100% Proof Islamic Threat is Overblown

Name just one such alleged law, and specify/quote exactly what it prohibits.

(3) Whoever publicly or in a meeting approves of, denies or renders harmless an act committed under the rule of National Socialism of the type indicated in Section 220a subsection (1), in a manner capable of disturbing the public piece shall be punished with imprisonment for not more than five years or a fine.

Criminal Code of the Federal Republic of Germany
Section 130



Come on. You've now claimed Germany prohibits certain beliefs or opinions -- per se. You are either immensely ignorant or dishonest.


No, they prohibit the expression of certain beliefs and opinions.



Ooooooo, looks like a defence of $cientology to me, but hey, let's give you a chance to back up the bullcrap first.


I have no desire to defend Scientology. One of the duties of freedom is to tolerate beliefs and positions that you do not like or agree with. If I had my way there would be no religion whatsoever. But I will defend the right of any person to practice the religion of their choice.



BTW, how do you feel about the massive internal spying by the USA, UK, Australia, etc. etc. etc. in the defence against terrorism? Or do you prefer to leave out suchlike to be able to utter false platitudes?


Massive internal spying?






You consider an open police search of someone suspected of being connected to criminal acts under authority of a warrant issued by a court to be "spying"? Interesting.

I am unaware of any New Zealand involvement in the current investigation. Do you understand the difference between monitoring organisations that preach a specific ideology, and monitoring organisations that participate in criminal acts?

-Gumboot
 
Tell me again, which part of the disntiction between an opinion and a public act do you fail to want to understand?
:)
This is like shooting fish in a barrel.
If I were a German citizen, in Germany, would I be permitted to send a letter to Der Spiegel in praise of Hitler? Would Der Spiegel be permitted to print it?

If I were a German citizen, in Germany, would I be permitted to send a letter to Der Spiegel denying the Holocaust? Would Der Spiegel be permitted to print it?
 
If I were a German citizen, in Germany, would I be permitted to send a letter to Der Spiegel in praise of Hitler? Would Der Spiegel be permitted to print it?

If I were a German citizen, in Germany, would I be permitted to send a letter to Der Spiegel denying the Holocaust? Would Der Spiegel be permitted to print it?


Just replace, "Germany", "Der Spiegel" and "Holocaust" with:
"America", "Washington Post" and "Let's kill the President"
and you got the answer. ;)
 
.... {stupidities snipped} ..
Tell me again, which part of the distinction between an opinion and a public act do you fail to want to understand?

Or do you need a dictionary yet again to learn the meaning of the big words there?
 
Just replace, "Germany", "Der Spiegel" and "Holocaust" with:
"America", "Washington Post" and "Let's kill the President"
and you got the answer. ;)
No you don't. That's a phony comparison, and you know it.
 
Tell me again, which part of the disntiction between an opinion and a public act do you fail to want to understand?
:)
This is like shooting fish in a barrel.
This makes no sense when the "public act" is merely stating an opinion.

If you try claiming actually marching down a street with any sign at all is only an idea, I'm going to question your sanity.

Cheers.
In the USA, it's merely an idea. In Germany, it's a violation of the Thought Police Act or something, I see. :rolleyes:
 
The peaceful sheep provide a place for the sharks to swim until they wish to strike. Reference? Mao, revolutionary warfare. They are not stupid, they are the enemy.
That Mao could really mix his metaphors!

Back when this thread seemed like it was a bit more on topic, I couldn't figure out what people were arguing about. Terrorists form only a small fraction of the population. Even a small fraction of a population can cause destruction and disruption. For the vast majority of people, this destruction and disruption form no real personal danger to themselves, so they are not afraid (for their own safety or well-being.) However, they do have legitimate concerns.

I live in Louisville. The chance of me, or anyone I know, being hurt in any clearly identifiable way, by a terrorist attack is very slim. I am not afraid. However, I do have a concern that someone could detonate a bomb in Rockefeller Center, or blow up a commuter train, or whatever.

I think that people, by and large, have a decent idea of the size of the threat: It runs a whole scale, from small and distant to horrendous and huge (but statistically unlikely at any particular point in time). The issue of whether citizens and governments are responding appropriately is another question.

One reason that the threat of Islamic terrorists seems overblown is because we've acted to contain the threats of such groups in Western countries. The terrorist attacks of 9/11 weren't overblown.
 
Tell me again, which part of the distinction between an opinion and a public act do you fail to want to understand?

Or do you need a dictionary yet again to learn the meaning of the big words there?
Please explain to me the value of an being allowed to have an opinion if the government can punish you for attempting to share it with others.
 
Name just one such alleged law, and specify/quote exactly what it prohibits.
No, they prohibit the expression of certain beliefs and opinions.
So, gumboot, you are totally unable to back up your claim and actually cite just one such law with details.

I am ever so unsurprised. :D
Massive internal spying?
I guess you don't follow the surveillance, do you? Tsk, go read the ACLU link given already.
You consider an open police search of someone suspected of being connected to criminal acts under authority of a warrant issued by a court to be "spying"? Interesting.
No, I don't. Dishonest much?
I am unaware of any New Zealand involvement in the current investigation. Do you understand the difference between monitoring organisations that preach a specific ideology, and monitoring organisations that participate in criminal acts?
Do you understand the actual facts, that NZ helps monitor organizations and individuals who advocate certain ideologies, such as Islamist jihadism?
 
Last edited:
No you don't. That's a phony comparison, and you know it.


No, it's not a phony comparison, both examples are based on laws and pretty much attract the same legal consequences. Oh, and both laws are limiting "Free Speech". Look it up.
 
I'm sorry but in a free society like New Zealand, the expression of Religion is much more important than insignificant, nitpicked details like killings. And remember: "Killing is not Murder". :D



If Scientologists in Germany have expressed a desire to kill people, the German Government is totally justified monitoring them. However the document you have previously provided does not indicate this. Near as I can tell, the German Government appears to be monitoring them because they teach that only a person who has gone through their indoctrination can have "personal freedom", and for some reason the German Government has concluded this means they want to take away rights from German citizens.

Perhaps it is an error of translation?

Please stop your strawman arguments Oliver. If you want to address my concerns, address them.

-Gumboot
 
I live in Louisville. The chance of me, or anyone I know, being hurt in any clearly identifiable way, by a terrorist attack is very slim.
Deaths and injuries are not the sole harm done by terrorist attacks. The economic damage done on 9/11 was quite substantial, and affected everyone - even those in Louisville. A dirty bomb could be even worse, and it only takes a handful of people to carry it out.
 
So, gumboot, you are totally unable to back up your claim and actually cite just one such law with details.
He quotes the law in Post 61... you lose this one big time Gurdur.
 
No, it's not a phony comparison, both examples are based on laws and pretty much attract the same legal consequences. Oh, and both laws are limiting "Free Speech". Look it up.
That's ridiculous, and you know it. Freedom of speech has never included the right to incite murder, either in the US, or in Europe.

But freedom of speech does include to right to claim, publicly, that the Holocaust never happened, or to glorify Hitler. At least it does in the US. Does that right exist in Germany? Yes or no?
 
This makes no sense when the "public act" is merely stating an opinion.
Tell me again, which part of:
"committing a public act" does NOT equate to only an opinion
do you not wish to grasp?

Which part of:

"publically stating an opinion" does NOT equate to "only an opion"

do you not wish to grasp?

Not terribly honest of you. Tell me again, BTW, all about how in the USA you can be barred from a plane only for wearing the wrong T-shirt.

Or how the Secret Service might investigate you for your T-shirt.

This is just TOO easy.
 
That's ridiculous, and you know it. Freedom of speech has never included the right to incite murder, either in the US, or in Europe. But freedom of speech does include to right to claim, publicly, that the Holocaust never happened, or to glorify Hitler.
Ooooo, look, BPSCG is trying to claim an objective definition, and indulge in some sudden special pleading.

How's it going with the T-shirts in the USA, BTW? See my above post.
 
Because it's very easy to deduce from the speed of recent events that UK and Australian police have had certain people under observation; anyone who wants to believe that the NZ police do not cooperate in this is IMHO deluded.



I think it's only easy to deduce this if you're paranoid, and have a preconceived notion of what is going on.

Do you understand the difference between monitoring criminal groups, and monitoring groups that practice a particular ideology.




Of course, I could also add links showing exactly and directly New Zealand doing what gumboot has claimed it doesn't do:

Linky


Do you even know what the Identity (Citizenship and Travel Documents) Bill is? It proposes changes to the Citizenship Act and the Passport Act. Neither of these is in any way related to spying on New Zealand citizens. Please try again.



Or how about I ask pointed questions about New Zealand's cooperation in the Echelon operation? Just what do the NZ Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB) do all day? Hmmm? I could add more direct links, but the point is made.


The GCSB monitor international satellite communications at Waihopai and international radio communications at Tangimoana. The GCSB also provides communication security and anti-bugging expertise for the New Zealand government. The GCSB was also recently tasked with the protection of critical national infrastructure from information borne threats.

The role of the GCSB has been publicly known by the New Zealand people since the 1980s.

If you have any evidence that the GCSB spies on New Zealanders, please provide that evidence as it is something I would be exceedingly concerned about.

-Gumboot
 
"publically stating an opinion" does NOT equate to "only an opion"

do you not wish to grasp?
Are you claimng that Germans are one Adolph Hitler poster away from engaging in another Holocaust, and therefore such a poster is incitement to violence?

The pilot can bar you from his plane for any reason he sees fit, this is not a government issue at all.

Asking a question of someone with a pic of Bush in crosshairs is an "investigation"? Bizarre. The person wasn't arrested, was he? If it had been a pic on his shirt praising Hitler, and he was in Germany, he could get 5 years in jail. No investigation needed at all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom