YEC's and Evolution

I'm sorry he took off so soon. I just found this thread and was wanting to discuss his belief in a young earth from a believer's perspective. There's actaully nothing in the Bible that requires that belief. It's something tacked on a few centuries ago.

Actually, that's not true. The belief in a 6,000(ish) year old Earth based on Biblical chronology goes back well before Bishop Ussher; it's simply that Ussher has been getting most of the press. But anyone who sits down and reads Genesis can do the same type of math he did, and I believe the Venerable Bede did so in the 7th century and got about the same answer. (See this wikipedia article for some other early examples.)

You're welcome to reject the literal interpretation of the dates in Genesis, of course. But it's a little misleading to suggest that "there's nothing in the Bible" requiring a young earth.
 
Does AvalonXQ have drkitten on ignore? I believe that drkitten has made some very good posts at the beginning of the thread leading the reader towards evidence of an old world based on rock dating. However, not a single time has these posts been replied to by AvalonXQ, that I noticed.
 
Therefore, "dog" can never become "cow" because it's missing the necessary DNA; it was lost when the two species split from the "mammal" branch.
Just to be sure that you have understood this correctly: genetic change is not just caused by losing information. There are a number of ways that new information can be built in the genome.
 
Does AvalonXQ have drkitten on ignore? I believe that drkitten has made some very good posts at the beginning of the thread leading the reader towards evidence of an old world based on rock dating. However, not a single time has these posts been replied to by AvalonXQ, that I noticed.

I think AvalonXQ Has much on ignore.
 
Does AvalonXQ have drkitten on ignore? I believe that drkitten has made some very good posts at the beginning of the thread leading the reader towards evidence of an old world based on rock dating. However, not a single time has these posts been replied to by AvalonXQ, that I noticed.

err, he's yec, evidence and the long string of posters of his ilk here have proven that by definition he has anything that contradicts his pet delusion on ignore.
That's why these threads are such a waist. Future yecs/fundies coming here will not bother to search the forum because they believe that their 'special' relationship with the skyfairy will win us over and any evidence to the contrary will be ignored.

wash rinse repeat

edit - I firmly believe that one of these days we'll find out that fundies or some such group has a specialmerrit badge for their cult members for posting on boards like this. If you can create a 15 page thread on a AAATHIEST forum you can get a hand job without sin. If you can get it up to 40 you can get laid. (avolon only gets to play with himself)
 
Last edited:
Does AvalonXQ have drkitten on ignore?

I don't think so, at least not initially.

As late as post #27, AvalonXQ was still reading, quoting, and responding to my points.

I think he tuned out at about the first actual citation of old earth rocks.

I believe that drkitten has made some very good posts at the beginning of the thread leading the reader towards evidence of an old world based on rock dating.

(Thank you.)


However, not a single time has these posts been replied to by AvalonXQ, that I noticed.

I noticed that, too. I think that was when he might have started to realize he was over his head, because from that point on, he started more or less responding only to Last of the Fraggles.

It might be that he's off reading the papers I cited -- they're certainly deep enough that I would expect him to devour them in seconds. Or he might simply have gotten scared off by the risk of learning something.

Hard to tell.
 
It might be that he's off reading the papers I cited -- they're certainly deep enough that I would expect him to devour them in seconds. Or he might simply have gotten scared off by the risk of learning something.

Hard to tell.
We've been chatting in the R&P section. He started to adopt a "I won't believe you unless you formulate a highly detailed argument..." position without offering any support for his counterclaims. It became clear that it was more of a debate tactic than an honest request for clarity.

So, I'm not really surprized things fizzled here.
 
We've been chatting in the R&P section. He started to adopt a "I won't believe you unless you formulate a highly detailed argument..." position without offering any support for his counterclaims. It became clear that it was more of a debate tactic than an honest request for clarity.

So, I'm not really surprized things fizzled here.
Well, he's made 53 posts today in other threads, so it seems more likely he's just abandoned this one.

:(
 
Actually, that's not true. The belief in a 6,000(ish) year old Earth based on Biblical chronology goes back well before Bishop Ussher; it's simply that Ussher has been getting most of the press. But anyone who sits down and reads Genesis can do the same type of math he did, and I believe the Venerable Bede did so in the 7th century and got about the same answer. (See this wikipedia article for some other early examples.)

You're welcome to reject the literal interpretation of the dates in Genesis, of course. But it's a little misleading to suggest that "there's nothing in the Bible" requiring a young earth.

To do that you have to assume that that genealogy in Genesis is complete. There is no reason to do so. To be valid from the Jewish perspective, it would need to be matriarchal.

And, of course, you have to accept the standard translation of the first few chapters that the "days" mention for creation are our normal 24-hour days. There's really no reason for that either. The 6000 years could be counting just from the first humans with language to tell stories, which really isn't too far off (at least not by 14 billion years).

Ussher gets all the press because his calculations were the first to be taken seriously, mostly due to its inclusion in the King James Bible, only one example of things that translation's responsible for spreading that are considered "gospel" today. Most biblical authorities have always held that the Earth was much older than that and that the Genesis timeline is not be taken literally.
 
To do that you have to assume that that genealogy in Genesis is complete. There is no reason to do so.

By the contrary, there's no reason NOT to do so. To do otherwise is to assume a deliberately non-standard translation, where "begat" (or the Hebrew original word) takes on something other than its standard meaning.

E.g, Genesis 5:28-32.
28 ¦ And Lamech lived an hundred eighty and two years, and begat a son:
29 And he called his name Noah, saying, This same shall comfort us concerning our work and toil of our hands, because of the ground which the LORD hath cursed.
30 And Lamech lived after he begat Noah five hundred ninety and five years, and begat sons and daughters:
31 And all the days of Lamech were seven hundred seventy and seven years: and he died.
32 And Noah was five hundred years old: and Noah begat Shem, Ham, and Japheth.

I suppose you could claim that "son" in Gen5:28 really means "grandson" or "great-grandson," but that doesn't help; it still puts Noah as being born 182 years after Lamech.

And since there are no gaps between the various begats and the fall of Jerusalem (588 B.C.), there's no basis for you to claim the geneology is incomplete.

To be valid from the Jewish perspective, it would need to be matriarchal.

No. Jewish inheritance is still largely patriarchal, as is the family naming scheme. How many times does the phrase "Solomon the son of David" appear vs. "Solomon the son of Bathsheba"?

And, of course, you have to accept the standard translation of the first few chapters that the "days" mention for creation are our normal 24-hour days.

Of course. And, again, the reason to do that is precisely because it's standard. If you want to reject the standard translation, I would think you would want to present an argument about why the standard translation fails -- the simple text of Genesis states that creation took place across seven days. If you're going to argue that the "days" were in fact millions of years but that creation was otherwise as described, then you get the rather interesting factoid that flowering plants (which are photosynthetic) predate the existence of any light source like the sun by those same millions of years.

I.e. the day/aeon argument simply doesn't hold water.

Genesis either says what it says (a seven day creation period about 6000 years ago) or it's a work of fiction. You can't reconcile the two.

Ussher gets all the press because his calculations were the first to be taken seriously,

Er, no. The first whose calculations were taken seriously were those of Rabbi Jose ben Halafta. The first christian whose calculations were taken seriously were the Venerable Bedes.

Most biblical authorities have always held that the Earth was much older than that and that the Genesis timeline is not be taken literally.

Only in if "most" in this case means "very few, almost all from the last two hundred years."
 
I guess we'll just disagree, then.

I suppose. But only because I'm right and you're wrong, I'm afraid.

I don't disagree that there can be variant interpretations of Genesis. But you're making a much stronger claim -- that there is no reasonable interpretation of Genesis that leads to a 6000 year old Earth. And that's clearly and obviously false; the most superficial and literal interpretation of Genesis does exactly that.
 
edit - I firmly believe that one of these days we'll find out that fundies or some such group has a specialmerrit badge for their cult members for posting on boards like this. If you can create a 15 page thread on a AAATHIEST forum you can get a hand job without sin. If you can get it up to 40 you can get laid. (avolon only gets to play with himself)

There is, but it is for class credit at at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, not sexual favors

See:

http://www.designinference.com/teaching/teaching.htm

specifically
This is the undegrad course. You have three things to do: (1) take the final exam (worth 40% of your grade); (2) write a 3,000-word essay on the theological significance of intelligent design (worth 40% of your grade); (3) provide at least 10 posts defending ID that you’ve made on “hostile” websites, the posts totalling 2,000 words, along with the URLs (i.e., web links) to each post (worth 20% of your grade).
 
AvalonXQ said:
1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
Well, I can prove that the basic principle is operational:

Marvin Minsky said:
The Process of Evolution is the following abstract idea:

There is a population of things that reproduce, at different rates in different environments. Those rates depend, statistically, on a collection of inheritable traits. Those traits are subject to occasional mutations, some of which are then inherited.

Then one can deduce, from logic alone, without any need for evidence, that:

THEOREM: Each population will tend to increase the proportion of traits that have higher reproduction rates in its current environment.
This doesn't prove that there has been enough time to evolve life on Earth as we know it. For that, you'll have to have patience while we flesh out the fossil record and continue to analyze genomes. Of course, if you insist that the Earth is young, then it is impossible.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
Should Avalon still be reading this thread (or for any other creationists).

One of the arguments I've most commonly heard against evolution is that it is extremely unlikely/impossible to mutate something essential without killing off the organism depending on it. Therefore creation must have taken place.
I'm afraid this is a misconception based on a limited understanding of genetics.
From what I know, most introduction on genetics and reproduction shows how as a cell divides its two progeny get an equal amount of the genetic information.
However, nature is nowhere near as efficient as its made out in begginers text books. It is not unlikely for one cell to get over 50% and the other cell less. If this contains something essential, we now have one cell with two essential genes and one without (which dies).

The one that got the two copies will now give these two copies to any further progeny. Since there are now two identical copies present there is no more pressure to prevent either from mutating and gaining a different function. As mutations are random in fact a number of daughter cells can gain a number of different mutations, causing one species to adapt to several different environments.

Now of course one might argue that this applies only to single cell organisms, but this is not true. To go with the dog-cow anology. A duplication in a gene in the digestive system could lead to dogs that can digest plants more effciently. Not normally an advantage (but not a bad thing either) unless there is a lack of prey, in which case dogs that can also eat leaves would start being more advantageous. Further events could lead to dog-like creatures that cannot use meat anymore but only eat grass. This would in time lead to a herbivore descended from dogs. However the timescale for this to happen is millions of years given the current rate of mutation, and as mentioned before, an ecological nice needs to be there.
 
Well, he's made 53 posts today in other threads, so it seems more likely he's just abandoned this one.

I've abandoned the discussion, but I'm still reading (or at least skimming) the thread. The primary discussion here quickly moved into an attack stance that I no longer considered valuable.
Digesting drkitten's and others' excellent links will take time.

I'll admit that the constant insults and jabs at my intelligence, education, and intentions here make me, viscerally, just want to abandon the whole thing. But the fact that many people here have been jerks to me, is no excuse; information has been shared here that I either didn't have or didn't understand. I'll take the opportunity to learn.
I just wish people would keep their nastiness to themselves.
 
Last edited:
I've abandoned the discussion, but I'm still reading (or at least skimming) the thread. The primary discussion here quickly moved into an attack stance that I no longer considered valuable.
Digesting drkitten's and others' excellent links will take time.

I'll admit that the constant insults and jabs at my intelligence, education, and intentions here make me, viscerally, just want to abandon the whole thing. But the fact that many people here have been jerks to me, is no excuse; information has been shared here that I either didn't have or didn't understand. I'll take the opportunity to learn.
I just wish people would keep their nastiness to themselves.

FWIW, I agree with you about the attack/insult thing. It does seem to stifle a lot of otherwise useful discussion. Cheers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom