Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

This is an interesting post, and I will be pursuing the question. Complexity has taken materialism to its logical conclusion - acts have no objective significance. The idea that it is wrong to shoot your neighbour is meaningless.


As usual, we don't agree upon much.

I think that acts are quite significant - they are quite real.

The idea that it is wrong to shoot your neighbor is not meaningless.

The question 'Is it wrong to shoot my neighbor?' does not have a valid answer, an answer that is contingent only upon things that have a truth value, things that are based in reality.

The ideas of right and wrong are an animal construct that humans have inherited and elaborated upon. They have cultural significance and may, in some limited sense, be hardwired into our brains. I suspect that these ideas, and which things fall into either category, are transmitted much more through culture than through genes.

The notions of what falls into the categories of right and wrong have evolved over time and will continue to do so. Science will be able to investigate this aspect of genetic and memetic evolution just as it can every other aspect of genetic and memetic evolution.

Whether one should shoot one's neighbor, and under which circumstances, has practical consequences, may be subject to genetic predisposition, and certainly is subject to cultural influences to which an individual may be susceptible.

It is not meaningless.

It is, however, not well founded and is, in the end, a matter of opinion that should in no way be regarded as the result of sound reasoning from unassailable foundations.


Interestingly, not all the atheists posting here seem to agree with this. I'm not sure why not. No doubt they can tell us.


Atheists don't believe in a god or gods - that is all that we need have in common.
 
Last edited:
An excellent post meg. Thank you.

When faced with a new situation in society, I have far more confidence in someone who will study the problem, think through the possible consequences and risks, and attempt to justify their beliefs about a possible solution than I do in someone who, when faced with a dilemma, just says "I prayed about it, and god said 'no'".

On the other hand, often people must make decisions on which their future depends without access to further knowledge. For example: Should girl A marry boy B or boy C or stay single for a while longer? She can't go to the library and check out a book on which decision will work out best for her. The best she can do is reflect on her knowledge of herself and the other people in her life. Prayer is a wonderful way to meditate and reflect on the problem. It allows you to talk it over between the various voices in your head and decide which path to take.

Don't dismiss prayers just because god doesn't actually intervene. Prayer has it's benefits without any supernatural results.
 
Don't dismiss prayers just because god doesn't actually intervene. Prayer has it's benefits without any supernatural results.

Not on any part out of the universe outside of the person's head it doesn't. And, if you actually do derive some strange benefit from engaging in a lie, that's quite sad.
 
I've had it for a while. Glad you like it.

:)

Now that you mention it, I think I may have read it before, but failed to appreciate it fully amidst others distractions...

or perhaps I was just distracted by the handsome Alan Turing avatar.

I can't imagine what you might be whispering to woos, but I'm sure it makes them paranoid even if it doesn't "tame" them.
 
Last edited:
Lets run through the list, shall we?

  • Misunderstanding the burden of proof.
  • Special pleading fallacy.
  • Strawman fallacy.
  • Claim that a belief is fine and dandy because it has no evidence to support it.

Yep, it ticks all the boxes! I proclaim the OP a...

funny-pictures-bird-window-fail.jpg
 
Last edited:
So presumably the question "should I shoot that guy next door playing his stereo too loud" has no valid answer?

Bingo. The answer to that question may well differ if evaluated in a number of different moral systems. Which moral decision we use is, for all intents and purposes, arbitrary: If we had a system that told us which moral system we should use, then that system would itself be a moral system, and we would be begging the question.

In reality, the moral systems that people adopt are based around what they value: Themselves; Society as a whole; Pleasure; Art, and so on. People who have moral systems that clash with society as a whole tend to be selected out - they wind up in jail, or ostracised by society. It may well be that we can evaluate different moral systems to determine which system produces the best functioning society (ironically, such a thing would be studied via the scientific method), but even if we were to determine what the 'best' moral system is, the decision to adopt it would still be essentially arbitrary.

---------------------​

PS: Scientism is still a silly word. I don't care if it has a wikipedia page.Ayurvedic medicine has a wikipedia page, but that doesn't stop it from being silly.
 
Last edited:
Actually scientists have tested it out... it's called game theory... it works in other social animals besides humans... what behavior maximizes the outcome for the most players?-- start out kind/trusting... and then respond in "tat for tat" fashion to ensure cooperation and trust and to punish cheaters (social shunning, etc.) basic "reciprocity"-- it's a very simple algorithm and we even understand some of the feedback loops involved... it works really great for trade and things like E-bay and netiquette... it's a nice easy algorithm...

Whether in games like the "prisoner's dilemma" or life... this is the "winningest" strategy for the most people... those who have this basic strategy are more likely to pass on genes encoding for this basic strategy. Sure, we codify it and put it into words and stories and religions and laws-- but it has evolved in other species too without the language to tell themselves why they are behaving as they do.

Would theists be killing people willy nilly if not for the invisible spy in the sky? Are they serious when they posit this scenario? They refrain from killing people and doing harm because they are trying to win heaven bonus points or stay our of hell or please the invisible man??? I hope that isn't true. We nonbelievers manage all that morality without the threats or promises. I think they really believe that they get their morality from god-- they are taught that everything good comes from god and so they get their thinking all twisted... but that makes them rather immoral from my perspective... or rather the have little kid morality... basic Skinner responses. "I get presents when I'm good; and punishment when I'm bad."

I am always so embarrassed when theists talk this way. I hope one day they become atheists and realize how ... childish they sounded and how bizarrely they viewed atheism.

"It's wrong to kill people because god said so." Isn't that what they are saying?

Why do even small kids know not to pull cat's tails even though god never mentions such in the bible? Or is god whispering in kids' ears with Satan on the other shoulder like in the cartoons?

Gee, westprog, how do you get your engrams cleared when you aren't a Scientologist?-- Don't you know you'd be a lot more happy and successful like Tom Cruise? Doesn't your lack of belief in Scientology explain the problems of your mind and your low level of operating thetan? Do you think you sound more logical than that?

If they could only hear how they sound-- I suspect they could "hear" the density, humor, and irony, if it was being written from a woo they didn't subscribe to. But when it comes to their sacred woo, they are blind.
 
Last edited:
Why do even small kids know not to pull cat's tails even though god never mentions such in the bible? Or is god whispering in kids' ears with Satan on the other shoulder like in the cartoons?

You must not have kids.

Sorry, articulett. I think you should drop that particular argument. That one is just plain false.

Loved the rest of the post though :)
 
Who is this mythical "they" to which the OP refers to because while I wish some of my more militant fellow atheists would give religious skeptics a confrontational break on the religion issue if they're not raving fundy lunatics.. it's a myth that skepticism "exempts" religion from skeptical scrutiny.
 
Of course there's a correct answer to the question "can/should i shoot my neighbour if he annoys me?"...the answer is NO!

I'm basing this opinion on self interest ( as was mentioned above ) because i no more want my neighbour to shoot me if I annoy him, and let's face it, sometimes I can be annoying:D.

I've never really had a problem with my being an atheist and morality. I'm not even fussed about a lot of Christian moral ideals. For instance, the ten commandments make sense on a *let's organise a group of people into a society where we can all be productive and lead reasonable lives* kind of way, likewise, the seven deadly sins ( excepting the pride one here, because it's strictly a faith issue ) suggest a recipe for clean living.

Having said that, though, I'm a pretty boring guy, who's never really run afoul of the Christian moral ideals. I can covet my neighbours wife, but i have the sense not to act on it. Not because I fear my neighbour will shoot me, or I'll burn in hell, but because, I don't expect my neighbour to covet my wife and act on it either.

If i was gay I'd sure have a reason to be anti-Christian, likewise if I were raised in an oppressive Christian household, I may formulate reasons to reject "the teachings" on a wholesale basis.

The thing I have the most trouble with is Christians demanding respect for their silly beliefs. A few weeks ago, over on another forum, I noticed a Christian "taking offense" at a few posts other posters had made regarding God. One was a simple cartoon of God sitting in front of a computer, designing the world. This, the Christian found "rude".

The second was a teenager relating "some story" about how the universe was created by God sitting around bored and lonely, masturbation, and his resulting ejaculate created what we see as the universe. The Christian...freaked. I found this odd seeing as how the masturbation story was presented as being a native American story ( Google left me high and dry on this one ) and if that were true, then obviously it's a different "God" ie, not the Christian one, being referred to here.

I posted something about the Catholic church ( this Christian is a Catholic ) being unable to take a firm stance regarding creation/evolution, IIRC i called it a "have your cake and eat it too" philosophy. The Christian went ballistic, accusing me of defamation...yadayada and demanded that I never speak to her again.

Oh well.

I really don't have any defense against this sort of behaviour. Other than condescension and given the particular nature of that forum, I thought it best to just let it go, giving the Christian the impression that she "won" and her morals and views are some how more important ( sacred ) than mine.

Interestingly, this same poster was raving about how the movie Boondock Saints was a "good" movie because "it brought people together" Yikes....

For those of you who haven't seen the movie, the basic premise is...a few brothers get drunk, thrown in jail, where they meet "God" who gives them special permission to be vigilantes. Hey....murder's alright, when God says so.

So in certain circumstances I'll give the skeptic thing a rest ( in the name of peace ) and let the believers have their say, all the while, congratulating myself on my restraint :)
 
You must not have kids.

Sorry, articulett. I think you should drop that particular argument. That one is just plain false.

Loved the rest of the post though :)

I have one ( a kid) he learned through "natural consequence" and was able to extrapolate to other sentient beings... you don't do things that can hurt other things... some hurt you back... eventually empathy kicks in. My son is fantastic with animals; it's a joy for me that he adores them as I do. But even toddlers show empathy... mirror neurons... they get upset when others are upset... the show delight when other giggle... I believe my son at 3 told me that the cat was his sister... and then later decided he might marry her. By 4 he was into humans, but found it great fun to see how assorted pets reacted to bows from presents stuck on them. Much hilarity ensued. Predictions were made based on species and body part adorned.
We felt slightly guilty, but then decided that our pets should earn their keep by amusing us. They have been stellar at the task, I might add.

We evolved to "feel" what is going on in the creatures around us... it's why we like drama and movies and stories... Moral choices such as those explored by Marc Hauser (google if you are interested) tend to be the same across cultures and religions and non religion... we have an aversion to killing other people... religion or seeing others as evil can over ride this instinct. Seeing people as "other" allows people to do harm without guilt. Also, there's an area of the brain that can be damaged so that people don't have these feelings or instincts associated with conscience--

What we think of as good and bad tend to be decisions made in the same part of our brain as emotions for joy and revulsion...

The stirrings of morality emerge early in childhood. Toddlers spontaneously offer toys and help to others and try to comfort people they see in distress. And according to the psychologists Elliot Turiel and Judith Smetana, preschoolers have an inkling of the difference between societal conventions and moral principles. Four-year-olds say that it is not O.K. to wear pajamas to school (a convention) and also not O.K. to hit a little girl for no reason (a moral principle). But when asked whether these actions would be O.K. if the teacher allowed them, most of the children said that wearing pajamas would now be fine but that hitting a little girl would still not be.

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/13/magazine/13Psychology-t.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all&oref=slogin
reprinted here: http://www.infidelguy.com/article191.html

The argument isn't false... it's backed up by lots of evidence... morality evolves-- culture merely hones and codifies it... just like language. We evolve to communicate... the language we speak is programmed by culture and evolves just like everything else.

We evolved to fit into our culture; religion has evolved to hijack that programming the way a venereal disease has hijacked the human sex drive to spread itself as far as I'm concerned.
 
Last edited:
Actually scientists have tested it out... it's called game theory... it works in other social animals besides humans... what behavior maximizes the outcome for the most players?-- start out kind/trusting... and then respond in "tat for tat" fashion to ensure cooperation and trust and to punish cheaters (social shunning, etc.) basic "reciprocity"-- it's a very simple algorithm and we even understand some of the feedback loops involved... it works really great for trade and things like E-bay and netiquette... it's a nice easy algorithm...

And of course, game theory works best for you when you are the only person to break the kind and trusting method.

Whether in games like the "prisoner's dilemma" or life... this is the "winningest" strategy for the most people... those who have this basic strategy are more likely to pass on genes encoding for this basic strategy. Sure, we codify it and put it into words and stories and religions and laws-- but it has evolved in other species too without the language to tell themselves why they are behaving as they do.

Would theists be killing people willy nilly if not for the invisible spy in the sky?

Would athiests be killing people willy nilly if a theory could be found that showed it was a winning strategy? Because sometimes it has been a winning strategy.

Clearly Articulett knows better than I do why I do things - but I think that I avoid doing bad things because they are actually wrong. Really wrong, not a bad strategy. Not because God will punish me - because, after all, I could always repent later, right?

Articulett seems to regard not injuring other people because it's a bad strategy as being a superior reason to not injuring other people because it's wrong. I wonder if I could persuade her to enlarge on that.
 
westprog - You deliberately misrepresent and warp what people say.

I suppose you do believe the end justifies the means.

Yuck.
 
Articulett seems to regard not injuring other people because it's a bad strategy as being a superior reason to not injuring other people because it's wrong. I wonder if I could persuade her to enlarge on that.

I had this conversation, or one like it, when my children were approaching their teen years. At the time, all of us were Christians.

They were both rapidly approaching the age when they'd start wanting to have sex, so we discussed it, among other things. It was, as I recall, a fairly long discussion. I'll condense and paraphrase.

I told them that, as Christians, we believed sexual intercourse outside of marriage was wrong. I asked them why they thought that might be so.

I was told: because God says so; because it's in the bible; because it's a sin.

Nothing else? I asked. I received blank looks for a moment, until one of them suggested: because you might get the girl pregnant. Very good. Anything else? Oh, one said: you might get a disease, like AIDS. That's true. What else?

We went on in this vein for a time, discussing all the things that could go wrong in any relationship, and what adding sex to that mix could do. By the end of it, they both understood that there were actually some pretty sound reasons for waiting a while to start having sex. That the sole reason wasn't just because their religion said it was "a sin."

The conversation then took that turn: is something wrong just because someone says it's a sin? Not just premarital sex, but anything they thought of as being a sin. Did it also have legitimate reasons that made it a bad idea, no matter what it was?

At the end of that, they understood that saying "this act is wrong, because it's a sin," was a pretty stupid reason. They should be thinking in opposite terms: "this act is a sin, because it's wrong." We defined "wrong" as being words and deeds that could hurt people, including yourself.

In the end, we concluded that "right and wrong" did not depend on what the bible or religion taught you. It depended on reason and empathy.

So, if someone says to you, "Don't do that; it's wrong," respond to them with "Why is it wrong?" And if they come back with "Because it's a sin," you'll know you are talking to someone who doesn't know how to use the brains god supposedly gave him.

My sons, now grown, have better than average moral compasses. One is agnostic, and one is Christian. And just so you know, we all get along just fine, thanks. :D
 
And of course, game theory works best for you when you are the only person to break the kind and trusting method.



Would athiests be killing people willy nilly if a theory could be found that showed it was a winning strategy? Because sometimes it has been a winning strategy.

Clearly Articulett knows better than I do why I do things - but I think that I avoid doing bad things because they are actually wrong. Really wrong, not a bad strategy. Not because God will punish me - because, after all, I could always repent later, right?

Articulett seems to regard not injuring other people because it's a bad strategy as being a superior reason to not injuring other people because it's wrong. I wonder if I could persuade her to enlarge on that.

If she sees it, I doubt you could prevent her from posting a long diatribe about how stupid people are if they believe that god might possibly exist. Of course, it will only tangentially touch upon the subject you requested. I was going to quote this so she'd see it, but then I remembered she has me on ignore too so it won't help you. So I'll just take this opportunity to thank you for a great series of posts and threads. I'm quite enjoying reading through them. Thanks and keep em up please.
 
Last edited:
westprog - You deliberately misrepresent and warp what people say.

I suppose you do believe the end justifies the means.

Yuck.

No, Compo, I'm trying to tease out exactly what you think, and getting you to address the implications of what you say. And if you want to qualify an earlier observation, I won't keep quoting your previous position back at you, I'll accept your new position and let you argue that. And if you change your mind, I'll take that as a sign of maturity, not something to jeer about. Because that is how adults engage in intellectual dispute.

Or I might just post a big picture of a monkey. Depends how I'm feeling.

Do not change someone's username. Stick to the argument.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom