YEC's and Evolution

Let's try another tack at the same time.

This was the post where the thread got off track -- where we stopped talking about the actual evidence, and started talking about the trustworthiness of academics. To quote my favorite Marion Zimmer Bradley novel, "This question neither interests us nor has meaning."
And since then, I've been spending so much energy defending myself from accusations of ignorance and hypocrisy, the good arguments ABOUT THE EVIDENCE being made started getting lost in the fray.
This is my last post on this subject. If I post here again, it will be to talk about the evidence. Any post on any other subject I will quote, label, and not respond.
 
Last edited:
This was the post where the thread got off track -- where we stopped talking about the actual evidence, and started talking about the trustworthiness of academics. To quote my favorite Marion Zimmer Bradley novel, "This question neither interests us nor has meaning."

But that quote does in no way match what you said and demanded. It was your very own demand to show evidence far beyond of what is possible, and far beyond of what many academics have already provided. You denied the existing evidence that the very same academics have collected and referred to it as "appeal to authority".

So, yes, that question is of interest, and it has indeed a meaning. Because if someone would bring up evidence, and another person would refer you to that evidence, it would be automatically voided by your standard, because it would be said appeal to authority in your opinion.

And again: How does "The bible says so, and the people studying the bible say so too", but without any evidence at all, not account as such an appeal to authority, while actual existing evidence for evolution, collected by a large body of scientists, does?
 
The problem is, it jsut happened the standard way I see YEC doing thread discussion on evolution. Pray tell me how this one diverged from it :

* make a bold statement asking for evidence but put a high enough standard that nothing short of divine intervention would fullfil it (example : require a complete chain of evidence going from a very ancient common specy to a very different descendant , aka proto shrew to cow).
* IGNORE all the good post and link, then instead concentrate on the petty or shallow post (no offense meant to the posters)
* Say that you were insulted. It does not matter whether it is true or not, it is enough to state it. Some forum member will anyway say "yes , it might be construed as insult" (that is where you come in)
* say you will think about what you were linked / posted to. Either : 1) never come back or 2) ignore all evidence and just state the evidence are not enough

I have yet to see a YEC - evolution debate end otherwise.

Then please leave, and let the rest of us engage in this futility (to you) in peace. If you're right, you won't have wasted your time. If you're wrong, then you will have avoided making your situation a self-fulfilling prophecy by adding to the level of attacks.
Again, if you don't want to talk about evolution and the evidence, please don't hang around to talk about how disingenuous I am. It's not helping.
 
But that quote does in no way match what you said and demanded. It was your very own demand to show evidence far beyond of what is possible, and far beyond of what many academics have already provided. You denied the existing evidence that the very same academics have collected and referred to it as "appeal to authority".

Incorrect. I never dismissed a single shred of evidence, or confused a citation of evidence with an appeal to authority. If something I posted was understood to mean that, then that was a misunderstanding.
A raw assertion that "this is what scientists believe, and so you should too" is an appeal to authority. A link to a paper discussing evidence or observations is not an appeal to authority.
Again, I consider this issue closed as irrelevant. I have some reading to do.
 
Of course, you're assuming that at least part of the reason Avalon didn't respond actually had something (at least in part) with the supposed poor treatment he received. Frankly, its quite likely that DrKitten's questions were going to be ignored anyways. His 'avoidence' goes all the way back to the first page of the thread, long before people started being mean.

Heck, I myself would love to have seen him answer some of the questions. I just don't hold much hope of that happening.

Just to give another example on the attack of my motives that contributes to neither the evidence nor anyone's interpretation of it. Stop it, please.
 
This was the post where the thread got off track -- where we stopped talking about the actual evidence, and started talking about the trustworthiness of academics. To quote my favorite Marion Zimmer Bradley novel, "This question neither interests us nor has meaning."

The only problem is that it's not at all off-track.

Questions of credibility are key for studying any kind of evidence : eyewitness, physical, scientific, whatever. Credibility is one of the reasons that IQ studies are so controversial, precisely because some of the early pioneers of IQ studies have been shown to have actively falsified data, which makes many of the fundamentals of the field questionable propositions at best. Credibility is also one of the reasons that there's such a flap about the practice of drug companies "ghost-writing" articles for medical journals.

Let's go back to one of the early articles I cited : Bowring, S.A., and Williams, I.S. (1999).

In this article, Dr. Bowring claims to have actively held in his hand a sample of a rock that is much, much older than any possible "young earth" could have produced.

This is a prima facie disproof of Young Earth Creationism; if his claim is true, YEC cannot be correct. In order to continue to believe (rationally) in YEC, you must therefore reject Dr. Bowring's claim.

Why?

Do you believe him to be incompetent?
Do you believe him to be misinformed?
Do you believe him to be actively lying?

Why does his rock sample appear to be multiple billions of years old, when it is in fact less than 10,000 years old?
 
Avalon,

I haven't read all of this thread so I assume this link has been brought up already but I'll post it again anyway. I recommend this section in particular.

Out of curiousity, what are your beliefs involving Noah's flood?
 
Avalon,

I haven't read all of this thread so I assume this link has been brought up already but I'll post it again anyway. I recommend this section in particular.

Out of curiousity, what are your beliefs involving Noah's flood?

TalkOrigins is a great resource; thank you for highlighting it again.

I believe that Noah's flood happens as described in Genesis. Evidence that a worldwide flood is geologically or physically unreasonable, or other problems with the flood story, would be of great interest to me -- but I'm not sure how it fits into the evolution discussion.
 
The only problem is that it's not at all off-track.

I say it is. And whether or not is ACTUALLY is? I'm not interested in discussing it.
As I said before, I'm quite happy to accept that the papers are an accurate account of what the scientists saw or the measurements they took (no deceit). I'm not willing to accept their conclusions unless I can do the footwork myself to understand them (I don't trust them to think for me). You can make a hundred posts CONVINCING me to accept the scientists' conclusions, because they're much smarter than me or they know more; I'm not interested.
Can we PLEASE get away from this?
 
I say it is. And whether or not is ACTUALLY is? I'm not interested in discussing it.
As I said before, I'm quite happy to accept that the papers are an accurate account of what the scientists saw or the measurements they took (no deceit). I'm not willing to accept their conclusions unless I can do the footwork myself to understand them (I don't trust them to think for me). You can make a hundred posts CONVINCING me to accept the scientists' conclusions, because they're much smarter than me or they know more; I'm not interested.
Can we PLEASE get away from this?

I don't think we can. It seems - and correct me if I'm wrong - that to achieve the evidence you will accept you will need to repeat, from scratch and with your own hands, the experiments that underpin geology and evolutionary biology. Sure, we can give you the papers - indeed, many already have, and Dr Kitten cited another one in the post you quoted only in part - but you can use the same form of objection to reject their methodology as you do their conclusions.

That's the point Dr K was making regarding credibility. If you don't trust their conclusions, on what basis can you logically and rationally trust their methodologies, or data sets? How, other than doing the experiments yourself (all the experiments, from working out whether atoms are radioactive all the way up), can you ever avoid someone else - an authority, no less - from "doing the footwork"?
 
Incorrect. I never dismissed a single shred of evidence, or confused a citation of evidence with an appeal to authority. If something I posted was understood to mean that, then that was a misunderstanding.

You think so? I could easily compose a post full of quotes of your posts that will show that. However, giving you the benefit of doubt, you may not have made yourself clear as to what your real intentions are and as such might be an misunderstanding.

A raw assertion that "this is what scientists believe, and so you should too" is an appeal to authority. A link to a paper discussing evidence or observations is not an appeal to authority.
Again, I consider this issue closed as irrelevant. I have some reading to do.

The raw assertion that creation and/or YEC is true because that is what some people believe, and so should we, is pretty much also an appeal to authority.

You have repeatedly made posts in which you stated that "evolutionists" are making errors because, well, basically because they have been teached what is known about evolution and base their statements and conclusions on that. You then complained that they "appeal to authority".

Tell me, where do you learn things from, if not from an authority on the topic that you want to learn? You simply misuse the "appeal to authority" fallacy, thats all. You simply can not complain about that, while doing it yourself. Either refrain from doing so, or live with the fact that people will constantly point that out to you. As said, such things work both ways.

Greetings,

Chris

Edit: As to you assertions that evolution can only make small changes, but you deem it impossible to make big changes over time. Imagine a vertical line. You have billions of billions of iterations available. With each iteration you are allowed to rotate the line around any point you want, but only by a maximum of 0.5 degrees.

Now, tell us, at what point there is a big change in the position of the line, lets say a rotation by 90 degrees? Why do you think it is not possible to reach such a big change by simply repeating many, many small changes?

Add a "degree of freedom" and lets allow the line to be bent at any position on that line during each iteration, but again only by a tiny angle. This will now allow you to get an triangle, a rectangle, or any other polygon out of that single line, over time, given enough iterations.

Now add a nice thing to that: With each iteration, you actually duplicate the original, and can do different modifications to all of them in the next iteration, but still only by a very small amount.

All of a sudden you end up with a vast number of things that you can manipulate, practically speeding up the whole process. Yes, most of the iterations will lead to anything, but not to a triangle, for example. But the more iterations you do, the higher the chances that you will get one. The more material you have to do that with, the faster you will come to that chance.
 
Last edited:
The raw assertion that creation and/or YEC is true because that is what some people believe, and so should we, is pretty much also an appeal to authority.

Yes, it is. It's an appeal to authority, and if you don't trust that authority, then it's a bad argument.
On the other hand, linking to articles written by YEC people explaining WHY they believe YEC, and from what EVIDENCE would be a good argument.
There's a difference between these two.
 
I say it is. And whether or not is ACTUALLY is? I'm not interested in discussing it.
As I said before, I'm quite happy to accept that the papers are an accurate account of what the scientists saw or the measurements they took (no deceit). I'm not willing to accept their conclusions unless I can do the footwork myself to understand them (I don't trust them to think for me). You can make a hundred posts CONVINCING me to accept the scientists' conclusions, because they're much smarter than me or they know more; I'm not interested.
Can we PLEASE get away from this?

Obviously, part of the discussion of evidence for evolution must involve disproving the idea of YEC. Therefore, you state that you are willing to accept the accuracy of the measurements that geologists present regarding the age of rocks on our planet.

However, you then state that you will not accept the conclusion that these reported measurements disprove young Earth creationism without doing the footwork yourself. Is this an accurate summary of your position?

If this is the case, then I am interested... what are your plans on doing the footwork yourself? If you are presented with scientific articles that provide geological evidence that rocks are much much older than YEC would allow, do you then plan to devote yourself to an education in geology? Do you plan on actually learning to perform the measurements yourself?

I'm not trying to state this as an insult, but this is very related to whether or not this discussion can possibly be intellectually honest from both sides. If you first state that you are not interested in article after article of scientific measurements unless you can do the footwork yourself... but then have actually no plan to pursue the education and resources necessary to perform that footwork... then wouldn't this just be a dishonest waste of the work and time other posters are providing in order to link you the evidence you requested?

I hope that we can all have intellectual honesty from both sides in this discussion. However, if you have absolutely no intent on actually pursuing the necessary steps in order to do the footwork that you state that you require, then it would be more honest of you to let people know now. Wasting their time further would not seem very ethical.

However, if you are interested in pursuing the education and experimentation to perform these experiments and measurements yourself, then that would probably encourage a lot of honest discussion. You would likely receive a great deal of advice on how to start, and this conversation would most certainly take a much more productive tone.
 
I don't think we can. It seems - and correct me if I'm wrong - that to achieve the evidence you will accept you will need to repeat, from scratch and with your own hands, the experiments that underpin geology and evolutionary biology. Sure, we can give you the papers - indeed, many already have, and Dr Kitten cited another one in the post you quoted only in part - but you can use the same form of objection to reject their methodology as you do their conclusions.

That's the point Dr K was making regarding credibility. If you don't trust their conclusions, on what basis can you logically and rationally trust their methodologies, or data sets? How, other than doing the experiments yourself (all the experiments, from working out whether atoms are radioactive all the way up), can you ever avoid someone else - an authority, no less - from "doing the footwork"?

This is a reasonable criticism, but I think at this point it's still speculative. I don't expect that I'm going to have any issue with their data sets; I don't expect I'm going to need to re-do the experiments they've done. But, I agree, the possibility exists; if you insist that that's what will happen, then I'd recommend going elsewhere. Again, accusing me of it a priori is just poisoning the well.
 
Obviously, part of the discussion of evidence for evolution must involve disproving the idea of YEC. Therefore, you state that you are willing to accept the accuracy of the measurements that geologists present regarding the age of rocks on our planet.

However, you then state that you will not accept the conclusion that these reported measurements disprove young Earth creationism without doing the footwork yourself. Is this an accurate summary of your position?

I don't think it is.
I am willing to accept the data that the geologists have; I won't necessarily accept the conclusion as to what this data shows.
It appears I shouldn't have made the mistake of using the term "footwork". I was talking about intellectual footwork, not physical footwork -- seeing the data and deciding for myself what it MEANS rather than assuming it means whatever somebody else says it means.
Hence, I'm very interested in the articles that have been provided here, and their presented data.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it is.
I am willing to accept the data that the geologists have; I won't necessarily accept the conclusion as to what this data shows.
It appears I shouldn't have made the mistake of using the term "footwork". I was talking about intellectual footwork, not physical footwork -- seeing the data and deciding for myself what it MEANS rather than assuming it means whatever somebody else says it means.
Hence, I'm very interested in the articles that have been provided here, and their presented data.

But is it then unreasonable to expect that one may need an education in geology to accurately interpret the measurements provided by geological experimentation?

I'll be the first to admit: I'm not terribly knowledgeable about geology. Therefore, it I'm presented with the raw data from the measurements, I may not have the education to actually make an informed conclusion. Therefore, I either need to rely upon those who actually are educated in geology... or I must commit myself to gaining that education myself.

Since you do not wish to rely upon the conclusions of those who have an extensive education in geology, are you planning on pursuing this education yourself in order to draw your own conclusions?
 
I say it is.

Uh-huh. And why should we accept YOUR unsupported word?

And whether or not is ACTUALLY is? I'm not interested in discussing it.

In other words, you admit that you're not actually interested in participating in this discussion; it has nothing to do with the "poor treatment" and the "nastiness" involved.

The reason you're being accused of disingenuousness is because you're being disingenuous.

You've been presented with evidence. You've failed to respond to the evidence.

People have noticed that you've failed to respond to the evidence. For some reason, you're willing to respond to that notice, but not to the evidence itself.

... and you wonder why people are now considering your behavior to be dishonest.

So, no, I don't think we can get away from this. This is a fundamental question. Why kind of evidence will you accept? If you accept the observations I've cited, but reject the conclusions, presumably you have some basis for doing so. But given that you've admitted both that you're cannot run the tests yourself (post #27), but that you will not accept the conclusions unless you can run the tests yourself (post #230).

Simple predicate logic shows that this is equivalent to an a priori rejection of all evidence presented.
 
This is a reasonable criticism, but I think at this point it's still speculative. I don't expect that I'm going to have any issue with their data sets; I don't expect I'm going to need to re-do the experiments they've done. But, I agree, the possibility exists; if you insist that that's what will happen, then I'd recommend going elsewhere. Again, accusing me of it a priori is just poisoning the well.

I'm not "accusing" you of anything; I'm just trying to work out exactly what it would take to satisfy you, in your own mind, that YEC is an erroneous belief. My questions were quite legitimate - if you doubt the conclusions, on what logical basis can you not doubt the methodologies, or the datasets?

I'm sure you know that there are literally millions of articles, across fields as diverse as anthropology, archaeology, astrophysics, molecular biology and even linguistics which run counter to the YEC hypothesis. You doubt every single one of these author's (replicable, repeatable, checkable) conclusions but you do not doubt their methods or their data? I just don't understand on what basis you can make that claim.

Maybe we could focus on Dr Kitten's rock. That seems to be a sensible, small-scale and easy-to-focus-on example of the type of issues your YEC position faces. If you accept the data - that is, you accept the radiocarbon and other data which show an age older than YEC would allow - on what basis can you discard the conclusions?

See what I mean? It's simply not logically coherent to handwave all conclusions because you haven't done the footwork yourself, but at the same time to accept the data and methodologies and centuries of prior experiments upon which those conclusions are based. If you want to "do the footwork" on this rock, you're right back to questioning the validity of radiocarbon dating, which means you're going to have to go right back to first principles and get yourself a degree in nuclear physics, repeating as you go the experiments of Rutherford, Curie and the rest. Hell, you may even need to go back to the 18th century experiments establishing the atomic structure of matter. I mean - how far down the rabbit hole do you want to go?
 
Last edited:
Uh-huh. And why should we accept YOUR unsupported word?



In other words, you admit that you're not actually interested in participating in this discussion; it has nothing to do with the "poor treatment" and the "nastiness" involved.
I'm unwilling to get into a discussion ABOUT WHY I DON'T ACCEPT SCIENTIST'S CONCLUSIONS AT THEIR WORD. I'm happy to talk about the evidence.

You've been presented with evidence. You've failed to respond to the evidence.
I haven't yet had the time to STUDY the evidence! Firing off a link takes how many seconds? Wading through an actual study to understand it (especially when it's outside my areas of expertise, which as I've acknowledged before are not biology or geology) takes a lot longer. If you want to call the discussion done because you're impatient with me, that's your right, but disingenuous I have not been.

If you accept the observations I've cited, but reject the conclusions, presumably you have some basis for doing so. But given that you've admitted both that you're cannot run the tests yourself (post #27), but that you will not accept the conclusions unless you can run the tests yourself (post #230).
I didn't say that. Like I said, I think people are misinterpreting the term "footwork" in post #230; in context, it should be clear that I haven't claimed I need to collect the data myself but have instead consistently indicated the opposite.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom