essential coverage has to come from a private insurance company.
Doesn't matter. If it mandated daily brocholli consumption, some would have it given to them or grown their own. The rest would be FORCED to buy it from a store.

If each of the states passed their own "public option" for example, the mandate would be satisfied without anyone having to purchase private insurance.
Doesn't matter. You continue to go down this line of, "if they did this or that, they wouldn't be forced to buy from a private company or face a penalty". The fact is some can't do "this or that" and WILL be forced to buy it or pay a penalty.

The fact that some people will have to purchase insurance or pay a tax penalty doesn't mean this is a law that mandates the purchase of private insurance.
That is the effect. That you are in denial of this is rather odd. Or maybe the court erred in taking this on. Perhaps if they had just consulted JoeTheJuggler they could have saved all this time they are wasting on a non-issue.

Neally, would you say that the IRS tax code is a law that requires the purchase of pencils? Or that requires contracting the services of a commercial tax preparer or accountant? Some people have to do these things in order to comply with the tax code.
Sure. The cost of tax compliance is a huge burden in the US. Do you think the SCOTUS erred in accepting this case? Do you think that their brocholli and cell phone analogies are bogus? Do you think that they don't understand what the law says and the impact of it?



There's no chance of jail or other punishment if you don't purchase health insurance.
But if I don't pay the penalty, they will take it from me by force.
 
Yep. In Tuesday's arguments, there were at least a couple of occasions where Ginsburg sort of did Verrilli's job for him (in the guise of asking a question). Even then, Verrilli did a poor job of saying, "Yes, that's exactly what I meant to say!"

I agree he did a bad job, but he was also hamstrung a bit by the fact that for political reasons he couldn't just say "It's a tax for constitutional purposes" or "Yes, the federal government could regulate broccoli if it wanted to, under the Commerce Clause." Even though the statements are arguably true, his boss likely didn't want him to say it that way, which made it very awkward for him when Scalia pushed him to the wall on those points.
 
A question about Obama Care and the Supreme Court arguments.

The Solicitor General*Donald B. Verrilli Jr. stated to the Supreme Court that religious belief is a valid excuse not to buy Obama Care.

This means that an Amish man driving a horse and buggy who is injured by a truck will not be fined when the public pays for his hospital bills.

Please explain why religious beliefs should determine who pays the medical bills and who is fined?
 
That's more or less correct. And it makes my case. There is economic activity that has a significant and measurable effect on interstate commerce.

Also, the "some compensation back from the fed" is simply another example of passing the costs of care to the uninsured on to the system at large (in this case, to taxpayers).

Are you suggesting that we change the laws such that health care providers cannot pass costs of care for the uninsured on to others? ....
That's already done in the private market, in that people who go to an emergency room with the intent to pay, or who go to a hospital with the intent to pay, are charged far more than the average payment, either from an insurance or government stream.

County taxes fund county hospitals here. I'd leave it right there, and let it be sorted out at that level, instead of getting the fed mixed up in it. As for a private hospital they should be able to refuse anyone they want.
 
Oh, and state governments don't actually force anyone to get car insurance. They just require it as a condition of driving on public roads, but you're free to not do that. The health care mandate is not likewise conditional.

Roberts was angling towards this during the day 1 and 2 arguments, and it could be postulated that there is a choice--between getting insurance or paying the penalty/tax. In either outcome, you're in compliance with the law as written.
 
A question about Obama Care and the Supreme Court arguments.

The Solicitor General*Donald B. Verrilli Jr. stated to the Supreme Court that religious belief is a valid excuse not to buy Obama Care.

This means that an Amish man driving a horse and buggy who is injured by a truck will not be fined when the public pays for his hospital bills.

Please explain why religious beliefs should determine who pays the medical bills and who is fined?

There are exemptions for certain classes of people to not be subject to the insurance requirement. Further from that, the law at it's most optimisitic was only expected to cover something like 80 -90 percent of the currently uninsured folks in the US; so there will still be a sizeable minority of uninsured, just not on the scale it is currently and with an attendant decrease in cost to the sytem.
 
This is one of the major flaws in the US system - tying health insurance to employment. That link should be broken, and the best way to do it is to tax such benefits as ordinary income.

The ACA actually further entrenches this mindless relic from World War II. I favor UHC, but the ACA is the clumsiest, most flawed attempt at UHC ever constructed in the history of mankind. Remember when foreigners on this board couldn't understand American's skepticism that the US government could do it right? Now they know.

Nail meet hammer. I suppose the rationality is continuity over a big (radical?) departure from our current system. But then, why change a damn thing? Employer based coverage is the dumbest method of providing care, and has been responsible for untold economic losses and poor health outcomes. My mom lost her coverage during the recession - because we all know people don't get sick when times are bad - but also can't take advantage of the tax breaks to insure herself that her company did when purchasing health insurance. It penalizes entrepreneurship, it makes hard economic times worse (mom was diagnosed with breast cancer within a year of losing coverage), and provides an incentive for employees to stay at jobs they are otherwise unsuited/over qualified/unhappy with because they dont want to risk losing coverage. Beyond stupidity.
 
Last edited:
No, it doesn't need that. In fact, you DON'T want to tie to deductions.

I propose a tax credit. Everyone has a baseline tax of XXXX. All you have to do is demonstrate that you have met the minimum requirement for health insurance, and you are given a tax credit of XXXX.
You're giving them 2 tax credits now - the value of their employer-provided health insurance which is tax-free income, plus extra money for being lucky enough to have employer-provided health insurance? That's insane!

There's no reason whatsoever to tie health insurance to employment. It's an extra burden on businesses, it keeps people from switching to better jobs, and it makes employee medical issues the business of employers. This relic from WWII needs to go away and never return.
 
If you're throwing out ideas that Congress will never implement, why not just sever the connection between the employer and health care entirely, go with single-payer, and be done with it?

-Bri
Single-payer is just one way to do it, there are other ways. Single payer isn't even the majority way in countries that have UHC.
 
There's no reason whatsoever to tie health insurance to employment.
With this I agree. I think fear of losing your family's health insurance may be one of the biggest impediments to people thinking of switching from employee to entrepeneur, and thus a serious handbrake on the economy.

It's a relic of the 1940's and it's time for it to be put down.
 
There are exemptions for certain classes of people to not be subject to the insurance requirement. Further from that, the law at it's most optimisitic was only expected to cover something like 80 -90 percent of the currently uninsured folks in the US; so there will still be a sizeable minority of uninsured, just not on the scale it is currently and with an attendant decrease in cost to the sytem.

Exemptions for certain classes?

Darn right.

Plus the exemptions for 1231 companies at last count?

Ain't that curious.
 
But why can't they implement this? It is effectively the exact same result as what they have now, but doing it without introducing a "fine." Do it as a tax with a tax credit.

They can, but they won't. I seriously doubt that the Republicans would go for any measure that falls short of dismantling Obamacare entirely.

-Bri
 
They can, but they won't. I seriously doubt that the Republicans would go for any measure that falls short of dismantling Obamacare entirely.

-Bri
Right. And Romney has said he'd introduce legislation to fix a number of things in health care that are screwed up. But that shouldn't be done on the carcass of a largely incomprehensible snakenest of legislation. Probably better to get that out of the way, and start with a blank piece of paper.
 
This would fall under IRS collection procedures for someone not paying a tax or a penalty. These matters are very clearly understood.

And they most certainly do take your house away, seize your bank account, etc.

see sections 7201 and 7203 of the code

The bolded part is wrong.

I meant that you can't be jailed or face criminal punishments for not purchasing health insurance. The only penalty for not purchasing health insurance is a tax penalty. And I don't believe they can take your house or seize your bank account. But they can withhold tax refunds.

-Bri
 
Sure. The cost of tax compliance is a huge burden in the US. Do you think the SCOTUS erred in accepting this case? Do you think that their brocholli and cell phone analogies are bogus? Do you think that they don't understand what the law says and the impact of it?

I think broccoli and cell phones are bogus.

1) There is no compelling need to madate purchasing broccoli. Indeed some are allergic. Broccoli is never a must-have item for anyone, and has reasonable alternatives for interested consumers.

2) Broccoli is not a form of payment for services. Nowhere are farmers forces to give broccoli away to individuals who may or not pay for it. Congress can indeed regulate payment methods.

3) Purchasing broccoli only after realizing you need it will not produce catastrophic economic losses. The timing of purchasing health insurance will.

I could go on, but we can start here.
 
They can, but they won't. I seriously doubt that the Republicans would go for any measure that falls short of dismantling Obamacare entirely.

-Bri
Bri, do you think the ACA is the best that we can do?

I'm not saying the GOP has better ideas or defending them in this, but if this bad law gets struck down before it entrenches itself into our system I think we'll be much better off. Replace it with something much better.
 
Bri, do you think the ACA is the best that we can do?

There are better systems than what we wound up with. But I don't think any of them will ever be implemented any time soon. So yes, it's better than nothing.

I'm not saying the GOP has better ideas or defending them in this, but if this bad law gets struck down before it entrenches itself into our system I think we'll be much better off. Replace it with something much better.

I think the best approach would be to make incremental improvements to the ACA.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Ah the old, "it's not really forcing anybody to do anything". Like when someone holds a gun to your head and demands a wallet. It's not really force-- you could always refuse and choose the bullet to the head instead.

But if I don't pay the penalty, they will take it from me by force.

Nobody will use a gun or anything that could reasonably be considered "force." The current law allows the IRS to withhold your tax refund to pay it (which makes perfect sense if it's a tax).

-Bri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom