YEC's and Evolution

My thought, and correct me if I'm wrong, is that for a dog to get to be a cat or a cow would first require the modern dog to mutate backwards to something closely resembling the common ancestor before then evolving down the 'cow' route.

While it might be theoretically possible for this to occur given enough millions of years I don't think there is any process by which the breeding of modern dogs would cause this to happen. At some point wouldn't you need a drastic change in conditions/environment?

I don't think there's any inherent reason for the dog to "mutate backwards" to the common starting point and then reduplicate the evolutionary course followed by the modern cow. As long as the end-point was equivalent, the course it used to get there would be immaterial (although it is conceivable that the course you suggest would be the most economical).

More importantly, my argument was simply to suggest that it is "theoretically possible." I hope I was very clear that I regarded it as a practical impossibility.
 
However, without presenting the underlying facts themselves, it's still engaging in an argument from authority -- and, in this case, the source is one that I do not accept as authoritative in all areas. It doesn't mean that I won't look at the underlying evidence; it means that the underlying evidence and not the conclusions of others are necessary to convince me in these matters.

I would again ask what exactly do you distrust? The scientific process? Peer review? The openness of the process?

The scientific process has a history that can be evaluated and has proven worthy of some measure of "trust" with respect to its methods. This isn't appeal to authority, this is knowledge that if a large number of papers on a particular subject have appeared in journals and have been extensively referenced and verified, that the conclusions have some merit, because so many people have tested them and tried to undermine them without success.

No one views any conclusion as absolute truth, but some conclusions are very well supported.
 
Thank you, I think that clarifies that issue up perfectly.

Of course the complication is that anti-evolution argument would simply contend that its still a dog, just a cowy looking and acting dog.

The argument so far has been that any variation we see is within a kind and that we define kind by observing the variations which means by definition anything that a dog gives birth to is still a dog in their book.

Without any kind of definitive statement of what a kind is we're always going to come back to that circular argument and I don't see any way to overcome it to Avalon's satisfaction.
 
I don't think there's any inherent reason for the dog to "mutate backwards" to the common starting point and then reduplicate the evolutionary course followed by the modern cow. As long as the end-point was equivalent, the course it used to get there would be immaterial (although it is conceivable that the course you suggest would be the most economical).

But an equivalent endpoint would be a different species than a cow - it wouldn't be interfertile with a cow. It would only be a cow in the sense that a marsupial lion is a lion - superficially the morhphology is similar, but the genome is quite different.

What you're describing is something that's not ever seen in nature.
 
It doesn't mean that I won't look at the underlying evidence; it means that the underlying evidence and not the conclusions of others are necessary to convince me in these matters.
I know that bothers a lot of atheists and other science-minded people, so I didn't really want to go into it here. But there you go.

I assume I'm on Avalon's ignore list now, but I'd like to point out that for all his vaunted willingness to look at the "underlying evidence," that's just what he is refusing to do. He hasn't bothered to avail himself of any of the myriad opportunities that lie quite literally at his fingertips (given that he's clearly writing on a computer connected to the internet). He can find a great deal of the "underlying evidence" and examine it in great detail if he has any interest in doing so.

Quite clearly, however, he's never bothered to take even a cursory glance at it, because he can't cite a single part of that evidence which troubles or puzzles him. That would have been a potentially productive discussion. The route he has chosen instead--the argument from personal incredulity--is guaranteed to be unproductive.
 
Of course the complication is that anti-evolution argument would simply contend that its still a dog, just a cowy looking and acting dog.

I guess I'm not done after all.
I would not accept the argument that it's just a "cowy looking and acting dog"; I would accept it as evidence for variations broad enough to bridge the two species. In fact, it would probably be enough for me to seriously question/reevaluate the whole idea of seperate genesis.
 
Again, an argument from authority is an argument from authority; it's useful if you trust the source, and not useful if you're looking for evidence. When I quote the Bible as a source of authority, I'm making an argument from authority; I usually do so in the context of explaining Christian beliefs and/or my beliefs rather than as any sort of "proof" that the ideas are objectively correct.
I'm aware that most people here accept the scientific consensus as authoritative...
And by definition, the 'scientific consensis' is not "argument from authority".

Got it?

... and therefore that using this consensus without additional evidence can often be useful (as the Wikipedia post indicated). However, without presenting the underlying facts themselves, it's still engaging in an argument from authority -- and, in this case, the source is one that I do not accept as authoritative in all areas.
So, what exactly do you expect us to do, drag you out to the badlands of mongolia so you can examine the fossils yourself? Send you to university for a decade so you can learn enough to conduct genetic analsis yourself?

From the looks of things, you appear to be spectacularly ignorant when it comes to understanding basic science. Yet you don't want to listen to listen to people who actually know what they're talking about, somehow thinking you'll be able to understand the evidence when its presented to you.

This reminds me of a quote from the movie "A Fish Called Wanda"...

Wanda: But you think you're an intellectual, don't you, ape?
Otto: [superior smile] Apes don't read philosophy.
Wanda: Yes they do, Otto, they just don't understand it! Let me correct you on a few things; Aristotle was not Belgian! The central message of Buddhism is not "Every man for himself!" And the London Underground is not a political movement! Those are all mistakes. I looked them up.

By the way, we're still waiting for you to answer a few basic questions, such as:

- Just how much 'change' or variation do you think can exist in a species, and what do you think limits it.

- Can individuals within a species exhibit so much variation that they are no longar able to interbreed?

- How do you explain convergence? The way that genetics, the fossil record, geology and astronomy all give supporting conclusions on so many issues (I gave several examples) when they wouldn't have to if there were separate creation events?

Perhaps the biggest question of all... why are people like you so intellectually dishonest? You started this thread so well, I'm sure people actually had hope. Now, within a very short period of time, you have exhibited the standard traits of any illogical buffon, ignoring any questions that they are unable to answer.
 
Well then I suggest you read up on ring species, because that's effectively exactly what we're talking about.. variation broad enough to result in two species.
 
But an equivalent endpoint would be a different species than a cow - it wouldn't be interfertile with a cow. It would only be a cow in the sense that a marsupial lion is a lion - superficially the morhphology is similar, but the genome is quite different.

What you're describing is something that's not ever seen in nature.

My whole point is that such a thing cannot be seen in nature. Did you miss the bit where I said that it would be so astronomically improbable as to make macroscopic quantum effects look commonplace?

What I'm saying is that there's no inherent limitation that prevents this being possible. It won't happen, of course, but that's simply because it is so staggeringly implausible--not because of any inherent physical limitation in the possible future sequence of changes that the dog's DNA sequence can undergo.

And no, I'm not saying "some sort of cow-like animal"--I'm talking about an animal that would be genetically indistinguishable from a modern cow. An animal, in other words, that could interbreed with the modern cow.

Again--I'm not saying that this will happen or that it could happen in reality--it's far too improbable. I'm saying that I can't see any physical limitation that would make it literally impossible.
 
I don't think there's any inherent reason for the dog to "mutate backwards" to the common starting point and then reduplicate the evolutionary course followed by the modern cow. As long as the end-point was equivalent, the course it used to get there would be immaterial (although it is conceivable that the course you suggest would be the most economical).

More importantly, my argument was simply to suggest that it is "theoretically possible." I hope I was very clear that I regarded it as a practical impossibility.

Yeah I guess part of the problem is that from our vantage point at the end of the branches it seems that through time dogs have been becoming more doggy, and cats more catty and cows more cowy as time progresses. It therefore seems difficult to imagine something becoming less doggy and more cowy through evolution.

Its hard not to think that way, and I have to remind myself that dog, cat and cow are lagely arbitrary definitions of sequences that happen to be present on the planet at the same time as me and there is nothing inherently special about dogness, catness and cowness that mean evolution should select for them.

Some of this stuff is just hard to compute and I guess that's why some people fall at that hurdle. Simplistic explanations do make life much simpler.
 
Someone with more knowledge can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it is truer to say that there is no physical reason why some species of dogs could not evolve into animals that were genetically indistinguishable from (and interbreedable with) modern day cows. The point is that it is vanishingly improbable. The series of steps that would require such a "targeted" evolution are each astronomically improbable. Multiply each improbability by the next and you have the kinds of improbability that make macroscopic quantum effects look commonplace.

But I don't think there is any inherent limit to the plasticity of a dog's (or any other animals) DNA code.

You're right, the only reason a dog couldn't evolve into somethign genetically identical to a cow is due to the improbability.

However, we ARE dealing with a creationist; as such, he's pretty scientifically ignorant. The last thing we need is to confuse him more with talks of probability.

I figured the more productive thing to do would be to discuss what actually might happen, if the niche of large grazing herbivores opened up and dogs were able to evolve.
 
Well then I suggest you read up on ring species, because that's effectively exactly what we're talking about.. variation broad enough to result in two species.

No no, you don't understand. "Reading" things is succumbing to the "argument from authority." He would have to actually do all the basic research himself or it wouldn't count. And as he's not going to bother to do even a half-assed job of research, he's invincibly armored in his ignorance. A great victory for God!
 
I guess I'm not done after all.
I would not accept the argument that it's just a "cowy looking and acting dog"; I would accept it as evidence for variations broad enough to bridge the two species. In fact, it would probably be enough for me to seriously question/reevaluate the whole idea of seperate genesis.

So how do you tell when something is no longer a dog? What's the criteria you use to make this judgement?

Given the timescales that evolution works on you do realise that not only would none of us be around to witness both modern dog and new cow-dog but civilisation would probably have ended and the planet died long before we even got close? So what evidence could be provided that would convince you?
 
So you agree that an argument from authority is insufficient for someone looking for evidentiary arguments?
If so, I fail to see the hypocrisy in acknowledging that this fact applies to ANY authority. I don't accept special pleading when I'm looking for evidence.
Perhaps you could stick with substantive contributions, or stay silent, rather than just ridiculing me? You're lowering the tone of the debate.

I always find it funy when people like you claim that you're being mistreated when one points out your hypocracy.

Or was it someone else who posted and I am paraphrasing - that you accept the bible in favor of ToE because the evidence for ToE being given you is an argument from authority WHICH IS NOT by the way.


Just what exactly do you think claiming that the bible is right about creation instead of ToE if not an appeal to authority.
 
Perhaps you could stick with substantive contributions, or stay silent, rather than just ridiculing me? You're lowering the tone of the debate.
He's right though. You can't seem to accept that the informal logical fallacies are not absolute.
When I quote the Bible as a source of authority, I'm making an argument from authority; I usually do so in the context of explaining Christian beliefs and/or my beliefs rather than as any sort of "proof" that the ideas are objectively correct.
Actually, no. Your invoking the argument from ignorance or god of the gaps fallacy.
 
Last edited:

youve mentioned a couple of times that you are just trying to explain your christian beliefs, but in reality you arent, the vast majority of christians on this planet have no issue with darwinian evolution at all. What you are actually stating is that your beliefs are in line with a bunch of semitic Jews circa 500bce, who in turn got their beliefs froma bunch of semitic babylonians, who in turn got their beliefs from the semitic akkadians circa 1900bce, who in turn got their beliefs from the sumerians circa 2500bce, who from all appearences made them up as a way of explaining something they were underequipped to understand. Newsflash, we are equipped to explain it, but you are incapable of listening because you are deluding yourself that what the Sumerians believed is 100% correct

none of your claims are christian, christian ideology says to follow the teachings of christ, last time I checked he taught christianity, not science, so your claims are neither christian or scientific.

sucks to be in a cult religion eh
:rolleyes:
 
Is it also true that said DNA could redevelop eventually through further mutation that reintroduces those changes? Essentially, that "dog" could "unevolve" back to the main branch, then "re-evolve" along the same lines as the current "cow"?

As far as I know, evolution can never move backward. There is no way that something can become less adapted to the environment, and still survive through enough generations to keep moving backward. But I suppose it is just semantics when you say 'backward' or 'forward'
Chickens still have the gene for teeth, if the environment changed so that having teeth was again beneficial, I suppose you could say that was moving 'backward' because the chicken was going back to how it was in earlier stages in some way. But this is not really 'backward' because it is still an improvement, based on whatever environmental or selection pressure is requiring it.

Even in the case of increased numbers of elephants being born with smaller or even absent tusks due to extensive poaching for ivory, this may not be immediately seen as an improvement and may be thought as a 'backward' move, but it increases the survivability of the elephant, and that is all evolution 'cares' about.
 
And, at the same time, you're telling me that evolution cannot do E, which seems to be in the same category as D.

A, B, and C, are all small changes; we have evidence for them. D is a change of a much more different and drastic kind. I understand that the wisdom is that D is just A repeated over millions of years, but I need direct evidence of D. A just isn't convincing of D.

I don't know if this has come up earlier in the thread, but think about the proof by contradiction. If you think that A has indeed repeated over millions of years, but has not led to speciation and large changes---well, what stopped it?

Imagine (say) two birds of species A which have been blown to different Galapagos islands. You agree that the A+ generation can differ from the A generation, and the A++ from the A+, and so on. How does that still look like A after a million years? Does someone take a hole of A++++++ and say, "Here now, you fellas are awfully short-beaked compared to your ancestors A, and your cousins A''''''''' on the other island are awfully long-legged these days. You're supposed to be the same species; please look at this breed-standard and sort yourself out."

What's the stabilizing force? Obviously if the environment is stable and the population is large enough, the law of averages can be the stabilizing force. But the environment is rarely stable (remember, "environment" includes predators, prey, food plants, and diseases, all of which are also evolving, as well as climate and whatnot), so how could A+++++++++ possibly be able to avoid diverging from some A'''''''' cousin it's never encountered or from an A ancestor it doesn't remember?
 
I think it fair to say that Avalon has been presented with a fair amount of reading material, and that it is unjust to expect him to comprehend all of them and reply to this thread at the same time. Perhaps this petty bickering over logical fallacies could cease and we allow him to return to the thread when he has perused the literature?

I would suggest, Avalon, that you make a start with drkitten's links.

~ Matt
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom