100% Proof Islamic Threat is Overblown

Source: http://wits.nctc.gov/reports/crot2006nctcannexfinal.pdf

Lethality - Comparison of Fatalities and Incidents by Regions:

Dead - 20,573
Number of attacks - 14,352 !

Fatalities in the Western Hemisphere: 556
Fatalities in the rest of the World: 20,017

Stunning, isn't it?

Oh, and look on page 20-21:

2005: Terror attacks by Islamic Extremist (Sunni) - 23%
2006: Terror attacks by Islamic Extremist (Sunni) - 19%
(Well, that decrease would make a good Propaganda Piece for the "War on Terror", wouldn't it?).
 
This is also very interesting:

Terror-Casualties in Iraq 2002: -
Terror-C's in the Middle East 2004: 725
Terror-Casualties in Iraq 2005: 8,262
Terror-Casualties in Iraq 2006: 13,340

Wohooo, we're getting at something with the War on Terror ... let's roll, Baby! /cynicism :boggled:

Source: http://wits.nctc.gov/
 
I agree with the OP, and if you read certain poster's posts (BPSCG, or whatever his initials are, comes to mind), there is this perception that Muslims and Arabs in general (especially combined) are a threat -- enough of a threat to be targeted in airports (though that's more based on statistics...). BPSCG made a point earlier that every single Muslim there is enabled or allowed Islamic extremists to do whatever, or somesuch, and because they weren't outspoken or somesuch, they must've wanted it or something. I forget what it was, I just found it trite and boring. Was a while back, I think, too.

Meh, anyways, he'll probably give an explanation of his viewpoint in this thread later on, I'm not fretting about that.

Regardless, .1% of a million people are 1,000 people. If .1% of one million people decided to kill you, and had resources and the ability of anonymity, you'd better be careful...
 
Last edited:
Source: http://wits.nctc.gov/reports/crot2006nctcannexfinal.pdf

Dead - 20,573
Number of attacks - 14,352

From the same source:

Incident tallies do not, by themselves, provide a complete picture of the magnitude or seriousness of the terrorism challenge confronting a country or region. [...] Moreover, different factors weigh more heavily than others
Fatalities in the Western Hemisphere: 556
Fatalities in the rest of the World: 20,017

Stunning, isn't it?
Not news to me.

2005: Terror attacks by Islamic Extremist (Sunni) - 23%
2006: Terror attacks by Islamic Extremist (Sunni) - 19%
(Well, that decrease would make a good Propaganda Piece for the "War on Terror", wouldn't it?).
from the same source:
[...]NCTC does not believe that a simple comparison of the total number of incidents from year to year provides a meaningful measure.
In many reports, attackers are alledged to be tied to to local or well-known terrorist groups but there is little subsequent reporting that verifies these connections.
This could explain the large amount of "unknown" terrorist perpetrators. For the sake of being accurate and thorough, when they didn't have enough evidence linking a certain group to an attack, they filed it under "unknown". But it's not that big of a stretch of the imagination to figure out who they are in most cases...


-According to open-source reports, Sunni terrorist groups, more than any other subnational groups, claimed they have conducted the largest number of incidents with the highest casualty totals.

-Sunni terrorist groups in various countries carried out the same number of high fatality attacks in 2006 [...]but with deadlier results.
This is also very interesting:

Terror-Casualties in Iraq 2002: -
Terror-C's in the Middle East 2004: 725
Terror-Casualties in Iraq 2005: 8,262
Terror-Casualties in Iraq 2006: 13,340

Wohooo, we're getting at something with the War on Terror ... let's roll, Baby! /cynicism :boggled:

It's no news to anyone that Iraq has become the center of terrorist activity.
 
Last edited:
Regardless, .1% of a million people are 1,000 people. If .1% of one million people decided to kill you, and had resources and the ability of anonymity, you'd better be careful...
Except that the 1000 people are not trying to kill me, they are trying to kill 300,000,000 of us. That makes me a little less scared.

How many people were trying to kill is in WWII? What kind of weapons did they have (clue, the best in the world, until we came up with the nuke).

I really don't care if the Muslim population of the world is set on world domination. Really. They so far behind in armaments etc. that there is no chance of this happening, and their sole source of funding has peaked and is now running down. I still fear being attacked by a crazed drug addict when I am downtown more than I fear being a victim of a terrorist attack.

IXP
 
Except that the 1000 people are not trying to kill me, they are trying to kill 300,000,000 of us. That makes me a little less scared.

How many people were trying to kill is in WWII? What kind of weapons did they have (clue, the best in the world, until we came up with the nuke).

I really don't care if the Muslim population of the world is set on world domination. Really. They so far behind in armaments etc. that there is no chance of this happening, and their sole source of funding has peaked and is now running down. I still fear being attacked by a crazed drug addict when I am downtown more than I fear being a victim of a terrorist attack.

IXP

The whole Muslim population of the world doesn't want to kill anyone. It's just a small minority of extremists. Not world dominating but still a danger to be watched for.
 
The whole Muslim population of the world doesn't want to kill anyone. It's just a small minority of extremists. Not world dominating but still a danger to be watched for.
Yes, my post was a reducto ad absurdum. Read it as even if the entire Muslim population...

Yes, we should be vigilant, just as we should against all other criminals.

IXP
 
The whole Muslim population of the world doesn't want to kill anyone. It's just a small minority of extremists. Not world dominating but still a danger to be watched for.

Your use of the word "Just" betrays a lack of understanding.

Let us postulate 0.1% of all Muslims, or .01% of a billion people.

That's 100,000.

Consider 100,000 Tim McVeys.

At even a 50% success rate, this is not a trivial matter.

The peaceful sheep provide a place for the sharks to swim until they wish to strike. Reference? Mao, revolutionary warfare. They are not stupid, they are the enemy.

One cannot count on the bulk of one's enemy being 'unable to tie their shoes' as the comment was presented.

"These days it only takes one lone nutter to create a terrible attack but thankfully most nutters can't tie their shoelaces together even with instructions from the internet".


Complacency is not helpful. Irrational fear is not helpful. Playing chicken little is not helpful.

Cold, calculating countermeasures are helpful, as is vigilance and sound police/security work.

DR
 
...to Canada and their nasty Canadian military interventions around the globe. :D
You're starting to understand, Thank you.

Oh Wait: Don't they have freedoms in Canada, too???
I don't know, Oliver, you tell me. You do seem to have a penchant for making judgements about the level of democracy when it comes to the United States.
 
The OP contains a number of glaring mistake, to my mind.

Firstly it makes the mistake of assuming that the lack of successful terrorist attacks in the west is evidence that there are no Radical Islamic terrorists wanting to carry out such attacks.

This is simply not the case. There have been many attempted attacks. Likewise, there are no doubt many who would carry out such attacks, but lack the means to do so. Finally, and perhaps most significantly, there are a very large number of people who do not wish to carry out such attacks, but support and agree with those that do.

In addition, this assumption fails to take into account the considerable effort by authorities to prevent such attacks.

Secondly, the OP mistakenly assumes that those declaring that Radical Islam is a serious threat are claiming that there are large numbers of Islamic Radicals, and that they comprise a significant percentage of the total Muslim population. Again, there is no reason to assume this. The nature of terrorism is such that a very small number of people can have a very significant effect. A single islamic terrorist could, with a campaign of bombs, bring a fair sized city to a grinding halt.

For an example of how devastating a small group of terrorists can be, I direct you to the Beltway sniper attacks of 2002.

Lastly, the OP assumes that those expressing concern about the threat of radical Islam believe that Radical Islam is an immediate and dire threat to Western Society.

I cannot speak for anyone else, but as someone that does consider Radical Islam a potentially serious threat, I do not consider it to be an immediate threat. The nature of Radical Islam is such that by the time it really is a serious threat (in 10 years, or 20, or 50, or 100) it will be too late to do anything about it.

Radical Islam is a cancer growing inside western society. The threat of Radical Islam is not bombs on trains and buses. It is not hijacked airliners. When the real threat of Radical Islam emerges some time in the next fifty years, they won't need to use bombs and hijackings to get their way. That is the threat of Radical Islam.

-Gumboot
 
I cannot speak for anyone else, but as someone that does consider Radical Islam a potentially serious threat, I do not consider it to be an immediate threat. The nature of Radical Islam is such that by the time it really is a serious threat (in 10 years, or 20, or 50, or 100) it will be too late to do anything about it.

Ok, then how does the threat posed by radical islam compare to past threats? Is it more serious than Nazi Germany or the USSR?

Radical Islam is a cancer growing inside western society. The threat of Radical Islam is not bombs on trains and buses. It is not hijacked airliners.

Then what is it?

When the real threat of Radical Islam emerges some time in the next fifty years, they won't need to use bombs and hijackings to get their way. That is the threat of Radical Islam.

Then what will they need to get their way? What is the "real threat" of radical islam that will emerge within the next 50 years?
 
Last edited:
Ok, then how does the threat posed by radical islam compare to past threats? Is it more serious than Nazi Germany or the USSR?


That's a pretty difficult question. I think all three threats presented the potential of ultimately destroying Western Civilisation (by replacing it with something else). I also think the threat of Radical Islam is also in some ways much easier to address than Nazism or the USSR. On the other hand, like with the threat of Nazism or the USSR, I think the outcome if the potential threat is totally ignored is about the same.



Then what will they need to get their way? What is the "real threat" of radical islam that will emerge?

The real threat is that they will achieve their aims via social revolution in the west. They won't need anything to get their way, because our western political systems and western liberalism offer everything they need.

-Gumboot
 
Your use of the word "Just" betrays a lack of understanding.

Let us postulate 0.1% of all Muslims, or .01% of a billion people.

That's 100,000.

Consider 100,000 Tim McVeys.

No, I'm pretty sure that's 1,000,000 people.

1,000,000,000 * 0.001 = 1,000,000, according to my calculator.

1% of 1 billion people are 10 million...
 
*snip* The real threat is that they will achieve their aims via social revolution in the west. They won't need anything to get their way, because our western political systems and western liberalism offer everything they need.

-Gumboot


Said the guy from the country that blindly accepts every self-appointed anti-constitutional cult religion as such. Hilarious. :D
 
I don't know, Oliver, you tell me. You do seem to have a penchant for making judgements about the level of democracy when it comes to the United States.


I tweaked Pardalis nose for his muslim-paranoia in such a peaceful country like Canada.

Estimated Number of Muslims in Canada = 783,700
Number of Muslims in Germany = 3,200,000
Estimated Number of Muslims in New Zealand = 25,000
 
No, I'm pretty sure that's 1,000,000 people.

1,000,000,000 * 0.001 = 1,000,000, according to my calculator.

1% of 1 billion people are 10 million...

But I doesn't matter because you can't just go pulling numbers out of thin air like that.

Darth said to figure .1% of all Muslims. Sure enough that's a scary number. But why not say .0000000001%?

I've known people to lose businesses because they've said that even if they only get x customers a day they'll make a profit, but pulled the estimated sales figures out of the air.
 
Said the guy from the country that blindly accepts every self-appointed anti-constitutional cult religion as such. Hilarious. :D



Oliver, this may be hard for you to understand, but unlike the Government of Germany, the Government of New Zealand allows its citizens to express any view they like. The Government of New Zealand allows its citizens to practice any religious customs they wish, as long as those practices do not conflict with our laws.

In New Zealand we do not ban something just because we do not agree with what they are saying. That is because New Zealand, unlike Germany, is a free society.

-Gumboot
 
I tweaked Pardalis nose for his muslim-paranoia in such a peaceful country like Canada.

Estimated Number of Muslims in Canada = 783,700
Number of Muslims in Germany = 3,200,000
Estimated Number of Muslims in New Zealand = 25,000



There's 36,072 Muslims in New Zealand, according to last year's census.

-Gumboot
 
Oliver, this may be hard for you to understand, but unlike the Government of Germany, the Government of New Zealand allows its citizens to express any view they like. The Government of New Zealand allows its citizens to practice any religious customs they wish, as long as those practices do not conflict with our laws.

In New Zealand we do not ban something just because we do not agree with what they are saying. That is because New Zealand, unlike Germany, is a free society.

-Gumboot

Oh come on.

Germany is not that bad.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom