100% Proof Islamic Threat is Overblown

...to Canada and their nasty Canadian military interventions around the globe. :D
You're starting to understand, Thank you.

Oh Wait: Don't they have freedoms in Canada, too???

Canuck, Canuck uber alles, Uber alles................:D :jaw-dropp :rolleyes:
 
That's because our governments and security agencies do take this threat seriously and are acting upon it, like those terror cells that were busted:
http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/n...d5d6cc&k=46849, http://www.canada.com/national/natio...a-3c8f6009581c

and those plots that were foiled :
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/08/10/AR2006081000152.html, http://cnn.websites-blog.com/2006/US/02/09/whitehouse.plots/index.html.



It may sound like a dumb question but how many terrorist attacks do you think were prevented if 14,352 Terror Attacks actually happened? :confused:

I also think that you wouldn't know about the links you gave if 9/11 wouldn't have happened and Terrorism wouldn't be such a trendy issue.

So let me ask: How many terrorist-attacks were prevented in Canada BEFORE 9/11. Do you have a "Counter terrorism-Federal Office" in Canada and could you link me to their official reports?
 
Stop putting words in my mouth. You said "The nazis were in a position the islamofascists will likely never be." Europe's current demographics say it's a distinct possibility.

Sure it's a possibility, but I still think it's unlikely.

Look, Tony, if you don't have a reasonable answer for a question, you really don't have to try to answer. Saying "I don't know" is a perfectly honorable response.

How is that unreasonable? It will resemble europe because those people will have grown up in and carried on the traditions of european governance.
 
It is a dumb question.


Well, let's proof or disproof your point once and for all:

Do you have a "Counter terrorism-Federal Office" in Canada and could you link me to their official reports?
 
Oliver, you seem to be the one using Twoofer logic:

If it did happen, it didn't happen enough, if it didn't happen, then it's not a threat. :hypnotize
 
Do you have a link for that stat about Mohammed being the second most popular boys' name in the UK? I'm not accusing you of making it up because I saw it reported too, but it would really surprise me if it was actually true. Muslims can't make up more than a few percent of the population, five at the very most I would say. They must be calling almost every male child Mohammed, and having a LOT of them, to make that stat true. :confused:

Plus, I've met many muslim males, and none of them have been called mohammed to my recollection.
UK's office for National Statistics
 
Oliver, you seem to be the one using Twoofer logic:

If it did happen, it didn't happen enough, if it didn't happen, then it's not a threat. :hypnotize


Nope, that's not my point. My point is that "X000" terror-attacks happened in Iraq since the beginning of the war.

Do we hear them yell about that? No.
Do we hear Pardalis whine about none terror attacks in Canada? Yes.

Why? Because 2 or 3 plots were prevented. :D

Sorry, but you're cute. :)
 
Nope, that's not my point. My point is that "X000" terror-attacks happened in Iraq since the beginning of the war.

If that's you point, then your point is irrelevant.

Do we hear them yell about that? No.
Actually, yes.

Do we hear Pardalis whine about none terror attacks in Canada? Yes.
Actually, no. I'm not whining, that's your strawman.

Why? Because 2 or 3 plots were prevented.
Remind me to thank the Canadian police and government.

Sorry, but you're cute. :)
I know.
 
How is that unreasonable? It will resemble europe because those people will have grown up in and carried on the traditions of european governance.
You're assuming the Muslim immigrant population will somehow be assimilated into the culture that is already there. The problem is, the Europeans have, up to now, shown little interest in assimilating their Muslim populations, and the Muslim populations show little interest in being assimilated. The result has been an angry Muslim underclass - think of France's car-torching youth - that may well not have any particular European values when they become the majority in the next 50 years.

To say, "Europe will resemble Europe" is not an answer; it's a tautology. How much will it resemble today's Europe? Will it resemble today's Europe more than it resembles today's Pakistan?
 
If that's you point, then your point is irrelevant.

Actually, yes.

Actually, no. I'm not whining, that's your strawman.

Remind me to thank the Canadian police and government.

I know.


I'm studying your countries Counter-Terrorism-Reports right now:

source: http://www.csis-scrs.gc.ca/en/publications/annual_report.asp

1993: Overall, the global security environment reflects a marked drop in superpower tensions and a reduction in traditional espionage activities which characterized the cold war era. Conversely, a rise in the number of conflicts involving nationalist, ethnic, religious and economic forces continues to pose a range of threats to Canadian security.

1993: With the growth abroad of extremist groups and incidents in the 1970s, international terrorism had become a significant concern from which Canada was clearly not immune. The 1982 assassination of a Turkish diplomat in Ottawa confirmed the point. So too did the attempted take-over of the Turkish Embassy in 1985. The greatest tragedy took place in June of that same year when an Air India aircraft, having departed Toronto, exploded in flight off the coast of Ireland, killing 329 people.

1994: Incidents of Islamic extremist violence continue to increase and have become more disquieting as they spill over into Western countries.


Sorry, Pardalis - Look's like the threat isn't new to Canadians - and even if Terrorism was also an "increasing threat" back in 1993, I see no reason to believe in your worries because you're telling nothing new. Same old business as before 9/11 ... exactly what I said. :rolleyes:
 
Do you have a "Counter terrorism-Federal Office" in Canada and could you link me to their official reports?
Counter-terrorism and intelligence gathering duties used to be handled by the RCMP. But after a couple of high-profile cases of wrongdoings in their handling of certain investigations some decades back, such duties were stripped from them.

A new organization was then created to handle such tasks - it's called the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, or CSIS for short.

You can find the English language version of their web site here. Have a look around it - I'm sure you can probably dig up some reports on it.

Here, I'll even get you started. On this page you can find a list of publications they have put together on terrorism-related matters.

ETA: I see now you've already found it.
 
So why should I be more concerned about radical Muslims?


Because as a percentage of your population they're increasing dramatically. (And by "your population" I mean Europe's population).

85% of Europe's population increase is due to immigration, and the overwhelming majority of those are Muslims. In addition, if we look at the population increase due to the birth rate, the birth rate of European Muslims is triple that of non-Muslims. Do the math.

Finally, and here's probably one of the key points, Radical Islam is far more widespread than anyone is willing to accept. If the supposedly most moderate mainstream mosques in the UK are preaching extremism, there's a major problem.



And I don't even mention New Zealand here. Looks like the countries with the smallest groups of Muslims are the most concerned ones, [ETA] according to Gumboot. [/ETA] :boggled:


New Zealand is not concerned at all. My view on this matter is quite different to that of my fellow countrymen.

-Gumboot
 
So? You seem to see this as a zero sum gain. It doesn't follow that western civ is declining because former colonies are wanting self-determination. Furthermore, since countries around the world are increasing adopting western language, clothing, science, entertainment, sports, political systems and ideologies, I'd say Western Civ's lock on the world is solid for a very long time. What do you see as Western Civilization?



By Western Civilisation I mean the fundamental values of Western Civilisation - free society, equality, liberalism, and so forth.

The independence of former western colonies is actually a product of western civilisation. But many of those nations are now rejecting those values. Look at Fiji for a prime example. There are countless others all over the Pacific, Africa, and Middle East.




So I consider that a bad thing.


Umm no. Division in the west now is not anywhere near the levels it was during WW1 or WW2.

I disagree. Despite our conflicts, and despite the brief ugliness of Nazi Germany, the ideological values of our societies have been very similar. Now they're not. Liberals and conservatives are diverging into extremist positions.



Frankly, your position is "the sky is falling" and you show symptoms of "good ole days" syndrome.


The sky's not falling. It's changing, as it always does. The notion of "western civilisation is invincible" is stupid and wrong. All civilisations fall.

As for "good ole days" syndrome, I'm not old enough to have ant "good ole days". :p

I think right now are the "good ole days". I consider our current state more or less the height of western civilisation.

-Gumboot
 
By Western Civilisation I mean the fundamental values of Western Civilisation - free society, equality, liberalism, and so forth.

The independence of former western colonies is actually a product of western civilisation.
Fascinating. You mean like, um, it's Western thinking that gave the former colonies independence, because, like, it was aliens who had taken them over in the first place and profited out of them in the first place?

Or like Mahatma Ghandi was such a paragon of Western thinking that he successfully led a national campaign, despite violence against him and his followers, against those UFO-aliens who were desperate to hold onto Empire?

Or was it a prime example of Western thinking that finally got Vietnam de-colonialised?

Those damn UFO-aliens, grabbing those colonies in the first place.

And of course, the Amritsar Massacre was carried out by those same UFO-aliens, while Western thinking opposed it!
________

Hint: face up to it, modern thinking owes just as much to East as to West, and to South as to North.
 
Because as a percentage of your population they're increasing dramatically. (And by "your population" I mean Europe's population).

85% of Europe's population increase is due to immigration, and the overwhelming majority of those are Muslims. In addition, if we look at the population increase due to the birth rate, the birth rate of European Muslims is triple that of non-Muslims. Do the math.

Finally, and here's probably one of the key points, Radical Islam is far more widespread than anyone is willing to accept. If the supposedly most moderate mainstream mosques in the UK are preaching extremism, there's a major problem.

New Zealand is not concerned at all. My view on this matter is quite different to that of my fellow countrymen.

-Gumboot


I'm aware of the birth-rates and that you may think that this automatically lead to a collapse of Europe some day. But until this will happen, there will be a lot of politics concerning overpopulation. Maybe with similar birth-restrictions as in china, you know: "For everyone".

So you think that muslims growing up and integrating themselves into the democratic system (Which pretty much most do), will suddenly change their mind and want some nutty, extreme, islamic Regime. :confused:

That would make a good laugh in the muslim communities here. :D
Why don't you ask someone in New Zealand who was born into your system?

And remember, Germany is more concerned about infiltration - so we might be more aware of this threat in contrast to what you said about Scientology.
 
Fascinating. You mean like, um, it's Western thinking that gave the former colonies independence, because, like, it was aliens who had taken them over in the first place and profited out of them in the first place?



No, of course not. You obviously missed the bit where I mentioned that western thinking naturally resulted in a progression of increased freedom and liberalism.

The Roman Empire retained its "colonies" for a thousand years. Most western colonies gained independence within a century or two of being conquered.



Or like Mahatma Ghandi was such a paragon of Western thinking that he successfully led a national campaign, despite violence against him and his followers, against those UFO-aliens who were desperate to hold onto Empire?


Western thinking meant he and his followers weren't exterminated the moment they resisted.



Or was it a prime example of Western thinking that finally got Vietnam de-colonialised?

Ever heard of an organisation called the UN?



*yawn*


And of course, the Amritsar Massacre was carried out by those same UFO-aliens, while Western thinking opposed it!


Actually the Amritsar Massacre was carried out by Indians against Indians. The westerners were the ones that came in afterwards and cleaned it all up. (I should know, my Great Grandfather was one of them).



Hint: face up to it, modern thinking owes just as much to East as to West, and to South as to North.


One of the great things about western culture is it gathers up everything from the cultures in comes into contact with and assimilates them into its own culture.

Much of the east is part of western civilisation.

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom