Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Two reasons. Or three rather. First, because conservatives are completely in charge for the next 2 years and probably 4. Second, because (IMHO) liberals have some catching up to do in the "understanding their opponent" sweepstakes. Third, because the mainstream media, the college campuses, and Hollywood are dominated by liberals, so the liberal perspective on things is easy to access. It is the conservative perspective which requires a bit of effort to find.

None of this answers the question you quoted.
 
We have ample proof that Republican presidents are worse for the economy and budget than democratic ones.

Ridiculous. There is not much in the way of evidence in either direction, let alone proof. From a logical standpoint, however, Republican policies should be better for the economy than Democratic ones. There are a lot of other factors involved, however, including (a) the President cannot always implement his policies without compromise, or at all; and (b) the timescale on which economic policies work can be far greater than a single Presidential term.

And who voted for Clinton? The states with by far the greatest economic output. The "Rust Belt" is not called that for nothing, and neither is Silicon valley.

Not that such a point is terribly relevant, but who voted for Clinton within those states? There's no question that Democrats get the votes of the majority of people with lower incomes. Clinton won 53% (vs 41% for Trump) of the voters with incomes below $50,000/yr, which of course includes those who receive far more in value from the federal government than they contribute in taxes (probably the vast majority do actually).

Trump's win is one of money spenders over money makers.

The data does not support this conclusion. Trump won the segment between $50,000/yr and $100,000/yr, and Clinton and Trump tied for the incomes above $100,000.
 
None of this answers the question you quoted.

Since I think it's obvious that both groups need to understand each other, I interpreted the question as asking why liberals have a greater need to understand conservatives than the other way around. I answered the question I thought was being asked. If the question was really the one with the obvious answer, well, the answer is conservatives do need to understand liberals. I think they do for the most part, however, and the reason why is that conservatives are inundated with liberal messaging from the time they start school.
 
<snip>

Its main goal was economic stimulus, and it looks like it achieved its purpose. I guess I'd have to hear your specific criticism to understand why you think it is an example of voters not understanding economics.

Dropping $4 billion in cash out of helicopters would have been a better economic stimulus. Cash for Clunkers was no different from breaking windows to stimulate the glazier trade. The government paid people to destroy valuable capital stock. In this case, millions of serviceable cars which could have been used as modes of transportation by people of moderate means. The negative consequences were easy to predict and indeed came to pass - price inflation in the used car market and a huge transfer of wealth to car dealers (weighted towards the most unscrupulous of the lot). It was an obviously idiotic policy, on par with FDR's policy of trying to reduce the supply of corn and hogs in order to raise prices for farmers while the country was suffering from widespread malnutrition.

The electric car subsidy is an investment in the future of American industry. The model specs were not pre-defined (sounds like they wanted to minimize regulation and let business decide how to use the incentive).

It's a stupid way of going about trying to correct for externalities. If indeed you believe fossil fuels have a negative net externality (which I'm not convinced of), it is not necessarily the case that alternative fuels have a positive one (and I've seen no argument that there is such a positive externality). Subsidies should be granted to things which have positive externalities, not to things which simply don't have negative externalities. If fossil fuels have negative externalities, then they should be taxed to compensate. By providing subsidies to the electric car market, the government is distorting the market and choosing winners and losers. Worse, it is actually subsidizing conspicuous consumption by the affluent. There is no question that building and using a $100,000 Tesla consumes more resources than building and using a $20,000 car. That information is contained in the relative prices.
 
@sunmaster

instead of relying on your logic, check the facts.
US deficit has reliably exploded under Republican presidents, and has been reduced under Democrats.
Incomes rise much more under D's.
And states which have implemented Republican-style 'trickle-down' tax systems are broke.

This is what the objective data says.
 
@sunmaster

instead of relying on your logic, check the facts.
US deficit has reliably exploded under Republican presidents, and has been reduced under Democrats.
Incomes rise much more under D's.
And states which have implemented Republican-style 'trickle-down' tax systems are broke.

This is what the objective data says.

No, that's not what the data says. That's simply your interpretation of the data, which differs from mine. And just as an aside, deficits are good, not bad. The national debt represents the net financial savings of the non-governmental sector. The budget surpluses towards the end of Clinton's Presidency were not only unsustainable; they were bad, inevitably leading to the collapse of the stock market and a recession, both of which would have been much worse without Bush's exquisitely timed tax cuts.
 
No, that's not what the data says. That's simply your interpretation of the data, which differs from mine. And just as an aside, deficits are good, not bad. The national debt represents the net financial savings of the non-governmental sector. The budget surpluses towards the end of Clinton's Presidency were not only unsustainable; they were bad, inevitably leading to the collapse of the stock market and a recession, both of which would have been much worse without Bush's exquisitely timed tax cuts.

There is no consistent correlation between cutting taxes (especially weighted towards high earners) and increased economic activity. On the other hand, food stamps, unemployment, and infrastructure spending have some of the best returns (even better in a recession). People receiving basic life needs assistance tend to spend that money very quickly on...basic life needs. There is no forbearance on their part. On the other hand, we gave powerful financial institutions bail outs and injected trillions of dollars into the system for 'liquidity' and for the most part they sat on it for years.

The velocity of money has a major impact on total economic activity, money tends to have a higher rate of turnover when it is in the hands of 100 poor people who must make purchases immediately than 10 rich ones who add it to their already abundant savings.
 
There is no question that building and using a $100,000 Tesla consumes more resources than building and using a $20,000 car. That information is contained in the relative prices.

This is not true. And I'm concerned about this since above you were kvetching about how 'some people' don't understand economics.

The principle in question is amortization of fixed costs. Tesla's sunken capital is new, and amortized into a small run of vehicle prices. GM's sunken capital is a century old, and long paid off, no longer a component of vehicle pricing.

Just as an example, I work at a telco. Our copper voice phone product is $60. Markup is 100% since the infrastructure was paid for two generations ago. Fiber voice phone product is also $60, which we operate at a negative markup, sustaining a loss probably for another decade. The pricing is not communicating anything about the per unit resource usage. The company is subsidizing fiber for a fixed period because it secures competitiveness for the next generation, just as the USA has a strategy of subsidizing electric cars for a fixed period because it secures competitiveness for the next generation.
 
There is no consistent correlation between cutting taxes (especially weighted towards high earners) and increased economic activity. On the other hand, food stamps, unemployment, and infrastructure spending have some of the best returns (even better in a recession). People receiving basic life needs assistance tend to spend that money very quickly on...basic life needs. There is no forbearance on their part. On the other hand, we gave powerful financial institutions bail outs and injected trillions of dollars into the system for 'liquidity' and for the most part they sat on it for years.

The velocity of money has a major impact on total economic activity, money tends to have a higher rate of turnover when it is in the hands of 100 poor people who must make purchases immediately than 10 rich ones who add it to their already abundant savings.

...In Panama.

There are quite a few models that have raised the same concern: the super wealthy are conduits for transferring money offshore and sequestering it. The more they get, the less remains for domestic economic activity.

This is a challenge for developing a tax strategy. Just as a specific example, my company's US operations (not the telco job mentioned above - my own company which handles stuff like copyright residuals for my books and an earlier business that has software licensing) are incorporated in Delaware because of their very low tax rate. But I don't actually employ anybody there, and the dividends are issued to me in Canada where I pay Canadian taxes. So what's in it for Delaware? Corporate tax is low, but not zero. If it was zero, what would be the point?

Expanding that to a US example, the risk is that a zero percent federal corporate tax will be greatest for offshore operations to cycle income through shells. But there's not necessarily any incentive to bring actual employment onshore. My concern is that all this does is reduce public revenues from onshore businesses that are using services, while providing no new revenues from new business to compensate, all the while accelerating the practice of shovelling final net income offshore, removing even more spending power from the economy.
 
There is no consistent correlation between cutting taxes (especially weighted towards high earners) and increased economic activity. On the other hand, food stamps, unemployment, and infrastructure spending have some of the best returns (even better in a recession). People receiving basic life needs assistance tend to spend that money very quickly on...basic life needs. There is no forbearance on their part. On the other hand, we gave powerful financial institutions bail outs and injected trillions of dollars into the system for 'liquidity' and for the most part they sat on it for years.

The velocity of money has a major impact on total economic activity, money tends to have a higher rate of turnover when it is in the hands of 100 poor people who must make purchases immediately than 10 rich ones who add it to their already abundant savings.

If the rich don't spend their tax cuts, then it's a freebie. No increase in aggregate demand, no increase in inflation, but the rich are happier (bigger numbers on their bank statements), and their incentive to work and produce increases.

Money given to the poor just ends up in the hands of the rich anyway after a couple of turns. That's fine since it improved the lives of the poor by allowing them to consume more stuff, but it does put pressure on supply but does nothing directly to stimulate more supply (by, for example, increasing the incentive to work). Yes, in an economy operating below capacity it's good to stimulate more consumption, but ultimately our aggregate standard of living is tied to what we can produce, not what we can consume. Deficits should be high enough such aggregate demand matches capacity, but after that it's important to facilitate new production (which means, in part, incentivizing work - or at least not discouraging it).
 
This is not true. And I'm concerned about this since above you were kvetching about how 'some people' don't understand economics.

The principle in question is amortization of fixed costs. Tesla's sunken capital is new, and amortized into a small run of vehicle prices. GM's sunken capital is a century old, and long paid off, no longer a component of vehicle pricing.

Just as an example, I work at a telco. Our copper voice phone product is $60. Markup is 100% since the infrastructure was paid for two generations ago. Fiber voice phone product is also $60, which we operate at a negative markup, sustaining a loss probably for another decade. The pricing is not communicating anything about the per unit resource usage. The company is subsidizing fiber for a fixed period because it secures competitiveness for the next generation, just as the USA has a strategy of subsidizing electric cars for a fixed period because it secures competitiveness for the next generation.

Tesla's gross profit margin is about 28%. So the cost to produce a $100,000 Tesla Model X is about $72,000. Although that cost of sale includes depreciation, that does not include amortization of goodwill or debt service or whatnot. I'll have to check if it includes their buildout of a supercharger station network where their customers get free energy, but I don't think it does. And even if, in theory, the cost of production can come down as battery technology gets cheaper and their manufacturing processes acquire economies of scale, the fact is they're wasting resources now. A guy driving around a Tesla is wasting resources relative to a guy driving around a Honda Accord. That cannot reasonably be denied, although it is seldom looked at that way.

Personally, I don't have a problem with people wasting resources using their own money (actually I do, but not much of one), but I really don't like the government subsidizing profligacy. For example, if Bill Gates wants to hire 1,000 workers to dig holes and fill them back in again, I don't care terribly much. But if the government gave him financial incentives to do it, I would care a lot.
 
Tesla's gross profit margin is about 28%. So the cost to produce a $100,000 Tesla Model X is about $72,000. Although that cost of sale includes depreciation, that does not include amortization of goodwill or debt service or whatnot. I'll have to check if it includes their buildout of a supercharger station network where their customers get free energy, but I don't think it does. And even if, in theory, the cost of production can come down as battery technology gets cheaper and their manufacturing processes acquire economies of scale, the fact is they're wasting resources now. A guy driving around a Tesla is wasting resources relative to a guy driving around a Honda Accord. That cannot reasonably be denied, although it is seldom looked at that way.

I think the idea is that the subsidy was for an industry, and the individual models would be up to the market. The 'winner' chosen would be electric cars, but not necessarily any particular model or consumer segment. Less regulatory entanglement, being the idea.


Personally, I don't have a problem with people wasting resources using their own money (actually I do, but not much of one), but I really don't like the government subsidizing profligacy. For example, if Bill Gates wants to hire 1,000 workers to dig holes and fill them back in again, I don't care terribly much. But if the government gave him financial incentives to do it, I would care a lot.

Me, too, but it's apples and oranges, IMO. I'd be looking at which expenditures were translating into investments into future generations of meaningful work that can provide meritocratic income mobility. The electorate is certainly justified in being anxious about this, and I believe government can be given a mandate to action solutions.

I have the 'macroparasite' model of government. I believe there is an outcome where the government can facilitate thrival of its electorate through strategic and hopefully minimal wealth redistribution. I see these electric car subsidies as an example, and well in the tradition of past American initiatives with similar vision (I mentioned the power grid above, but highways are another - cars were luxuries when the highway network was approved, &c.). Monitoring GM, I'm pleased to see that the real world of electric car subsidies for the lifetime of the initiative is shaping to look more like massmarket models such as the Bolt, for middle income families, fleet, and even sharing fleets, for those who cannot afford any car.

This is the future, and America is at a crossroads about whether they want to make America great the way their grandparents did with electricity and transportation subsidies, or do they want to reject the investment model out of principle and hope it all hangs together for their kids somehow.
 
Last edited:
Since I think it's obvious that both groups need to understand each other, I interpreted the question as asking why liberals have a greater need to understand conservatives than the other way around. I answered the question I thought was being asked. If the question was really the one with the obvious answer, well, the answer is conservatives do need to understand liberals. I think they do for the most part, however, and the reason why is that conservatives are inundated with liberal messaging from the time they start school.

That last sentence makes me think that you're using two definitions of "liberal" simultaneously.
 
I think the idea is that the subsidy was for an industry, and the individual models would be up to the market. The 'winner' chosen would be electric cars, but not necessarily any particular model or consumer segment. Less regulatory entanglement, being the idea.




Me, too, but it's apples and oranges, IMO. I'd be looking at which expenditures were translating into investments into future generations of meaningful work that can provide meritocratic income mobility. The electorate is certainly justified in being anxious about this, and I believe government can be given a mandate to action solutions.

I have the 'macroparasite' model of government. I believe there is an outcome where the government can facilitate thrival of its electorate through strategic and hopefully minimal wealth redistribution. I see these electric car subsidies as an example, and well in the tradition of past American initiatives with similar vision (I mentioned the power grid above, but highways are another - cars were luxuries when the highway network was approved, &c.). Monitoring GM, I'm pleased to see that the real world of electric car subsidies for the lifetime of the initiative is shaping to look more like massmarket models such as the Bolt, for middle income families, fleet, and even sharing fleets, for those who cannot afford any car.

This is the future, and America is at a crossroads about whether they want to make America great the way their grandparents did with electricity and transportation subsidies, or do they want to reject the investment model out of principle and hope it all hangs together for their kids somehow.

I think it makes sense for the government to subsidize things with positive externalities, like basic research, vaccines, education to a limited degree, maintenance of common resources, defense, etc. but I don't see how subsidizing consumption of an electric car fits the bill. Like I said before, there are no positive externalities about electric cars, even if you feel that burning fossil fuels is bad. And if it's about subsidizing basic research into new technologies, which the purchase of an electric car at the consumer level is pretty darn far removed from, then there are a lot more efficient ways of subsidizing that research than helping some rich guy to buy a fun toy. And virtually nobody buys electric cars to save money, since they don't actually save money. Hybrids, maybe, although I still kind of doubt it even today, almost two decades after they first hit the market. People buy such cars to have fun, or to virtue signal, or perhaps, in rare cases, to save time because going to the gas station is somewhat time-consuming. I suppose you can also get preferred parking at the high-end malls, along with a free charging. I wouldn't exactly call that a savings for society, however.
 
I think it makes sense for the government to subsidize things with positive externalities, like basic research, vaccines, education to a limited degree, maintenance of common resources, defense, etc. but I don't see how subsidizing consumption of an electric car fits the bill. Like I said before, there are no positive externalities about electric cars, even if you feel that burning fossil fuels is bad.

OK, but at least I see a place where we disagree. I believe there are net positive externalities to switching from fossil fuel to electric transportation infrastructure, for example.


And if it's about subsidizing basic research into new technologies, which the purchase of an electric car at the consumer level is pretty darn far removed from, then there are a lot more efficient ways of subsidizing that research than helping some rich guy to buy a fun toy.

It's not subsidizing basic research from what I can tell. Rather: subsidizing an industry and allowing them to develop whatever capital investments are required to establish future enterprise, be it basic research, applied research, physical plant, network... let the market decide.



And virtually nobody buys electric cars to save money, since they don't actually save money. Hybrids, maybe, although I still kind of doubt it even today, almost two decades after they first hit the market. People buy such cars to have fun, or to virtue signal, or perhaps, in rare cases, to save time because going to the gas station is somewhat time-consuming. I suppose you can also get preferred parking at the high-end malls, along with a free charging. I wouldn't exactly call that a savings for society, however.

I've never heard anybody suggest that the current crop of electric models are expected to save the consumer money directly. The long term economic and quality of life gains for the customers are in the externalities, which are shared benefits with noncustomers as well.
 
By the way, there have been studies that show the more people understand economics, the more conservative they get on economic issues.

By the way did you know that economists specialize in finding special meaning in polls.

Quite the data sampling. Meh? I'd look at the tables and say.... "50% of the sampling are in southern states. What's the predominant political leaning in that area? 35% from the midwest. In the states that are predominantly lilberal and Democratic (the west and northeast), they have 14% of their respondents.

Do you think that a sampling of Economics majors in schools with a different demographic than Florida Atlantic, Purdue, North Carolina and U. Nebraska at Lincoln might have had a different result. Wonder why they excluded the highest rated universities for Economics. Those would be, cough cough, MIT, Harvard, Stanford, U. of Chicago, Princeton, Berkley, UCLA, Yale.

Not that it's germane to the discussion, just an interesting insight into sourcing of selective information.
 
The Democrats have been complaining about Russia digging up dirt on Hillary's campaign, but are they willing to acknowledge that the New York Times and the Washington Post preferentially dig up dirt on Republicans and hide dirt on Democrats? Why is Russia's impact considered illegitimate, but the impact of partisan media isn't?

What an incredible question. Whether or not you agree, that "partisan media" on both sides believe they are advancing policy that's the best for our nation; Putin wants what's worst.
 
No, that's not what the data says. That's simply your interpretation of the data, which differs from mine. And just as an aside, deficits are good, not bad. The national debt represents the net financial savings of the non-governmental sector. The budget surpluses towards the end of Clinton's Presidency were not only unsustainable; they were bad, inevitably leading to the collapse of the stock market and a recession, both of which would have been much worse without Bush's exquisitely timed tax cuts.

nope - it is you who needs special pleading, like "velocity of money" blaming external factors and engaging in counter-factuals.

The data over the last 50 years is clear: democracts in power are better for the economy. Compare the per capita income in democratic to republican states, and then look again at your biases:
For you, conservative politics MUST be better, so with this narrative you cherry-pick and re-interpret the data to suit your needs.
But can you manage to put the blame for the 2008 crisis on anyone but Bush?
Not in good faith you can't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom