Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

JoeTheJuggler

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jun 7, 2006
Messages
27,766
Just thought I'd start a new thread on this since oral argumentation began today.

The issues they'll take up are:
Monday: the issue of whether the Anti-Injunction Act applies (because if it does, the case can't go further until the mandate goes into effect and people are assessed the tax penalty).

Tuesday: the question of whether or not the individual mandate is constitutional

Wednesday: the question of whether or not the individual mandate is severable (that is, if it's deemed unconstitutional can just that portion of the law be struck down, or must the entire thing be voided)


The transcript of today's oral argumentation is here:

http://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transcripts/11-398-Monday.pdf

I have a question for the keen legal minds here about the issue argued today. Both parties in the case agree that the Anti-Injunction Act doesn't apply, and the Court appointed a special advocate to argue the position that it does.

Why exactly does the government not want to argue that the Anti-Injunction Act should apply?

It entails arguing that the tax penalty is indeed a tax (as are other tax penalties). In tomorrow's topic, the government will offer as an alternative argument (to the Commerce Clause authority) the authority of Congress to levy taxes.

I don't see what they gain by not arguing in favor of the Anti-Injunction Act. Just as a practical/political matter, there will be less popular support for the case against the Affordable Care Act after more of these measures have taken effect.

Is it simply that they're so confident that they'll win on the issue of the constitutionality of the mandate that they'd just as soon clear the constitutional challenge right away rather than postponing it?
 
Last edited:
Rumor is they are going to overlook the anti-injunction act. Bad precedent in my opinion. Hits at the root of "no harm, no foul."
 
Just thought I'd start a new thread on this since oral argumentation began today.

The issues they'll take up are:
Monday: the issue of whether the Anti-Injunction Act applies (because if it does, the case can't go further until the mandate goes into effect and people are assessed the tax penalty).

Tuesday: the question of whether or not the individual mandate is constitutional

Wednesday: the question of whether or not the individual mandate is severable (that is, if it's deemed unconstitutional can just that portion of the law be struck down, or must the entire thing be voided)
If the individual mandate is unconstitutional, it makes no practical difference if it is severable or not because the law is unworkable without the mandate.
 
Rumor is they are going to overlook the anti-injunction act. Bad precedent in my opinion. Hits at the root of "no harm, no foul."

This is based on an old law that the court can't consider tax cases until someone is actually required to pay the tax. That won't happen for a couple of years, using the government's argument that the fine is a tax legally. (That Obama swore on a stack of bibles while trying to pass this that the fine was not a tax and now swears it is, thus justifying it legally, is odd to say the least.)

In any case, they work with what the government claims as it stands before the court, which is "It's a tax!" but apparently had a difficult time actually making that case.
 
Last edited:
This is based on an old law that the court can't consider tax cases until someone is actually required to pay the tax. That won't happen for a couple of years, using the government's argument that the fine is a tax legally. (That Obama swore on a stack of bibles while trying to pass this that the fine was not a tax and now swears it is, thus justifying it legally, is odd to say the least.)

In any case, they work with what the government claims as it stands before the court, which is "It's a tax!" but apparently had a difficult time actually making that case.

Yeah, didn't one of the Justices comment on that? That today the Gov is arguing it's not a tax to get past this hurdle, but tomorrow they'll be arguing it is a tax...

This one is going to be fun.
 
If the individual mandate is unconstitutional, it makes no practical difference if it is severable or not because the law is unworkable without the mandate.

Isn't that another way of saying it's not severable?

FWIW, I agree it's not severable--at least all the large main features of the law. Clearly Congress did not conceive of the insurance reforms without the individual mandate. That situation would allow unfettered gaming of the system (everyone still paying for insurance would be chumps since they could stop making premium payments until such a time as they required costly medical care), and would pretty much spell the end of the private insurance industry.
 
This is based on an old law that the court can't consider tax cases until someone is actually required to pay the tax. That won't happen for a couple of years, using the government's argument that the fine is a tax legally. (That Obama swore on a stack of bibles while trying to pass this that the fine was not a tax and now swears it is, thus justifying it legally, is odd to say the least.)

Actually that's not true. The government agreed with the petitioner respondents on this point. The person who argued that the AIA should apply was an advocate appointed by the court.

My question is, why did the government take that position? Why would they not want to argue that the AIA is applicable just to postpone the big constitutional test?

The two main issues argued wrt to the AIA yesterday was the question as to whether or not the Affordable Care Act was a jurisdictional statute or a claims-processing statute and the question as to whether the tax penalty is a tax for purposes of the AIA.

My guess is that the court will agree with the parties that the AIA does not apply and the case should be decided now (or this June).
 
Last edited:
Rumor is they are going to overlook the anti-injunction act. Bad precedent in my opinion. Hits at the root of "no harm, no foul."

What do you mean by "overlook"? They heard arguments on that issue yesterday, and since the court has made it an issue at controversy, and they've taken the case, they will have to resolve it. They will probably resolve it by deciding that the AIA doesn't apply. They are certainly not overlooking it! Yesterday's transcript on this issue ran over 90 pages! And that doesn't include the briefs filed by 3 different parties! (I doubt if there were any amicus briefs filed, but they're conducting a fairly in-depth analysis of the arguments on this point.)
 
I thought Day 3 they were going to discuss the Medicaid expansion as well; actually that's all I've heard about tomorrow's discussion at this point. I had also heard the were going to consider severability though, so I'm a bit confused.

Anyway, to your first point--I think the Admin wanted to get the case through the courts this year, ahead of the election and have it sorted once and for all.

Not a great day for the ACA today; though I'm not sure anything was set int stone today either. The optimistic projecitons of potentially near-unanimous support now appear far fetched; but I don't know that it's doomed either.

As for severability; the only bit the Administration is saying needs to get ditched if the mandate falls is community rating/pre-existing condition exclusion. It will be interesting to see how the discussions go tomorrow.
 
I thought Day 3 they were going to discuss the Medicaid expansion as well;

You are correct. Tomorrow, oral arguments will be on the topics of severability and the constitutionality of the federal intrusion into state Medicaid programs.
 
As for severability; the only bit the Administration is saying needs to get ditched if the mandate falls is community rating/pre-existing condition exclusion. It will be interesting to see how the discussions go tomorrow.

Yep. The petitioner respondent will argue for complete non-severability (if the mandate is voided, the entire Act is to be voided); the government will argue that only key provisions are non-severable (if the mandate is voided those few provisions have to be voided); and a court-appointed advocate will argue the position that the mandate is completely severable (can be voided without touching anything else).

[ETA: D'oh! I've been incorrectly calling the respondent "the petitioner". The government is the petitioner (asking for appeal) and Florida et. al is the respondent.]
 
Last edited:
Anyway, to your first point--I think the Admin wanted to get the case through the courts this year, ahead of the election and have it sorted once and for all.
Which seems to me a strategy born of confidence.

Not a great day for the ACA today; though I'm not sure anything was set int stone today either. The optimistic projecitons of potentially near-unanimous support now appear far fetched; but I don't know that it's doomed either.

Trying to suss out the final decision based on the justices' question in oral arguments is always a fool's errand, but I think you're right. After today, I'm thinking 5-4 or 6-3 is far more likely than a 7-2 decision.
 
One issue hinted at, but not discussed in detail in today's argument, is the effect of other government health programs, for which there is no specific constitutional mandate, for which payment is compulsory and for which some services are provided by private businesses.

Some have wondered whether there is a basis for knocking down the Affordable Care Act WITHOUT knocking down the programs that people really like.

If the five guys on the Supreme Court swat down the Affordable Care Act, will they inadvertently swat down Medicare as well? Highly unlikely, I think. But if they uphold Medicare, then could not the Medicare program be expanded to cover everyone? ("Medicare For All" was proposed as one approach to health care.) The end result would be essentially the same, except the insurance companies could lose out.

(By the way, did anybody notice the irony that Justice Alito seemed to fear that insurance companies might be getting too much money from people who don't make many claims? "[It] appears to me that the CBO has estimated that the average premium for a single insurance policy in the non-group market would be roughly $5,800 in -- in 2016. Respondents ... estimate that a young, healthy individual targeted by the mandate on average consumes about $854 in health services each year. So the mandate is forcing these people to provide a huge subsidy to the insurance companies...." This remark represents a staggering indication by the Justice that he did not understand what insurance is all about, and Justice Ginsburg could hardly believe her ears: "If you're going to have insurance, that's how insurance works.")

Most troubling, perhaps, is the notion of five members of the US Supreme Court that the United States CAN'T do something that every other leading nation in the world CAN do and HAS DONE. For shame.
 
SCOTUS Hears Health Care Arguments

The Court is taking arguments now, and questions the Commerce Clause...

Justice Anthony Kennedy, whose questioning is closely watched because he represents a potential swing vote, posed several skeptical queries to the Obama administration's lawyer.

"Can you create commerce in order to regulate it?" he asked. "I understand we must presume laws are constitutional" until it is demonstrated otherwise, he told Solicitor General Donald Verrilli, representing the administration. But he said the administration has "a heavy burden of justification."

I realize there's several threads about the health care law, but I'm hoping to stick solely to the Supreme Court's discussion. I'm also hoping the legal eagles on this board will be able to enlighten, because this linked article is anything but. Could someone please tell me what they're thinking with this line of questioning?
 
I find the transcript fascinating. Mostly, what I find fascinating is how poorly prepared the Solicitor General appeared to be. I mean on page 15, Justice Breyer basically step sin and tells Verrilli that the answers he just gave to Alito, Scalia, and Ginsberg were incorrect and then gives him what Breyer clearly thinks is the appropriate answer. And I find Breyer's answer much better than Verrilli's.

It seems to me that the Court is split as expected. Alito and Scalia seem firmly committed to the idea that the Commerce Clause does not authorize Congress to compel individual people to enter the market for health insurance. Sotomayor, Kagan, Ginsberg and Breyer seem to believe the Commerce Clause does authorize such powers. Thomas said nothing at the argument (not unusual), but he has always had the narrowest interpretation of the Commerce Clause of the nine, even narrower than Scalia, so I think it's a fair bet he will vote to overturn it. Which leaves Kennedy and, to my surprise, Roberts, who each indicate an ambivalence to both sides of the argument. I would not be surprised to see the statute upheld 6-3 with only Scalia, Thomas, and Alito dissenting. However, I would be equally unsurprised to see it struck down 5-4.

On a personal note, I think Scalia and Kagan had the best senses of humor during the argument.

The Constitution, as is often said, is a document of limited grant of federal power. And that seems anachronistic in a time when people assume the federal government's only limit is the Bill of Rights. These other limits -- particularly the Commerce Clause -- seem antiquated. But if they are antiquated, it's not the shame of the Supreme Court for enforcing them; it's the shame of the American electorate for not amended the Constitution to eliminate it. (That said, I'm fairly convinced that the Health Care Act is authorized under the Commerce Clause.)
 
Looks like Verrilli is in the soup...

Verrilli appeared to stumble over his words at the beginning of his hourlong questioning, and took a drink of water less than a minute after beginning his statement before composing himself. After the oral arguments were over, some court watchers weren't exactly kind when assessing his performance.

CNN legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin said that the day's arguments were a "train wreck" for the Obama administration and that Verrilli seemed unprepared. "I don't know why he had a bad day," he said. "He is a good lawyer, he was a perfectly fine lawyer in the really sort of tangential argument yesterday. He was not ready for the answers for the conservative justices."

Time Magazine writer Kate Pickert wrote on Twitter that Verrilli "lost his footing a bit," relying on the liberal Justices to remind the other Justices of the key arguments for the law. Washington Post columnist Ezra Klein said Verrilli "lost big."

I'm not sure how anyone can say he "lost big," at least not yet. The court hasn't gone to chambers to discuss this yet.
 
The big headline today in regards to this is how the conservative justices were questioning where a health insurance mandate would lead. Mandatory purchases of broccoli, cell phones, and burial insurance were brought up.

My question is: Is this an appropriate line of questioning? Isn't the Supreme Court just supposed to weigh the legality and not theorize about potential consequences? That certainly seemed to be the case during the whole Citizens United kerfuffle.
 
I think it's a perfectly apropos line of questioning. If the government can compel you to buy health insurance, it establishes a very dangerous precedent (that is, that the government can compel you to buy stuff).

My personal opinion (IANAL, but I have considerable experience in the health-insurance field) is that the law will fail on this point and the next administration will have to try another tack. Eventually (I predict by 2020) there will be universal healthcare in the US; the simplest way to accomplish this will be to extend Medicare to everyone and increase the payroll deduction to cover the increased cost (to maybe 3% from the current 1.45%). I'll take my million in twenties, Mr. Randi.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom