Are you implying that I don't understand the rudiments of logic?
No, I believe he was inferring that.
Specifically, he was inferring from your question that you don't understand the relationship between authority, "evidence" (your word), logic, and proof.
Post #63 outlines a framework (a sort of "rules of evidence") under which expert judgment is "a valid argument, akin to evidence." Quoting from that post:
It is /not/ fallacious, however, to support an argument for "X" by citing work done by those who are authorities on "X", where that work is a) supported by objective evidence, and b) the work is independently replicable and verifiable. Published, peer-reviewed scinetific research meets these criteria.
Your question nearly sixty posts later suggested you either hadn't read, hadn't understood, or had simply ignored post #63.
One of the mistakes you're making is conflating "a valid argument" with "evidence"; the two are not equivalent. A valid argument is by definition final and dispositive; evidence is usually merely indicative (just because your fingers were on the murder weapon and your footprints were in the room where the murder was committed doesn't mean you did it, but it probably
does mean a long session with the detectives).
Under this rubric, Sam Bowring's work should be acceptable; he's a well-recognized expert (they don't tenure people at MIT for being incompetent), his papers describe the objective evidence, and you can in theory replicate his work six months from now when you can get that far north and pick up the rocks yourself.
Similarly, Andy Purvis' data (post #63) is good evidence for the relationship between morphological similarity and genetic similarity, one of the key pieces of evidence for common descent.
Really, this gets back to your treatment of scientific evidence. Let me ask you -- for something like the fifth time, I believe --
do you insist on analyzing the damn rocks yourself or not? If you aren't going to accept what professional geologists say about the rocks, and you're unable to do a comparable analysis yourself, then you're
a priori rejecting evidence.
... and that's dishonest.