JoeTheJuggler
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2006
- Messages
- 27,766
Just thought I'd start a new thread on this since oral argumentation began today.
The issues they'll take up are:
Monday: the issue of whether the Anti-Injunction Act applies (because if it does, the case can't go further until the mandate goes into effect and people are assessed the tax penalty).
Tuesday: the question of whether or not the individual mandate is constitutional
Wednesday: the question of whether or not the individual mandate is severable (that is, if it's deemed unconstitutional can just that portion of the law be struck down, or must the entire thing be voided)
The transcript of today's oral argumentation is here:
http://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transcripts/11-398-Monday.pdf
I have a question for the keen legal minds here about the issue argued today. Both parties in the case agree that the Anti-Injunction Act doesn't apply, and the Court appointed a special advocate to argue the position that it does.
Why exactly does the government not want to argue that the Anti-Injunction Act should apply?
It entails arguing that the tax penalty is indeed a tax (as are other tax penalties). In tomorrow's topic, the government will offer as an alternative argument (to the Commerce Clause authority) the authority of Congress to levy taxes.
I don't see what they gain by not arguing in favor of the Anti-Injunction Act. Just as a practical/political matter, there will be less popular support for the case against the Affordable Care Act after more of these measures have taken effect.
Is it simply that they're so confident that they'll win on the issue of the constitutionality of the mandate that they'd just as soon clear the constitutional challenge right away rather than postponing it?
The issues they'll take up are:
Monday: the issue of whether the Anti-Injunction Act applies (because if it does, the case can't go further until the mandate goes into effect and people are assessed the tax penalty).
Tuesday: the question of whether or not the individual mandate is constitutional
Wednesday: the question of whether or not the individual mandate is severable (that is, if it's deemed unconstitutional can just that portion of the law be struck down, or must the entire thing be voided)
The transcript of today's oral argumentation is here:
http://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transcripts/11-398-Monday.pdf
I have a question for the keen legal minds here about the issue argued today. Both parties in the case agree that the Anti-Injunction Act doesn't apply, and the Court appointed a special advocate to argue the position that it does.
Why exactly does the government not want to argue that the Anti-Injunction Act should apply?
It entails arguing that the tax penalty is indeed a tax (as are other tax penalties). In tomorrow's topic, the government will offer as an alternative argument (to the Commerce Clause authority) the authority of Congress to levy taxes.
I don't see what they gain by not arguing in favor of the Anti-Injunction Act. Just as a practical/political matter, there will be less popular support for the case against the Affordable Care Act after more of these measures have taken effect.
Is it simply that they're so confident that they'll win on the issue of the constitutionality of the mandate that they'd just as soon clear the constitutional challenge right away rather than postponing it?
Last edited: