YEC's and Evolution

There is no "similar information" on the YEC side. All they got is the bible.

That doesn't hold them back, they have created tons of information... made it all up, but that doesn't mean it isn't there... It's out there poisoning new generations......
 
I've abandoned the discussion, but I'm still reading (or at least skimming) the thread. The primary discussion here quickly moved into an attack stance that I no longer considered valuable.
Digesting drkitten's and others' excellent links will take time.

I'll admit that the constant insults and jabs at my intelligence, education, and intentions here make me, viscerally, just want to abandon the whole thing. But the fact that many people here have been jerks to me, is no excuse; information has been shared here that I either didn't have or didn't understand. I'll take the opportunity to learn.
I just wish people would keep their nastiness to themselves.

I agree.I would like to ask you why you accept the bible as an authority,with no evidence.
 
How many people have to believe something before trusting them becomes a valid argument, tantamount to evidence? What credentials do they need to have?

Hmm... I could swear that I addressed the question of when "argument from authority" is and is not a logical fallacy. Yes, I see that I did, back in post #63.

To bring logical analysis to bear on your issues it would probably be advisable to learn something of the rudiments of logic, don't you think?
 
To bring logical analysis to bear on your issues it would probably be advisable to learn something of the rudiments of logic, don't you think?

Are you implying that I don't understand the rudiments of logic? Should I interpret this as a personal attack?
If it was intended as a legitimate argument rather than malicious, please explain what the appropriate take-away is.
 
Are you implying that I don't understand the rudiments of logic?

No, I believe he was inferring that.

Specifically, he was inferring from your question that you don't understand the relationship between authority, "evidence" (your word), logic, and proof.

Post #63 outlines a framework (a sort of "rules of evidence") under which expert judgment is "a valid argument, akin to evidence." Quoting from that post:

It is /not/ fallacious, however, to support an argument for "X" by citing work done by those who are authorities on "X", where that work is a) supported by objective evidence, and b) the work is independently replicable and verifiable. Published, peer-reviewed scinetific research meets these criteria.

Your question nearly sixty posts later suggested you either hadn't read, hadn't understood, or had simply ignored post #63.

One of the mistakes you're making is conflating "a valid argument" with "evidence"; the two are not equivalent. A valid argument is by definition final and dispositive; evidence is usually merely indicative (just because your fingers were on the murder weapon and your footprints were in the room where the murder was committed doesn't mean you did it, but it probably does mean a long session with the detectives).

Under this rubric, Sam Bowring's work should be acceptable; he's a well-recognized expert (they don't tenure people at MIT for being incompetent), his papers describe the objective evidence, and you can in theory replicate his work six months from now when you can get that far north and pick up the rocks yourself.

Similarly, Andy Purvis' data (post #63) is good evidence for the relationship between morphological similarity and genetic similarity, one of the key pieces of evidence for common descent.

Really, this gets back to your treatment of scientific evidence. Let me ask you -- for something like the fifth time, I believe -- do you insist on analyzing the damn rocks yourself or not? If you aren't going to accept what professional geologists say about the rocks, and you're unable to do a comparable analysis yourself, then you're a priori rejecting evidence.

... and that's dishonest.
 
Under this rubric, Sam Bowring's work should be acceptable; he's a well-recognized expert (they don't tenure people at MIT for being incompetent), his papers describe the objective evidence, and you can in theory replicate his work six months from now when you can get that far north and pick up the rocks yourself.

Similarly, Andy Purvis' data (post #63) is good evidence for the relationship between morphological similarity and genetic similarity, one of the key pieces of evidence for common descent.
I agree, and I've said so, more than once.
How many times are we going to go through this? There's a big difference between saying "You should believe X because Sam Bowring said so", and "You should believe X because of this paper that Sam Bowring presented that shows X". The first is an argument from authority; the second is not. The second is good evidence if the paper shows X or presents evidence regarding X.
Again, we got derailed when someone asked me why I don't accept evolution simply because the scientists believe it. It is that idea, and that idea alone, that I dismiss as an unsuccessful and unproductive argument from authority; I DO NOT likewise dismiss the actual evidence presented.


Really, this gets back to your treatment of scientific evidence. Let me ask you -- for something like the fifth time, I believe -- do you insist on analyzing the damn rocks yourself or not?

Let me answer you -- for something like the fifth time, I believe. No.

I predict that at least ten more posts will be wasted on this exact topic.
 
Last edited:
I agree, and I've said so, more than once.
How many times are we going to go through this? There's a big difference between saying "You should believe X [just] because Sam Bowring said so"

No-one has said that. Not one person.

ETA: More than one post has taken you to task on these questions, and attempted to move this discussion productively forward. My post #250 (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5211213&postcount=250), for example, posted a number of questions which, were you to answer them, would elucidate what exactly your position is on this issue. And mine is not the only one. Might I respectfully request you actually address some of the questions but to you?
 
Last edited:
Let me answer you -- for something like the fifth time, I believe. No.

I predict that at least ten more posts will be wasted on this exact topic.

Only if we continue to discuss it.

Which really means only if YOU continue to discuss it, I'm afraid. It's the very nature of the internet; idiots will continue to pour out of the woodwork like cockroaches in a student apartment and ask distracting, ill-posed questions. I can't control the posts others make, but I can control the posts to which I respond. And I'm doing my best not to get involved in an unproductive discussion of "authority" in general and to focus on specific authorities (such as Bowring) and specific claims (such as the idea that igneous rock can be dated accurately via radiometry, and the idea that specific rocks have been dated to ages incompatible with a "young earth."). And I'm trying my best to find specific, documented information in peer-reviewed primary sources so that you can see all the cards on the table.

But I can't control the posts to which YOU respond, either.
 
I agree, and I've said so, more than once.
How many times are we going to go through this? There's a big difference between saying "You should believe X because Sam Bowring said so", and "You should believe X because of this paper that Sam Bowring presented that shows X". The first is an argument from authority; the second is not. The second is good evidence if the paper shows X or presents evidence regarding X.
Again, we got derailed when someone asked me why I don't accept evolution simply because the scientists believe it. It is that idea, and that idea alone, that I dismiss as an unsuccessful and unproductive argument from authority; I DO NOT likewise dismiss the actual evidence presented.




Let me answer you -- for something like the fifth time, I believe. No.

I predict that at least ten more posts will be wasted on this exact topic.

Yet another post in which Avalon says that all s/he wants to do is to talk about the evidence. And yet another post in which Avalon avoids talking about the evidence. Sigh.
 
I'm not interested in appeals to the authority of the scientific community that accepts the theory of evolution as historical fact. "A whole lot of smart men believe this" does not an evidentiary argument make.
However, to briefly address the post as to my own personal opinion: it's (a), mistake, and definitely not (b), dishonesty.


To what extent does biology make common ancestry assumptions rather than simply assumptions for natural selection across a distinct population? To what extent are the processes of biology reliant on these assumptions?

That is not an "appeal to authority." It is the fact that thousands upon thousands of people, over the past century and more, have used the method to great effect and it has been proven, when used correctly, to be remarkably consistent. An appeal to authority is, "Because my pastor said it's in the Bible and I choose to believe that." You conscious choice to see it as a "mistake" is what's dishonest. It's like successfully flipping on a light switch a million times over your lifetime and then saying, "but those electrical engineers are soooo full of it." You, quite obviously, have no interest in changing your mind regarding evolution. Your pseudo-debate is silly and duplicitous and a waste of time. I'm sorry I ran across this thread.
 
Last edited:
As far as I know, evolution can never move backward. There is no way that something can become less adapted to the environment, and still survive through enough generations to keep moving backward. But I suppose it is just semantics when you say 'backward' or 'forward'
Chickens still have the gene for teeth, if the environment changed so that having teeth was again beneficial, I suppose you could say that was moving 'backward' because the chicken was going back to how it was in earlier stages in some way. But this is not really 'backward' because it is still an improvement, based on whatever environmental or selection pressure is requiring it.

Even in the case of increased numbers of elephants being born with smaller or even absent tusks due to extensive poaching for ivory, this may not be immediately seen as an improvement and may be thought as a 'backward' move, but it increases the survivability of the elephant, and that is all evolution 'cares' about.

Ah. I had actually forgotten to consider the adaptation to environment in this argument (silly, I know). Thank you for reminding me. The elephant tusk example is wonderfully illustrative of that and a good reminder that there ARE still selection pressures at play, even if it seems, at times, like the world has lost them all to our tight controls (yes, I know that's a laughable statement).

FWIW, I'm not a YEC and never was; I just don't have a complete picture of evolution myself (it wasn't in my educational track, specifically), and I'm interested in the subject. It has recently also come up in family discussions (my father has suddenly decided that the Bible is literally true), and I need the ammunition to discuss it reasonably. Thank you for helping out.
 
Just to be sure that you have understood this correctly: genetic change is not just caused by losing information. There are a number of ways that new information can be built in the genome.

Yes, I understand that, thank you. I'm abbreviating, somewhat, for the sake of the analogy, which seems to be confusing enough as it is, but I understand that the differences between two species (splits in the tree) could be due to additional or even just different DNA information appearing in the genome.

Thank you for your help!
 
That is not an "appeal to authority." It is the fact that thousands upon thousands of people, over the past century and more, have used the method to great effect and it has been proven, when used correctly, to be remarkably consistent. An appeal to authority is, "Because my pastor said it's in the Bible and I choose to believe that." You conscious choice to see it as a "mistake" is what's dishonest. It's like successfully flipping on a light switch a million times over your lifetime and then saying, "but those electrical engineers are soooo full of it." You, quite obviously, have no interest in changing your mind regarding evolution. Your pseudo-debate is silly and duplicitous and a waste of time. I'm sorry I ran across this thread.

Not helpful.
 
Are you implying that I don't understand the rudiments of logic? Should I interpret this as a personal attack?
If it was intended as a legitimate argument rather than malicious, please explain what the appropriate take-away is.

I am stating, not implying, that you gave no evidence of having a complete understanding of what "argument from authority" means, inasmuch as you didn't seem to know when it is an appropriate logical critique and when it is not. I, and several others, explained the point.

The fact that you continue to inappropriately use "argument from authority" as a logical critique after its correct application has been several times explained, strongly suggests that you still do not understand its proper usage, nor why your usage is incorrect.

The observation that your understanding of this point of logical argument is lacking is a critique of your argument, specifically of the structure of your argument. It is not an attack on your person.
 
Last edited:
Similarly, my pointing out that Dr H's usage of "it's" is incorrect in his post (it should be "its") is a statement of fact, not an attack on Dr H as a person.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom