YEC's and Evolution

I've abandoned the discussion, but I'm still reading (or at least skimming) the thread. .....
I just wish people would keep their nastiness to themselves.
The little "!" in the triangle is for reporting a post that is "nasty". The mods take this very seriously here.
 
Perhaps you would like to cite the "nastiness".
I have not seen anything other than comments you may be acting like the other YECs we have seen in the forum.

These meta-discussions are also not very useful.
I was attacked more than a dozen times for being disingenuous, stupid, ignorant, and/or uneducated. I'm surprised if you can't see that just from reading over the thread.
Bottom line: this thread started promising, and very quickly turned into something else, and as a result, I'll likely be the only one to get much of value out of it. Disappointing.
 
Very disappointing indeed. I have done a search for "stupid", and all I find is this so far:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=5200871#post5200871
wherein we find:
I regret starting this thread, because rather than attempting to explain what I understand and get feedback, it became something else entirely -- first, a "why don't you accept evolution?" and then a "how can you be so ignorant/stupid/incredulous/unscrupulous/hypocritical as to not accept evolution?"
and then there is this:
by AvalonXQ: I was attacked more than a dozen times for being disingenuous, stupid, ignorant, and/or uneducated. I'm surprised if you can't see that just from reading over the thread.
I could search for the other descriptors you mention, but I find this claim that you have been called "stupid" to be a false accusation. Do you have a response to this? A dozen times? Sir, I cannot find even one time you were called "stupid". The poster would have been warned, and then suspended if he had persisted. What on earth do you mean?

Whoa! Just did a search for "ignorant". It was used once to mean "not aware", which is a perfectly good usage and was not meant as an offense, by Joe the Juggler. After that, it seems you are the only poster using the word. I am going to make a wild guess and say that I would find the same for "uneducated". People just don't often pull that kind of ad hom on the forum. In very bad taste.
So, what is going on here? A case of paranoia? You have some 'splainin' to do, my friend.
"incredulous"!! Sorry, dude no one ever used the word.
So let's try this word on for size: prevaricator, look it up.
 
Last edited:
I'll predict now that no amount of evidence presented in this thread will change your view. In my opinion, the issue is not with the lack of evidence its with how you choose to process that evidence and your expectations of how that evidence should look and how the scientific community should present it and deal with your objections.

Well, in Avalon's defense, things like the above, whether true or not, only serve to bring the discussion down.

I mean, if someone posted something like that in response to me, I would certainly feel insulted by it.

And personally, I think that we have so few YECs on here, I'd prefer that they were given the benefit of the doubt so we could see how they respond to actual arguments.
 
edit - I firmly believe that one of these days we'll find out that fundies or some such group has a specialmerrit badge for their cult members for posting on boards like this. If you can create a 15 page thread on a AAATHIEST forum you can get a hand job without sin. If you can get it up to 40 you can get laid. (avolon only gets to play with himself)

This isn't an atheist forum. It's a skeptics forum.
 
I've abandoned the discussion, but I'm still reading (or at least skimming) the thread. The primary discussion here quickly moved into an attack stance that I no longer considered valuable.
Perhaps the reason why you feel 'attacked' (and the reason why you have not always been treated 'nicely') is because of your lack of response to simple questions.

You see, some of us are used to dealing with creationists who use the 'gun and run' approach... they post nonsense statements, then when you point out problems with their claims, they disappear without responding, only to 'pop up' later with pretty much the same claims they had made before (totally ignoring the fact that their arguments were already debunked.). People who engage in such dishonest tactics should, in my opinion, receive little if any respect.

For example, you were asked (both by paximperium and myself) about limits to genetic changes that you think would be possible within your 'creationist' framework. No answer was provided, even though you had made several postings AFTER this question was asked.

We also questioned your mis-definition of the concept of an "argument from authority".

You see, you started the thread reasonably, yet it didn't take long for you to start acting like a more "typical" creationist, by avoiding avoiding questions that might expose flaws in your belief and by using incorrect definitions and facts, in other words, the type of individual who normally deserves no respect. Perhaps you actually are an honest, well-meaning person capable of rational thought who clearly just needs some correct information. But if you ACT like a typical disreputable creationist, there is a pretty good chance you will be treated as a disreputable creationist.
 
Well, in Avalon's defense, things like the above, whether true or not, only serve to bring the discussion down.

I mean, if someone posted something like that in response to me, I would certainly feel insulted by it.

And personally, I think that we have so few YECs on here, I'd prefer that they were given the benefit of the doubt so we could see how they respond to actual arguments.

The problem is, it jsut happened the standard way I see YEC doing thread discussion on evolution. Pray tell me how this one diverged from it :

* make a bold statement asking for evidence but put a high enough standard that nothing short of divine intervention would fullfil it (example : require a complete chain of evidence going from a very ancient common specy to a very different descendant , aka proto shrew to cow).
* IGNORE all the good post and link, then instead concentrate on the petty or shallow post (no offense meant to the posters)
* Say that you were insulted. It does not matter whether it is true or not, it is enough to state it. Some forum member will anyway say "yes , it might be construed as insult" (that is where you come in)
* say you will think about what you were linked / posted to. Either : 1) never come back or 2) ignore all evidence and just state the evidence are not enough

I have yet to see a YEC - evolution debate end otherwise.
 
Last edited:
I agree with you that this is the way these "debates" tend to go. I also think, though, that we can't put all of the blame on the YECs.

I'm not suggesting that they are right to fail to address the important points. I actually went ahead and pointed one such ignored post out to Avalon. I'm just saying that I think we would do better to let them address those and avoid semi-insulting posts.
I say this mainly because when I read posts like those by Dr Kitten I was looking forward to Avalon's response. I wanted to see where that part of the discussion went.

When they were overlooked, in part because of the posts made by others, I was disappointed.

Edit: Anyway, this is off-topic, sorry for the detour, and I hope Avalon has the intellectual courage to return and address the real points made, and the links he said he's looking over.
 
Last edited:
These meta-discussions are also not very useful.
I was attacked more than a dozen times for being disingenuous, stupid, ignorant, and/or uneducated. I'm surprised if you can't see that just from reading over the thread.
Bottom line: this thread started promising, and very quickly turned into something else, and as a result, I'll likely be the only one to get much of value out of it. Disappointing.

not exactly a very honorable way to sneak out of a debate...
 
I'm not suggesting that they are right to fail to address the important points. I actually went ahead and pointed one such ignored post out to Avalon. I'm just saying that I think we would do better to let them address those and avoid semi-insulting posts.
I say this mainly because when I read posts like those by Dr Kitten I was looking forward to Avalon's response. I wanted to see where that part of the discussion went.

When they were overlooked, in part because of the posts made by others, I was disappointed.
Of course, you're assuming that at least part of the reason Avalon didn't respond actually had something (at least in part) with the supposed poor treatment he received. Frankly, its quite likely that DrKitten's questions were going to be ignored anyways. His 'avoidence' goes all the way back to the first page of the thread, long before people started being mean.

Heck, I myself would love to have seen him answer some of the questions. I just don't hold much hope of that happening.
 
About the need for courtesy in a YEC/evolution discussion:
it's for readers and lurkers since the discussion as such is a display piece, obviously.

Evolution, as we know it to date, cannot exist in the timeframe of YEC.
Can't.
YEC cannot exist in the timeframe of evolution.
Can't.

In my view, however, the discussion is useful, very useful for the information and links and I'd like to see a similar offer of information and links from Avalon or any other YEC supporter.
 
Perhaps the reason why you feel 'attacked' (and the reason why you have not always been treated 'nicely') is because of your lack of response to simple questions.

You see, some of us are used to dealing with creationists who use the 'gun and run' approach... they post nonsense statements, then when you point out problems with their claims, they disappear without responding, only to 'pop up' later with pretty much the same claims they had made before (totally ignoring the fact that their arguments were already debunked.). People who engage in such dishonest tactics should, in my opinion, receive little if any respect.

For example, you were asked (both by paximperium and myself) about limits to genetic changes that you think would be possible within your 'creationist' framework. No answer was provided, even though you had made several postings AFTER this question was asked.

We also questioned your mis-definition of the concept of an "argument from authority".

You see, you started the thread reasonably, yet it didn't take long for you to start acting like a more "typical" creationist, by avoiding avoiding questions that might expose flaws in your belief and by using incorrect definitions and facts, in other words, the type of individual who normally deserves no respect. Perhaps you actually are an honest, well-meaning person capable of rational thought who clearly just needs some correct information. But if you ACT like a typical disreputable creationist, there is a pretty good chance you will be treated as a disreputable creationist.

Nicely put. This neatly sums up my opinion about this thread too.
 
Edit: Anyway, this is off-topic, sorry for the detour, and I hope Avalon has the intellectual courage to return and address the real points made, and the links he said he's looking over.

I hope too, but I'm not holding my breath and you shouldn't either...
 
In my view, however, the discussion is useful, very useful for the information and links and I'd like to see a similar offer of information and links from Avalon or any other YEC supporter.

There is no "similar information" on the YEC side. All they got is the bible.
 
1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
2) In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.

There is evidence for evolution,there is no evidence for the existence of god or creationism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom