Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

Yes, I should have clarified that. The Court stated that it was the potential aggregate effect of farmers growing their own wheat for personal use that mattered.

Yes--"aggregate" is the term. I probably shouldn't use "collective".

Still, I've always thought Wickard was the highwater mark. Lopez and Morrison seemed to say, "Hey, now Congress, you can't just call anything 'commerce' and regulate willy-nilly."

That implies that there has been a reversal of or backing away from Wickard. It's still the test, and it's still current law. (Obviously the current court could reverse it. Or they could distinguish the facts in this case from those in Wickard.)

Neither Lopez nor Morrison reversed Wickard. They just said the activity regulated had to be economic activity that had a substantial direct effect on interstate commerce (and not an indirect effect). At any rate, Gonzales v. Raich was later than those two cases, and was decided in favor of the federal government. Hard to say that Wickard is a higher-water mark than Gonzales v. Raich wrt CC authority.
 
But that too is the result of government action. So if that possible participation in the health care market (and it's only possible) is what justifies the mandate, then you're basically saying that the government can force you into the market so that it can dictate how you participate in it. And we're again left with the question: where is the limit of government power? Because I'm not seeing anyone actually drawing a solid line with the health care mandate on the allowed side. You say that government can't require arbitrary purchases, but I don't see any argument for why they can't which doesn't also forbid this mandate.

Oh, and state governments don't actually force anyone to get car insurance. They just require it as a condition of driving on public roads, but you're free to not do that. The health care mandate is not likewise conditional.

Yes and your free to not go to the hospital just go and die quietly.
 
Yes and your [sic] free to not go to the hospital just go and die quietly.

I hope that wasn't a veiled threat directed at my esteemed forum friend and frequent intellectual adversary, Ziggurat. That'd be against the forum rules. . . .

To the point, in fact, a person who is unconscious gives implied consent to treatment, so even a person who really wanted to opt out of the healthcare system altogether (unlike all of the actual plaintiffs in this case), they actually aren't free to do that. They would not be able to prevent getting care (even care that they might not be able to afford) in such a situation.
 
That implies that there has been a reversal of or backing away from Wickard. It's still the test, and it's still current law. (Obviously the current court could reverse it. Or they could distinguish the facts in this case from those in Wickard.)

Neither Lopez nor Morrison reversed Wickard. They just said the activity regulated had to be economic activity that had a substantial direct effect on interstate commerce (and not an indirect effect). At any rate, Gonzales v. Raich was later than those two cases, and was decided in favor of the federal government. Hard to say that Wickard is a higher-water mark than Gonzales v. Raich wrt CC authority.


It's been many years since I've read any of the cases, but I seem to recall Congress going to great lengths to try and link the aggregate economic effects of domestic violence to interstate commerce and the Morrison Court still standing its ground and not buying the argument that the economic effects of domestic violence warranted federal regulation under the Commerce Clause. That suggests to me that Wickard did not have the reach it once did.

As for Raich -- again, I have not read it in years -- but I thought the Court was more concerned about the potential interstate transportation of marijuana (and thus the federal government's ability to regulate) than it was about the aggregate effect individual marijuana growers would have on the market price.
 
It does do that.
That ALL people wouldn't be forced to obtain private insurance or face a penalty is irrelevant. SOME most certainly would. That you are still trying to make this argument is laughable, along with the "It doesn't actually force people to do anything..."

Nobody is being forced to buy anything from any private company. Anyone can pay a tax penalty and not purchase health insurance.

-Bri
 
It's been many years since I've read any of the cases, but I seem to recall Congress going to great lengths to try and link the aggregate economic effects of domestic violence to interstate commerce and the Morrison Court still standing its ground and not buying the argument that the economic effects of domestic violence warranted federal regulation under the Commerce Clause. That suggests to me that Wickard did not have the reach it once did.
Those cases cited Wickard. They distinguished the cases as I have noted (the activity wasn't economic and its effects on interstate commerce weren't direct).
 
I hope that wasn't a veiled threat directed at my esteemed forum friend and frequent intellectual adversary, Ziggurat. That'd be against the forum rules. . . .

To the point, in fact, a person who is unconscious gives implied consent to treatment, so even a person who really wanted to opt out of the healthcare system altogether (unlike all of the actual plaintiffs in this case), they actually aren't free to do that. They would not be able to prevent getting care (even care that they might not be able to afford) in such a situation.


Um no
 
Nobody is being forced to buy anything from any private company. Anyone can pay a tax penalty and not purchase health insurance.

And indeed the law itself doesn't say minimum essential coverage has to come from a private insurance company.

If each of the states passed their own "public option" for example, the mandate would be satisfied without anyone having to purchase private insurance.

The fact that some people will have to purchase insurance or pay a tax penalty doesn't mean this is a law that mandates the purchase of private insurance.

Neally, would you say that the IRS tax code is a law that requires the purchase of pencils? Or that requires contracting the services of a commercial tax preparer or accountant? Some people have to do these things in order to comply with the tax code.
 
As for Raich -- again, I have not read it in years -- but I thought the Court was more concerned about the potential interstate transportation of marijuana (and thus the federal government's ability to regulate) than it was about the aggregate effect individual marijuana growers would have on the market price.

Raich relied heavily on Wickard:

Of particular relevance here is Wickard v. Filburn, 317 U.S. 111, 127—128, where, in rejecting the appellee farmer’s contention that Congress’ admitted power to regulate the production of wheat for commerce did not authorize federal regulation of wheat production intended wholly for the appellee’s own consumption, the Court established that Congress can regulate purely intrastate activity that is not itself “commercial,” i.e., not produced for sale, if it concludes that failure to regulate that class of activity would undercut the regulation of the interstate market in that commodity. The similarities between this case and Wickard are striking.

My point being that the test for Commerce Clause authority laid out in Wickard is still the law of the land. Basically that Congress has the authority to regulate any economic activity (even activity taken in aggregate) that has a substantial effect on interstate commerce.

In fact, according to Raich's assessment of Lopez, the Lopez decision broadened the authority by saying that the activity taken in aggregate didn't have to affect interstate commerce in fact, but only that there had to be a "rational basis" for concluding that it would.

If the current Court strikes down the individual mandate, I don't think it's likely they will void Wickard to do so. Even the conservative justices recognize it as established law. They would accept arguments that differentiate this case from Wickard. (If the court upholds the mandate, we can look for this reasoning in the dissenting opinion.)
 
Those cases cited Wickard. They distinguished the cases as I have noted (the activity wasn't economic and its effects on interstate commerce weren't direct).


If domestic violence and its effects (i.e. emergency medical care, etc.) is not directly related to interstate commerce (Morrison), I'm having a hard time understanding how not purchasing private health insurance is.
 
Last edited:
I stand by what I said in a previous thread:

None of this matters.

It will find its way to the SCOTUS, where it will be ruled unconstitutional in a 5-4 decision.

None of this matters. Not the arguments. Not the questions during arguments. Not even whether the ACA mandate is in fact unconstitutional or not. For cases of such political magnitude, the SCOTUS is a purely political institution.

The breakdown will be along "party lines":

ACA Mandate Unconstitutional: Roberts, Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, Alito.

ACA Mandate Constitutional: Ginsberg, Breyer, Sotomayor, Kagan.

The mandate (and with it the ACA) are going down, 5-4. This has been a preordained outcome since before the POTUS even signed it into law. Since before the details of the ACA legislation were hammered out, even! I am so certain of this result - including the specific breakdown of Judges above - that I'll stake a one month forum avatar bet with anyone here over it.

Lo, I have spoken. Yea verily. May God have mercy on your souls.
 
Last edited:
Just getting into the oral arguments, but reading it has been sort of a chore, considering how much Verrilli fumbles over his words. Maybe the audio would be better.

I did enjoy Kennedy on page 24 or 25 talk about the difference constitutionally between single-payer and the ACA. Basically, if a single-payer system is constitutional, why isn't using market-oriented means to derive themselves same result? It involves the same powers: If we just made it Medicare for all, we would all be forced to pay the tax, and thus we'd be de facto forced to have insurance. Why does the provider matter?
 
Last edited:
Sure it is.

Not one of the actual plaintiffs in this case has successfully opted out participation in the healthcare market.

You're arguing standing. That's a very weak defense of the constitutionality of a law. Especially given how tenuous you need to make the definition of "participation".
 
I stand by what I said in a previous thread:



None of this matters. Not the arguments. Not the questions during arguments. Not even whether the ACA mandate is in fact unconstitutional or not. For cases of such political magnitude, the SCOTUS is a purely political institution.

The breakdown will be along "party lines":

ACA Mandate Unconstitutional: Roberts, Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, Alito.

ACA Mandate Constitutional: Ginsberg, Breyer, Sotomayor, Kagan.

The mandate (and with it the ACA) are going down, 5-4. This has been a preordained outcome since before the POTUS even signed it into law. Since before the details of the ACA legislation were hammered out, even! I am so certain of this result - including the specific breakdown of Judges above - that I'll stake a one month forum avatar bet with anyone here over it.

Lo, I have spoken. Yea verily. May God have mercy on your souls.

Further evidence it ain't just health care that's broken.
 
You mean because the government doesn't allow hospitals to let people die if they can't prove that they can pay?

Yes. And? Remember, what we're arguing about is the constitutionality of the law, not whether or not it would be a good thing.

I didn't mention car insurance

Others have.

but isn't the government forcing you to pay for those roads even if you don't drive on them?

The government is forcing me to pay taxes. What they do with those taxes is a different question. That's the way the system works. But this mandate isn't a tax. Nor is it the equivalent of a tax.
 
I think it's a perfectly apropos line of questioning. If the government can compel you to buy health insurance, it establishes a very dangerous precedent (that is, that the government can compel you to buy stuff).

Some things I have to buy or pay a penalty for not doing so:

Safety belts
Gun lock
IRS Form 6969 (although, if I hadn't waited so long, I could have gotten it free from the IRS)
Checking account/credit card/money order/cashiers check to pay my taxes
Social Security Insurance
Funeral (well, my heirs -- they can't simply put my body in the trash)
Trash pickup
Lawn care -- or get cited for "blight"

Arguably, I could opt out of some of these.
 
Some things I have to buy or pay a penalty for not doing so:

Safety belts

Only if you buy a car that you drive on public roads.


Only if you keep a gun in your house.

IRS Form 6969 (although, if I hadn't waited so long, I could have gotten it free from the IRS)

Then you didn't have to buy it.

Checking account/credit card/money order/cashiers check to pay my taxes

That is often available for free.

Social Security Insurance

Again, taxes. And you didn't buy that, because you don't own it. You have no legal right to it.

Funeral (well, my heirs -- they can't simply put my body in the trash)

Your heirs can, if they so choose, leave you and your estate for the government to clean up.

Trash pickup
Lawn care -- or get cited for "blight"

Both contingent upon owning a house.

Arguably, I could opt out of some of these.

You could opt out of all of them except the taxation. But the mandate isn't a tax.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom