Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

I think it's a perfectly apropos line of questioning. If the government can compel you to buy health insurance, it establishes a very dangerous precedent (that is, that the government can compel you to buy stuff).

My personal opinion (IANAL, but I have considerable experience in the health-insurance field) is that the law will fail on this point and the next administration will have to try another tack. Eventually (I predict by 2020) there will be universal healthcare in the US; the simplest way to accomplish this will be to extend Medicare to everyone and increase the payroll deduction to cover the increased cost (to maybe 3% from the current 1.45%). I'll take my million in twenties, Mr. Randi.

My thought is you're right.

When you get the mil, remember your friends. Buddy. Pal. Amigo...
 
I think it's a perfectly apropos line of questioning. If the government can compel you to buy health insurance, it establishes a very dangerous precedent (that is, that the government can compel you to buy stuff).

Yes, but is the Supreme Court supposed to consider that question, or merely judge the law on its merits? Again, I don't recall the consequences of Citizens United being considered. The question was merely one of deciding whether it was in accordance with constitutional law.
 
Oral arguments are mostly for show. The Justices are already well versed on the arguments and come into this with established views. The lines of questioning are mostly interesting because they signal how the Justices are likely to rule.
 
My question is: Is this an appropriate line of questioning? Isn't the Supreme Court just supposed to weigh the legality and not theorize about potential consequences? That certainly seemed to be the case during the whole Citizens United kerfuffle.

I think it's appropriate. Offering hypotheticals is standard fare in oral argumentation. They're trying to discern what the argument is by trying to apply the same standard to other possible situations.

[I created a thread on this topic yesterday in the Current Events forum. I've requested the threads be merged.]
 
Most troubling, perhaps, is the notion of five members of the US Supreme Court that the United States CAN'T do something that every other leading nation in the world CAN do and HAS DONE. For shame.

:confused:
 
Most troubling, perhaps, is the notion of five members of the US Supreme Court that the United States CAN'T do something that every other leading nation in the world CAN do and HAS DONE. For shame.
No other nation on earth has implemented UHC in such a mindless, stupid way. If this kills the ACA at least maybe we can look at what other countries are doing and formulate a program that borrows the best ideas.

Does any other country, for example, have seperate health care systems for the elderly, the poor, military veterans, and government employees? It's stupidity in the highest order and it's bankrupting the country.
 
I think it's a perfectly apropos line of questioning. If the government can compel you to buy health insurance, it establishes a very dangerous precedent (that is, that the government can compel you to buy stuff).

My personal opinion (IANAL, but I have considerable experience in the health-insurance field) is that the law will fail on this point and the next administration will have to try another tack. Eventually (I predict by 2020) there will be universal healthcare in the US; the simplest way to accomplish this will be to extend Medicare to everyone and increase the payroll deduction to cover the increased cost (to maybe 3% from the current 1.45%). I'll take my million in twenties, Mr. Randi.
You may be right. That probably should have been the approach from the beginning but politics being what it is, they tried to eat the elephant one bite at a time rather then woofing it down.

I do find it laughable (and not in a funny kind of way) that the conservative justices would bring up stuff (broccoli) that I would expect from people on this forum.
 
Yes, but is the Supreme Court supposed to consider that question, or merely judge the law on its merits? Again, I don't recall the consequences of Citizens United being considered. The question was merely one of deciding whether it was in accordance with constitutional law.

I don't think these hypotheticals are about making judgements based on the consequences. They're trying to ask how the principle being proffered might be applied in other situations.
_______

I'm only just now reading through the transcript of today's oral arguments (on the mandate issue).

I'm rather surprised that the government hasn't pointed out that all of the actual plaintiffs (the real people that respondent's standing is based on) have migrated into and out of health care coverage. I just heard on the news today that one of them has even filed for bankruptcy protection (largely due to medical bills). I would have pointed to this as evidence that it is in fact impossible to opt out of the healthcare market. All that relatively low-risk people can really opt out of is paying their fair share into the system. . .for a while.
 
Article I, Section 8, Clause 1 of the US Constitution.

"The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence[note 1] and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States;"

So I'm not sure where the "unconstitutional" thing comes from. If you don't have health insurance, you pay a tax. A tax that congress shall have the power to lay and collect. A tax that provides for the general welfare.
 
If the individual mandate is unconstitutional, it makes no practical difference if it is severable or not because the law is unworkable without the mandate.

I'm actually hoping the individual mandate gets tossed, because it's idiotic to begin with. The only way health care reform works is to go single payer (i.e. "free" healthcare for all). Either do that or not, I don't care either way, because I have health coverage. Individual mandate will never work.
 
Oral arguments are mostly for show. The Justices are already well versed on the arguments and come into this with established views. The lines of questioning are mostly interesting because they signal how the Justices are likely to rule.

I agree with the first part of what you say, but not so much the last part. I've seen times where the questioning was very nearly deceptive wrt the final decision (and who voted which way).
 
In a practical sense, but not a legal one.

That's not true. If it can be shown that there is no logical way for one part of a law to stand without another, then they are deemed (legally) not severable.

If it can be shown that Congress never intended that one part should remain without another part, they are deemed not severable.

Stupid, unworkable laws aren't necessarily unconstitutional.
The question of severability is not the same as the question of constitutionality.

Also, the fact that part of a law might be stupid and unworkable doesn't mean that the law as a whole might not be stupid and might be workable. Indeed, that's why some parts of some laws are deemed not to be severable.
 
Article I, Section 8, Clause 1 of the US Constitution.

"The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence[note 1] and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States;"

So I'm not sure where the "unconstitutional" thing comes from. If you don't have health insurance, you pay a tax. A tax that congress shall have the power to lay and collect. A tax that provides for the general welfare.

Except the authority being argued is the Commerce Clause authority to regulate any activity that has a substantial effect on interstate commerce and not the power to raise taxes.

If we had a single payer system, the constitutional case would be a lot more clear, as you point out. But the Affordable Care Act attempts to make healthcare affordable to nearly everyone--particularly those not already covered-- in part by means of private insurance regulation, including the individual mandate.
 
Except the authority being argued is the Commerce Clause authority to regulate any activity that has a substantial effect on interstate commerce and not the power to raise taxes.

If we had a single payer system, the constitutional case would be a lot more clear, as you point out. But the Affordable Care Act attempts to make healthcare affordable to nearly everyone--particularly those not already covered-- in part by means of private insurance regulation, including the individual mandate.

But I thought health insurance wasn't interstate commerce because insurance companies couldn't sell across state borders. They had to get approval by each state separately.
 
I agree with the first part of what you say, but not so much the last part. I've seen times where the questioning was very nearly deceptive wrt the final decision (and who voted which way).

I suspect our positions on this are not very far apart. I think you can make high percentage guesses based on what the Justices say during oral arguments, but there is always a significant change those guesses will be wrong.
 
I do find it laughable (and not in a funny kind of way) that the conservative justices would bring up stuff (broccoli) that I would expect from people on this forum.
That it was in fact used on this forum and the justices as well should demonstrate that it is a legitimate analogy and concern as to where the limits are.

I've seen times where the questioning was very nearly deceptive wrt the final decision (and who voted which way).
Agreed. Neither side should count their chickens based on the line of questioning. Playing devils advocate doesn't always translate directly into the decision that you might think.
 
The federal government can forbid people from trading across State borders. That's quintessentially interstate commerce. The issue is whether the government can force someone to buy a commodity they didn't want to buy.

Saying it's a tax only redefined the problem. Can the government impose a tax on a class of people who don't take an affirmative act? It's one thing to tax income, which has a Constitutional amendment authorizing its enactment. It's another thing for the federal government to impose a "user fee" on an activity that a person could choose not to participate in. It's another to force a private citizen to either pay a fee/tax or buy a private commodity.

I think this does fall under the Commerce Clause, but I can see why it's so troubling to Constitutional scholars.
 
Agreed. Neither side should count their chickens based on the line of questioning. Playing devils advocate doesn't always translate directly into the decision that you might think.

This is partly what concerns me. Remember the Bakke case? Trying to make sense of that decision gave me headaches. The only clear winner was Bakke, who got to attend UC Davis. (Which, btw, is about an hour from me.)
 
The Court is taking arguments now, and questions the Commerce Clause...



I realize there's several threads about the health care law, but I'm hoping to stick solely to the Supreme Court's discussion. I'm also hoping the legal eagles on this board will be able to enlighten, because this linked article is anything but. Could someone please tell me what they're thinking with this line of questioning?

No legal eagle either, but from what I've read/heard today, it's basically the nut of the "inactivity argument". There was apparently much to the discussion today about the distinction between "healthcare" and "private insurance"; with the government wanting to confate the two; and the conservative jurists wanting them separated. The point being, the law requires the purchase of insurance; while you can engage in the healthcare marketplace without it. So requiring the purchase of insurance is essentially creating a new market, if I'm understanding the argument correclty.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom