Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

... I'm afraid I don't really understand these critiques. "appear contrived," "not consilient with". I have trouble grasping the actual claims.

Short of doing the research or paying for access, we have these links to the abstracts. My general point stands, nevertheless, that MFT is not described or formulated in terms of cognitive science or neuroscience. To highlight that, I provided the other link in a later post to a full paper showing the type of methods required. (The quote from the MFT page also shows that the professional background of the group is not appropriate for this type of research, even if I was kind enough not to point that out before.)

It feels like the critique hasn't read Haight's work. Innate does not mean heritable, and they dedicate several chapters to explaining this, so this critique is a strawperson IMO.

Nope. That's probably the gap, then. Innate does not mean inheritable, for one thing, and secondly, their research is focusing on the categories themselves as innate, rather than the importance individuals attribute to them.

Innate means it comes with the genetic equipment and is not learned behavior (tho innate competencies may be later shaped by culture). Granted, a single person's genes may provide a sort of unique innateness. However, MFT is proposing modules that should be broadly present and not merely anecdotal. To explain morality at a species level, MFT needs to take independent datasets and show that one can derive some universals directly from them. In cognitive terms, that means demonstrating a common innate competency shared by the species. This makes dividing humans into groups based on differing competencies something that would require heritability OR some explanation for variable gene expression that is nonetheless very stable in its outcomes, such as is the case for basic personality types (which, by the way, are not related to competency).

Basically, MFT needs to tie values to specific morphology, that morphology to genetics, and the genetics to behaviors, something it has not shown by a long shot. To be fair, that is hard for any science.

So, back to the analogy. They're saying people have tastebuds for morals. They're not saying people necessarily are born preferring sweet over salty. We have some predisposition sure, but mostly develop flavour preferences through our culture.

Which seriously changes the conversation and challenges the validity of the claims as stated.

I'm not sure why, sorry, not clear on how you connect saying liberals and conservatives have value prioritization with a sense of alarm.

The point is that the OP starts with the premise that liberals should understand conservative values, and then cites MFT for two competing lists of purported "values." If one takes this approach as valid, liberals are "missing" some values conservatives possess, making them genetic misfits. You do see where this can lead, I trust.

What MFT is actually proposing in all likelihood is that upbringing can tack on criteria to a worldview, which is nothing new. What is new is claiming any of these "values" as universals without scientific evidence.
 
Innate means it comes with the genetic equipment and is not learned behavior (tho innate competencies may be later shaped by culture). Granted, a single person's genes may provide a sort of unique innateness.

Yesss. Although, "comes with genetic equipment" does not mean diversity within the population is genetic. (eg: we have genetic capacity for language, but my preference for English is learned) Are we talking past each other about this, then?

By analogy, MFT postulates that we have the innate capacity to strive for a limited set of moral axes (which is the core innovation of their model), but our individual preference for some over others is not claimed to be innate in their model (which I think is the misunderstanding you're responding to).



However, MFT is proposing modules that should be broadly present and not merely anecdotal. To explain morality at a species level, MFT needs to take independent datasets and show that one can derive some universals directly from them. In cognitive terms, that means demonstrating a common innate competency shared by the species. This makes dividing humans into groups based on differing competencies something that would require heritability OR some explanation for variable gene expression that is nonetheless very stable in its outcomes, such as is the case for basic personality types (which, by the way, are not related to competency).

OK, I really do think you're not understanding their claim, then. It sounds like you are misinterpreting their model to say that people have inherited their different moral preferences. This is not their claim.

I return to the analogy: they're claiming that there seem to be discreet moral axes (modules, call them what you like) / analogy is taste receptors.

And that people prioritize these moral modules differently / analogy is that some people have a sweet tooth.

The axes are innate (everybody understands the concept of group loyalty / everybody can taste saltiness), but the prioritization does not appear to be strongly innate and is probably heavily cultural (some people feel that loyalty to the group is more important than fair access to opportunity / some people are drawn to salty foods more than sweet foods), is their thesis.



Basically, MFT needs to tie values to specific morphology, that morphology to genetics, and the genetics to behaviors, something it has not shown by a long shot. To be fair, that is hard for any science.

I don't think they 'need' to do this, no. I think this is still flowing from a misunderstanding of their claim.



Which seriously changes the conversation and challenges the validity of the claims as stated.

It might change the conversation, yes, I think that's the point. It would change the conversation to addressing their actual claims.




The point is that the OP starts with the premise that liberals should understand conservative values, and then cites MFT for two competing lists of purported "values." If one takes this approach as valid, liberals are "missing" some values conservatives possess, making them genetic misfits. You do see where this can lead, I trust.

Sort of. I don't think you're summarizing the claims correctly, is the problem. MFT is not saying that liberals are 'missing' any values. Just that they assign them a lower priority. The innovative portion of their model is more about these discrete moral modules.



What MFT is actually proposing in all likelihood is that upbringing can tack on criteria to a worldview, which is nothing new. What is new is claiming any of these "values" as universals without scientific evidence.

I think they have scientific evidence, and quite a bit of it. Your view confuses me.
 
Sort of. I don't think you're summarizing the claims correctly, is the problem. MFT is not saying that liberals are 'missing' any values. Just that they assign them a lower priority. The innovative portion of their model is more about these discrete moral modules.

Additionally... it may not really matter whether MFT is completely correct... the key observation is that however you may want to slice and dice the composition of a worldview into discreet topics, firstly they do seem to be reproduceably weighed differently by conservatives and liberals; and secondly, that liberals have less success in anticipating conservatives' moral base for resistance to proposals.

This overlaps with findings from my exploration of skepticism's dismal reputation, as Skepticism has a lot of overlap with Liberals in this type of binary modelling. We don't invest in establishing a foundation of trust based on shared values before introducing our proposals, for example.
 
I'm sure the banks lend it out.

Is the argument at the end of this being that it doesn't matter who owns the money, as long as it's in the bank, it's working?

Technically, yes, in some sense at least. But it is incomplete, since it fails to mention that the money is "working" for the person who owns it.
 
Additionally... it may not really matter whether MFT is completely correct... the key observation is that however you may want to slice and dice the composition of a worldview into discreet topics, firstly they do seem to be reproduceably weighed differently by conservatives and liberals; and secondly, that liberals have less success in anticipating conservatives' moral base for resistance to proposals.

This overlaps with findings from my exploration of skepticism's dismal reputation, as Skepticism has a lot of overlap with Liberals in this type of binary modelling. We don't invest in establishing a foundation of trust based on shared values before introducing our proposals, for example.

Not sure I agree there is difficulty anticipating any moral bases, only a profound disagreement with them. In fact, I think loyalty, authority and purity are simply not moral values as much as they are learned social adaptations and survival strategies, but are often overextended when expressed politically. They are not up to snuff in relation to a complex, interrelated world that requires more analytical as opposed to emotional processing. I would consider them underweighted among those who are better at integrative complexity, and present as criteria only for the purposes below.

For example, push "loyalty" far enough, and you are either acting the fool, or you end up realizing loyalty can only be expressed properly as fidelity to conviction, else one risks being contradictory, if not immoral or grossly unfair. Unless oriented toward practicality in specific circumstances or domains, "authority" cannot be broadly understood as relating to ethics or morals beyond the family unit (parenting), and even then it can be extremely abused. "Purity," if not relating exclusively to health (avoid poison, etc), is actually a highly dangerous, unscientific and usually immoral basis for reasoning.

In terms of outreach or establishing trust, the domains of interpersonal interactions and formal statements (eg blog posts made under own name elsewhere) are where I make the sort of outreach you mention, and it includes people of faith. Here, the crucible. We have too much "been there, done that" to have to coddle or cuddle statements or judgments we've already had a chance to evaluate.

I do have greater regard for the MFT concepts of equity and so on, because these can be more clearly attached to a theory of mind, something required in higher social animals to function, but which, by its very nature, backdoors a fundamental sameness among actors (similar needs and motives must be posited to be able to predict the behavior of others).
 
Not sure I agree there is difficulty anticipating any moral bases, only a profound disagreement with them. In fact, I think loyalty, authority and purity are simply not moral values as much as they are learned social adaptations and survival strategies, but are often overextended when expressed politically. They are not up to snuff in relation to a complex, interrelated world that requires more analytical as opposed to emotional processing. I would consider them underweighted among those who are better at integrative complexity, and present as criteria only for the purposes below.

For example, push "loyalty" far enough, and you are either acting the fool, or you end up realizing loyalty can only be expressed properly as fidelity to conviction, else one risks being contradictory, if not immoral or grossly unfair. Unless oriented toward practicality in specific circumstances or domains, "authority" cannot be broadly understood as relating to ethics or morals beyond the family unit (parenting), and even then it can be extremely abused. "Purity," if not relating exclusively to health (avoid poison, etc), is actually a highly dangerous, unscientific and usually immoral basis for reasoning.

In terms of outreach or establishing trust, the domains of interpersonal interactions and formal statements (eg blog posts made under own name elsewhere) are where I make the sort of outreach you mention, and it includes people of faith. Here, the crucible. We have too much "been there, done that" to have to coddle or cuddle statements or judgments we've already had a chance to evaluate.

I do have greater regard for the MFT concepts of equity and so on, because these can be more clearly attached to a theory of mind, something required in higher social animals to function, but which, by its very nature, backdoors a fundamental sameness among actors (similar needs and motives must be posited to be able to predict the behavior of others).

Yeah, I think you're still not getting it.

You're not addressing the scientific question about which module model makes sense - you're engaging in a philosophical discussion about which moral modules (if they exist) are better than others. And saying that because your moral preferences are 'right' then there's no point in taking other opinions into account when performing outreach.

So: I think you're proving the OP's point quite nicely, unfortunately.



I think I understand your process.... that last paragraph about having high regard for equity, for example, because it's attached to a theory of mind and important for social animals... I think in your eyes this makes it 'right' but that's not the question, we're not trying to compare them for worth, just for existence. Problem is: we also have that fish brain, and it shares our one vote with the rest of that mind. It's important to find out how to connect with all our specieswide shared mental trigger points if the goal is to persuade.

The pitch is for empathy, but not for sympathy, if that makes any sense. A desire to understand how opponents' minds work is not saying I am extending them any credit or ceding them any moral highground. It's a desire for understanding what's under the hood so I don't march into the yet another avoidable political disaster without trying my best.

Here's yet another in the long march of "skeptics just keep doing it wrong": [Data shows that using science in an argument just makes people more partisan]
 
In terms of outreach or establishing trust, the domains of interpersonal interactions and formal statements (eg blog posts made under own name elsewhere) are where I make the sort of outreach you mention, and it includes people of faith. Here, the crucible. We have too much "been there, done that" to have to coddle or cuddle statements or judgments we've already had a chance to evaluate.

I don't think anybody's recommending cuddling or coddling.

An example from Frank Luntz' (coiner of the phrase "death panels") "Words That Work: It's Not What You Say, It's What People Hear" is that you have to identify the audience's values and speak to them in the introduction, and relate your ideas to those values, or they just won't even be paying attention, you're wasting your breath.

As a "Liberal" example, the topic of climate change can be successfully pitched to a conservative church congregation, but not by weighing the bulk of the content with the scientific information. It'd be more effective to load up with stewardship themes, if for no other reason than maintaining attention.

There's no need to coddle. Just craft the conversation to the audience, is the suggestion.
 
Technically, yes, in some sense at least. But it is incomplete, since it fails to mention that the money is "working" for the person who owns it.

If they're a banker, it does. For the rest of us it's not the money itself but the assets purchased with the money.
 
I don't think anybody's recommending cuddling or coddling.

An example from Frank Luntz' (coiner of the phrase "death panels") "Words That Work: It's Not What You Say, It's What People Hear" is that you have to identify the audience's values and speak to them in the introduction, and relate your ideas to those values, or they just won't even be paying attention, you're wasting your breath.

As a "Liberal" example, the topic of climate change can be successfully pitched to a conservative church congregation, but not by weighing the bulk of the content with the scientific information. It'd be more effective to load up with stewardship themes, if for no other reason than maintaining attention.

There's no need to coddle. Just craft the conversation to the audience, is the suggestion.

Agreed for the venues I mentioned. I only do my Sid Vicious routine on ISF and in a few egregiously alt-right comment sections. In fact, in any conference or presentation, my approach is based on going from the known to the unknown; that is, presenting the familiar and bridging from it to pave the way to talking points.
 
I don't think anybody's recommending cuddling or coddling.

An example from Frank Luntz' (coiner of the phrase "death panels") "Words That Work: It's Not What You Say, It's What People Hear" is that you have to identify the audience's values and speak to them in the introduction, and relate your ideas to those values, or they just won't even be paying attention, you're wasting your breath.

As a "Liberal" example, the topic of climate change can be successfully pitched to a conservative church congregation, but not by weighing the bulk of the content with the scientific information. It'd be more effective to load up with stewardship themes, if for no other reason than maintaining attention.

There's no need to coddle. Just craft the conversation to the audience, is the suggestion.

Small problem with this.

You are adopting a meta position without allowing the other side the ability or willingness to do the same.

Wouldn't it be more rational to seek out and converse with the elite thought-leaders on a peer basis instead of playing Pepsi v. Coke with the rank and file consumers? I suggest this is what actually happens in the halls of power, where everyone has at least a Bachelor's in PolySci, or a law degree, or decades in the school of political hard knocks.
 
Small problem with this.

You are adopting a meta position without allowing the other side the ability or willingness to do the same.

Wouldn't it be more rational to seek out and converse with the elite thought-leaders on a peer basis instead of playing Pepsi v. Coke with the rank and file consumers? I suggest this is what actually happens in the halls of power, where everyone has at least a Bachelor's in PolySci, or a law degree, or decades in the school of political hard knocks.

I'm sorry, I don't quite understand what you are asking.

Are you saying that we shouldn't have a strategy for convincing the actual voters, but rather, focus attention on convincing their trusted leaders? (Convince the pastor, and let him convince the flock?)
 
You do not need to be a banker to profit from capital investments the bank makes with your money. Why would you think this?
Because the return is typically less than what is lost through inflation. If one does make a profit it would be a small one.
 
Both look like good investments, if the goal is national economic growth, employment, and permanent energy independence. Kvetching about the model specs seems to be digging for something to criticize.

Of interest, most of the people I know who have purchased electric cars are pretty thrifty and not the type to be interested in displays of wealth.

Here's an example of somebody who I consider to be a model of thrift (he and I are aligned on the principle of early retirement being more important than 'stuff'), somebody who thinks pricey cars are literally stupid: [So I Bought an Electric Car…]

His general opinion on expensive cars: [Curing your Clown-Like Car Habit]
 
Because the return is typically less than what is lost through inflation. If one does make a profit it would be a small one.

Yep. Thanks to inflation, savings accounts don't make the saver any profit.
The saver loses value a little less quickly compared to stuffing cash in a mattress... maybe, depending on the account.

eg: My wife's business savings account had a $30/mo service fee, which chewed up every penny of interest plus some of the principal every month. I put a stop to that within an hour of discovering it. Banks really do see MDs as walking dollar signs. Anyway, she'd have been better off putting the cash in our safe versus this bank account.
 
Yes they do. I'm related to about three people you would traditionally call welfare kings/queens. The amount they work is directly tied to how much free benefits they can extract.
You're on a skeptics board and you trot out a personal anecdote to justify an assertion about the relationship between jobs and welfare. Really? I don't know whether to laugh or cry.
 
Because the return is typically less than what is lost through inflation.

No it isn't.

If one does make a profit it would be a small one.

Well, we were talking about the 30 trillion dollars held in offshore tax-haven accounts, not grandma's little savings account with the local bank which is ripping her off. Feel free to provide your estimate for the "small" profit that is being made from that by its owners.
 
You're on a skeptics board and you trot out a personal anecdote to justify an assertion about the relationship between jobs and welfare. Really? I don't know whether to laugh or cry.

You are ignoring the post where I said I would not make policy based on it. I purposely never asserted a magnitude of impact.
 
Well, we were talking about the 30 trillion dollars held in offshore tax-haven accounts, not grandma's little savings account with the local bank which is ripping her off. Feel free to provide your estimate for the "small" profit that is being made from that by its owners.

Firstly: It's not the money itself that's making a profit. It's the tax evasion that's eliminating a cost. They would have the same benefit if they were smuggling gold bars, Picassos, or child slaves instead of money. The profit is from crime, not investment. They could be willing to take a 1% annual loss to inflation for 30 years because they saved 30% on the up front tax evasion.

Those of us citizens who are not tax evaders would not profit from it.

Secondly, we don't know what form the money is currently taking. It could be, for example, invested in equities. I doubt it's cash balances.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom