Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

If the rich don't spend their tax cuts, then it's a freebie. No increase in aggregate demand, no increase in inflation, but the rich are happier (bigger numbers on their bank statements), and their incentive to work and produce increases.

Again, there's not even a correlation, let alone a causal link to support your position that making rich people even richer 'incentivizes' increased investment into productive capacity. There is no ratio of more dollars flowing to them = more jobs created. Jobs are created when unfilled demand exists that would generate more revenue to fill than it costs to create.

If demand remains flat or stagnant, no new jobs. Doesn't matter how much money you give the high earner, they have no reason to put it at risk.

Money given to the poor just ends up in the hands of the rich anyway after a couple of turns. That's fine since it improved the lives of the poor by allowing them to consume more stuff, but it does put pressure on supply but does nothing directly to stimulate more supply (by, for example, increasing the incentive to work). Yes, in an economy operating below capacity it's good to stimulate more consumption, but ultimately our aggregate standard of living is tied to what we can produce, not what we can consume. Deficits should be high enough such aggregate demand matches capacity, but after that it's important to facilitate new production (which means, in part, incentivizing work - or at least not discouraging it).

I'm not talking about one-off cash infusions, I'm talking about an ongoing policy of keeping cyclical consumption moving. One part of the circle can't just collect money but not spend it. Well, they can, but that means less and less circulating, that means less disposable income, which in turn means less demand.

Food stamps and unemployment don't discourage work, that's a tired old line (along with the entire 'voo-doo' supply side hoax). Our standard of living may be 'tied to what we can produce' but again, without demand there is no production, without production there is no employment, and without employment there is no demand. Oops, big problem. This is economically unsustainable (because: math). We've even bought into the idea that the government (biggest spender in the entire economy) should lower spending when there's a recession (which actually makes debts and deficits worse, again because: math). Government is supposed to prevent or correct market inefficiencies, not participate in them or exacerbate them.

One such method for correcting the inefficiency of wealth hoarding is to enforce downward redistribution. Not because of some romanticized 'robin hood' sense of justice, but because it just flat doesn't work otherwise.
 
Yes, you obviously have a keen eye. I used one version as a noun and another as an adjective. Good catch.

:rolleyes: As usual I see you have little interest in improving yourself by discovering your errors.

You seem to be using "liberal" to mean both "politicially left-leaning" and "proponent of classic liberalism". So which is it?
 
If the rich don't spend their tax cuts, then it's a freebie. No increase in aggregate demand, no increase in inflation, but the rich are happier (bigger numbers on their bank statements), and their incentive to work and produce increases.


There's no upper bound on that?

A man with tens of millions of dollars working a 90 hour week is going to decide to work a 95 hour week if he gets a tax break?


At which point would you consider that the effect is maxed out?
 
The only thing"liberals" need to understand is that when Trump messes up royally, "conservatives" will claim that it wasn't his or their fault - most likely Hillary's.
 
Again, there's not even a correlation, let alone a causal link to support your position that making rich people even richer 'incentivizes' increased investment into productive capacity. There is no ratio of more dollars flowing to them = more jobs created.

It's not the fact of making them richer that incentivizes productive activity. It's the cut in marginal tax rates which does it. The rich getting richer is just a side effect. Of course, the rich will get richer if you give more money to the poor to spend too. Would you concede that? But nobody ever says that the point of giving money to the poor is to make the rich richer.


Jobs are created when unfilled demand exists that would generate more revenue to fill than it costs to create.

True. But there has to be a balance between boosting aggregate demand and facilitating production. Consumption is the easy part. Production is the hard part. Anybody can consume. All you need is to give them little green pieces of paper to spend. Or, more commonly today, credits in their account at Amazon. Production, on the other hand, requires blood, sweat, and tears, and innovation, and creativity, and investment. You can't just boost that out of thin air, like you can with aggregate demand. You can drop money out of helicopters, and aggregate demand will be boosted. But dropping money out of helicopters isn't going to magically design and implement a new production process.

If demand remains flat or stagnant, no new jobs. Doesn't matter how much money you give the high earner, they have no reason to put it at risk.

True. But putting more money into the economy through tax cuts will do the job. If cutting taxes by 10% doesn't boost aggregate demand enough, then you have room to cut some more. Personally, I think income tax rates (including the wage tax) should be zero, so you can probably see that I think we have quite a bit of room to go.

I'm not talking about one-off cash infusions, I'm talking about an ongoing policy of keeping cyclical consumption moving. One part of the circle can't just collect money but not spend it. Well, they can, but that means less and less circulating, that means less disposable income, which in turn means less demand.

We already have a pretty robust welfare system. It is discouraging work by creating extremely high implicit marginal tax rates at the low end of the income spectrum. I don't think we need to do more there. Cutting the wage tax would be great, and I have advocated that. Democrats don't like the idea, for philosophical reasons.

Food stamps and unemployment don't discourage work, that's a tired old line (along with the entire 'voo-doo' supply side hoax). Our standard of living may be 'tied to what we can produce' but again, without demand there is no production, without production there is no employment, and without employment there is no demand. Oops, big problem. This is economically unsustainable (because: math). We've even bought into the idea that the government (biggest spender in the entire economy) should lower spending when there's a recession (which actually makes debts and deficits worse, again because: math). Government is supposed to prevent or correct market inefficiencies, not participate in them or exacerbate them.

Well, food stamps and unemployment benefits do discourage work. That's, as you say, math. The rest I can agree with.

One such method for correcting the inefficiency of wealth hoarding is to enforce downward redistribution. Not because of some romanticized 'robin hood' sense of justice, but because it just flat doesn't work otherwise.

Why is wealth hoarding an inefficiency or, as you seem to imply, a negative externality? I think hoarders are great. They produce far more than they consume. Not everybody can do that, of course. Production has to net out to consumption. But I'd personally rather consume more than I produce. It is far easier to find lazy people like me than to find the misers that you worry about.
 
Food stamps and unemployment don't discourage work, that's a tired old line (along with the entire 'voo-doo' supply side hoax).

Yes they do. I'm related to about three people you would traditionally call welfare kings/queens. The amount they work is directly tied to how much free benefits they can extract.
 
One such method for correcting the inefficiency of wealth hoarding is to enforce downward redistribution. Not because of some romanticized 'robin hood' sense of justice, but because it just flat doesn't work otherwise.

Making sure it "works" is not a legitimate government function.
 
There's no upper bound on that?

A man with tens of millions of dollars working a 90 hour week is going to decide to work a 95 hour week if he gets a tax break?


At which point would you consider that the effect is maxed out?

In my experience, the rich consider wealth gathering to be some sort of competition with other rich people. So, yes, they do seem incentivized by lower marginal tax rates, even if they have enough money already to meet all of their needs for the rest of their life. And of course, you can never really have enough money if you want to create a legacy or pass on your wealth to your progeny.
 
In my experience, the rich consider wealth gathering to be some sort of competition with other rich people. So, yes, they do seem incentivized by lower marginal tax rates, even if they have enough money already to meet all of their needs for the rest of their life. And of course, you can never really have enough money if you want to create a legacy or pass on your wealth to your progeny.

Well, if they're competing against others paying the same tax rate then the tax take makes no difference as it affects all parties equally.


Even disregarding this, there's still an upper limit on how many effective hours one person can work in a week.


And, in addition, I never quite get the implication that rich and successful people would just stop working if they were taxed more. given the number of failed startups every year, even if they did, there's a queue of people behind them ready to take their place at 5p less in the pound.
 
I would not set policy on it. But my policy proposals are not dependent on the outcome they would cause, so it is moot to me.


I realise that for you principle is more important than outcome.

On this fundamental principle, we disagree so I really don't think we're likely to find too much in the way of common ground.
 
There can be no doubt that top incomes are no longer in any relation to the work being done: top executives have not become 100x more productive since the 70's.
Top tax rates of 80% or even 95% had the nice effect of putting a ceiling on income: there was no point to pay anyone more, since the tax collector would get most of it.
As a result, the rich did not try to outdo each other by the size of their bonuses.

The main point (which has already been made) is that supply-side and 'trickle-down' economics only work in a certain margin: when there is an abundance of capital, further investment incentives will have no effect.
 
There can be no doubt that top incomes are no longer in any relation to the work being done: top executives have not become 100x more productive since the 70's.
Top tax rates of 80% or even 95% had the nice effect of putting a ceiling on income: there was no point to pay anyone more, since the tax collector would get most of it.
As a result, the rich did not try to outdo each other by the size of their bonuses.

The main point (which has already been made) is that supply-side and 'trickle-down' economics only work in a certain margin: when there is an abundance of capital, further investment incentives will have no effect.




There is an undesirable extreme at both ends of the spectrum (everyone having exactly the same vs one man having everything.)

I often wonder how much wealth has to accumulate in one place for those who see no harm in laissez-faire economic policies to believe that it has become a problem.
 
There can be no doubt that top incomes are no longer in any relation to the work being done: top executives have not become 100x more productive since the 70's.

The people who own the stock think those executives are worth it. Those major investors are greedy, you would think if they would be richer if they cut CEO pay then they would.
 
But there has to be a balance between boosting aggregate demand and facilitating production.

There is no need for government to try and centrally manage production vs consumption, markets work this out on their own.

But putting more money into the economy through tax cuts will do the job. If cutting taxes by 10% doesn't boost aggregate demand enough, then you have room to cut some more. Personally, I think income tax rates (including the wage tax) should be zero, so you can probably see that I think we have quite a bit of room to go.
Tax cuts don’t put money into the economy they change the distribution of wealth within an economy. Deficit spending, either from tax cuts or spending increases can stimulate demand for a time, but in a positive inflation environment fiscal policy plays second fiddle to monetary policy and the Fed. In fact at times if you stimulate demand by cutting taxes, the Fed may regularly be called on to stomp out these demand increases because they create inflation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom