Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Except, you've constantly been upset at me calling you liberal.


Seeing how the left lies cheats and steals, calling it a mental disorder was just being charitable.

You are quite wrong on this matter (gerrymandering alone is clear proof of it!!)!
However, the right wingers most certainly do such and with gusto!!!! Not to mention sucking a lot!!!!!
 
No, I told you that I'm not a leftist. That's not the same thing.



BS. You're using it as an insult. You're calling half of your country insane on the simple basis of having different values from yours. And considering the state of the GOP, you have no place calling the other side dishonest.



Conservatism isn't a movement, by definition. Think about it.



It's not my box, it's yours! You're the one who said one thing in one post, and tried to bait and switch in another.
Not at all unexpected or unheard of in any right wing circle jerk.
 
Last edited:
Total control is a clown car? Lol


No the actions of republickers on anything certainly is though!!!



Actually you talk jibberish

I have been amiss - unfamiliar with the language of the Jibber tribe.............
 
Tax rates and budget expenditures don't really address the problem of a cyclical system freezing up because one critical link in the chain decides it wants to hold currency outside of the cycle. This is a classic 'fallacy of composition' issue. What is positive and prudent for one person to do (accumulate savings) is disastrous for everyone to do all at the same time.

I'm not committing a fallacy of composition. I'm saying that if aggregate savings desires are unfulfilled, then it's up to the government to "top them up." And the only way to do that is to run budget deficits. If people want to save, that's fine, as long as the government recognizes that fact and runs commensurately higher deficits to accommodate those savings desires while maintaining aggregate demand. The government is the only source of net financial wealth (not to be confused with tangible wealth of course, like capital stock, or gold, or even part ownership of businesses, e.g. stocks).


You're getting very good at making statements that are true, but miss the problem entirely. Growth of productivity/GDP/total combined wealth has continued at roughly the same pace in the 1980-present era as it did from 1945-1980. The distribution of earnings has changed dramatically, however. The four lower quintiles have all been flat or stagnant adjusted for inflation. So for at least 80% of the population, they have contributed to ever-higher levels of productivity, but get less and less personal quality of life increases for it.

You're concerned about a certain kind of inequality for some reason. I'm not. The greatest economic inequality is wealth inequality, but does it really matter? Some people like to save; some people don't. Some people are huge risk takers hit it big; some people are risk-averse (like I am) and are content with being moderately wealthy. The medium level of inequality is income inequality, but I'd say that's in large part due to different levels of productivity which have been exponentially exacerbated by technology and globalism. The difference between somebody who can solve a complicated problem and somebody who can't is potentially billions of dollars of value. Do you think it's a bad thing that a star major league pitcher gets paid $20 million per year, and somebody with a fast ball just a few kph slower and a curveball which breaks 1 cm less has to get a second job to make ends meet?

I honestly don't even know where to start with this other than to say your conception of the economic model is fascinating.

Good. Start here and then move on to the Mandatory Readings at the site.

Monetary policy has 'no material effect' on the economy? I'm fairly sure that businesses are impacted by interest rates and capital liquidity. The follow-on implications are quite clear. There's a lot of interplay between fiscal and monetary policy, certainly. But this "only one of them is important and here's a cherry-picked line of reasoning to support it" is stunningly out of step with reality.

Not sure what you mean by capital liquidity, but interest rates aren't that big a deal for most businesses. It's just a cost input, which impacts everybody, and which gets incorporated into prices. Whatever drag it might have in terms of pricing some small businesses out of financing an expansion or a purchase of equipment is more than offset by the extra income consumers earn on their savings. Higher interest rates are actually stimulative because consumers tend to spend out of income or income on savings rather than the savings themselves (i.e. principal).

Yes, I agree that this goes against the conventional wisdom, but the conventional wisdom is wrong. Am I 100% sure I'm right? No. But I'm about 80% sure.
 
Higher interest rates are actually stimulative because consumers tend to spend out of income or income on savings rather than the savings themselves (i.e. principal).

I have no idea where you get this, unless we're shifting into a discussion about interest rate versus 'real' interest rate?

Real Interest rate increases decrease spending in general, but the problem is exacerbated since 2008 because most American consumers don't have interest bearing savings anymore, and their primary monthly expense is mortgage payments which are increasingly beyond their safe limit.

Maybe there's a few consumers out there with trust funds for whom an uptick in interest rates translates into more spending, but there's not enough of them out there to model an economy.

I'm not aware of any model that considers a rise in real interest rates to do anything but reduce aggregate demand, all things being equal.
 
I'm not committing a fallacy of composition. I'm saying that if aggregate savings desires are unfulfilled, then it's up to the government to "top them up." And the only way to do that is to run budget deficits. If people want to save, that's fine, as long as the government recognizes that fact and runs commensurately higher deficits to accommodate those savings desires while maintaining aggregate demand. The government is the only source of net financial wealth (not to be confused with tangible wealth of course, like capital stock, or gold, or even part ownership of businesses, e.g. stocks).

No, it is up to the government to keep the system functioning in a healthy manner, not fulfill individual desires for wealth accumulation.

You're concerned about a certain kind of inequality for some reason. I'm not. The greatest economic inequality is wealth inequality, but does it really matter? Some people like to save; some people don't. Some people are huge risk takers hit it big; some people are risk-averse (like I am) and are content with being moderately wealthy. The medium level of inequality is income inequality, but I'd say that's in large part due to different levels of productivity which have been exponentially exacerbated by technology and globalism. The difference between somebody who can solve a complicated problem and somebody who can't is potentially billions of dollars of value. Do you think it's a bad thing that a star major league pitcher gets paid $20 million per year, and somebody with a fast ball just a few kph slower and a curveball which breaks 1 cm less has to get a second job to make ends meet?

My concern arises from the fact that it is economically unsustainable. As we are seeing unfold across almost the entire OECD sphere, it seems to also be politically unsustainable.

Good. Start here and then move on to the Mandatory Readings at the site.

I understand economic concepts so further review of them doesn't help me understand a paragraph of oversimplified and borderline contradictory statements.

Not sure what you mean by capital liquidity, but interest rates aren't that big a deal for most businesses. It's just a cost input, which impacts everybody, and which gets incorporated into prices. Whatever drag it might have in terms of pricing some small businesses out of financing an expansion or a purchase of equipment is more than offset by the extra income consumers earn on their savings. Higher interest rates are actually stimulative because consumers tend to spend out of income or income on savings rather than the savings themselves (i.e. principal).

Again, oversimplified to the point of being totally flawed.

First of all not every financed expansion or equipment purchase leads to higher prices, sometimes it can actually lower per-unit cost more than the additional cost of repaying the loan. An example that totally explodes your reasoning is financing an automation system that puts employees out of work so the level of demand within the system shrinks.

But generally prices do rise, yes. What's odd to me is that you see consumers forbearing from making purchases as 'savings.' That's not what is happening. They are spending an essentially fixed (or even shrinking) income on less and less goods and services. They aren't turning their nose up at the price of things, they flat out can't afford said things.

Sure, it's nice to 'spend out of income on savings'...but this assumes that people have savings.

Yes, I agree that this goes against the conventional wisdom, but the conventional wisdom is wrong. Am I 100% sure I'm right? No. But I'm about 80% sure.

You're repeating the mantras of a failed economic system that has yet to work as advertised after decades of attempts.
 
Last edited:
You're repeating the mantras of a failed economic system that has yet to work as advertised after decades of attempts.

After 35 years of it, it can't even be called 'doubling down' anymore. It's... what... quadrupling down?
 
After 35 years of it, it can't even be called 'doubling down' anymore. It's... what... quadrupling down?

I call it "naked and unrestrained upward redistribution of wealth."

Sometimes "recklessly divorced from reality" or, if I'm feeling quite pedestrian, "selfish greed."
 
Last edited:
Real Interest rate increases decrease spending in general, but the problem is exacerbated since 2008 because most American consumers don't have interest bearing savings anymore, and their primary monthly expense is mortgage payments which are increasingly beyond their safe limit.

Maybe there's a few consumers out there with trust funds for whom an uptick in interest rates translates into more spending, but there's not enough of them out there to model an economy.

I was just reviewing my notes to make sure I wasn't out to lunch on this one... the 2016 numbers aren't complete, but 2015 stats show the median average American retirement savings is sub $5,000. Gah! In the 32-37 age bracket, mean average retirement savings is $480, which is effectively nothing.

Millenials are still negative savings rate (-2%), as observed in previous years.

Real interest rates' impact on aggregate demand is probably the strongest it's been since the early 90s.
 
I was just reviewing my notes to make sure I wasn't out to lunch on this one... the 2016 numbers aren't complete, but 2015 stats show the median average American retirement savings is sub $5,000. Gah!
I wonder: how much if this is the result of being unable to save due to the pressures of making a limited income stretch to cover the basis vs being unwilling to save because people want to buy shiny things?

In the 32-37 age bracket, mean average retirement savings is $480, which is effectively nothing.
They may, however, be paying down a mortgage, which at least gives them equity.

Millenials are still negative savings rate (-2%), as observed in previous years.
Is this any different from 20-30 year olds from a generation or two ago?

Real interest rates' impact on aggregate demand is probably the strongest it's been since the early 90s.
I can't comment on this because I haven't researched the topic enough to come to any conclusion.
 
I wonder: how much if this is the result of being unable to save due to the pressures of making a limited income stretch to cover the basis vs being unwilling to save because people want to buy shiny things?


They may, however, be paying down a mortgage, which at least gives them equity.


Is this any different from 20-30 year olds from a generation or two ago?


I can't comment on this because I haven't researched the topic enough to come to any conclusion.

Anecdotal, of course, but almost nobody in my peer group owns a home. Only a handful engage in upgrading their phones about once a year, the rest of us are riding out 3-4 year old models. Most of us can get our hands on a neat trinket now and then, but none of us are swimming in SWAG by any means. The best among us have their name on an apartment lease and rent the other rooms out to whoever can can afford it at the time. That seems to be the definition of 'successful and stable' right now for almost everyone I know. The few people I do know who own homes are totally saddled by it and are basically expecting another downturn to completely ruin them.
 
Anecdotal, of course, but almost nobody in my peer group owns a home. [Respectful snip--if you want to read the whole reply, just look one post above]
Thank you for your comment. Where I am, most people In my peer group are doing all right. I've worked in I/T all my life, where the salaries are definitely above the median. That means the majority of people I work with own either a home or a condominium, drive a decent automobile, and overall do not seem to be having money issues. I have no idea what their retirement savings look like. Mine look great, but that's largely because I never had children. Given how much it costs to raise a child, if I did have any my retirement savings would be an awful lot less.
 
I have been amiss - unfamiliar with the language of the Jibber tribe.............
Not to mention remiss as I have been that too though I still find no references to that language or it's primary users.........
 
it is simple

the nut-con's are the dark side

the progressives the light side
 
My impression from Wowbagger's OP was that his intention was not to engage in a normative argument about which value cluster was 'right' - but rather, an attempt to explain why the population is clustered. I think the hope is that understanding the underlying nature of the clustering could lead to a strategy to curtail the polarization.

For me, it's important input for my model of a Skeptical Outreach program.

I think that may be missing the point... The problem may be that we're assuming people are translating their values into policy comparisons. I think the research is showing us that voting may not be very policy-oriented. That we are choosing candidates based on how they make us 'feel' they will fulfill our value goals.

Case in point... we constantly see surveys that show how point by point, Americans want every feature of a universal healthcare program. It's Americans' preferred policy. But they constantly vote against these initiatives. It's not Americans' preferred values.

I would agree there are rationalizations involved in political choices. That is not controversial. Yet, from the OP:
Both liberals and conservatives can learn something important from each other's moral values.

I do not think Moral Foundations Theory is actually a reliable depiction of values, and makes appeals to innate tendencies that are not derived at the level needed. My basic objection is that MFT does not sound like cognitive science or neuroscience to me, especially in terms of suggesting quite high level concepts that are not granular enough to make the derivation plausible. To take two critiques from other sources:

Cognitive Neuroscience. "First, innateness and modularity figure centrally in Haidt's account, but terminological and conceptual problems foster confusion and ambiguities. Second, both the theory's proposed number of moral foundations and its taxonomy of the moral domain appear contrived, ignoring equally good candidate foundations and the possibility of substantial intergroup differences in the foundations' contents. Third, the mechanisms (viz., modules) and categorical distinctions (viz., between foundations) proposed by the theory are not consilient with discoveries in contemporary neuroscience concerning the organization, functioning, and development of the brain. In light of these difficulties, we suggest that Haidt's theory is inadequate as a scientific account of morality."

American Journal of Political Science. "MFT posits that political attitudes are rooted in instinctual evaluations generated by innate psychological modules evolved to solve social dilemmas. If this is correct, moral foundations must be relatively stable dispositional traits, changes in moral foundations should systematically predict consequent changes in political orientations, and, at least in part, moral foundations must be heritable. We test these hypotheses and find substantial variability in individual-level moral foundations across time, and little evidence that these changes account for changes in political attitudes. We also find little evidence that moral foundations are heritable. These findings raise questions about the future of MFT as a theory of ideology.

Emphases mine. For a theory that relies on innateness, heritability should trump environment, and values should be fairly stable.

From the MFT page: "Moral Foundations Theory was created by a group of social and cultural psychologists (see us here) to understand why morality varies so much across cultures yet still shows so many similarities and recurrent themes. In brief, the theory proposes that several innate and universally available psychological systems are the foundations of “intuitive ethics.” Each culture then constructs virtues, narratives, and institutions on top of these foundations, thereby creating the unique moralities we see around the world, and conflicting within nations too."

MFT starts out at very high level in neurological terms. It further suggests that cultures provide the specifics to moral universals, much as a single grammar might be the local variant of a universal grammar. This claim requires datasets that are not something researchers posit at the outset, but which are truly independent. Finally, if there are moral universals that are not fully expressed or even present in a great many individuals, and heritability is a problem, the innateness theory falls apart entirely.

***
Voting may very well be based more on deeper narratives that are subscribed to, and be the result of rationalization more than reason. However indirectly it may be stated, MFT contains an unfortunate backdoor suggestion that liberals have a truncated value set. If we are concerned about rationalizations, this should be the first thing to set off alarms.
 
Case in point... we constantly see surveys that show how point by point, Americans want every feature of a universal healthcare program. It's Americans' preferred policy. But they constantly vote against these initiatives. It's not Americans' preferred values.
But did they really vote against these initiatives? In 2016 election only two major party candidates said anything positive about universal health care. One was Bernie Sanders. The other was Donald Trump.
 
A new publication about the neuroscience related to political beliefs is up on Nature, including an author quite familiar to posters here, Sam Harris. It's longish and I'm working through it, but this is the kind of work that seems to put forward valid suggestions for further study.
 
it is simple

the nut-con's are the dark side

the progressives the light side

No. Neither are light or dark side. They are different views. Some may dislike one or the other view with their own bias or habits or ethical judgement. But neither are intrinsically universally evil or good. (*).

That is not helping the discussion frankly.

(*) heck the role would be deserved , as in star wars universe dark side is about emotion passion, something more on the democratic side IMO, and the light side is about order and law, emotionless/equilibrium more like reps. It was not really about good vs evil at least in the expanded universe.
 
No. Neither are light or dark side. They are different views. Some may dislike one or the other view with their own bias or habits or ethical judgement. But neither are intrinsically universally evil or good. (*).

That is not helping the discussion frankly.

(*) heck the role would be deserved , as in star wars universe dark side is about emotion passion, something more on the democratic side IMO, and the light side is about order and law, emotionless/equilibrium more like reps. It was not really about good vs evil at least in the expanded universe.

nice try to spin the starwars universe

but NO

the con's support or recently did
sexism anti-ERA
racism anti-civil rights and voting rights
an anti-gay rights program
anti-public education (vouchers for religious schools )
anti-reproductive rights (the planned parenthood defunding )
stupid wars nam to iraq
low tax rates for the 1%
no public heath ins program
a very tali-ban like extreme religious view
favor censorship
killing SS


all evil dark side positions
plus they are mean greedy self-righteous pigs
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom