100% Proof Islamic Threat is Overblown

Well, if you agree - then why are you attacking me for questioning what went wrong concerning the start-up to go to war?

I never attacked you on that because I don't think we ever discussed this particular issue.

Anyway: You now seem to basically agree with Parky and his initial post, right?
I don't agree with Parky's OP, I don't think the threat of islamic terrorism is overblown. It is real.
 
Last edited:
Most Muslims who emigrate to western countries do so to escape the persecution of the regimes they came from. They come here for our freedoms. Of course like everywhere else there are extremists who ask for sharia law to be implemented, but still these are a minority.


I suspect the majority of Muslims come to the west to escape poverty.

-Gumboot
 
Well no, not really. Because we're not much of a religious nation. We also don't have much of a problem with extremism. If someone paints a swastika on a Mosque or a Synagogue it's rare enough to warrant a place as lead article on the nightly news.

I think I understand what you mean, but the problem there is the Mafia are an organised criminal group. They are persecuted because they are criminals, not because of their ideology.

The difference between a democracy and mob rule is that in a democracy the mob cannot override the rights of minorities.

I have no problem whatsoever with them being denied "tax free status".

Again, I have no problem with the German government refusing to recognise them as a religion.

This is what I have a problem with. I'm interested in evidence that the Church of Scientology in Germany is involved in criminal activity.

I honestly don't see how not being a religion constitutes a threat to national security.

-Gumboot


Of course the "Mob" can't overrule basic rights - but the government has to look into concerns from their citizens. That's why a neutral commission was built to look into the issue and the final report suggested to keep Scientology under observation. That was the most democratic way to deal with this issue, wasn't it?

Now I admit that I didn't read the final commissions report yet, but if you're interested to do so, here it is:

Final Report of the Enquete Commission on "So-called Sects and Psychogroups":
http://www.solitarytrees.net/pubs/enquete.pdf

I can't address your question about current, domestic incidents concerning criminal behavior about constitutional issues because it's under the surveillance of the intelligence and therefore not published yet for the same reasons why the final FBI's anthrax-report isn't published yet, ongoing investigations.

You may find the domestic constitutional issues in the report above, as I said - I didn't read it yet and why they came to the suggestion to keep Scientology under surveillance from the Verfassungsschutz. To me it's evidence enough that they did so in foreign countries to personally have no problem to keep an eye on them and to deny religious status in context to all the other convictions and incidents about them:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology_controversy
 
Right now, the fastest-growing segment of the population in many European countries is Muslims. "Muhammad" is now the second or third most popular name for newborn boys in the UK.

So that automatically means they'll become the next nazi government?

What happens when and if Europe becomes Muslim majority?

Good question, what will happen?

Will it resemble Turkey, where there is a clear, bright line between church and state?

It will resemble europe.
 
I never attacked you on that because I don't think we ever discussed this particular issue.

I don't agree with Parky's OP, I don't think the threat of islamic terrorism is overblown. It is real.


Of course it's real. Did someone ever said the contrary??? :confused:

"Overblown" means that the portrayed threat is exaggerated, that's all.
 
I suspect the majority of Muslims come to the west to escape poverty.

Yes, that too, and to escape war also. So I'm pretty confident that the great majority of them don't want to cause trouble, let alone a revolution.

It's the radicals we have to worry about. They are indoctrinating the youth who feel out of place through their imams (the bad ones, most of them are very good people) and the anti-American propaganda, the same Oliver is naively swallowing wholeheartedly.
 
Yes, that too, and to escape war also. So I'm pretty confident that the great majority of them don't want to cause trouble, let alone a revolution.

It's the radicals we have to worry about. They are indoctrinating the youth who feel out of place through their imams (the bad ones, most of them are very good people) and the anti-American propaganda, the same Oliver is naively swallowing wholeheartedly.


Well, Pardalis - I live with 3.2 million Muslims countrymen in my country and I AM NOT concerned, mainly because pretty much all of them accept our way of life and understand the society with all it's pro's and contra's. Of course there are radical elements, which are under observation for exactly this reason: Radicalism.

But I don't see Extremists as a threat that would overthrow the western world as you might think and Gumboot suggested. That's Truther-Paranoia to me, even if there's some truth to it after the Iraq mess started.

Only God knows what the effects of the Iraq destabilization will be. And this is exactly why I criticize American foreign policies. Not based on hate - but based on concerns about stability and "Blow-Backs".

"Hate our Freedoms" is simply ridiculous. In this case Holland should be scared to death. :D
 
Of course there are radical elements, which are under observation for exactly this reason: Radicalism.

Yes, they are under "observation" because they are a threat.

Now that's not fear mongering is it? It's proper caution, which is what it's all about, no more no less. Not fear, just caution.

"Hate our Freedoms" is simply ridiculous. In this case Holland should be scared to death. :D
Again with the same strawman. You keep suggesting that we equate the Muslims to the fundamentalists, we're not. The radicals hate our freedoms, not the moderate Muslims.
 
Last edited:
Yes you did:

It's not my problem if you don't even understand your own words.

But it does explain alot.



That was a deliberately controversial Thread-Title to attract attention, but literally I give you this point, even if the initial post in this thread explained what I actually meant.

And you know that, Rascal. :D
 
Yes, they are under "observation" because they are a threat.

Now that's not fear mongering is it? It's proper caution, which is what it's all about, no more no less. Not fear, just caution.

Again with the same strawman. You keep suggesting that we equate the Muslims to the fundamentalists, we're not. The radicals hate our freedoms, not the moderate Muslims.


They're are under observation since 10 or more years. It's not the german intelligences fault that the US didn't use the information - nevertheless, so are radical Neo-Nazis, the radical left and so on: ...under observation.

Quite frankly - even if the radical Left is a much, muuuuch smaller group over here, they also caused much more trouble than the radical muslims.

So why should I be more concerned about radical Muslims?

You might not like the Idea, but the Muslim world is located on the same piece of earth like I live - in contrast to all the safe water that protects you in Canada and America.

So why are you more concerned about it than I am? If it's not paranoia, what is it? :confused:

And I don't even mention New Zealand here. Looks like the countries with the smallest groups of Muslims are the most concerned ones, [ETA] according to Gumboot. [/ETA] :boggled:
 
Last edited:
Oliver, I already gave you examples of terror cells busted in Canada, of Ahmed Ressam, of the London and Madrid bombings. Just this weekend British police foiled another attack. What more do you want?
 
BPSCG said:
Right now, the fastest-growing segment of the population in many European countries is Muslims. "Muhammad" is now the second or third most popular name for newborn boys in the UK.
So that automatically means they'll become the next nazi government?
Stop putting words in my mouth. You said "The nazis were in a position the islamofascists will likely never be." Europe's current demographics say it's a distinct possibility.
Tony said:
BPSCG said:
Will it resemble Turkey, where there is a clear, bright line between church and state?
It will resemble europe.
Look, Tony, if you don't have a reasonable answer for a question, you really don't have to try to answer. Saying "I don't know" is a perfectly honorable response.
 
I tweaked Pardalis nose for his muslim-paranoia in such a peaceful country like Canada.
Peaceful is a relative term. If you measure it by rates of violent crime, such as murder, then while Canada has a lower rate per capita than the United States, we have a higher rate of occurrence than many European nations.

In terms of radical or extremist Muslim practioners, there are some here. There was a suspected terrorist plot broken up here; some of the individuals involved had purchased large quantities of fertilizer which they had no rational use for (they were not farmers).

These folks will eventually have their day in court and will either be convicted or acquitted of the charges against them.
 
Right now, the fastest-growing segment of the population in many European countries is Muslims. "Muhammad" is now the second or third most popular name for newborn boys in the UK.

Do you have a link for that stat about Mohammed being the second most popular boys' name in the UK? I'm not accusing you of making it up because I saw it reported too, but it would really surprise me if it was actually true. Muslims can't make up more than a few percent of the population, five at the very most I would say. They must be calling almost every male child Mohammed, and having a LOT of them, to make that stat true. :confused:

Plus, I've met many muslim males, and none of them have been called mohammed to my recollection.
 
Oliver, I already gave you examples of terror cells busted in Canada, of Ahmed Ressam, of the London and Madrid bombings. Just this weekend British police foiled another attack. What more do you want?



Are you THAT stubborn???

In 2006 there were 14,352 Terror Attacks.
In 2006 there were Null, Nada, Zero, None executed Terror Attacks in the US or Canada.
Please stop whining. You're obviously exaggerating, don't you see that on your own? :confused:

So what's your complain anyway?
 
Last edited:
In 2006 there were Null, Nada, Zero, None executed Terror Attacks in the US or Canada.

That's because our governments and security agencies do take this threat seriously and are acting upon it, like those terror cells that were busted:
http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/n...d5d6cc&k=46849, http://www.canada.com/national/natio...a-3c8f6009581c

and those plots that were foiled :
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/08/10/AR2006081000152.html, http://cnn.websites-blog.com/2006/US/02/09/whitehouse.plots/index.html.
 
The western sphere of influence is shrinking rapidly. We have lost Africa and the Middle East already, and we are rapidly losing the Pacific.

So? You seem to see this as a zero sum gain. It doesn't follow that western civ is declining because former colonies are wanting self-determination. Furthermore, since countries around the world are increasing adopting western language, clothing, science, entertainment, sports, political systems and ideologies, I'd say Western Civ's lock on the world is solid for a very long time. What do you see as Western Civilization?

In Europe, the birthrate amongst Muslims is triple the rate of non-Muslims, and the majority of immigrants to Europe (immigration accounts for 85% of Europe's total population growth) are Muslim.

So?

Internally, we're also fracturing. The west is becoming increasingly divided. The cracks are beginning to appear.

Umm no. Division in the west now is not anywhere near the levels it was during WW1 or WW2.

All of this does not constitute evidence. These are merely the reasons for why I hold the opinion I do. I don't expect anyone to be convinced by my opinion.

Frankly, your position is "the sky is falling" and you show symptoms of "good ole days" syndrome.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom