100% Proof Islamic Threat is Overblown

I'm aware of the birth-rates and that you may think that this automatically lead to a collapse of Europe some day. But until this will happen, there will be a lot of politics concerning overpopulation. Maybe with similar birth-restrictions as in china, you know: "For everyone".


I don't think anything will lead to a "collapse of Europe".



So you think that muslims growing up and integrating themselves into the democratic system (Which pretty much most do), will suddenly change their mind and want some nutty, extreme, islamic Regime. :confused:

No, I think a great chunk of them are not integrating themselves into a democratic system. Further, I think a smaller chunk of them are actively trying to deceive the west into thinking they are integrating. And indeed another chunk are taking advantage of the democratic system to undermine it.



That would make a good laugh in the muslim communities here. :D
Why don't you ask someone in New Zealand who was born into your system?


Ask them what?





And remember, Germany is more concerned about infiltration - so we might be more aware of this threat in contrast to what you said about Scientology.


I think the problem is we're all focused on infiltration by terrorists. That's not the real threat.

-Gumboot
 
By Western Civilisation I mean the fundamental values of Western Civilisation - free society, equality, liberalism, and so forth.

Ok. I think it's much broader than that, but good.

The independence of former western colonies is actually a product of western civilisation.

Agreed.

But many of those nations are now rejecting those values.

What's the ratio of nations rejecting western values to the nations retaining those values? What are they rejecting western values in favor of?

Look at Fiji for a prime example.

What's happening in Fiji?

There are countless others all over the Pacific, Africa, and Middle East.

What countries?

So I consider that a bad thing.

It has the potential to be a bad thing, but I doubt every muslim born into europe in the next 100 years is likely to retain that identity.

I disagree. Despite our conflicts, and despite the brief ugliness of Nazi Germany, the ideological values of our societies have been very similar. Now they're not. Liberals and conservatives are diverging into extremist positions.

I don't think that justifies your disagreement. Division is never higher than when nations are at war with each other. There is no war, nor is there an immediate danger of war within the West at the moment. The same cannot be said in times past.

The sky's not falling. It's changing, as it always does. The notion of "western civilisation is invincible" is stupid and wrong.

I think the west has already conquered the world, I believe it's only a matter of time before "western civilization" becomes "human civilization". The two largest nations in the world are becoming more westernized every year.

I think right now are the "good ole days". I consider our current state more or less the height of western civilisation.

I strongly disagree.
 
Last edited:
I don't think anything will lead to a "collapse of Europe".

No, I think a great chunk of them are not integrating themselves into a democratic system. Further, I think a smaller chunk of them are actively trying to deceive the west into thinking they are integrating. And indeed another chunk are taking advantage of the democratic system to undermine it.

Ask them what?

I think the problem is we're all focused on infiltration by terrorists. That's not the real threat.

-Gumboot


Why do you have the impression that a great chunk doesn't integrate themselves - is this your experience in New Zealand? And why should a great chunk of Muslims in New Zealand dislike your democracy? :confused:

I'm sorry, but that's not my experience with Muslims who grew up here. They're a completely different Generation, also about traditional values that made it much harder for their parents to integrate when they came here.

I guess THEY should be scared to lose their traditional values instead we ours, don't you think? Because that's what happening. Oh, and they're much less religious than their parents. ;)
 
What's the ratio of nations rejecting western values to the nations retaining those values? What are they rejecting western values in favor of?


Good question.

For me these two maps are telling:

Governments that identify themselves as democratic

Nations classified as free by Freedom House



What's happening in Fiji?


Um... they've only had yet another coup d'etat. They've become increasingly aggressive towards New Zealand and Australia, have kicked out the New Zealand High Commissioner, and are refusing to allow various high profile Fijians to leave the country.

Fiji is now a military dictatorship.




What countries?


See the maps I posted for some examples of nations that claim to be democratic, but are not.




It has the potential to be a bad thing, but I doubt every muslim born into europe in the next 100 years is likely to retain that identity.


Neither do I. And let me be clear, I believe the threat is only from Radical Islam. The problem is, how many people practising Radical Islam does there need to be, before there's a problem?

And while most Muslims are not Radicals, most Muslims are also unwilling to take a strong stance against Radicals in their society.

"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing"


I don't think that justifies your disagreement. Division is never higher than when nations are at war with each other. There is no war, nor is there an immediate danger of war within the West at the moment. The same cannot be said in times past.


I'm not entirely sure I agree. During times of war societies tend to bond together and put aside their differences in support of the common goal. During times of peace those differences fester and become focus points for social fracturing.

A typical WW2 American soldier probably has more in common with a typical WW2 German soldier than a hard core American left-winger has with a hardcore American right-winger.




I think the west has already conquered the world, I believe it's only a matter of time before "western civilization" becomes "human civilization". The two largest nations in the world are becoming more westernized every year.


I can't agree. And if history is anything to go by, western civilisation will collapse. The Goths were becoming more Roman every year up until the point that they sacked Rome.



I strongly disagree.


Fair enough. I'm glad we can discuss the topic. :)

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom