Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

The people who own the stock think those executives are worth it. Those major investors are greedy, you would think if they would be richer if they cut CEO pay then they would.

nope.

Groups who control large amount of stocks might, but the individual shareholder doesn't. Mutual funds will support big-ticket bosses because it is pretty much the only thing they can control and they want to be able to tell their investors that they've picked "only the best", something which basically can not be measured: most CEOs don't work long enough to tell whether their policies have a net positive effect. They only observable effect is stock market value.

We do have enough data to tell that there is at best no correction between CEO pay and the success of a company, with the occasional inverse relation.

But big investors don't care, because a million or ten extra for one person is negligible compared to a slight pay-rise for all employees, even if the latter would have a much larger positive effect.
 
I think you have. I have neither the time nor the inclination to prove it to you, but things are seldom as simple as they seem and this instance is no different.

That is a shame. Because I have the inclination to correct your corrections.
 
That is a shame. Because I have the inclination to correct your corrections.

Are we going for an infinite regression here? :)

Anyway, it seems I have been saved from metaphorically banging my head against a brick wall by post 622 wherein The Great Zaganza outlines the issues.
 
Last edited:
Making sure it "works" is not a legitimate government function.

on the contrary: it is the central government function.

Every time the state stays out of market, they either collapse or turn criminal (or both).
There isn't a single historical example of a market working in the absence of a government-enforced system of laws.
 
Mutual funds will support big-ticket bosses because it is pretty much the only thing they can control and they want to be able to tell their investors that they've picked "only the best", something which basically can not be measured:

What you described is how CEO pay is valuable to the people that determine CEO pay. Notice I never said stock price but just "worth it".

This week I read an article about a ham cutter that makes 4,000 a night rather than the average 250. He is worth it.
 
That's a pretty incredible statement. How do you define when a market is "working"?



One of the benefits of the free market economy over, say, old style,. Russian top-down economics is that it puts bread in the shops and on the tables of people that need bread.

Now, if we see that there are those that don't have bread we can say that the market isn't working.
 
What you described is how CEO pay is valuable to the people that determine CEO pay.

CEO’s actually have zero incentive to act in the long term best interest of shareholders. In fact they typically receive a strong incentive for immediate results even at the expense of long term company health.
 
CEO’s actually have zero incentive to act in the long term best interest of shareholders. In fact they typically receive a strong incentive for immediate results even at the expense of long term company health.

Which would make no sense. But in that post I replied to, he described a prestige value. The owners seem to trade stock value for reputation because of that value.

A rational decision.
 
That's a pretty incredible statement. How do you define when a market is "working"?

For a market to work, buyer and seller have to be able to make deals without coercion. They also must be assured that their property, be it wealth or goods, will be protected from theft/robbery before, during and after the transaction.

This doesn't work without property laws and law enforcements.

Even ancient bazaars and black markets have some sort of regulation and enforcement, even if informal.


In the few cases that anthropologists have studied when different, possibly hostile, tribes trade with each other, the exchange is highly ritualized and never happens without some display of power on both sides.
 
One of the benefits of the free market economy over, say, old style,. Russian top-down economics is that it puts bread in the shops and on the tables of people that need bread.

Now, if we see that there are those that don't have bread we can say that the market isn't working.

Bread is a pretty low bar, maybe. Americans are used to the government protecting more, like the safety of their food and drugs and water, the defense of their home's title, their right to a day in court if they're wronged. Will they be satisfied if the economy gets so crappy they can only be sure about bread?

I have relatives in Eastern Europe, and visited them from time to time since I was a teenager. So: before and after the dissolution of the Communist regimes there. Specifically, Lithuania, Russia, and Yugoslavia. My employer also sends me to Romania frequently, but I hadn't visited there until recently.

I would say their current free market system works about as badly at providing a standard of living there as the Communist one. They don't have a free market, precisely because there's no reliable protection of property rights, and too many ordinary transactions involve coercion.

Just as an example, whenever I visit relatives in St. Petersburg, I'm asked to bring over the counter pharmaceuticals. Tylenol is a big one. Why? Because practically everything on the shelf is counterfeit, and the police don't care. In a market where you're not sure you'll get what you paid for, and you can't seek compensation through a court system... you just stop buying stuff. Their economy is going to be sluggish and depressed until the government at least starts taking care of protecting property rights.

Caveat Emptor cripples trade.
 
Well, if they're competing against others paying the same tax rate then the tax take makes no difference as it affects all parties equally.

You're missing the point. It's changing the balance between the incentive to make more money and the incentive to spend it, or at least indulge in leisure. I was just rebutting your claim that the uber-rich have little incentive to make more money because they have enough already. In my experience, that's not remotely true. I've watched a billionaire kick a garbage can across the room in anger because of a $50,000 trading mistake.

Even disregarding this, there's still an upper limit on how many effective hours one person can work in a week.

Few people are anywhere near that limit. There is actually quite a lot of idleness in the world, and humans are becoming more idle with each passing year because of increasing standards of living and more government involvement in their lives. Not necessarily a bad thing, but it does mean that progress will be slower than it ordinarily would be if there weren't a tax on productivity.
 
There is no need for government to try and centrally manage production vs consumption, markets work this out on their own.

In a fiat currency system, the government must decide how much money (i.e. net financial wealth) there is. Too little, and we have insufficient aggregate demand and growth and unfulfilled savings desire. Too much, and we have inflation. The government doesn't need to get into the weeds of production or consumption as if it were a socialist hellhole. But it does need to cut taxes or increase spending during a recession and raise taxes or cut spending when there is inflation. It's not exactly rocket surgery, although few people in power seem to understand such a simple concept.

Tax cuts don’t put money into the economy they change the distribution of wealth within an economy.

Utterly false. Tax cuts increase net financial wealth, as does government spending. Net financial wealth can only come from the government. The increase each year is precisely equal to the federal budget deficit. By definition.

Deficit spending, either from tax cuts or spending increases can stimulate demand for a time, but in a positive inflation environment fiscal policy plays second fiddle to monetary policy and the Fed. In fact at times if you stimulate demand by cutting taxes, the Fed may regularly be called on to stomp out these demand increases because they create inflation.

No, monetary policy is useless. All it is really is shifting government obligations from one form into another (from, say, federal reserves to T-bills, or back again). Yes, that affects interest rates, but interest rates don't really matter except to bond traders like myself. Only fiscal policy has a material effect on the economy. Probably the main way interest rates have an effect on the economy is through increasing or decreasing the federal deficit (through the action of interest paid on T-bills), strengthening or weakening the currency, and perhaps through the deflation or inflation of the stock market, respectively. There are all indirect effects though. There's nothing like increasing net financial wealth directly, however, which can only be accomplished through fiscal policy.
 
In a fiat currency system, the government must decide how much money (i.e. net financial wealth) there is. Too little, and we have insufficient aggregate demand and growth and unfulfilled savings desire. Too much, and we have inflation. The government doesn't need to get into the weeds of production or consumption as if it were a socialist hellhole. But it does need to cut taxes or increase spending during a recession and raise taxes or cut spending when there is inflation. It's not exactly rocket surgery, although few people in power seem to understand such a simple concept.

Tax rates and budget expenditures don't really address the problem of a cyclical system freezing up because one critical link in the chain decides it wants to hold currency outside of the cycle. This is a classic 'fallacy of composition' issue. What is positive and prudent for one person to do (accumulate savings) is disastrous for everyone to do all at the same time.

Utterly false. Tax cuts increase net financial wealth, as does government spending. Net financial wealth can only come from the government. The increase each year is precisely equal to the federal budget deficit. By definition.

You're getting very good at making statements that are true, but miss the problem entirely. Growth of productivity/GDP/total combined wealth has continued at roughly the same pace in the 1980-present era as it did from 1945-1980. The distribution of earnings has changed dramatically, however. The four lower quintiles have all been flat or stagnant adjusted for inflation. So for at least 80% of the population, they have contributed to ever-higher levels of productivity, but get less and less personal quality of life increases for it.

No, monetary policy is useless. All it is really is shifting government obligations from one form into another (from, say, federal reserves to T-bills, or back again). Yes, that affects interest rates, but interest rates don't really matter except to bond traders like myself. Only fiscal policy has a material effect on the economy. Probably the main way interest rates have an effect on the economy is through increasing or decreasing the federal deficit (through the action of interest paid on T-bills), strengthening or weakening the currency, and perhaps through the deflation or inflation of the stock market, respectively. There are all indirect effects though. There's nothing like increasing net financial wealth directly, however, which can only be accomplished through fiscal policy.

I honestly don't even know where to start with this other than to say your conception of the economic model is fascinating.

Monetary policy has 'no material effect' on the economy? I'm fairly sure that businesses are impacted by interest rates and capital liquidity. The follow-on implications are quite clear. There's a lot of interplay between fiscal and monetary policy, certainly. But this "only one of them is important and here's a cherry-picked line of reasoning to support it" is stunningly out of step with reality.
 
Last edited:
<snip>
I've watched a billionaire kick a garbage can across the room in anger because of a $50,000 trading mistake.

Okay, but did that $50,000 trading mistake mean he might have to go without dinner or miss a rent payment?

Because when I locked my keys in the car the other night and had to pay a tow truck $50 to open the door, that's what was going through my head.

Some people have the luxury of being personally upset with themselves/embarrassed over costly mistakes. Some people don't have that luxury, they have actual basic physical needs deficits. One of these is an irrational temper tantrum, the other is stress over personal security and well-being.
 
Growth of productivity/GDP/total combined wealth has continued at roughly the same pace in the 1980-present era as it did from 1945-1980. The distribution of earnings has changed dramatically, however. The four lower quintiles have all been flat or stagnant adjusted for inflation. So for at least 80% of the population, they have contributed to ever-higher levels of productivity, but get less and less personal quality of life increases for it.

I feel this is what has been a major driver since 2008. Employment is at an all time high, productivity is at an all time high. More Americans are working, they're working longer days, they're more productive thanks to technology and even a better attitude toward work than in previous generations.

The nation is much wealthier... but after all this work, the contributors are not getting raises, they're spending a larger portion of their stagnant incomes on necessities such as smaller houses, food, education, transportation. They know somebody's siphoning what they're owed. The politics is about who's doing it, and thus how to fix it.

I was talking with a childhood friend the other day about her restaurants. She's noticed that restaurant attendance is down YOY for several years in a row. For reasons I can't fathom, she thinks health regulations are to blame. She just can't shake this theory. I can't get her to connect the dots for me. Ultimately, she wants deregulation, and somehow that will bring more people into her restaurants.

Meanwhile on reality street... the average home in Vancouver is over a million dollars now. I recently sold a 450 square foot condo in North Vancouver - my last revenue property - for $300,000. Customers ten years ago had at least some spending money after paying the mortgage. Today, we're all 'house poor'. Her restaurants are suffering because her customer's cost of basics like housing and transportation have gone up faster than wages for 30 years and we hit the wall recently: there's no discretionary income padding left.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom