Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

Yes, but is the Supreme Court supposed to consider that question, or merely judge the law on its merits? Again, I don't recall the consequences of Citizens United being considered. The question was merely one of deciding whether it was in accordance with constitutional law.

The consequences are not being debated here. The issue is where is the limit. Does the government have an absolute right to require people to purchase something? If health insurance, then why not broccoli?
 
I'm wondering if they're going to try an drag the fact that you're required to have insurance to operate a car. That might be a separate point, but we'll see.
 
I'm wondering if they're going to try an drag the fact that you're required to have insurance to operate a car. That might be a separate point, but we'll see.

That's a state issue, not a federal government issue.
 
The consequences are not being debated here. The issue is where is the limit. Does the government have an absolute right to require people to purchase something? If health insurance, then why not broccoli?

I don't think the argument is that the government has an absolute right to require people to purchase something (i.e. broccoli).

I think the argument is that everyone is already participating in the health care system. If someone without insurance winds up in the emergency room they are provided health care at the expense of everyone else.

The idea is a very Republican, small-government, free-market idea that there should be no freeloaders. Ironically, few would argue that the big-government non-free-market approach -- a single-payer system -- is unconstitutional.

-Bri
 
That's a state issue, not a federal government issue.

I don't think the argument is that the government has an absolute right to require people to purchase something (i.e. broccoli).

I think the argument is that everyone is already participating in the health care system. If someone without insurance winds up in the emergency room they are provided health care at the expense of everyone else.

The idea is a very Republican, small-government, free-market idea that there should be no freeloaders. Ironically, few would argue that the big-government non-free-market approach -- a single-payer system -- is unconstitutional.

-Bri

Which almost dovetails into the point I was trying (clumsily) to make.
 
I don't think the argument is that the government has an absolute right to require people to purchase something (i.e. broccoli).

I think the argument is that everyone is already participating in the health care system. If someone without insurance winds up in the emergency room they are provided health care at the expense of everyone else.

But that too is the result of government action. So if that possible participation in the health care market (and it's only possible) is what justifies the mandate, then you're basically saying that the government can force you into the market so that it can dictate how you participate in it. And we're again left with the question: where is the limit of government power? Because I'm not seeing anyone actually drawing a solid line with the health care mandate on the allowed side. You say that government can't require arbitrary purchases, but I don't see any argument for why they can't which doesn't also forbid this mandate.

Oh, and state governments don't actually force anyone to get car insurance. They just require it as a condition of driving on public roads, but you're free to not do that. The health care mandate is not likewise conditional.
 
But that too is the result of government action.

You mean because the government doesn't allow hospitals to let people die if they can't prove that they can pay?

Oh, and state governments don't actually force anyone to get car insurance. They just require it as a condition of driving on public roads, but you're free to not do that. The health care mandate is not likewise conditional.

I didn't mention car insurance, but isn't the government forcing you to pay for those roads even if you don't drive on them?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I'm actually hoping the individual mandate gets tossed, because it's idiotic to begin with. The only way health care reform works is to go single payer (i.e. "free" healthcare for all).

FSM help me, I agree with Scrut. Obama's health care "reform" is the ultimate case of trying to polish a turd.
 
FSM help me, I agree with Scrut. Obama's health care "reform" is the ultimate case of trying to polish a turd.

Do you think if the mandate is tossed it will be replaced with a single-payer system?

-Bri
 
But I thought health insurance wasn't interstate commerce because insurance companies couldn't sell across state borders. They had to get approval by each state separately.

The current test for Commerce Clause authority is any activity that has substantial effect on interstate commerce.

This includes everything from growing wheat for your own consumption (Wickard v. Fillburn--where the collective activity of farmers not buying wheat on the open market by consuming over-quota wheat they grew themselves was seen as having a significant effect on interstate commerce) to growing pot for your own consumption (Gonzales v. Raich).
 
Oh, and state governments don't actually force anyone to get car insurance. They just require it as a condition of driving on public roads, but you're free to not do that. The health care mandate is not likewise conditional.

Sure it is.

Not one of the actual plaintiffs in this case has successfully opted out participation in the healthcare market.
 
I'm wondering if they're going to try an drag the fact that you're required to have insurance to operate a car. That might be a separate point, but we'll see.


As Brainster mentioned above, auto insurance is a state issue. The question here is the limit of the federal governemnt's authority. Under its original conception, the federal government was given authority to regulate interestate commerce, but was not supposed to interfer with purely state issues. Thus, some connection to interstate commerce was necessary to justify federal legislation.

The definition of what constituted "commerce" sufficient to warrant federal regulation has changed over time. The previous high water mark of federal authority under the Interstate Commerce Clause was the case of Wickard v. Filburn (1942) where the Supreme Court held that a farmer who was growing wheat for on-site consumption (feeding it to his animals) was subject to federal regulation because, the Court said, even though he was not selling the wheat himself his act of growing wheat for personal consumption influenced the overall price of wheat.

Since the Wickard case, the Court has backed away from that broad interpretation, but if the government gets its way here, I think it would go beyond Wickard. It would mean that inaction (i.e. not buying a product) would now represent commercial activity sufficient to warrant federal government regulation. Thus, the questions above related to whether there would be any limit to the federal government's authority under this interpretation (e.g. the federal government's authority to require the purchase of a cell phone or broccoli) are legitimate.
 
That's a state issue, not a federal government issue.

In today's argumentation, several justices mentioned McCulloch and the creation of the Bank of the U.S.

I've elsewhere mentioned federal flood insurance mandates.

The question to be decided, of course, is the issue Ziggurat just mentioned: whether we all participate in the economic activity being regulated. (I argued that we do since no one can meaningfully opt out of that participation. All they opt out of is paying into the system while they are low risk.)
 
the case of Wickard v. Filburn (1942) where the Supreme Court held that a farmer who was growing wheat for on-site consumption (feeding it to his animals) was subject to federal regulation because, the Court said, even though he was not selling the wheat himself his act of growing wheat for personal consumption influenced the overall price of wheat.
Actually it wasn't the activity of one single farmer. The court ruled that the effect of all the farmers who were doing this could be taken collectively as having a significant influence on interstate commerce. (Clearly, the activity of one farmer did not itself have such an influence.)

Since the Wickard case, the Court has backed away from that broad interpretation,
Wickard has not been reversed. The test is still the same: Congress has the authority to regulate any activity that has a significant effect on interstate commerce. This is current jurisprudence. In fact, the SCOTUS relied on Wickard in the 2005 Gonzales v. Raich marijuana case I just mentioned.

ETA:
It would mean that inaction (i.e. not buying a product) would now represent commercial activity sufficient to warrant federal government regulation.
Not really. Verilli argued that it's simply regulating activity in advance. I wouldn't have said it that way. I'd have pointed out that all the actual plaintiffs in this case have migrated into and out of health insurance coverage (and one just filed for bankruptcy protection, the result of which will be pushing those medical debts off onto the rest of the system). I would assert that we are all actively participating in the healthcare system, one way or another. Since we also have laws that mandate a minimum standard of treatment regardless of one's ability to pay, every one of us runs some measurable risk (and at the collective level, as in Wickard, this cost is quantifiable) of requiring medical treatment we can't possibly pay for that the system must account for. (So even "now" we are a cost to the system.)

Unless we not only remove the laws requiring treatment regardless of ability to pay but also pass laws prohibiting health care providers from giving "free" treatment and passing the cost on to others, then no one can truly opt out of this economic activity.

I've elsewhere pointed out that one could as easily have argued Wickard as regulating "inactivity". The real concern was the effect on the wheat market of these farmers not purchasing their wheat on the open market.
 
Last edited:
I didn't mention car insurance, but isn't the government forcing you to pay for those roads even if you don't drive on them?
I believe most highway funding comes from fuel taxes, so don't buy fuel, and you don't fund the roads, but this same line of reasoning could be used for everything else provided by the government. Unfortunately the analogy doesn't hold due to the fact that all those other things are funded by taxes, not by forcing people to buying something that they might not need or want from a private company, or face a financial penalty if they don't.
 
not by forcing people to buying something that they might not need or want from a private company,
Of course the Affordable Care Act doesn't do that. One can satisfy the minimum essential coverage mandate by having Medicare or Medicaid, by being a military vet, by having a great job where someone else buys your insurance for you, etc. In fact, very nearly half of our total healthcare spending is of the public sort. The law is neither worded as a mandate to buy private insurance, nor is that the actual effect in all cases. In fact, under the Affordable Care Act, many of the currently uninsured will get coverage from the expansion of Medicaid.

And see my previous posts about the "something they might not need" issue. We all run the risk of requiring medical treatment that cannot be refused on the basis of ability to pay that we personally cannot afford to pay for.
 
It would mean that inaction (i.e. not buying a product) would now represent commercial activity sufficient to warrant federal government regulation.

I don't think that is quite right. Not buying health insurance is choosing to not pay for the insurance that is emergency medicine. And that is an insurance that everyone has. It is true that any given uninsured person may never use emergency services. This is true for people who pay for their insurance as well. But it is still there for them. It is just paid for by the rest of us.
 
Actually it wasn't the activity of one single farmer. The court ruled that the effect of all the farmers who were doing this could be taken collectively as having a significant influence on interstate commerce. (Clearly, the activity of one farmer did not itself have such an influence.)


Yes, I should have clarified that. The Court stated that it was the potential aggregate effect of farmers growing their own wheat for personal use that mattered. Still, I've always thought Wickard was the highwater mark. Lopez and Morrison seemed to say, "Hey, now Congress, you can't just call anything 'commerce' and regulate willy-nilly."
 
Of course the Affordable Care Act doesn't do that.
It does do that.
One can satisfy the minimum essential coverage mandate by having Medicare or Medicaid, by being a military vet, by having a great job where someone else buys your insurance for you, etc. In fact, very nearly half of our total healthcare spending is of the public sort. The law is neither worded as a mandate to buy private insurance, nor is that the actual effect in all cases.
That ALL people wouldn't be forced to obtain private insurance or face a penalty is irrelevant. SOME most certainly would. That you are still trying to make this argument is laughable, along with the "It doesn't actually force people to do anything..."
 
I'm actually hoping the individual mandate gets tossed, because it's idiotic to begin with. The only way health care reform works is to go single payer (i.e. "free" healthcare for all). Either do that or not, I don't care either way, because I have health coverage. Individual mandate will never work.

Do you support single payer?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom