Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

I'd love to get into data more, really deep into it, including figuring out whether there's too much treatment of the "worried well," where preventive screening works (financially) and where it doesn't; estimates of cost savings if primary care were delivered by nurses or nurse practitioners; the average number of visits in, say, initial cancer diagnoses (primary care visit, referral to radiological screening, referral BACK to primary care then referral to oncologists (or whatever the usual sequence); millions/billions spent per year on unnecessary antibiotics to fight viral infections; costs due to criminal acts; potential inflationary temptation due to third-party payers; potential inflationary costs to due to lawsuits and malpractice insurance; inflationary temptations due to a startling lack of price transparence; costs spent trying to save limbs that end up having to be amputated; costs due to seat belt and helmet infractions; cost spent in predictable end-of-life scenarios (NOT aggressive treatments where cures are possible); etc. Just everything.

Because I understand everybody dies, and that if you need catastrophic care you will get it if you present with an emergency. Is it better to seize assets, thus driving people to indigence and eligibility for public benefits, or is it better (fiscally, socially) to have some level of universal coverage beforehand?

I want reliable data and arguments that are neither unrealistic about what reform can deliver nor driven excessively by "everyone dies, tough luck" social Darwinism. If anyone knows of any let me know. Preferably from sources taking a neutral view politically. If there are such things.
 
...Is it better to seize assets, thus driving people to indigence and eligibility for public benefits, or is it better (fiscally, socially) to have some level of universal coverage beforehand?...
If I buy more of any good or service than I can afford, bankuptcy court will "seize assets". Aggregating responsibility for payment for any good or service into the State's hands expands the numbers of people whose assets the State seizes (taxation). Considerations of moral hazard and the tragedy of the commons suggest that bankruptcy will increase under the subsidized scheme.

You might find a disinterested supplier of treatment effectiveness statistics and mortality statistics by various categories. I find hard to imagine anyone sufficiently informed to present the range of policy options who has no policy preference.
 
I'd love to get into data more, really deep into it, including figuring out whether there's too much treatment of the "worried well," where preventive screening works (financially) and where it doesn't; estimates of cost savings if primary care were delivered by nurses or nurse practitioners; the average number of visits in, say, initial cancer diagnoses (primary care visit, referral to radiological screening, referral BACK to primary care then referral to oncologists (or whatever the usual sequence); millions/billions spent per year on unnecessary antibiotics to fight viral infections; costs due to criminal acts; potential inflationary temptation due to third-party payers; potential inflationary costs to due to lawsuits and malpractice insurance; inflationary temptations due to a startling lack of price transparence; costs spent trying to save limbs that end up having to be amputated; costs due to seat belt and helmet infractions; cost spent in predictable end-of-life scenarios (NOT aggressive treatments where cures are possible); etc. Just everything.

Because I understand everybody dies, and that if you need catastrophic care you will get it if you present with an emergency. Is it better to seize assets, thus driving people to indigence and eligibility for public benefits, or is it better (fiscally, socially) to have some level of universal coverage beforehand?

I want reliable data and arguments that are neither unrealistic about what reform can deliver nor driven excessively by "everyone dies, tough luck" social Darwinism. If anyone knows of any let me know. Preferably from sources taking a neutral view politically. If there are such things.
About the only way that what you would like to do can be done is to limit the scope of the inquiry to a particular clearly specified subset of medical treatments, procedures and associated ailments. Then you may reach valid conclusions.
 
I find hard to imagine anyone sufficiently informed to present the range of policy options who has no policy preference.

Yeah, me too. Which means getting data from people who do have policy preferences and being skeptical about all of it. A UK reader asked some time ago, how much premiums would be if his National Health package was delivered via insurance. I'd like that info too but if anyone even hazarded a guess, I missed it.
 
Yeah, me too. Which means getting data from people who do have policy preferences and being skeptical about all of it. A UK reader asked some time ago, how much premiums would be if his National Health package was delivered via insurance. I'd like that info too but if anyone even hazarded a guess, I missed it.
That's okay because exactly where you are headed with this line of beliefs and inquiry is an opinion that if you were provided with the facts and statistics, you could do an efficient and possibly even an optimal job on a government death panel.

I suggest you carefully think about this and not laugh it off - this attitude is the problem, not the solution.
 
That's okay because exactly where you are headed with this line of beliefs and inquiry is an opinion that if you were provided with the facts and statistics, you could do an efficient and possibly even an optimal job on a government death panel.

I suggest you carefully think about this and not laugh it off - this attitude is the problem, not the solution.
What's wrong with information? Government policy planners can contribute to efficient markets with targeted regulation and data can guide policy design. Whether planners will use their power for good is a separate question.
 
You are suggesting everything takes a back seat to heart problems? The fact that our costs are rising faster than all other systems, that so many American's don't have health care, you would give up everything for a single data point, isn't that special pleading?

But aren't you ignoring everything else for this? Isn't that cherry picking? Or do you have some special pleading to justify your cherry picking?

No, ignoring everything but the relevant stats that saves lives is not cherry picking.

Making other stats important, and important to the point of overriding the lifesaving stats, is murder.

Heavy-handed socialism, which saves some lives (one assumes), but slows business down, and thus slows technological growth, murders because more people die from delayed tech introduction than are saved. This is not even close.

If Europe's business climate (not just socialized medicine) were freer, more like that of the US, the planetary medical tech level (among other techs) would probably be at least 10 years ahead. Their scientific production has been dropping, per-capita, further and further behind the US for at least 5 decades.

The entire planet on the "horrible, savage" US style medical insurance system, or lack thereof, with 10 year better tech than today, would save many, many more lives than socialized medicine does with free, universal handouts of 2012-level tech.

Ergo, socialism (of the style that kicks business in the balls) is mass-murder.
 
Last edited:
You guys are rushing to shove currently-existing pillows under dying men's heads, when you should be creating cures.


And kicking the pillow-makers in the balls, and feeling warm and fuzzy for the effort. :(
 
No, ignoring everything but the relevant stats that saves lives is not cherry picking.
It's a single issue. There are other issues and other nations have lower mortality rates. Sifting through all of the data to pick a single data point to justify a POV is the very definition of cherry picking.

Making other stats important, and important to the point of overriding the lifesaving stats, is murder.

Heavy-handed socialism, which saves some lives (one assumes), but slows business down, and thus slows technological growth, murders because more people die from delayed tech introduction than are saved. This is not even close.

If Europe's business climate (not just socialized medicine) were freer, more like that of the US, the planetary medical tech level (among other techs) would probably be at least 10 years ahead. Their scientific production has been dropping, per-capita, further and further behind the US for at least 5 decades.

The entire planet on the "horrible, savage" US style medical insurance system, or lack thereof, with 10 year better tech than today, would save many, many more lives than socialized medicine does with free, universal handouts of 2012-level tech.

Ergo, socialism (of the style that kicks business in the balls) is mass-murder.
If people on the left use words like "socialism" the right is all over them whipping out the dictionary. Mhaze, wildcat, etc. will go to great lengths to tell you that what you call socialism isn't in fact socialism. Well, they won't tell you because you are on the right.

In any event, these are assertions, ad hoc and straw men. Pare it down and clean it up and we can talk.

RE: mass-murder, odd that other nations have UHC, lower mortality rates and yet they are committing mass-murder.
 
You guys are rushing to shove currently-existing pillows under dying men's heads, when you should be creating cures.


And kicking the pillow-makers in the balls, and feeling warm and fuzzy for the effort. :(
There is no valid argument here. European nations have pillow makers that do great stuff and saving an awful lot of lives.
 
You guys are rushing to shove currently-existing pillows under dying men's heads, when you should be creating cures.


And kicking the pillow-makers in the balls, and feeling warm and fuzzy for the effort. :(
But that's what someone who wants to take control "can do". He can't create cures or innovate. He has to work with the past, the stuff that he can loot from people who built it.

Get power today, have fun, why worry?
 
It's a single issue. There are other issues and other nations have lower mortality rates. Sifting through all of the data to pick a single data point to justify a POV is the very definition of cherry picking.
Selecting a topic on which to comment from the JREF forum is "cherry picking" then.
 
What's wrong with information? Government policy planners can contribute to efficient markets with targeted regulation and data can guide policy design. Whether planners will use their power for good is a separate question.
ABSOLUTELY NOT.

It's the classic problem in any business model of having the same guy handle accounts receivable and accounts payable. You don't do that.

Here the question is should the government be allowed to produce it's own statistics and "information" and then on those basis spend your money on procedures and life giving or taking.

Many, many examples of the abuse and outright lying by governments exist in this sort of environment.

"The better I cook the numbers, the more money I can keep".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom