I wonder: how much if this is the result of being unable to save due to the pressures of making a limited income stretch to cover the basis vs being unwilling to save because people want to buy shiny things?
The research shows it's a collapse of 'discretionary spending'. Meaning: the portion of income dedicated to nondiscretionary spending (housing, transportation, groceries) has grown to crowd out discretionary spending. Real estate and (in the USA) medical expenses have grown so much faster than wage inflation they have overwhelmed budgets in that age bracket.
They may, however, be paying down a mortgage, which at least gives them equity.
Yes, the increased percentage of money spent on housing is a big portion of the impact on discretionary spending. The expression here in Canada is "house poor" - meaning, buying a house is a decision to exclude a great deal of consumption. A major contributor to this is that housing costs have increased faster than wage inflation. We're long past the 30% rule.
Just as a concrete example... I live in Vancouver, where average house is about $1.2M, for 25x average income. My parents bought their first house in 1965 - almost identical in size (they lived a few blocks away from where I live now) for $8k, about 1.5x average income.
So, yes, some have equity, but it's a decreasing percentage of the population (down 10% since 2008, and still dropping). Additionally, the properties that are in the affordable price range are of smaller size, which contributes to this generation's perception of reduced standard of living. There is no property in Vancouver of any size priced at 1.5x average income, such as my parents were able to purchase. The rule of thumb in the 1960s was 25% of income was the highest safe housing cost. Today, most of my peers are spending 50-60% of their income on housing. Those who cannot afford the bare minimum are renting instead. Rent has gone up in proportion to property values. That is to say, renters are also seeing their housing costs climb to 50-60% of income, which crowds out more and more discretionary spending. And all that for much smaller properties.
Is this any different from 20-30 year olds from a generation or two ago?
Yes. The personal savings rate in that age bracket in 1969 was 15%, whereas now it's close to zero percent, possibly negative. And most households were on a single income, to boot. And union membership with retirement packages was more common, so the savings rate was padding their existing retirement package. All in all, the boomers have done quite well, versus the segment that followed.
The age bracket that is losing their homes the fastest right now is the 40-50 year age group, believe it or not. They have lost the most from the real estate market crash, as they spent the prior years building up equity and have lost it all, with only a couple of decades left before retirement. This is an important segment politically, IMO. They have jobs, they saved and invested and gave up some discretionary spending, and they feel their efforts to save and invest have not been rewarded by the system, and have despair about their future.
I can't comment on this because I haven't researched the topic enough to come to any conclusion.
The good news is that interest rates are already so low, and any proposed changes so small (+ 0.5% over 2017 would be a surprise) that their impact is trivial at this point anyway.