Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

You're missing the point. It's changing the balance between the incentive to make more money and the incentive to spend it, or at least indulge in leisure. I was just rebutting your claim that the uber-rich have little incentive to make more money because they have enough already. In my experience, that's not remotely true. I've watched a billionaire kick a garbage can across the room in anger because of a $50,000 trading mistake.


Given the state of the global economy, the balance hasn't been changed enough - the rich hoard their wealth, they don't seem to spend it. No amount of tax cuts in the past has seemed to make them want to spend it. Are you suggestion that taxes haven't been cut enough?
 
Last edited:
Given the state of the global economy, the balance hasn't been changed enough - the rich hoard their wealth, they don't seem to spend it. No amount of tax cuts in the past has seemed to make them want to spend it. Are you suggestion that taxes haven't been cut enough?

That article talks about lavish expenditures and placing it in banks where it is loaned.
 
I'm not contending anything other than the article cited does discuss lavish spending and investment....Not hoarding. It is about tax avoidance.


I see your point, however, it does seem to show that up to 30 odd trillion dollars is held in offshore accounts - that's 30 trillion dollars not directly invested in the global economy. (it might get their obliquely)
 
I see your point, however, it does seem to show that up to 30 odd trillion dollars is held in offshore accounts - that's 30 trillion dollars not directly invested in the global economy. (it might get their obliquely)

Are you saying those havens engage in less lending or are you calling bank lending oblique?
 
Are you saying those havens engage in less lending or are you calling bank lending oblique?



I'm sure the banks lend it out.

Is the argument at the end of this being that it doesn't matter who owns the money, as long as it's in the bank, it's working?
 
I wonder: how much if this is the result of being unable to save due to the pressures of making a limited income stretch to cover the basis vs being unwilling to save because people want to buy shiny things?

The research shows it's a collapse of 'discretionary spending'. Meaning: the portion of income dedicated to nondiscretionary spending (housing, transportation, groceries) has grown to crowd out discretionary spending. Real estate and (in the USA) medical expenses have grown so much faster than wage inflation they have overwhelmed budgets in that age bracket.




They may, however, be paying down a mortgage, which at least gives them equity.

Yes, the increased percentage of money spent on housing is a big portion of the impact on discretionary spending. The expression here in Canada is "house poor" - meaning, buying a house is a decision to exclude a great deal of consumption. A major contributor to this is that housing costs have increased faster than wage inflation. We're long past the 30% rule.

Just as a concrete example... I live in Vancouver, where average house is about $1.2M, for 25x average income. My parents bought their first house in 1965 - almost identical in size (they lived a few blocks away from where I live now) for $8k, about 1.5x average income.

So, yes, some have equity, but it's a decreasing percentage of the population (down 10% since 2008, and still dropping). Additionally, the properties that are in the affordable price range are of smaller size, which contributes to this generation's perception of reduced standard of living. There is no property in Vancouver of any size priced at 1.5x average income, such as my parents were able to purchase. The rule of thumb in the 1960s was 25% of income was the highest safe housing cost. Today, most of my peers are spending 50-60% of their income on housing. Those who cannot afford the bare minimum are renting instead. Rent has gone up in proportion to property values. That is to say, renters are also seeing their housing costs climb to 50-60% of income, which crowds out more and more discretionary spending. And all that for much smaller properties.



Is this any different from 20-30 year olds from a generation or two ago?

Yes. The personal savings rate in that age bracket in 1969 was 15%, whereas now it's close to zero percent, possibly negative. And most households were on a single income, to boot. And union membership with retirement packages was more common, so the savings rate was padding their existing retirement package. All in all, the boomers have done quite well, versus the segment that followed.

The age bracket that is losing their homes the fastest right now is the 40-50 year age group, believe it or not. They have lost the most from the real estate market crash, as they spent the prior years building up equity and have lost it all, with only a couple of decades left before retirement. This is an important segment politically, IMO. They have jobs, they saved and invested and gave up some discretionary spending, and they feel their efforts to save and invest have not been rewarded by the system, and have despair about their future.



I can't comment on this because I haven't researched the topic enough to come to any conclusion.

The good news is that interest rates are already so low, and any proposed changes so small (+ 0.5% over 2017 would be a surprise) that their impact is trivial at this point anyway.
 
I'm sure the banks lend it out.

Is the argument at the end of this being that it doesn't matter who owns the money, as long as it's in the bank, it's working?

You keep waiting for the shoe to drop where I make a bigger point. In reality I'm just a pedantic person.
 
But did they really vote against these initiatives? In 2016 election only two major party candidates said anything positive about universal health care. One was Bernie Sanders. The other was Donald Trump.

I'm referring to state level proposals where they were explicitly on the ballot as independent initiatives, separate from electing their representatives. Eg: Colorado's Amendment 69.
 
nice try to spin the starwars universe

but NO

the con's support or recently did
sexism anti-ERA
racism anti-civil rights and voting rights
an anti-gay rights program
anti-public education (vouchers for religious schools )
anti-reproductive rights (the planned parenthood defunding )
stupid wars nam to iraq
low tax rates for the 1%
no public heath ins program
a very tali-ban like extreme religious view
favor censorship
killing SS


all evil dark side positions
plus they are mean greedy self-righteous pigs

*Puts on pedant hat*

It's "taliban". Plural of talib. No hyphen.
 
nice try to spin the starwars universe

but NO

the con's support or recently did
sexism anti-ERA
racism anti-civil rights and voting rights
an anti-gay rights program
anti-public education (vouchers for religious schools )
anti-reproductive rights (the planned parenthood defunding )
stupid wars nam to iraq
low tax rates for the 1%
no public heath ins program
a very tali-ban like extreme religious view
favor censorship
killing SS


all evil dark side positions
plus they are mean greedy self-righteous pigs

You can do all of that without being evil.

But however we may want to flag action we do not like as evil, in a way to des-humanize the opponent, they are not. They may lack empathy toward certain of category of people, or want to impose their own concept of moral onto women/gay/others, *politician* may not have the same excuse as the average republican, but do not confuse "not sharing your values" with being evil.

Most people doing the above are neither profoundly malevolent, nor profoundly immoral. So not evil.
 
I would agree there are rationalizations involved in political choices. That is not controversial. Yet, from the OP:


I do not think Moral Foundations Theory is actually a reliable depiction of values, and makes appeals to innate tendencies that are not derived at the level needed. My basic objection is that MFT does not sound like cognitive science or neuroscience to me, especially in terms of suggesting quite high level concepts that are not granular enough to make the derivation plausible. To take two critiques from other sources:

I'll address them separately.

Cognitive Neuroscience. "First, innateness and modularity figure centrally in Haidt's account, but terminological and conceptual problems foster confusion and ambiguities. Second, both the theory's proposed number of moral foundations and its taxonomy of the moral domain appear contrived, ignoring equally good candidate foundations and the possibility of substantial intergroup differences in the foundations' contents. Third, the mechanisms (viz., modules) and categorical distinctions (viz., between foundations) proposed by the theory are not consilient with discoveries in contemporary neuroscience concerning the organization, functioning, and development of the brain. In light of these difficulties, we suggest that Haidt's theory is inadequate as a scientific account of morality."

I'm afraid I don't really understand these critiques. "appear contrived," "not consilient with". I have trouble grasping the actual claims.



American Journal of Political Science. "MFT posits that political attitudes are rooted in instinctual evaluations generated by innate psychological modules evolved to solve social dilemmas. If this is correct, moral foundations must be relatively stable dispositional traits, changes in moral foundations should systematically predict consequent changes in political orientations, and, at least in part, moral foundations must be heritable. We test these hypotheses and find substantial variability in individual-level moral foundations across time, and little evidence that these changes account for changes in political attitudes. We also find little evidence that moral foundations are heritable. These findings raise questions about the future of MFT as a theory of ideology.

It feels like the critique hasn't read Haight's work. Innate does not mean heritable, and they dedicate several chapters to explaining this, so this critique is a strawperson IMO.

Emphases mine. For a theory that relies on innateness, heritability should trump environment, and values should be fairly stable.
.

Nope. That's probably the gap, then. Innate does not mean inheritable, for one thing, and secondly, their research is focusing on the categories themselves as innate, rather than the importance individuals attribute to them.

So, back to the analogy. They're saying people have tastebuds for morals. They're not saying people necessarily are born preferring sweet over salty. We have some predisposition sure, but mostly develop flavour preferences through our culture.



Voting may very well be based more on deeper narratives that are subscribed to, and be the result of rationalization more than reason. However indirectly it may be stated, MFT contains an unfortunate backdoor suggestion that liberals have a truncated value set. If we are concerned about rationalizations, this should be the first thing to set off alarms.

I'm not sure why, sorry, not clear on how you connect saying liberals and conservatives have value prioritization with a sense of alarm.
 
I'm sure the banks lend it out.

Is the argument at the end of this being that it doesn't matter who owns the money, as long as it's in the bank, it's working?

What does it mean for money to be working? Money is just little green pieces of paper representing credits against federal taxes, at least over here. Actually, they're just electronic records representing those tax credits. Or, more commonly, they're just electronic records of credits against banks whose IOUs the government has decided to accept as credits against taxes.

Work is done by people, not money. If you keep that in mind, you'll be on the road to understanding how the economy and our monetary system really works.
 
Can we get a working definition of 'evil'?

I immediately set off to Ambrose Bierce's The Devil's Dictionary to find your answer. While there is an entry for 'good' there is no entry for 'evil.'

I now find myself wondering if this was intentional...
 
Work is done by people, not money. If you keep that in mind, you'll be on the road to understanding how the economy and our monetary system really works.


I can go much better places than this to be patronised, so you can chuff right off chap.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom