I do accept the standard model of radioactive decay. I think where the disagreement will set in, if I have one, will be over the nature and clarity of the starting event. Isochron dating (which, as I understand it, is the procedure of using multiple decay rates to establish and confirm age) will certainly be helpful in that regard.
Perhaps I can be more helpful, then, in light of this.
Isochron dating is not so much using multiple
decay rates, but multiple measurements of decay.
Essentially, you measure three different quantities. I'll use Rb/Sr for an example. It is well understood that Rb-87 decays to Sr-87, but not to Sr-86. In standard notation, Rb-87 is the
parent (P), Sr-87 is the
daughter (D), and Sr-86 is a non-radiogenic isotope of the daughter (Di).
Since D and Di are the same chemical element, they have identical chemical composition; when the rock crystallizes, any compound containing strontium will have the same ratio of D/Di. The exact ratio doesn't matter, just that it's the same for all compounds. Since rubidium is a different element than strontium, it will form different compounds and at different proportions than strontium, so measuring different types of crystals will give us different ratios for P/Di.
If we plot P/Di on the X axis and D/Di on the Y axis, we get a horizontal line. Why? Because D/Di is constant and any value with constant Y is a horizontal line.
Now, let's wait some time. During that time, some of the rubidium will decay, producing strontium-87 (but not strontium-86). However, since the rock has remained solid all this time, the new strontium will still be trapped where the old rubidium was. This means that the concentration of rubidium will decrease, the concentration of strontium-86 will stay the same, and the concentration of strontium-87 will
increase. Because of this, the ratio P/Di will
decrease and the ratio D/Di will
increase.
If we re-plot the points, we'll therefore see that all of them will shift up and to the left -- up, because D/Di increased, and to the left, because P/Di decreased.
But --
and here is the key point -- the amount of the shift is directly proportional to the amount of P that decayed, which in turn is directly proportional to the amount of P originally present in the sample. That's what "half-life" means. In one "half-life" of P, half of the rubidium will have turned into strontium. If there was a lot of rubidium, half of "a lot" will have decayed and the point will have shifted "a lot." If there was "only a little bit", half of "only a little bit" will have decayed and the point will have shifted "only a little bit."
Since the points were originally collinear, they will remain collinear as they shift. The line will rotate, but not bend.
And the more time passes, the more rotation will occurred. Specifically, after N half-lives, we expect to see the new line have a slope (rise/run) of N.
Suppose we get a slope of 0.10 +/- 0.001. Because the half-life of Rb-87 is about 50 billion years, this means that the rock is 5 billion years from crystallization, plus or minus 0.001 half-lives, or 50 million years. In other words, the rock is somewhere between 5,005,000,000 and 4,995,000,000 years old. Of course, most rocks wouldn't be this old, but you get the idea.
One of the strengths of isochron dating is that we can use other methods. We can use rubidium and strontium, but we can also use potassium and argon, uranium and lead, rhenium and osmium, and so forth.
And if we do all four of those methods, and all four agree that the rock is about 5 billion years old, that's pretty conclusive, yes?