Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Firstly: It's not the money itself that's making a profit. It's the tax evasion that's eliminating a cost. They would have the same benefit if they were smuggling gold bars, Picassos, or child slaves instead of money. The profit is from crime, not investment. They could be willing to take a 1% annual loss to inflation for 30 years because they saved 30% on the up front tax evasion.

Those of us citizens who are not tax evaders would not profit from it.

Secondly, we don't know what form the money is currently taking. It could be, for example, invested in equities. I doubt it's cash balances.

I think it is mostly legal tax avoidance.
 
I think it is mostly legal tax avoidance.

Either way, the cash isn't 'making money' - if it's in cash, it's losing value regardless of nation of hosting.

It's probably invested, is the point, and the instruments purchased with the cash would be making the owners a decent return.
 
Either way, the cash isn't 'making money' - if it's in cash, it's losing value regardless of nation of hosting.

It's probably invested, is the point, and the instruments purchased with the cash would be making the owners a decent return.

I just reviewed the Apple auditing on their $260Billion overseas cash hoarde, and they indicate that only about $16B is cash; the rest is invested in equities, bonds, and other yield bearing instruments.

I would expect those tax avoidant stashes to be similar, as this is the only way to preserve the original value.
 
Firstly: It's not the money itself that's making a profit. It's the tax evasion that's eliminating a cost.

Do you have some sort of evidence for this? Like comparing actual return on various investment accounts by banks to actual inflation?

The profit is from crime, not investment.

The difference being?

The profit is from surplus value, a piece gets taken by the bank in exchange for running the investment, another piece by the person who owns the investment (to varying degree) and a last piece by the state.
 
Do you have some sort of evidence for this? Like comparing actual return on various investment accounts by banks to actual inflation?

You just have to look at interest rates, yes. Banks offer interest rates on savings accounts that have historically always been below inflation. The highest interest savings account in the USA right now that I could find was offering 1%. Annual inflation is expected to be 2.2%. This 'best identifiable' US savings account is expected to lose the lender 1.2% of its value in one year.



The difference being?

The difference being related to the point of the conversation, which was that cash savings do not generate a positive return on investment, after adjusting for inflation.



The profit is from surplus value, a piece gets taken by the bank in exchange for running the investment, another piece by the person who owns the investment (to varying degree) and a last piece by the state.

Yep, and those pieces taken by other parties, and inflation, are why the investor who merely saves cash does not have a positive return on investment, as I stated. I'm not seeing any refutation here. It feels like we're not having the same conversation.
 
You just have to look at interest rates, yes. Banks offer interest rates on savings accounts that have historically always been below inflation.

What makes you think people who have the money to leverage offshore tax haven accounts would put their money in savings accounts rather than investment accounts even if they were to do this "at home"?

The difference being related to the point of the conversation, which was that cash savings do not generate a positive return on investment, after adjusting for inflation.

Cash savings? No. Putting it in the bank as a form of investment? Yes.

Yep, and those pieces taken by other parties, and inflation, are why the investor who merely saves cash does not have a positive return on investment, as I stated. I'm not seeing any refutation here. It feels like we're not having the same conversation.

Investors use savings accounts? Then what do investment accounts exist for?
 
Last edited:
What makes you think people who have the money to leverage offshore tax haven accounts would put their money in savings accounts rather than investment accounts even if they were to do this "at home"?

Nothing. It was you that brought it up as an example.



Cash savings? No. Putting it in the bank as a form of investment? Yes.

So, now I'm thinking we're quibbling about whether 'putting it in the bank' meant 'savings account.' ?



Investors use savings accounts? Then what do investment accounts exist for?

I think that's my point. Savings are not investing.

I still think we're having different conversations.

This is referring to when you said:
the money is "working" for the person who owns it.

and Mycroft said:
If they're a banker, it does. For the rest of us it's not the money itself but the assets purchased with the money.

I was agreeing with Mycroft: money does not 'work' for the person who owns it (it decays in value). But if the owner buys assets with the money, those assets might generate returns.
 
Nothing. It was you that brought it up as an example.

I didn't. I find the discussion on savings accounts irrelevant since it's clear that investors would not use them.

I think that's my point. Savings are not investing.

So the profit being made by investors putting their money in investment accounts of banks in tax havens would not disappear if they were to do the same "here"?

I was agreeing with Mycroft: money does not 'work' for the person who owns it (it decays in value). But if the owner buys assets with the money, those assets might generate returns.

I think you two are simply being ideological in comparing big investors (who are currently engaged in putting their money with banks in offshore tax havens) with grandma's savings account, thereby making a category error which leads to the claim that the profit these big investors make in tax havens is due to "crime" rather than "investment".

In the end the profit is due to the extraction of surplus value, and then distributed among several parties, among which being the banks and the investors.
 
No it isn't.

:oldroll:

Well, we were talking about the 30 trillion dollars held in offshore tax-haven accounts, not grandma's little savings account with the local bank which is ripping her off. Feel free to provide your estimate for the "small" profit that is being made from that by its owners.

So far the only evidence you're presented that they are very profitable is that you imagine they are. Go ahead and work on that. If you want me to do research for you then you will need to provide more data. Who specifically does the account belong to? Where, as in what bank, is it held? What specifically are the terms of the account?
 
So the profit being made by investors putting their money in investment accounts of banks in tax havens would not disappear if they were to do the same "here"?

An investment account invests the money. In that account, it's not really money anymore, it's whatever the investment is, which can be represented as a dollar value (or whatever currency), which will change from day to day based on the market value of the investments.
 
It's more complicated than I what I posted, so far, but I hope to raise awareness to encourage others to learn more.


I just learned more about what liberals and conservatives have in common.
Americans are turning their 2024 election fatigue into the latest fetish: political humiliation. From a Dominatrix specializing in shaming liberals to getting turned on by confederate bikinis, sex experts break down the fetishization of Trump, Biden, and the political landscape. Who knew 80-year-old men could make people so horny?
Humiliation Kinks Get Political In Advance of the 2024 Election (The Daily Show on YouTube, June 12, 2024 - 6:24 min.)
I would have expected them to look more like MTG and AOC.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom