100% Proof Islamic Threat is Overblown

I brought it up because Libel&Slandering are the closest explanations for this law - because their similarity for you to understand it in a better way. Now this might not be the best translation, but "criminal" translates to: "against the law", well, at least my translator says so. :boxedin:
Anyway: You know what I meant, don't you?



I understand what you mean Oliver, but I have a bit of a problem with your comparisons. You're right, in that the laws against Holocaust Denial etc. are indeed somewhat similar to libel and slander. But therein lies a big problem. Libel and slander are not criminal offenses, and nor should they be.



Concerning your question: I don't consider Holocaust Denier as a threat - they're just stupid Truthers in my own humble opinion.

Neo-Nazis also are a pretty minor problem. Of course there are big news about it whenever there is an incident, especially here in Germany, but on one hand this minority is getting observed just like the Jihadists and other radical groups - on the other hand most of these Nuts are Teenagers who grow up in most cases.

So one way or another, I'm not concerned, nor do I see them as major threat to the public or my freedoms.


Oliver, do you have a problem with your Government spying on organisations or prohibiting organisations that you do not consider to be a threat?

-Gumboot
 
Oliver, with all due respect, you don't seem to be taking in anything I'm posting.

-Gumboot


Maybe I missed an important Message from you, in which case I apologize. My understanding about New Zealand concerning religion so far is, that there seems to be no controversy at all about religions, no matter what they're about. Is that correct?

And do you know what I meant concerning the far-fetched "Mafia-Example"?

The Scientology issue here in Germany was pretty much started by petitions, that's a pretty democratic way to address issues. So the Scientology's claim that this is some kind of "German government conspiracy", is simply wrong.

Also they failed to get the "Tax-Free status" like a religion because their own faults: "repeatedly failed to establish its qualifications". What does this have to do with "Freedom of Religion" if they don't get full religious status concerning Taxes?

Then they multiply stated that they ARE NOT a religion in countries in which they saw no chance to claim they are - just like they please.

Also they have an aggressive history - including unconstitutional, criminal behavior.

And: Their treatment against members is in question in several issues including Brainwashing, disconnecting from their families, financial exploitation and so on.

And they don't offer their "holy scripts" about the alien-souls.

Honestly: Personally I see absolutely no reason to even consider anything from them as spiritual or religious in my general understanding of Religion or their followers treatment.

Now I may not know all reasons to deny the religion-status, but I have a hard time to believe that in New Zealand there are no concerns at all - and never had been. In this case I would consider such a behavior as irresponsible and a great lack of national security.
 
I understand what you mean Oliver, but I have a bit of a problem with your comparisons. You're right, in that the laws against Holocaust Denial etc. are indeed somewhat similar to libel and slander. But therein lies a big problem. Libel and slander are not criminal offenses, and nor should they be.

Oliver, do you have a problem with your Government spying on organisations or prohibiting organisations that you do not consider to be a threat?

-Gumboot


I guess Libel and Slander are prosecuted in New Zealand, too - so I guess it makes sense to you to understand the whole issue much better, don't you?

Well, I would be concerned if the government would spy on groups without reasons. (That's very rarely the case (I honestly don't remind such a case right now besides this major event) in contrast to the well known FBI cases).

But it's the other way around: I'm not concerned because I know that I'm safe and the "Verfassungsschutz" takes care of these domestic threats.

So even if I know about these Groups and their dangerous potential, I don't have to feel scared or concerned. I wouldn't even be more concerned after a 9/11 like attack in Germany because I know that such an incident would focus the Verfassungsschutz even more on it's radical origins.

ETA: Maybe other Germans feel differently about that?
 
The real threat is that they will achieve their aims via social revolution in the west. They won't need anything to get their way, because our western political systems and western liberalism offer everything they need.

This is one of the most bizarre and extraordinary claims I've seen someone make in Politics. How will islamofascists achieve a social revolution in the "west"? In what countries will this revolution happen? How does liberalism offer muslim fundies, the very epitome of religious conservatism, everything they need? That's like saying liberalism gives Pat Robertson everything he needs to eastablish a theocracy.

That's a pretty difficult question.

Not really. Nazi Germany and the USSR were world powers, the USSR had nuclear weapons and enough ICBM to totally destroy the West and the US. The threat they posed was much greater than Islamofascists can ever dream.

I also think the threat of Radical Islam is also in some ways much easier to address than Nazism or the USSR.

Of course it is. Radical islam is weak, Nazi Germany and the USSR were not.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to speak for Gumboot but I think he's talking over a lenghty period of time.
 
Maybe I missed an important Message from you, in which case I apologize. My understanding about New Zealand concerning religion so far is, that there seems to be no controversy at all about religions, no matter what they're about. Is that correct?



Well no, not really. Because we're not much of a religious nation. We also don't have much of a problem with extremism. If someone paints a swastika on a Mosque or a Synagogue it's rare enough to warrant a place as lead article on the nightly news.



And do you know what I meant concerning the far-fetched "Mafia-Example"?



I think I understand what you mean, but the problem there is the Mafia are an organised criminal group. They are persecuted because they are criminals, not because of their ideology.



The Scientology issue here in Germany was pretty much started by petitions, that's a pretty democratic way to address issues. So the Scientology's claim that this is some kind of "German government conspiracy", is simply wrong.


The difference between a democracy and mob rule is that in a democracy the mob cannot override the rights of minorities.




Also they failed to get the "Tax-Free status" like a religion because their own faults: "repeatedly failed to establish its qualifications". What does this have to do with "Freedom of Religion" if they don't get full religious status concerning Taxes?


I have no problem whatsoever with them being denied "tax free status".



Then they multiply stated that they ARE NOT a religion in countries in which they saw no chance to claim they are - just like they please.


Again, I have no problem with the German government refusing to recognise them as a religion.




Also they have an aggressive history - including unconstitutional, criminal behavior.


This is what I have a problem with. I'm interested in evidence that the Church of Scientology in Germany is involved in criminal activity.



Now I may not know all reasons to deny the religion-status, but I have a hard time to believe that in New Zealand there are no concerns at all - and never had been. In this case I would consider such a behavior as irresponsible and a great lack of national security.


I honestly don't see how not being a religion constitutes a threat to national security.

-Gumboot
 
I don't want to speak for Gumboot but I think he's talking over a lenghty period of time.



You're quite right Pardalis. Western Civilisation is on the decline. Something else is going to replace us as the law of the land. The question is what?

Democracy is in no way protection against the rise of extremism or authoritarian government. The Nazis gained power in a democratic system.

Ancient Rome "democratically" elected its Imperators.

Give it 50 - 100 years. Absent an Islamic Reformation or a social revolution in China, one of these entities will destroy our civilisation.

-Gumboot
 
Strawman. :mad::mad::mad:

This has nothing to do with Muslims. We're talking about the radicals.


*snip*
There is a current of dangerous Islamic fundamentalism that is sweeping the Middle East, an ideology that is clearly stating its intentions. If we let it unchallenged, the balance of power in the world could very well turn in their favor, and terrorism could rapidly become a much more significant and imminent problem.


Well, where does it come from? Do you see a relation to the Iraq war?
If not - what is your paranoia about? That "3 Muslims in your Hometown overthrows your town hall"? :confused:
 
I don't want to speak for Gumboot but I think he's talking over a lenghty period of time.

Which makes his assertions much more dubious. He's trying to predict the distant future and we all know how successful that been throughout history...
 
Well, where does it come from? Do you see a relation to the Iraq war?
If not - what is your paranoia about? That "3 Muslims in your Hometown overthrows your town hall"? :confused:

Don't you understand the difference between ordinary Muslims who just want to go about their daily lives and radical fundamentalists?

Are you this thick? :mad:
 
Western Civilisation is on the decline.

Evidence?

The Nazis gained power in a democratic system.

The nazis were in a position the islamofascists will likely never be.

Give it 50 - 100 years. Absent an Islamic Reformation or a social revolution in China, one of these entities will destroy our civilisation.

Can I borrow your crystal ball?
 
Which makes his assertions much more dubious. He's trying to predict the distant future and we all know how successful that been throughout history...


Hey, I never claimed I was right.

-Gumboot
 
Do you understand the difference between ordinary Muslims who just want to go about their daily lives and radical fundamentalists?

Are you this thick? :mad:


Of course I understand that - well, since I was 8. So what?
If there is a reason to be concerned then it's the destabilization of the Region - as a result of the Iraq war - drawing "harmless Muslims" into the conflict, do YOU understand that? :confused:

If not, a nice flash-summary for you:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17722026
 
Will you apologize for your latest strawman Oliver?

ETA: and btw, I never said the Iraq war was a good thing, actually I agree it was a grave mistake.
 
The nazis were in a position the islamofascists will likely never be.
Speaking of trying to make a long-term prediction... :rolleyes:

Right now, the fastest-growing segment of the population in many European countries is Muslims. "Muhammad" is now the second or third most popular name for newborn boys in the UK.

What happens when and if Europe becomes Muslim majority? Will it resemble Turkey, where there is a clear, bright line between church and state?
 
Will you apologize for your latest strawman Oliver?

ETA: and btw, I never said the Iraq war was a good thing, actually I agree it was a grave mistake.


I use so many Strawmen, which one did you mean? :confused: :D :p


Well, if you agree - then why are you attacking me for questioning what went wrong concerning the start-up to go to war?

Anyway: You now seem to basically agree with Parky and his initial post, right?
 
Evidence?


The western sphere of influence is shrinking rapidly. We have lost Africa and the Middle East already, and we are rapidly losing the Pacific.

In Europe, the birthrate amongst Muslims is triple the rate of non-Muslims, and the majority of immigrants to Europe (immigration accounts for 85% of Europe's total population growth) are Muslim.

Internally, we're also fracturing. The west is becoming increasingly divided. The cracks are beginning to appear.

All of this does not constitute evidence. These are merely the reasons for why I hold the opinion I do. I don't expect anyone to be convinced by my opinion.



The nazis were in a position the islamofascists will likely never be.


Obviously we don't agree. :)




Can I borrow your crystal ball?


I claim no psychic powers. This is only my own theoretical hypothesis of our likely future. It has no more validity than any other hypothesis.

-Gumboot
 
Right now, the fastest-growing segment of the population in many European countries is Muslims. "Muhammad" is now the second or third most popular name for newborn boys in the UK.

What happens when and if Europe becomes Muslim majority? Will it resemble Turkey, where there is a clear, bright line between church and state?

Most Muslims who emigrate to western countries do so to escape the persecution of the regimes they came from. They come here for our freedoms. Of course like everywhere else there are extremists who ask for sharia law to be implemented, but still these are a minority.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom