Delphic Oracle
Philosopher
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2016
- Messages
- 6,416
If the rich don't spend their tax cuts, then it's a freebie. No increase in aggregate demand, no increase in inflation, but the rich are happier (bigger numbers on their bank statements), and their incentive to work and produce increases.
Again, there's not even a correlation, let alone a causal link to support your position that making rich people even richer 'incentivizes' increased investment into productive capacity. There is no ratio of more dollars flowing to them = more jobs created. Jobs are created when unfilled demand exists that would generate more revenue to fill than it costs to create.
If demand remains flat or stagnant, no new jobs. Doesn't matter how much money you give the high earner, they have no reason to put it at risk.
Money given to the poor just ends up in the hands of the rich anyway after a couple of turns. That's fine since it improved the lives of the poor by allowing them to consume more stuff, but it does put pressure on supply but does nothing directly to stimulate more supply (by, for example, increasing the incentive to work). Yes, in an economy operating below capacity it's good to stimulate more consumption, but ultimately our aggregate standard of living is tied to what we can produce, not what we can consume. Deficits should be high enough such aggregate demand matches capacity, but after that it's important to facilitate new production (which means, in part, incentivizing work - or at least not discouraging it).
I'm not talking about one-off cash infusions, I'm talking about an ongoing policy of keeping cyclical consumption moving. One part of the circle can't just collect money but not spend it. Well, they can, but that means less and less circulating, that means less disposable income, which in turn means less demand.
Food stamps and unemployment don't discourage work, that's a tired old line (along with the entire 'voo-doo' supply side hoax). Our standard of living may be 'tied to what we can produce' but again, without demand there is no production, without production there is no employment, and without employment there is no demand. Oops, big problem. This is economically unsustainable (because: math). We've even bought into the idea that the government (biggest spender in the entire economy) should lower spending when there's a recession (which actually makes debts and deficits worse, again because: math). Government is supposed to prevent or correct market inefficiencies, not participate in them or exacerbate them.
One such method for correcting the inefficiency of wealth hoarding is to enforce downward redistribution. Not because of some romanticized 'robin hood' sense of justice, but because it just flat doesn't work otherwise.