Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

That's what the law does do. Except, because the word "tax" is unpopular, they call it a "fine" for not buying insurance. But functionally it's a tax.

No, it isn't. Functionally, if it works perfectly, nobody pays it at all, and no revenue is obtained. That's not how taxes work, that's how fines work.
 
For example, the government could force grocery stores to provide free samples of broccoli.

Assuming this is constitutional, how would that force everyone in the country to participate unless grocery stores are forced to feed you broccoli if you pass out in their store? There seems to be a pretty clear line between providing emergency health care and broccoli.

Not according to Congress or Obama. And the penalty IS intended to force you to purchase health insurance. That's its explicit justification.

Actually, the Obama administration is saying that it's a tax and is collected through the tax system. And it doesn't force you to purchase health insurance, but rather provides an option whereby you don't have to purchase health insurance. There's no chance of jail or other punishment if you don't purchase health insurance.

-Bri
 
No, it isn't. Functionally, if it works perfectly, nobody pays it at all, and no revenue is obtained. That's not how taxes work, that's how fines work.

If it works perfectly, nobody is freeloading, no extra expenses are incurred by taxpayers because everyone is covered, and there's no reason to collect the tax. It's a tax on people without insurance.

-Bri
 
No, it isn't. Functionally, if it works perfectly, nobody pays it at all, and no revenue is obtained. That's not how taxes work, that's how fines work.
Remarks like this remind me of a study or survey I once thought about doing, the premise of which is this:

One person pays money to another. What legal consequences attach to that payment?

It's simple question, but payments of money are called by an astonishing number of names, and the legal consequences attendant to the payment depend upon which name is most apt. Is the payment a fee (and if so, what kind of fee)? Is it a tax (and if so, what kind)? Is it a dividend? A surcharge? A refund? A bribe? A wage? A penalty? A premium? A reward? Interest? A disbursement? A stock purchase? A real estate purchase? A settlement? A kickback? A subsidy? A contribution? A donation? Rent? A gift? A bequest? Tribute? Duty? A tithe? A toll? An assessment? Dues? A rebate? An allowance? A capital expenditure? A levy? A fine? Shipping and handling? Points? Salary? A deduction? An admission? A bet? Earnest money? A loan? A down payment? A grant? A profit? A bonus? The list of names for particular kinds of payments of money, each perhaps treated differently under the law, could go on and on.

There often are not clear demarcations between or among the various categories. It can be difficult to define the categories and to determine which category or categories a particular payment falls into.
 
Dumb idea - instead of making it a tax added on if you fail to have insurance, why not apply the tax across the board on everyone, and then provide tax credits for those who have insurance?
Only if employer-provided health insurance is taxed as ordinary income.

This is one of the major flaws in the US system - tying health insurance to employment. That link should be broken, and the best way to do it is to tax such benefits as ordinary income.

The ACA actually further entrenches this mindless relic from World War II. I favor UHC, but the ACA is the clumsiest, most flawed attempt at UHC ever constructed in the history of mankind. Remember when foreigners on this board couldn't understand American's skepticism that the US government could do it right? Now they know.
 
Last edited:
Only if employer-provided health insurance is taxed as ordinary income.

No, it doesn't need that. In fact, you DON'T want to tie to deductions.

I propose a tax credit. Everyone has a baseline tax of XXXX. All you have to do is demonstrate that you have met the minimum requirement for health insurance, and you are given a tax credit of XXXX.

I get a tax credit just for having children, and it is not tied at all to the actual cost of raising them. This would work the same way.
 
No, it isn't. Functionally, if it works perfectly, nobody pays it at all, and no revenue is obtained. That's not how taxes work, that's how fines work.

As far as the Constitution is concerned, any measure that might obtain revenue for the government can be described as a tax. The distinction between "tax" and "fine" might matter to lay people, but the Constitution makes no such distinction.

I paid more taxes before I owned a home than I did before, because I could not take the mortgage deduction to my income taxes. Was I being taxed for having a taxable level of income and yet not owning a home, or was I being fined for not owning a home despite having a taxable level of income? It's a distinction without a difference. It's money going to the government.
 
I propose a tax credit. Everyone has a baseline tax of XXXX. All you have to do is demonstrate that you have met the minimum requirement for health insurance, and you are given a tax credit of XXXX.

If you're throwing out ideas that Congress will never implement, why not just sever the connection between the employer and health care entirely, go with single-payer, and be done with it?

-Bri
 
Assuming this is constitutional, how would that force everyone in the country to participate unless grocery stores are forced to feed you broccoli if you pass out in their store? There seems to be a pretty clear line between providing emergency health care and broccoli.



Actually, the Obama administration is saying that it's a tax and is collected through the tax system. And it doesn't force you to purchase health insurance, but rather provides an option whereby you don't have to purchase health insurance. There's no chance of jail or other punishment if you don't purchase health insurance.

-Bri
This would fall under IRS collection procedures for someone not paying a tax or a penalty. These matters are very clearly understood.

And they most certainly do take your house away, seize your bank account, etc.

see sections 7201 and 7203 of the code

The bolded part is wrong.
 
Last edited:
If domestic violence and its effects (i.e. emergency medical care, etc.) is not directly related to interstate commerce (Morrison), I'm having a hard time understanding how not purchasing private health insurance is.
The activity being regulated isn't not purchasing health insurance. It's participation in the health care system. The regulation involves not allowing people to lack coverage. But the not buying (or even not having) insurance isn't the activity that gives rise to the CC authority.

The activity being regulated is that taken in the aggregate health care services provided to people without coverage costs the health care system a measurable amount of money*. This is a significant effect on interstate commerce.

*In 2004, it was something like $40 billion. http://www.kff.org/uninsured/upload...uld-full-coverage-add-to-medical-spending.pdf
 
If you're throwing out ideas that Congress will never implement, why not just sever the connection between the employer and health care entirely, go with single-payer, and be done with it?

-Bri

But why can't they implement this? It is effectively the exact same result as what they have now, but doing it without introducing a "fine." Do it as a tax with a tax credit.
 
As far as the Constitution is concerned, any measure that might obtain revenue for the government can be described as a tax. The distinction between "tax" and "fine" might matter to lay people, but the Constitution makes no such distinction.

And FWIW, the tax penalty for the mandate actually is intended to raise revenues to help defray the costs to the system incurred by the uninsured. In the CBO estimates, that revenue was part of the calculation. So I think it's wrong to claim that the goal of the tax penalty is strictly as a penalty and not at all to raise revenue.
 
No, it isn't. Functionally, if it works perfectly, nobody pays it at all, and no revenue is obtained. That's not how taxes work, that's how fines work.

Nah. You can't claim that people opting to pay the penalty rather than buy coverage that they can afford isn't also working perfectly. It's part of the law, so why would implementing it not be seen as the law working as intended?

(See also my previous post. The revenue from the penalty was part of the CBO cost estimate.)
 
If it works perfectly, nobody is freeloading, no extra expenses are incurred by taxpayers because everyone is covered, and there's no reason to collect the tax. It's a tax on people without insurance.

Again, why isn't the way that is likely to happen--that some people opt to pay the tax penalty rather than buy coverage--also considered the law working perfectly? I don't understand the argument that the law functioning as it's designed to isn't the law working perfectly.

The money collected from the tax penalty is actual revenue.

One could as well argue that "sin taxes" don't work perfectly as long as they're actually implemented. Sure the taxes might be designed to discourage smoking (or whatever), but they're also taxes in that they raise revenues. For that matter, we could spin federal fuel taxes as "penalties" that discourage fuel consumption too. While that might be an unintended consequence, it doesn't mean they're not taxes.
 
The activity being regulated isn't not purchasing health insurance. It's participation in the health care system. The regulation involves not allowing people to lack coverage. But the not buying (or even not having) insurance isn't the activity that gives rise to the CC authority.

The activity being regulated is that taken in the aggregate health care services provided to people without coverage costs the health care system a measurable amount of money*. This is a significant effect on interstate commerce.

*In 2004, it was something like $40 billion. http://www.kff.org/uninsured/upload...uld-full-coverage-add-to-medical-spending.pdf

A pretty good amount of that is due to the pre existing legal requirement that emergency rooms treat anyone who walk in. Then there's some compensation back from the fed for those services.

Voila! Interstate commerce! Create it anytime you want! Then try to justify more government control because you've got grounds!

Wheee!!!

Why, it is so nice when you can invent problems that then you can solve. Except, of course, that these morons don't get the problem they thought they'd create, and can't solve a problem like 1+1 = 2.
 
Again, why isn't the way that is likely to happen--that some people opt to pay the tax penalty rather than buy coverage--also considered the law working perfectly? I don't understand the argument that the law functioning as it's designed to isn't the law working perfectly.

The money collected from the tax penalty is actual revenue.

One could as well argue that "sin taxes" don't work perfectly as long as they're actually implemented. Sure the taxes might be designed to discourage smoking (or whatever), but they're also taxes in that they raise revenues. For that matter, we could spin federal fuel taxes as "penalties" that discourage fuel consumption too. While that might be an unintended consequence, it doesn't mean they're not taxes.
I'm getting awfully tired of this doubletalk, weasel words, complicated redefinitions, and other sleazy lawyer tactics. For thousands of years, there have been taxation systems, and each included penalties for non payment, in order to insure compliance.

I think that's why the justices are having so much funny asking simple questions based on sound constitutional law to the plaintiff.
 
Last edited:
Just finished. Verrilli was not good, neither was Carver. Verrilli, i thought, had several opportunities to really make solid, cogent points and failed to do so. A big one was his response to Scalia's request to articulate the limiting principle to the mandate vis a his the commerce clause as succinctly as possible. Took him a few pages and several studders to make it happen.

Yep. In Tuesday's arguments, there were at least a couple of occasions where Ginsburg sort of did Verrilli's job for him (in the guise of asking a question). Even then, Verrilli did a poor job of saying, "Yes, that's exactly what I meant to say!"
 
I'm getting awfully tired of this doubletalk, weasel words, complicated redefinitions, and other sleazy lawyer tactics.

I think that's why the justices are having so much funny asking simple questions based on sound constitutional law to the plaintiff.

Thanks, haze, that's a well-reasoned reply to the content of my post.

Oh wait--nope. . it's not. It's just insulting arm-waving that fails to respond to the content of my post.
 
A pretty good amount of that is due to the pre existing legal requirement that emergency rooms treat anyone who walk in. Then there's some compensation back from the fed for those services.

That's more or less correct. And it makes my case. There is economic activity that has a significant and measurable effect on interstate commerce.

Also, the "some compensation back from the fed" is simply another example of passing the costs of care to the uninsured on to the system at large (in this case, to taxpayers).

Are you suggesting that we change the laws such that health care providers cannot pass costs of care for the uninsured on to others? You'd not only have to repeal EMTALA, you'd have to enact laws prohibiting hospitals from providing care to the uninsured and then passing those costs on in higher fees. Even if that's what you want, it's not how things are now, and it's not something that's ever going to happen.
 
But why can't they implement this? It is effectively the exact same result as what they have now, but doing it without introducing a "fine." Do it as a tax with a tax credit.

I don't think that changes anything wrt the constitutional questions. The court isn't limited to the superficiality of the language. They can consider intent and purpose. I think what you suggest is indeed exactly the same thing as the tax penalty.

(BTW, along with that tax credit there would need to be an increase in taxes or else the impact on reduced federal revenues would be significant. We know the vast majority of Americans already satisfy the individual mandate. While it's easy enough to give every man, woman and child a tax credit, it's very difficult to adjust tax rates such that the increase in tax liability for each person is exactly equal to the compliance-tax-credit you propose.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom