100% Proof Islamic Threat is Overblown

If Scientologists in Germany have expressed a desire to kill people, the German Government is totally justified monitoring them. However the document you have previously provided does not indicate this. Near as I can tell, the German Government appears to be monitoring them because they teach that only a person who has gone through their indoctrination can have "personal freedom", and for some reason the German Government has concluded this means they want to take away rights from German citizens.

Perhaps it is an error of translation?

Please stop your strawman arguments Oliver. If you want to address my concerns, address them.

-Gumboot


Weeeell, so it's okay to use the "Bundeskriminalamt" (German "FBI") if there are reasons to be concerned about possible murder from Scientology.

-BUT-

The "Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution" isn't' allowed to protect the constitution after Scientology actually did exactly that: Undermine it in several cases.

That makes sense... :rolleyes:

Good luck. :D

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R._v._Church_of_Scientology_of_Toronto
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Snow_White
 
*BUMP*

Do the FBI spy on non-criminal groups in the USA as a matter of policy?

-Gumboot


Yes, they do - here's a nice article mentioning some FBI-Spy-Programs:

http://www.independent.org/newsroom/article.asp?id=1544

About two weeks ago, the FBI admitted in federal court to collecting thousands of documents on non-violent activist groups, including the ACLU, Greenpeace and various antiwar organizations.
Throughout the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s, the FBI snooped on the personal lives of radical leftists, peace activists, and Civil Rights personalities such as Martin Luther King, infiltrated activist groups opposed to mandatory busing, and even spied on John Lennon.
Reborn as the “Bureau of Investigation” in the late 1920s, it continued to spy upon such “socialists” as Albert Einstein


Jesus, I already learned all of that in the first X-Files episode. :rolleyes: :D :p
 
Name just one such alleged law, and specify/quote exactly what it prohibits.
.....No, they prohibit the expression of certain beliefs and opinions.
For the slow of thinking, I will state here that that is simply not what Gumboot originally claimed.

Gumboot claimed originally certain opinions are prohibited.

He has now changed his tune and admitted that it is the public expression, not the opions themselves, that are prohibited.

*yawn* Totally unsurprised, it was just too easy. Tell us about hate-crime legislation in NZ, Gumboot, or NZ cooperation in surveillance of groups deemed to be potentially dangerous.
He quotes the law in Post 61... you lose this one big time Gurdur.
You wish. :D

He quoted NO such law backing up his original claim. D'oh. He quoted a law which does something quite different to what he claimed originally. I'm guessing that elementary logic was never your strong point?

BTW, do tell us all about T-shirts in the USA. Apparently some love forbidding the wearing of some T-shirts at times (see above). So much for expression of free speech.
 
BPSCG said:
That's ridiculous, and you know it. Freedom of speech has never included the right to incite murder, either in the US, or in Europe.
Ooooo, look, BPSCG is trying to claim an objective definition, and indulge in some sudden special pleading.
Gurdur, if you're going to reply to a post that wasn't directed to you, please at least answer the central question in that post, which was:
But freedom of speech does include to right to claim, publicly, that the Holocaust never happened, or to glorify Hitler. At least it does in the US. Does that right exist in Germany? Yes or no?
Does the right to claim, publicly, that the Holocaust never happened, or to glorify Hitler, exist in Germany? Yes or no?
 
Gurdur, if you're going to
Given your repetetive dishonesty, and your childish games of altering quotes, let alone your constant hysteria, you know, somehow I just don't take you personally too seriously at all.

So how about you tell us all about the wearing of T-shirts in the USA? Hmmmmm? Or of course ACLU's worries about the FBI.

Really, this is all too easy. If you or gumboot make inflated claims, they get shot down; the grasp of elementary logic is something you really should try to attain.
 
How strange, in view of the fact that $cientology are quite busy in NZ, and even congratulating themselves on certain successes.



Thanks for that. I stand corrected. I'm not sure I'd agree that they are "very busy in New Zealand", nor that being designated a charity by the IRD is much of a success to get excited over.





Thanks for that. It looks like ACLU is stirring up a storm, which is good to see. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe ACLU is contending that what the FBI is allegedly doing is illegal and unconstitutional?

-Gumboot
 
So, gumboot, you are totally unable to back up your claim and actually cite just one such law with details.


I quoted the law in question, and provided a link to it. If it lacks detail, take up your issue with the German government, not me.



No, I don't. Dishonest much?


So why did you link to an article about the Australian police doing precisely that, in support of your spying claim?



Do you understand the actual facts, that NZ helps monitor organizations and individuals who advocate certain ideologies, such as Islamist jihadism?


You have evidence to support this claim? I dispute your claim. It is not a fact. It is a lie.

-Gumboot
 
Really, this is all too easy. If you or gumboot make inflated claims, they get shot down; the grasp of elementary logic is something you really should try to attain.
Say's the guy who thinks the arrest of a suspect in Australia, in relation to the recent terrorist activity in the UK, is some sort of proof he had been under surveillance for some time.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Given your repetetive dishonesty, and your childish games of altering quotes, let alone your constant hysteria, you know, somehow I just don't take you personally too seriously at all.
Translation: "I'd rather engage in some more ad hominem attacks than actually answer a serious question."

Okay, thanks. I think your refusal to answer a simple yes-or-no question tells me what I need to know: The right to deny the Holocaust, or to glorify Hitler, does not exist in Germany.

Frankly, I wasn't expecting anything more from you than your usual streams of triumphalist self-congratulation. But I do like to see you come snarling out of your cage from time to time so newbies here can observe, and be instructed. That accomplished, my work here is done. Have a nice day!
 
Weeeell, so it's okay to use the "Bundeskriminalamt" (German "FBI") if there are reasons to be concerned about possible murder from Scientology.


Absolutely.




The "Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution" isn't' allowed to protect the constitution after Scientology actually did exactly that: Undermine it in several cases.

That makes sense... :rolleyes:


Well that's something of a murky area. The entire notion of a government agency to protect the constitution is a bit strange to be honest. Surely that's the duty of the judiciary?

As for undermining the constitution, well again, it depends how you define "undermining". I have read the official government report on this matter, which you provided me. I couldn't find any point in there that indicated Scientology had acted in a way which undermined the constitution.

Perhaps you can clarify this matter for me, instead of your constant strawman arguments, attacks on my character, and so forth.

In plain English (sorry, I don't know much German), please paraphrase the actions by the Church of Scientology in Germany that undermine the German Constitution.






Waht bearing do either of these have on Germany?

-Gumboot
 
For the slow of thinking, I will state here that that is simply not what Gumboot originally claimed.

Gumboot claimed originally certain opinions are prohibited.

He has now changed his tune and admitted that it is the public expression, not the opions themselves, that are prohibited.


Gurdur is of course correct. I did originally claim that certain ideas are prohibited, when in fact the law prohibits the expression of certain ideas - either publicly or at a "meeting" (which pretty much means anywhere).

I guess I took it for granted that most people realise the German government cannot read people's minds, and thus cannot punish people for certain ideas until those ideas are expressed.

In light of Gurdur's objections, allow me to rephrase my claims.

The German government prohibits the expression of certain ideas and beliefs. I contend that in a free society it is not illegal to express a personal belief, no matter how distasteful it may be to others.



*yawn* Totally unsurprised, it was just too easy. Tell us about hate-crime legislation in NZ, Gumboot, or NZ cooperation in surveillance of groups deemed to be potentially dangerous.


The New Zealand government is only legally permitted to carry out surveillance in New Zealand under authority of a warrant. Such warrants are issued by the court, and require that the group being monitored is suspected of criminal activity. It is not permissible for any branch of the New Zealand government to carry out surveillance on a group based on their ideological beliefs.

Furthermore there is no specific hate crime legislation in New Zealand. The role of hate-crime in New Zealand is only relevant in the sentencing of a person found guilty of a crime. Like many other common law nations, numerous factors are permitted to be considered in sentencing, including the general character of the offender and their apparent remorse. These factors are considered either mitigating (justify a lighter sentence) or aggravating (justify a harsher sentence).

You cannot be convicted of a hate crime in New Zealand.

Recently, the New Zealand government tried to introduce an Anti Hate Speech law, and it was thoroughly rejected.

-Gumboot
 
Absolutely.

Well that's something of a murky area. The entire notion of a government agency to protect the constitution is a bit strange to be honest. Surely that's the duty of the judiciary?

As for undermining the constitution, well again, it depends how you define "undermining". I have read the official government report on this matter, which you provided me. I couldn't find any point in there that indicated Scientology had acted in a way which undermined the constitution.

Perhaps you can clarify this matter for me, instead of your constant strawman arguments, attacks on my character, and so forth.

In plain English (sorry, I don't know much German), please paraphrase the actions by the Church of Scientology in Germany that undermine the German Constitution.

Waht bearing do either of these have on Germany?

-Gumboot


It might sound strange to have the Bundesverfassungsamt (Complicated translation: "Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution"), but it monitors possible threats against the constitution -AKA- Organizations who "disagree" with it, such as Jihadists, Nazis, the radical Left and Groups like that.

What's the New Zealand Federal Office called that monitors Groups like radical Jihadists?

You may start with the FAQ concerning Scientology vs. Germany:
  1. Is scientology a religion in Germany ?
  2. Under what status does scientology operate in Germany?
  3. How is scientology doing in german courts?
  4. What's the meaning of legal precedents in german courts?
  5. How is scientology reacting about the labor court decision?
  6. What about the "InSects" booklet ?
  7. What's going on with "Chick" Corea?
  8. Hasn't a criminal investigation on the co$ been closed?
  9. Were any scientologists sent to jail?
  10. How many scientology members are there in Germany?
  11. Any links between Scientology and right-extremists?
  12. Does scientology get money thru real-estate deals of its members?
  13. Were children expelled out of Kindergartens?
  14. Why is Germany more attacked by scientology than other countries?
  15. Who is Ursula Caberta?
  16. Who is Wiebke Hansen?
  17. What are the human rights violations against scientology?
  18. Does scientology own a german beer company?
  19. Are there similarities between pictures in the SS magazine "Der Stürmer" and german newspapers?
  20. Can "Xena Warrior Princess" be seen in Germany ?
  21. Did the State Department mention Germany negatively?
  22. Did a UN report mention Germany negatively?
  23. Did the OSCE mention Germany negatively?
  24. How does the german constitution protect religions?
  25. What exactly does the labor court decision say?
  26. What was decided in Bavaria?
  27. What does the german population think about scientology?
  28. Overview of recent legal trouble by scientology / scientologists
This is the official Statement posted on the Website of the German Embassy
in Washington:

Background Papers
Scientology and Germany
Understanding the German View of Scientology
 
Gurdur is of course correct. I did originally claim that certain ideas are prohibited, when in fact the law prohibits the expression of certain ideas - either publicly or at a "meeting" (which pretty much means anywhere).

I guess I took it for granted that most people realise the German government cannot read people's minds, and thus cannot punish people for certain ideas until those ideas are expressed.

In light of Gurdur's objections, allow me to rephrase my claims.

The German government prohibits the expression of certain ideas and beliefs. I contend that in a free society it is not illegal to express a personal belief, no matter how distasteful it may be to others.
Gumboot, rest assured that most of us did understand your point, long before this post.
 
It might sound strange to have the Bundesverfassungsamt (Complicated translation: "Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution"), but it monitors possible threats against the constitution -AKA- Organizations who "disagree" with it, such as Jihadists, Nazis, the radical Left and Groups like that.


Their role seems somewhat superfluous to me.




What's the New Zealand Federal Office called that monitors Groups like radical Jihadists?


There isn't one. (We're not a Federation so there isn't a Federal Office of anything).

The New Zealand Police have the authority to obtain warrants to monitor individuals or organisations suspected of criminal activity.

The Security Intelligence Service has the responsibility of advising the New Zealand government of security risks to New Zealand (including immigrants who are suspected of being terrorists). The SIS is a civilian organisation and has no enforcement role, although it has limited authority to intercept communications and conduct searches under a warrant.

The New Zealand Police are not permitted to monitor groups that preach radical ideologies, but are not suspected of criminal activities (a New Zealand court would refuse a warrant application).


You may start with the FAQ concerning Scientology vs. Germany:


Thanks, although that doesn't seem to address my question. That FAQ seems primarily focused on whether Scientology should be considered a religion. Although I usually refer to it as a religion, that's not really something I car about. I don't think religion should be defined by government. A religion is defined by the religion's belief that they are a religion. However at the same time, neither should a government be required to recognise a particular group as a religion.




This is the official Statement posted on the Website of the German Embassy
in Washington:

Background Papers
Scientology and Germany
Understanding the German View of Scientology


Thanks, that's more what I was looking for.

-Gumboot
 
The German government prohibits the expression of certain ideas and beliefs. I contend that in a free society it is not illegal to express a personal belief, no matter how distasteful it may be to others.


I'm sorry if I have to disagree with your understanding - as long there are no libel-, slander-, hate-hatemongering -Laws at all in New Zealand.

The law in question about "free speech" here in Germany is called "Volksverhetzung" - Translation: (stirring up the populace by hatemongering)

Similar laws exist around the world, for instance:


Now even if it's hard to understand, it might be even harder to understand that the big majority of people here are glad about- and agree with this law because it pretty much punishes >public<, radical thinking that opposes the constitutional understanding of equality of all humans.

Hate-Mongering against an ethic group/gender/race etc. therefore is considered as criminal act - which is why I try to compare it with libel or slander for you to get a better feeling for this law as non-german citizen.

Concerning the "Holocaust-Denial", in this context, is partly considered as hate-mongering against Jews. The closest explanation for you to understand this law is libel/slandering again:

Holocaust denial is illegal in a number of European countries. Many countries also have broader laws against libel or inciting racial hatred, as do a number of countries that do not specifically have laws against Holocaust denial, such as Canada and the United Kingdom.

Many Holocaust deniers claim their work should be protected by a universal right to free speech, and see these laws as a confirmation of their own beliefs, arguing that truth does not need to be legally enforced. However, the argument that laws punishing holocaust denial are incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights and the UN Declaration on Human Rights have been rejected by institutions of the Council of Europe (the European Commission of Human Rights,[76] the European Court of Human Rights[77]) and also by the United Nations Human Rights Committee.[78]

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust_denial_laws#Laws_against_Holocaust_denial
 
I'm sorry if I have to disagree with your understanding - as long there are no libel-, slander-, hate-hatemongering -Laws at all in New Zealand.

The law in question about "free speech" here in Germany is called "Volksverhetzung" - Translation: (stirring up the populace by hatemongering)




Now even if it's hard to understand, it might be even harder to understand that the big majority of people here are glad about- and agree with this law because it pretty much punishes >public<, radical thinking that opposes the constitutional understanding of equality of all humans.

Hate-Mongering against an ethic group/gender/race etc. therefore is considered as criminal act - which is why I try to compare it with libel or slander for you to get a better feeling for this law as non-german citizen.

Concerning the "Holocaust-Denial", in this context, is partly considered as hate-mongering against Jews. The closest explanation for you to understand this law is libel/slandering again:



Oliver neither Slander nor Libel are criminal offenses.

-Gumboot

ETA. And I do not agree with the anti-hate speech laws in the UK either, although I do understand the motivation for implementing them as they actually do have a very serious problem with Radical Islam.

Do you consider Neo-Nazis and Holocaust Deniers to be a serious problem in Germany?
 
Their role seems somewhat superfluous to me.

There isn't one. (We're not a Federation so there isn't a Federal Office of anything).

The New Zealand Police have the authority to obtain warrants to monitor individuals or organisations suspected of criminal activity.

The Security Intelligence Service has the responsibility of advising the New Zealand government of security risks to New Zealand (including immigrants who are suspected of being terrorists). The SIS is a civilian organisation and has no enforcement role, although it has limited authority to intercept communications and conduct searches under a warrant.

The New Zealand Police are not permitted to monitor groups that preach radical ideologies, but are not suspected of criminal activities (a New Zealand court would refuse a warrant application).


Well, basically the "Verfassungsschutz" is one of the german intelligence agancies - specialized in domestic threats:

List of intelligence agencies of Germany:
  • Office of Intelligence of the Federal Armed Forces (ANBw) – Amt für Nachrichtenwesen der Bundeswehr
  • Office for Radio Monitoring of the Federal Armed Forces (AFMBw) – Amt für Fernmeldewesen Bundeswehr
  • State Office for the Protection of the Constitution (LfV) – Landesamt für Verfassungsschutz
Thanks, although that doesn't seem to address my question. That FAQ seems primarily focused on whether Scientology should be considered a religion. Although I usually refer to it as a religion, that's not really something I car about. I don't think religion should be defined by government. A religion is defined by the religion's belief that they are a religion. However at the same time, neither should a government be required to recognise a particular group as a religion.

Thanks, that's more what I was looking for.

-Gumboot


Well, the Crux is that the Mafia itself could change their status to a "Religion". Does that mean they should be allowed to do so and have "a good, legal time?" - just because they're a religion now?

You sounded like this is the case in New Zealand: "They're all welcome - without any questions". :confused:

The Embassies Statement concerning this issue is:

In Germany, there is no process by which the government officially recognizes a religion. However tax authorities grant tax-exempt status to organizations that act in the public interest and are non-profit. Some 10,000 groups have requested and received tax free status, but to date, the Scientology organization has repeatedly failed to establish its qualifications. Among the groups that are tax free are the Jehovah's Witnesses and the Mormons. On March 22, 1995, the Federal Labor Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht) ruled that the Scientology branch in Hamburg was not a religious congregation, but clearly a commercial enterprise. In its decision, the court quotes one of L. Ron Hubbard's instructions "make money, make more money -- make other people produce so as to make money" and concludes that Scientology purports to be a "church" merely as a cover to pursue its economic interests.

source: http://www.germany.info/relaunch/info/archives/background/scientology.html


You may also review this link to get an idea what the concerns are about:


Scientology - Major Criminal Convictions:
http://www.scientology-lies.com/convictions.htmlhttp://www.scientology-lies.com/crimesindex.html
http://www.scientology-lies.com/convictions.html
 
Last edited:
Oliver neither Slander nor Libel are criminal offenses.

-Gumboot

ETA. And I do not agree with the anti-hate speech laws in the UK either, although I do understand the motivation for implementing them as they actually do have a very serious problem with Radical Islam.

Do you consider Neo-Nazis and Holocaust Deniers to be a serious problem in Germany?


I brought it up because Libel&Slandering are the closest explanations for this law - because their similarity for you to understand it in a better way. Now this might not be the best translation, but "criminal" translates to: "against the law", well, at least my translator says so. :boxedin:
Anyway: You know what I meant, don't you?

Concerning your question: I don't consider Holocaust Denier as a threat - they're just stupid Truthers in my own humble opinion.

Neo-Nazis also are a pretty minor problem. Of course there are big news about it whenever there is an incident, especially here in Germany, but on one hand this minority is getting observed just like the Jihadists and other radical groups - on the other hand most of these Nuts are Teenagers who grow up in most cases.

So one way or another, I'm not concerned, nor do I see them as major threat to the public or my freedoms.
 
The last two pages of this thread are rife with red herrings.

Anyone for some crackers, vokda, slivered onions and capers to go with the herring?

DR
 
Well, the Crux is that the Mafia itself could change their status to a "Religion". Does that mean they should be allowed to do so and have "a good, legal time?" - just because they're a religion now?

You sounded like this is the case in New Zealand: "They're all welcome - without any questions". :confused:



Oliver, with all due respect, you don't seem to be taking in anything I'm posting.

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom