JoeTheJuggler
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2006
- Messages
- 27,766
Yes, I should have clarified that. The Court stated that it was the potential aggregate effect of farmers growing their own wheat for personal use that mattered.
Yes--"aggregate" is the term. I probably shouldn't use "collective".
Still, I've always thought Wickard was the highwater mark. Lopez and Morrison seemed to say, "Hey, now Congress, you can't just call anything 'commerce' and regulate willy-nilly."
That implies that there has been a reversal of or backing away from Wickard. It's still the test, and it's still current law. (Obviously the current court could reverse it. Or they could distinguish the facts in this case from those in Wickard.)
Neither Lopez nor Morrison reversed Wickard. They just said the activity regulated had to be economic activity that had a substantial direct effect on interstate commerce (and not an indirect effect). At any rate, Gonzales v. Raich was later than those two cases, and was decided in favor of the federal government. Hard to say that Wickard is a higher-water mark than Gonzales v. Raich wrt CC authority.