YEC's and Evolution

I'm pretty sure that Avalon has me on ignore, but somebody should ask Avalon what other scientific fields s/he adopts this radically skeptical attitudes towards. I mean, assuming for a moment that Avalon is not the world greatest polymath (a pretty safe assumption) one must logically conclude that s/he refuses to accept the theory of relativity (can't prove it independently), refuses to accept that we live in a heliocentric solar system (bet s/he can't prove that indepedently), refuses to believe in the germ theory of disease etc. etc. etc. Heck, even Newtonian physics is, presumably, an object of similar deep skepticism.

Come to that, I'll bet Avalon cannot independently prove the antiquity of any of the sources of the Biblical texts upon which s/he relies for an explanation of the universe. I'll be s/he has not independently performed any of the tests and has not independently verified any of the bibliographical and historical researches that go to prove that the Bible was not invented in, say, 1420AD.

And yet, oddly enough, I'll also bet that Avalon is quite happy to rely upon this knowledge without putting it all under the ban of "argument from authority." For some reason it will only be when scientific results conflict with his or her particular interpretation of the bible that this radical skepticism suddenly asserts itself.

Quoted for Avalon. An excellent, excellent point.
 
The Devil's advocate tells us that in fact the flood can explain everything. The Flood was a mgaical event with water coming from outer space and disappearing into nowhere. There is no reason why this god would not also have used magic to bring all the animals to the Ark and afterwards to wherever it pleased him. He could also have used magic to fit all the animals into the tiny Ark. The Flood story is about a supernatural event, and when magic is involved, anything goes.

That is one way to justify the flood but not all YECists base their opinions on pure faith. Some try to use evidence. If a YECist falls back on miracles, then (s)he must admit their hypothesis is unfalsifiable. Unfortunately, doing so disqualifies you from all future discussion of evidence in any context because you have declared evidence irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
Re the "argument from authority." This really is one of the most misunderstood and misused of the terms used to describe logical fallacies. The argument from authority is a fallacy where there is nothing <i>but</i> the charisma associated with a particular name behind the argument. Thus "well Newton believed in God and Newton was a pretty sharp fellow, so obviously God exists" would be a classic example of the fallacious "argument from authority."

There is no such argument from authority involved, however, if I go see a famed cardiologist at the Mayo clinic and he tells me--after running a series of tests--that I'm suffering from such-and-such a disease of the heart. In this case I have every reason to think that I very probably do, in fact, suffer from that disease. This is not 100% proof, of course, but in this instance I would be a fool to shrug my shoulders and say "poof, what does he know. Just because he went to Harvard Medical School and has specialized in cardiology for 20 years and is a respected leader in the field. I know better than to fall prey to the argument from authority!!" No, my safe course of action is to presume that it is highly likely that what he told me is correct. I might seek a second opinion, of course, but that would be so as to remove any last remaining doubts, not to move from a position of complete uncertainty.

Similarly, when I accept, say, that the half life of uranium-235 is 704 million years, or that a hyena is genetically closer to a cat than a dog, or that light takes about 1.3 seconds to travel from the moon to earth (all things I have no possible way of verifying independently) I am not doing so because I think "well, scientists are respectable people, they wouldn't lie about these things, would they?" I do so because I understand the nature of the scientific institution. I know that every single "fact" in every single science textbook is potentially up for review and reexamination. I know that every young scientist entering the field dreams of making a discovery that upends conventional wisdom and is constantly thinking of ways to put generally agreed-upon findings to the test. Any findings (like those above) that pass as utterly uncontroversial for all the relevant experts in the field have passed through a withering fire of skeptical and probing testing. Does this mean that they are indisputable? No, of course not. Nothing in science is every indisputable. But does it mean that they are almost certainly true and that it is in no way a fallacious "argument from authority" to rely upon them? Yes. It is not "authority" I am relying upon here, it is the observed nature of the institution that produces and verifies these findings. It is no more irrational to rely upon the "scientific consensus" than it is to rely upon FedEx to deliver your package or to rely upon a package of Special K cornflakes not to contain dog turds. In all these cases you are relying upon the observed and well-understood operation of large institutions.

(And yes, FedEx occasionally loses a package, a large corporation will occasionally botch its quality control etc. etc. Science will occasionally embrace what later turns out to be an error; but that doesn't mean it is rational to refuse to ever use a courier or mail service, or to insist that you'll only ever eat food you've grown yourself; which is the equivalent of Avalon's stance.)
 
(And yes, FedEx occasionally loses a package, a large corporation will occasionally botch its quality control etc. etc. Science will occasionally embrace what later turns out to be an error; but that doesn't mean it is rational to refuse to ever use a courier or mail service, or to insist that you'll only ever eat food you've grown yourself; which is the equivalent of Avalon's stance.)

To be fair, it's not clear what Avalon's stance is. He has consistently denied that he must run the physical experiments himself. For example, 'I am willing to accept the data that the geologists have; I won't necessarily accept the conclusion as to what this data shows. It appears I shouldn't have made the mistake of using the term "footwork". I was talking about intellectual footwork, not physical footwork -- seeing the data and deciding for myself what it MEANS rather than assuming it means whatever somebody else says it means.'

Now, of course, this is still vague. I'm not sure how he plans to be able to interpret the data other than in the standard geophysical basis. If he accepts the standard model (i.e., the half-lives of the various isotopes are both constant over time and well-documented in the literature) -- well, that's itself a conclusion that physicists have drawn from a set of experiments they have run.

If he chooses to go that way, it's just a question of working out the algebra and checking for mistakes in the sums, and he should be able to satisfy himself in short order that the sums are correct.

If he does not accept the standard model (for example, he rejects the claim that half-lives are constant over time), he should be able to at least point out which elements of the standard model he rejects. And we can discuss whether, for example, there is any support for the idea that half-lives have been getting longer over time (which would result in isochron data yielding systematically long dates). [N.b. there is no support for that idea, but a full discussion of that would take us too far afield at this point.]

If he doesn't accept the standard model but can't isolate the reasons that he doesn't accept them, then I think he will have retrospectively justified all the criticism that has been heaped upon him in this thread, and much more besides.
 
Well, in Avalon's defense, things like the above, whether true or not, only serve to bring the discussion down.

I mean, if someone posted something like that in response to me, I would certainly feel insulted by it.

And personally, I think that we have so few YECs on here, I'd prefer that they were given the benefit of the doubt so we could see how they respond to actual arguments.

I think that's unfair. It wasn't meant as an insult. It was also explained elsewhere. It was a valid comment that I didn't think posting more links to more evidence was going to help here.

It seems that a number of people here feel that all anti-evolutionists need is good evidence and that will change their mind, if only you can show them a solid scientific paper or some experimental evidence.

It my experience that doesn't work. It probably work on me either.

Avalon's initial post showed that he had an issue with the whole fundamental concept of scientific evidence. I assumed he had already seen 'good' evidence of evolution and rejected it. Not because the evidence wasn't strong enough scientifically but because that wasn't what he was looking for.

My statement was intended to provoke thought around alternative methods of convincing Avalon; not around insult.

In that light I find your comments a bit uncalled for.
 
This was the post where the thread got off track -- where we stopped talking about the actual evidence, and started talking about the trustworthiness of academics. To quote my favorite Marion Zimmer Bradley novel, "This question neither interests us nor has meaning."
And since then, I've been spending so much energy defending myself from accusations of ignorance and hypocrisy, the good arguments ABOUT THE EVIDENCE being made started getting lost in the fray.
This is my last post on this subject. If I post here again, it will be to talk about the evidence. Any post on any other subject I will quote, label, and not respond.

Sorry the discussion was distinctly NOT about the trustworthiness of academics it was about you questioning your own thought process and how you have arrived at the conclusions you did.

You then started huffing and puffing about argument from authority and took it off on a totally different track.

Your argument basically amounted to 'I think science has got this wrong' without a shred of argument or evidence in support of that assertion.

You then chickened out of the discussion when the going got tough citing imaginary insults when, if you read the actual thread, you will see people going out of their way to be polite to you.
 
A raw assertion that "this is what scientists believe, and so you should too" is an appeal to authority.

Nobody made that assertion. The only place that assertion even exists is in your posts.

As for your demand for evidence, I believe you agreed with me when I stated that no amount of evidence would help you.
 
Sorry the discussion was distinctly NOT about the trustworthiness of academics it was about you questioning your own thought process and how you have arrived at the conclusions you did.

You then started huffing and puffing about argument from authority and took it off on a totally different track.

Your argument basically amounted to 'I think science has got this wrong' without a shred of argument or evidence in support of that assertion.

You then chickened out of the discussion when the going got tough citing imaginary insults when, if you read the actual thread, you will see people going out of their way to be polite to you.

I'm sorry that you feel that way. Thank you for your comments and posts in this thread.
 
Now, of course, this is still vague. I'm not sure how he plans to be able to interpret the data other than in the standard geophysical basis. If he accepts the standard model (i.e., the half-lives of the various isotopes are both constant over time and well-documented in the literature) -- well, that's itself a conclusion that physicists have drawn from a set of experiments they have run.

I do accept the standard model of radioactive decay. I think where the disagreement will set in, if I have one, will be over the nature and clarity of the starting event. Isochron dating (which, as I understand it, is the procedure of using multiple decay rates to establish and confirm age) will certainly be helpful in that regard.
 
Avalon, can you be a bit clearer here. Do you mean that you accept the ages derived from igneous rocks? I have a feeling that you don't. And if you don't why not?
 
I do accept the standard model of radioactive decay. I think where the disagreement will set in, if I have one, will be over the nature and clarity of the starting event. Isochron dating (which, as I understand it, is the procedure of using multiple decay rates to establish and confirm age) will certainly be helpful in that regard.

Perhaps I can be more helpful, then, in light of this.

Isochron dating is not so much using multiple decay rates, but multiple measurements of decay.

Essentially, you measure three different quantities. I'll use Rb/Sr for an example. It is well understood that Rb-87 decays to Sr-87, but not to Sr-86. In standard notation, Rb-87 is the parent (P), Sr-87 is the daughter (D), and Sr-86 is a non-radiogenic isotope of the daughter (Di).

Since D and Di are the same chemical element, they have identical chemical composition; when the rock crystallizes, any compound containing strontium will have the same ratio of D/Di. The exact ratio doesn't matter, just that it's the same for all compounds. Since rubidium is a different element than strontium, it will form different compounds and at different proportions than strontium, so measuring different types of crystals will give us different ratios for P/Di.

If we plot P/Di on the X axis and D/Di on the Y axis, we get a horizontal line. Why? Because D/Di is constant and any value with constant Y is a horizontal line.

Now, let's wait some time. During that time, some of the rubidium will decay, producing strontium-87 (but not strontium-86). However, since the rock has remained solid all this time, the new strontium will still be trapped where the old rubidium was. This means that the concentration of rubidium will decrease, the concentration of strontium-86 will stay the same, and the concentration of strontium-87 will increase. Because of this, the ratio P/Di will decrease and the ratio D/Di will increase.

If we re-plot the points, we'll therefore see that all of them will shift up and to the left -- up, because D/Di increased, and to the left, because P/Di decreased.

But -- and here is the key point -- the amount of the shift is directly proportional to the amount of P that decayed, which in turn is directly proportional to the amount of P originally present in the sample. That's what "half-life" means. In one "half-life" of P, half of the rubidium will have turned into strontium. If there was a lot of rubidium, half of "a lot" will have decayed and the point will have shifted "a lot." If there was "only a little bit", half of "only a little bit" will have decayed and the point will have shifted "only a little bit."

Since the points were originally collinear, they will remain collinear as they shift. The line will rotate, but not bend.

And the more time passes, the more rotation will occurred. Specifically, after N half-lives, we expect to see the new line have a slope (rise/run) of N.

Suppose we get a slope of 0.10 +/- 0.001. Because the half-life of Rb-87 is about 50 billion years, this means that the rock is 5 billion years from crystallization, plus or minus 0.001 half-lives, or 50 million years. In other words, the rock is somewhere between 5,005,000,000 and 4,995,000,000 years old. Of course, most rocks wouldn't be this old, but you get the idea.

One of the strengths of isochron dating is that we can use other methods. We can use rubidium and strontium, but we can also use potassium and argon, uranium and lead, rhenium and osmium, and so forth.

And if we do all four of those methods, and all four agree that the rock is about 5 billion years old, that's pretty conclusive, yes?
 
I find that to be a very good explanation of how radioactive decay rates can be used to show the age of rocks. (Incidentally, I do have the educational background to understand radioactive decay, extrapolation from exponential rates, etc.)
So, lets see if I understand the process here. We take a hundred samples from a certain rock layer; we assume the crystals were formed contemporaneously. For each crystal, we measure three quantities: the amount of the decaying parent, the amount of the decayed daughter resulting from the parent's decay, and another isotope of the same element as the daugher that the parent does not decay into.
We normalize the amount of parent and daugher in each sample according to the amount of the non-radiogenic isotope, then we examine the ratio of parent to daughter remaining. We expect that the normalized ratio will be consistent across the samples (forming a straight line when plotted against each other), and can calculate the amount of time since the crystals formed by comparing the ratio to the rate of parent decay.
Is that right?
 
Last edited:
So, lets see if I understand the process here. We take a hundred samples from a certain rock layer; we assume the crystals were formed contemporaneously. For each crystal, we measure three quantities: the amount of the decaying parent, the amount of the decayed daughter resulting from the parent's decay, and another isotope of the same element as the daugher that the parent does not decay into.

Not quite. We measure the amount of the decayed daughter that corresponds to the end product of the parent's decay chain. We do not distinguish between atoms that are actually the product of parental decay and atoms that were present at the original crystallization; if we need do, we can figure out that number later from the results of the experiment.

One of the key benefits of this approach is that we do not need to assume (as we would with more straightforward calculations) that the amount of the radiogenic daughter isotope is initially zero.

Depending upon the structure of the crystals, we may also be able to extract multiple samples (of multiple compounds) from each crystal. The whole point is to have a collection of different contemporaneously-formed chemical compounds with a different amount of parent-element trapped in each.

We normalize the amount of parent and daugher in each sample according to the amount of the non-radiogenic isotope, then we examine the ratio of parent to daughter remaining. We expect that the normalized ratio will be consistent across the samples (forming a straight line when plotted against each other), and can calculate the amount of time since the crystals formed by comparing the ratio formed to the rate of parent decay.
Is that right?

Sort of. We don't examine the ratio of parent to daughter, but the ratio of parent to non-radiogenic daughter, and the ratio of radiogenic to non-radiogenic daughter. This gives us the necessary two "observations" per sample so we can plot it in two-space.

Your understanding, though, is largely correct.
 
Not quite. We measure the amount of the decayed daughter that corresponds to the end product of the parent's decay chain. We do not distinguish between atoms that are actually the product of parental decay and atoms that were present at the original crystallization; if we need do, we can figure out that number later from the results of the experiment.

One of the key benefits of this approach is that we do not need to assume (as we would with more straightforward calculations) that the amount of the radiogenic daughter isotope is initially zero.

Depending upon the structure of the crystals, we may also be able to extract multiple samples (of multiple compounds) from each crystal. The whole point is to have a collection of different contemporaneously-formed chemical compounds with a different amount of parent-element trapped in each.



Sort of. We don't examine the ratio of parent to daughter, but the ratio of parent to non-radiogenic daughter, and the ratio of radiogenic to non-radiogenic daughter. This gives us the necessary two "observations" per sample so we can plot it in two-space.

... and after we plot it in two-space, we're going to do a linear regression to arrive at a slope, which is the actual number we use to calculate the age, correct? Isn't this equivalent to the direct ratio between amount of the parent isotope and amount of the daughter isotope present? What prevents the non-radiogenic daughter from cancelling out in the regression?

EDIT: No, it's not, because of the offset from zero. Okay, now that makes sense. Man, it's been too long since I've done any sort of statistical regression.
 
Last edited:
... and after we plot it in two-space, we're going to do a linear regression to arrive at a slope, which is the actual number we use to calculate the age, correct? Isn't this equivalent to the direct ratio between amount of the parent isotope and amount of the daughter isotope present? What prevents the non-radiogenic daughter from cancelling out in the regression?

EDIT: No, it's not, because of the offset from zero. Okay, now that makes sense. Man, it's been too long since I've done any sort of statistical regression.

Exactly. And it's the offset from zero that makes the linearity practical, because we can treat property for the initial conditions: the amount of radiogenic daughter isotope present already at crystallization.
 
Dr. K: Essentially, you measure three different quantities. I'll use Rb/Sr for an example. It is well understood that Rb-87 decays to Sr-87, but not to Sr-86. In standard notation, Rb-87 is the parent (P), Sr-87 is the daughter (D), and Sr-86 is a non-radiogenic isotope of the daughter (Di).

Do they use a scintillation counter scheme of some sort, or is there a newer system for these measurements?
 
Do they use a scintillation counter scheme of some sort, or is there a newer system for these measurements?

My understanding is that the typical equipment is a type of mass spectrometer (crystals aren't typically big enough to make scintillation counters practical). But I'd also not be surprised to learn that there are several different experimental setups that are in use; the equipment to do this is unfortunately complex and expensive, which is why isochron dating isn't typically done in high school geology class.
 
My understanding is that the typical equipment is a type of mass spectrometer (crystals aren't typically big enough to make scintillation counters practical). But I'd also not be surprised to learn that there are several different experimental setups that are in use; the equipment to do this is unfortunately complex and expensive, which is why isochron dating isn't typically done in high school geology class.

Or even in an undergrad college geology class. If you were doing some work for your masters or doctorate you might actually get to use the equipment. Otherwise it is all theory. But then again they don't let too many physics students at colliders either. The theory is sound whether you get to do the work or not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom