100% Proof Islamic Threat is Overblown

I am not a regular contributor to this forum, but why did Parky start this thread and disappear? No attacks in the US since 2001? So what. Only 4 trains? Should it have been 20? No mention of Bali? Radical Islam no threat? Tell that to my daughter in London. He posted rubbish and ran away.
 
Oh come on.

Germany is not that bad.

Nope, unlike New Zealand, Germany wants to STAY a free society. ;)



Any country that has laws prohibiting certain beliefs or opinions is not a free society. Germany has such laws. Germany also spies on organisations for no reason other than a suspicion that said organisations are expressing a desire to undermine the freedom of others.

In a free society, such behaviour by the government is absolutely unacceptable.

New Zealand does not have such laws, and the New Zealand government does not spy on organisations simply for expressing views the New Zealand government disagrees with. This is because New Zealand is a free society. New Zealand will continue to be a free society.

-Gumboot
 
Any country that has laws prohibiting certain beliefs or opinions is not a free society. Germany has such laws. Germany also spies on organisations for no reason other than a suspicion that said organisations are expressing a desire to undermine the freedom of others.

In a free society, such behaviour by the government is absolutely unacceptable.

New Zealand does not have such laws, and the New Zealand government does not spy on organisations simply for expressing views the New Zealand government disagrees with. This is because New Zealand is a free society. New Zealand will continue to be a free society.

-Gumboot


So what are you concerned about? :

gumboot said:
The real threat is that they will achieve their aims via social revolution in the west. They won't need anything to get their way, because our western political systems and western liberalism offer everything they need.


You live in a free country that obviously isn't concerned about the free expression like Jihadists, I guess. See, that's the price to live free, either the 36,072 Muslims or Scientologists will overthrow your Government. :D

Oh, and by your "spying" Statement, you pretty much confirmed what you think about the FBI and as such, the "free society" of America. :)
 
Any country that has laws prohibiting certain beliefs or opinions is not a free society. Germany has such laws.
Name just one such alleged law, and specify/quote exactly what it prohibits.

Come on. You've now claimed Germany prohibits certain beliefs or opinions -- per se. You are either immensely ignorant or dishonest.
Germany also spies on organisations for no reason other than a suspicion that said organisations are expressing a desire to undermine the freedom of others.
Ooooooo, looks like a defence of $cientology to me, but hey, let's give you a chance to back up the bullcrap first. BTW, how do you feel about the massive internal spying by the USA, UK, Australia, etc. etc. etc. in the defence against terrorism? Or do you prefer to leave out suchlike to be able to utter false platitudes?
New Zealand does not have such laws, and the New Zealand government does not spy on organisations simply for expressing views the New Zealand government disagrees with.
Oh really? Want to seriously claim NZ does not cooperate with Australia just for one in the longterm observation (spying) on those judged to be potential terrorists but who have not yet actually committed any crime?
 
Last edited:
What if thier "expression" is killing you?


I'm sorry but in a free society like New Zealand, the expression of Religion is much more important than insignificant, nitpicked details like killings. And remember: "Killing is not Murder". :D
 
You can talk numbers and percentages all day if you like.All it takes is one evil mad idoit (Hitler) a whole deluded country (German) to believe what they are told to believe,and you've got a world war.
 
You can talk numbers and percentages all day if you like.All it takes is one evil mad idoit (Hitler) a whole deluded country (German) to believe what they are told to believe,and you've got a world war.


Thank you for sharing your sympathy against the Bush era with me. :)
 
Why did you add that link?
Because it's very easy to deduce from the speed of recent events that UK and Australian police have had certain people under observation; anyone who wants to believe that the NZ police do not cooperate in this is IMHO deluded.

Of course, I could also add links showing exactly and directly New Zealand doing what gumboot has claimed it doesn't do:

Linky

Or how about I ask pointed questions about New Zealand's cooperation in the Echelon operation? Just what do the NZ Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB) do all day? Hmmm? I could add more direct links, but the point is made.
 
And to forestall the strawman that will doubtlessly make its appearance regarding gumboot's claim on Germany, how about we talk about hate-crime legislation in New Zealand?
Linky
....
In 2002 the New Zealand Government added hate crimes to the list of aggravating factors to be taken into account when sentencing criminals in this country. Section 9(1)(h) of the Sentencing Act 2002 requires higher sentences for crimes involving hostility towards a group of persons on the basis of their race, colour, nationality, religion, gender identity, sexual orientation, age or disability. ....

You see, either:
  1. gumboot is eventually forced to admit that legislating against public acts is NOT the same as "prohibiting opinions", in which case his allegations against Germany are shown as false
    .
  2. or it is demonstrated that New Zealand does exactly the same thing as Germany anyway, in which case his claims about New Zealand are shown to be false
    .
  3. or of course, both
 
You can talk numbers and percentages all day if you like.All it takes is one evil mad idoit (Hitler) a whole deluded country (German) to believe what they are told to believe,and you've got a world war.

That's... not quite as easy as it sounds.

It would be difficult to reenact the recipe of WWII. You'd need WWI, a battered country that was being taken advantage of by everyone, a lot of angst, and old ideas from a russian moron about a race descended from Atlantis...
 
So what are you concerned about? :


In terms of New Zealand's continuation as a free society? Nothing.



You live in a free country that obviously isn't concerned about the free expression like Jihadists, I guess. See, that's the price to live free, either the 36,072 Muslims or Scientologists will overthrow your Government. :D


I am not aware of any mosques in New Zealand teaching extremism, and indeed the actions by the Federation of Islamic Associations of New Zealand (FIANZ) in response to the Mohammed cartoon controversy were exemplary, and a role model for moderate Muslims the world over.

I'm also not aware of a Scientology presence in New Zealand. I would be concerned if a large number of New Zealanders started practicing it, but not as concerned as I would have been had the New Zealand government refused to cooperate with the filming of The Last Samurai.

Hypothetically, pretending there are extremist Muslims in New Zealand, yes that would concern me a great deal. Likewise the small number of Neo-Nazi groups in New Zealand concern me. But the banning of these groups (assuming they have not made any efforts to actually commit crimes) would concern me more.




Oh, and by your "spying" Statement, you pretty much confirmed what you think about the FBI and as such, the "free society" of America. :)


Do the FBI spy on non-criminal groups in the USA as a matter of policy?

-Gumboot
 
Name just one such alleged law, and specify/quote exactly what it prohibits.

Come on. You've now claimed Germany prohibits certain beliefs or opinions -- per se. You are either immensely ignorant or dishonest.
So you could march down a street in Germany with a sign praising Adolph Hitler? Or denying the Holocaust? Aren't their certain political parties that have been banned?

You'll find no such things going on in the United States, where we're not afraid of ideas, even extreme and hateful ones.
 
The whole Muslim population of the world doesn't want to kill anyone. It's just a small minority of extremists. Not world dominating but still a danger to be watched for.


Not in New Zealand, "Home of the free". :D
 
Wait. Scientologists aren't criminal groups?

Even though they did things on international waters that are illegal in most countries except, maybe, Africa? (Child abuse, for one)

Even though they have a rule (in scientology) that stated that they could do anything they wanted to "enemies of scientology" (Including anyone that questions them)?

Even though they have directly and intentionally infiltrated any organization that questions them?

That scientology?

They're completely innocent people?

Okay, yeah, right.

But yes, Germany is an utterly horrible place. :rolleyes:

I'm done here.
 
So you could march down a street in Germany with a sign praising Adolph Hitler? Or denying the Holocaust? Aren't their certain political parties that have been banned?
Tell me again, which part of the disntiction between an opinion and a public act do you fail to want to understand?
:)
This is like shooting fish in a barrel.
You'll find no such things going on in the United States, where we're not afraid of ideas, even extreme and hateful ones.
If you try claiming actually marching down a street with any sign at all is only an idea, I'm going to question your sanity.

Cheers.
 
Do the FBI spy on non-criminal groups in the USA as a matter of policy?

-Gumboot


Yes, they do - here's a nice article mentioning some FBI-Spy-Programs:

http://www.independent.org/newsroom/article.asp?id=1544

About two weeks ago, the FBI admitted in federal court to collecting thousands of documents on non-violent activist groups, including the ACLU, Greenpeace and various antiwar organizations.
Throughout the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s, the FBI snooped on the personal lives of radical leftists, peace activists, and Civil Rights personalities such as Martin Luther King, infiltrated activist groups opposed to mandatory busing, and even spied on John Lennon.
Reborn as the “Bureau of Investigation” in the late 1920s, it continued to spy upon such “socialists” as Albert Einstein

Jesus, I already learned all of that in the first X-Files episode. :rolleyes: :D :p
 
I am not a regular contributor to this forum, but why did Parky start this thread and disappear?
Some people like to do that. My favorite was Nie Trink Wasser, who IIRC, rarely posted anything after starting a thread. He's been gone for a few years now.

He also had the most repellent avatar I ever saw.
 
Because it's very easy to deduce from the speed of recent events that UK and Australian police have had certain people under observation; anyone who wants to believe that the NZ police do not cooperate in this is IMHO deluded.

Of course, I could also add links showing exactly and directly New Zealand doing what gumboot has claimed it doesn't do:

Linky

Or how about I ask pointed questions about New Zealand's cooperation in the Echelon operation? Just what do the NZ Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB) do all day? Hmmm? I could add more direct links, but the point is made.
No it's not; it's about quickly gathering evidence and arresting anyone (for further questioning) who may have been involved.

For example, when the bomber struck London the police found his mobile phone in the car and they quickly traced all the calls made from and to his mobile. As a further example, several phone calls were made to a letting company and apparently the net was already closing in on a property in Glasgow prior to the attacks on the airport.

Is it merely a coincidence they arrested this guy in Australia after the attacks?

Anyways, how do you know he had been under surveillance, prove to me he was! If not you are just making it up, it's just this kind of huge leap a conspiracy theorist would make...

"How did they arrest him so quickly, he must have been under surveillance for a long time, must have been Echelon!!!!111!!!!"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom