Complexity
Philosopher
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2005
- Messages
- 9,242
This is an interesting post, and I will be pursuing the question. Complexity has taken materialism to its logical conclusion - acts have no objective significance. The idea that it is wrong to shoot your neighbour is meaningless.
As usual, we don't agree upon much.
I think that acts are quite significant - they are quite real.
The idea that it is wrong to shoot your neighbor is not meaningless.
The question 'Is it wrong to shoot my neighbor?' does not have a valid answer, an answer that is contingent only upon things that have a truth value, things that are based in reality.
The ideas of right and wrong are an animal construct that humans have inherited and elaborated upon. They have cultural significance and may, in some limited sense, be hardwired into our brains. I suspect that these ideas, and which things fall into either category, are transmitted much more through culture than through genes.
The notions of what falls into the categories of right and wrong have evolved over time and will continue to do so. Science will be able to investigate this aspect of genetic and memetic evolution just as it can every other aspect of genetic and memetic evolution.
Whether one should shoot one's neighbor, and under which circumstances, has practical consequences, may be subject to genetic predisposition, and certainly is subject to cultural influences to which an individual may be susceptible.
It is not meaningless.
It is, however, not well founded and is, in the end, a matter of opinion that should in no way be regarded as the result of sound reasoning from unassailable foundations.
Interestingly, not all the atheists posting here seem to agree with this. I'm not sure why not. No doubt they can tell us.
Atheists don't believe in a god or gods - that is all that we need have in common.
Last edited: