YEC's and Evolution

Yeah, too bad Avalon is so easily scared off. I find this very interesting. One thing that posters seem to be forgetting though, me included, is the "Y", in YEC. Everyone is throwing around millions of years, when he is presupposing 6000. That kind of gets in the way.
 
Right. Not that evolution is an intelligent thing that cares about our distinctions, but that the range of variation available isn't going to take us from dog to cat; it will take us from dog to smaller dog to dog with different shape of snout or color of coat. It will not give us a dog with the ability to speak, or opposable thumbs, or retractable claws, or tapeta (tapetums?).

[TANGENT] Most dogs DO have tapeta: http://www.ccmr.cornell.edu/education/ask/index.html?quid=597[/TANGENT]
 
Look at the primate family tree.

It should be obvious from morphology that humans are more similar to apes than to monkeys, that humans and apes collectively are more similar to old world monkeys than to new world monkeys, that old world monkeys collectively are more similar to each other than they are to apes, and so forth. You can confirm this for yourself with a visit to any decently equipped zoo.

The corresponding tree as obtained from genetic studies can be seen here. (The actual citation is : A Composite Estimate of Primate Phylogeny, by Andy Purvis Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences © 1995 The Royal Society.)

Note the similarities. See in particular figures 8 and 4, which show that "humans are more similar to apes than to monkeys, that humans and apes collectively are more similar to old world monkeys than to new world monkeys, that old world monkeys collectively are more similar to each other than they are to apes." And so forth.

Avalon, considering that you are interested in the evidence, this is probably the most important post in this thread (though Dr Kitten made a few others of similar worth). Just thought it was worth reposting in case you missed it.
 
An interesting thread, I've just now caught up.
As has been pointed out, evolution is something which occurs over time; time which YEC denies.
While dating according to the known process of molecular breakdown is understood, it is too abstract to offer as proof, I think, at least at this point.
How about the different magnetization of rock layers, which testifies the changes (flips) in the earth's poles?
Too abstract?

Tree rings are observable and understandable- the alternating summer/winter rings are consistent and verifiable.

The same thing occurs with winter and summer ice falls and this gives us, through the ice core sampling done, some extremely indicative results.
Here's a link to what I found to be an excellent paper on the subject:

http://www.asa3.org/ASA/PSCF/2003/PSCF12-03Seely.pdf

Because it's simple, 'just snow' the banding modestly yields little more than the tale of the years which have passed. Occasionally there's an band of ash from major volcanoes or meteor hits over the millenia, but other than that, the cores (some over 1,500 meters long) show winter following summer during a very, very long time.

This is just my own take on the subject.
I can see Avalon's frustration with dependance on lab results whose provenance and interpretation can't be verified personally without the necessary technical background to handle the data. It will be interesting to see where the thread goes as Avalon takes on-board the information which has been posted up.

Now I'm off to read the links which have been provided up til now.
 
Pakeha, nice post.

One of the interesting things about it is that all of those various lines of evidence agree about the earth being very old. If they were all mistaken, we wouldn't expect them all to err in the same direction. That is, if the methods used were somehow flawed, we'd likely see some pointing to an earth much younger than it is, as well as some pointing to an earth much older.
But we don't.

Which is more evidence that the earth is in fact old.
 
Fascinating thread.

Summary by analogy; IMHO, AvalonXQ believes in inches but not in miles and will not accept evidence from those that do believe in miles because they're not in his club.

Did I miss something?
 
A more general summary:
AvalonXQ prefers a hypothesis with zero evidence over one with an abundance of evidence… ironically, citing lack of evidence as the reason.
 
Clearly a tiger and a leopard are different animals today. Could they both have evolved from a common ancestor? How about a hyena and a wolf? I am just pointing out that often what we as humans perceive to be similar animals (wolves and dogs for example), are just an extension of what can be proven to be the same phenomenon in other species. The proof is in the genetics. Let's say that evolution is not true, but all the evidence that we use in modern medicine points to its validity, then it may as well be true, just by Occam's razor.

A good example of this is while one might at first think Hyenas were Canids, they're actually a branch of Feliforma. Creationists seem to think common ancestry and relatedness are determined only by superficial characteristic, but we can more accurately determine relatedness through closer anatomical comparisons and finally, as you noted, genetics.
 
Well, I don't know about you guys, but I'm disappointed. The thread started off well. Avalon seemed to be genuinely interested in discussion. After a few pages however, probably due to the many excellent links disproving his "ideas", the true creationist got out, barricaded behind a pile of crap called the bible. Truly sad.
 
I don't see the evidence that shows that the current diversity of life on Earth could or did arise from common ancestors. My alternative hypothesis is that many different organisms were created independently.


The issue is whether A can also evolve into B, which seems wholly different than A in a way that A-, A+, and A* does not.

Ahh, speciation. Then you need to define what makes B fundamentally different from A.

Please don't be put off by this definition racket, but it is my experience that especially the definition of a species becomes a stumbling block in evolution/creation debates. So when you claim that variation within a species cannot become speciation, you need to define where the border between variation and speciation is.

Hans
 
Read link ? As far as I can tell he ignored all argument about it. Heck way earlier in the thread I provided a link to the GENETIC evidence of common ancestry of human and other simian species, what are the gene diffierence with our "cousins" and he fully ignored it, squaring instead with the more easily "fightable" poster.

There are enough evidence out there with protein make up, mitochondria etc... which shows how some species came in the "tree of evolution" heck this is why some speccy migrated from a branch to anotehr or were put to be branching earlier, because some of the protein make up showed an earlier genetic change.

All that was ignored to dwelve into petty argument.

As for the argument from authority... You have to reject it outright (so NO you cannot use it to support your own pet-belief, like YEC) or accept that specialist have some authorithy on what they discuss on (I would consult a priest if I wanted to know more about religion, but about SCIENCE and particularly EVOLUTION I consult a BIOLOGIST).
 
I need persuasive evidence of a starting event to get the clock running, persuasive evidence that the current conditions are at a predictable length of time from the starting event, and step-by-step explanation of the data analysis that gets us there. I don't think I'll need to run the tests myself; at present, I don't have access to the tools needed to do so anyway.


The problem with the bolded parts above is that (as far as i understand it) evolution does not concern itself with a 'starting event'. In YEC, the 'starting event' is god creating everything. The alternate explanation would be a big bang event or abiogenesis.

Evolution deals with change over time, not the beginning of time. Am i right?
 
Last edited:
A good example of this is while one might at first think Hyenas were Canids, they're actually a branch of Feliforma.

... which neatly answers AvalonXQ's question posed earlier about what type of changes might cause a cat-like animal to become a dog-like animal.
 
The problem with the bolded parts above is that (as far as i understand it) evolution does not concern itself with a 'starting event'. In YEC, the 'starting event' is god creating everything. The alternate explanation would be a big bang event or abiogenesis.

Evolution deals with change over time, not the beginning of time. Am i right?

Yes, you are perfectly right.
 
Yeah, too bad Avalon is so easily scared off. I find this very interesting. One thing that posters seem to be forgetting though, me included, is the "Y", in YEC. Everyone is throwing around millions of years, when he is presupposing 6000. That kind of gets in the way.

Well, that's why I was trying -- unsuccessfully, I guess -- to address the issue of age of rocks.

It's not like it's hard to find a rock that's demonstrably more than 100,000 years old. Quite the opposite; it's hard to find rocks that are newer than that.
 
Yeah, too bad Avalon is so easily scared off. I find this very interesting. One thing that posters seem to be forgetting though, me included, is the "Y", in YEC. Everyone is throwing around millions of years, when he is presupposing 6000. That kind of gets in the way.

I'm sorry he took off so soon. I just found this thread and was wanting to discuss his belief in a young earth from a believer's perspective. There's actaully nothing in the Bible that requires that belief. It's something tacked on a few centuries ago.
 
youve mentioned a couple of times that you are just trying to explain your christian beliefs, but in reality you arent, the vast majority of christians on this planet have no issue with darwinian evolution at all.

You're right. I wanted to discuss his questions from his standpoint of taking the Bible as a valid authority. If he does it honestly, he would see that there is nothing there to back up a belief in a 6000 year old earth and very little that isn't completely consistent with modern theories of evolution.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom