Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

In any case, there are plenty of Christians for whom the virgin birth is of no great significance.

Gee, the whole being the son of god thing is sort of central to Christianity.

In any case, digging up Jesus would have far more significance than finding out his parentage.

Yeah, it would prove he didn't ascend bodily into Heaven.
 
Last edited:
Gee, the whole being the son of god thing is sort of central to Christianity.

If he existed, his Y chromosome would be of great interest to scientists. What does an almighty Y chromosome look like? (And if we are all gods children, then what makes Jesus so special?-- it seems like someone got some exalted DNA from somewhere, eh? You do have to wonder about a deity that impregnates a virgin and then tells her about it after the fact, though.)
 
I was going to reply to this (and many others along the same lines) on the "coddle" thread, but that seems to have run off in all directions, and I wanted to deal with this specific point.

Let's first consider how a skeptic should approach the specific claims of, say, homeopathy. What is his approach? How does he deal with the issue?

It's fairly obvious. He deals with the science. He examines the scientific theory behind homeopathy, and finds that it's gibberish. He then examines the experimental evidence, and finds that all the double blind tests fail. It's fairly straightforward.

How does a skeptic then deal with the claims of religion? Well, when it's a claim like "The Earth is six thousand years old and all species were created independently" he follows exactly the same strategy. The claim is in the realm of science, and it is rebutted scientifically.

But what about the claim that the universe was created by an omnipotent, omniscient being? How should that claim be dealt with? Let's go to the science. What do the textbooks say? Nothing. Shelf after shelf on physics and cosmology have nothing to say about God. No physicist has claimed to have demonstrated the non-existence of God. Many physicists don't believe that a God exists. However, many do, and they seem to be doing exactly the same physics. I don't think the same could be said for biologists who believe in homeopathy.

So the skeptic has to move to another section of the library altogether. He can look in Philosophy, and he'll find plenty of stuff there. Neitzche will tell him that God is dead. He can make the arguments accordingly.

But what about the atheists who claim that the arguments are the same? They claim that rather than advancing a philosophical point of view, they are arging scientifically? They are doing exactly what the creationists do - conflating religion and science in a way designed to cause confusion.

By your own argument, homeopathy is more legitimate than "God". At least the homeopaths pretend that their claims can be tested in a lab, and confirmed by evidence. Theists, on the other hand, can only make completely unfounded assertions, not even pretend to back up their claims, and stupidly say "prove me wrong" over and over until people give up trying to correct their fallacy... and then claim that as a victory of their fairy-tale worldview.
 
You do have to wonder about a deity that impregnates a virgin and then tells her about it after the fact, though.)

It's somewhat more disturbing when you consider the Catholic dogma that Mary was the Immaculate Conception - convinced without sin for the express purpose of later being the mother of Christ.

A god who manipulates a fetus just so that he can later impregnate her when she is a teenager without even asking her permission is. . .sick.
 
Last edited:
I was raised Catholic... I remember asking what "round yon virgin" meant from Silent Night... and what did it mean: the "virgin" Mary. I was told it meant "pure".

And then later I figured out the sex stuff but I heard that Mary, herself, was immaculately conceived because something or other about original sin and yada, yada, yada. You're right. God is one sick bastard.

Killing your kid because someone else bit from the "tree of knowledge" and now there has to be a blood sacrifice because your plan was messed up? That test of Abraham where he asks him to kill Isaac? Stoning people? Foreskins of philistines? Killing fatted calves for the prodigal son? Plagues?

Religion never made any sense to me... even when I was young, guilt ridden, and gullible.

I was always much more moral than the invisible god I was supposed to believe in, it seems.
 
Complexity, I think that's backwards.

Science, to advance, requires reasoning to ask the next question, take the next step, form the next hypothesis, design the next experiment, come to conclusions, test and or confirm them, and thus advance science to the next state.

It seems to me more correct to say "science can advance no farther than reason allows" but we may not be talking about the same thing.

DR


Reason is one of the most important tools that science uses.

My remark was intended to contradict the suggestion that reason, being carried out apart from the context of science, can arrive at discoveries about reality that science can not address - that philosophy can achieve what science can not.

Science is how we learn about reality. Our best models of reality - our best understanding of how the world works and how it will work - are constructed through science.

Anything that we imagine or dream of, whether born of whimsy or years of careful reason, can be admitted to the collection of ideas that we hold to be 'true' only by being tested against the touchstone of science. Even then, its admission is provisional and it remains subject to retesting and reconsideration as long as we endure.

Reasoning, creative leaps, gut feelings, irrational associations, imagination - all can lead to ideas that can contribute to scientific advances and, thereby, improvements in our understanding of reality.

If they remain untested, however, if they are not subjected to the intense skeptical scrutiny and tested against our best understanding of reality, if they are not subjected to science, no claim regarding their truthfulness or accuracy should be made.
 
So presumably the question "should I shoot that guy next door playing his stereo too loud" has no valid answer?


No, it does not.

How you would answer that question is contingent upon the set of beliefs that you hold and the machinery for decision making that you happen to have installed. Those beliefs have nothing to do with what is true.

Your answer will not be founded upon moral absolutes, for there are none, but rather on received values and those that you've happened upon as you've gotten to this point in your life.

You may think that your beliefs are founded upon moral absolutes, but you'd be wrong.

Personally, I'm usually inclined to shoot the bastard, for I really don't like inconsiderate people, but I have yet to act on that impulse.

This is one reason I don't have a gun.
 
Last edited:
Plus dead people stink, and who knows what your next new neighbor will be like, and there's those damn legal consequences.

(Would theists be raping and killing willy nilly without the invisible man in the sky watching them every second... maybe we ought to encourage their belief? Maybe theists really do need to believe in god to be moral... the rest of us can manage fine without the delusion-- heck, even our pets can.)
 
Last edited:
Reason is one of the most important tools that science uses.

My remark was intended to contradict the suggestion that reason, being carried out apart from the context of science, can arrive at discoveries about reality that science can not address - that philosophy can achieve what science can not.

Science is how we learn about reality. Our best models of reality - our best understanding of how the world works and how it will work - are constructed through science.

Anything that we imagine or dream of, whether born of whimsy or years of careful reason, can be admitted to the collection of ideas that we hold to be 'true' only by being tested against the touchstone of science. Even then, its admission is provisional and it remains subject to retesting and reconsideration as long as we endure.

Reasoning, creative leaps, gut feelings, irrational associations, imagination - all can lead to ideas that can contribute to scientific advances and, thereby, improvements in our understanding of reality.

If they remain untested, however, if they are not subjected to the intense skeptical scrutiny and tested against our best understanding of reality, if they are not subjected to science, no claim regarding their truthfulness or accuracy should be made.


Then I think you misunderstood what I was saying. What I said was "Science cannot determine a person's morality or ethics, but reason can,- or should."

One's morality and ethics are not only a reflection of how you think the world works, but how you think you should behave in it, something that I don't think science will ever be able to tell us.

While we can use science to help us achieve our goals, for instance to figure out how to feed the world, we cannot use it to decide whether we should feed everyone. We have to use reason for that.
 
Then I think you misunderstood what I was saying. What I said was "Science cannot determine a person's morality or ethics, but reason can,- or should."

One's morality and ethics are not only a reflection of how you think the world works, but how you think you should behave in it, something that I don't think science will ever be able to tell us.

While we can use science to help us achieve our goals, for instance to figure out how to feed the world, we cannot use it to decide whether we should feed everyone. We have to use reason for that.


My point is that questions like 'should we feed everyone' do not have any valid answers. Reason all you like, your reasoning is not well-founded and your conclusions will be without value.

I have opinions on many of these questions, and I try to act according to those opinions, but I also try to remember that my opinions are just that - opinions, rather than truth.

I do the best I can with what I've got.
 
Last edited:
I think we agree more than we disagree, here, really.

I think while questions like 'should we feed everyone' might not have a yes or no "proven" answer, there are many valid answers based on reasoning, stemming from tentatively accepted moral theories and philosophies.

For instance, if we accept the notion that every human is entitled to a fundamental right to life, we may feel compelled to act when we see a nation is starving.

If, on the other hand, we have strong belief in self-determination, we might not feel a need to interfere.

The reality, for most of us, is somewhere in between.

The point I was trying to make is that I believe it is far better to acknowledge (and even acclaim, perhaps) our own reasoning in determination of our moral philosophies, which keeps them open to criticism and change, than it is to pretend (as some here do) that our morals have been determined by some other higher power, which leaves them static and less able to change to solve new problems we encounter in our society.

When faced with a new situation in society, I have far more confidence in someone who will study the problem, think through the possible consequences and risks, and attempt to justify their beliefs about a possible solution than I do in someone who, when faced with a dilemma, just says "I prayed about it, and god said 'no'".
 
:My remark was intended to contradict the suggestion that reason, being carried out apart from the context of science, can arrive at discoveries about reality that science can not address - that philosophy can achieve what science can not.
.
Ask Aristotle how many teeth Mrs. Aristotle has. He'd say "Fewer than I do."
He reasoned it out. Women are inferior in every way to men, ergo, fewer teeth.
Reality says... they have the same number. Open wide, start at the right bottom....
But that was too messy for A. who wasn't in to actually verifying things like that.
 
By your own argument, homeopathy is more legitimate than "God". At least the homeopaths pretend that their claims can be tested in a lab, and confirmed by evidence. Theists, on the other hand, can only make completely unfounded assertions, not even pretend to back up their claims, and stupidly say "prove me wrong" over and over until people give up trying to correct their fallacy... and then claim that as a victory of their fairy-tale worldview.

So a belief that has been disproven is superior to a belief that is not capable of proof or disproof? Cool.
 
No, it does not.

How you would answer that question is contingent upon the set of beliefs that you hold and the machinery for decision making that you happen to have installed. Those beliefs have nothing to do with what is true.

Your answer will not be founded upon moral absolutes, for there are none, but rather on received values and those that you've happened upon as you've gotten to this point in your life.

You may think that your beliefs are founded upon moral absolutes, but you'd be wrong.

Personally, I'm usually inclined to shoot the bastard, for I really don't like inconsiderate people, but I have yet to act on that impulse.

This is one reason I don't have a gun.

This is an interesting post, and I will be pursuing the question. Complexity has taken materialism to its logical conclusion - acts have no objective significance. The idea that it is wrong to shoot your neighbour is meaningless.

Interestingly, not all the atheists posting here seem to agree with this. I'm not sure why not. No doubt they can tell us.

I can turn
And walk away
Or I can fire the gun
Staring at the sky
Staring at the sun
Whichever I chose
It amounts to the same










Absolutely nothing
 
I think we agree more than we disagree, here, really.

I think while questions like 'should we feed everyone' might not have a yes or no "proven" answer, there are many valid answers based on reasoning, stemming from tentatively accepted moral theories and philosophies.

For instance, if we accept the notion that every human is entitled to a fundamental right to life, we may feel compelled to act when we see a nation is starving.

If, on the other hand, we have strong belief in self-determination, we might not feel a need to interfere.

The reality, for most of us, is somewhere in between.

The point I was trying to make is that I believe it is far better to acknowledge (and even acclaim, perhaps) our own reasoning in determination of our moral philosophies, which keeps them open to criticism and change, than it is to pretend (as some here do) that our morals have been determined by some other higher power, which leaves them static and less able to change to solve new problems we encounter in our society.

When faced with a new situation in society, I have far more confidence in someone who will study the problem, think through the possible consequences and risks, and attempt to justify their beliefs about a possible solution than I do in someone who, when faced with a dilemma, just says "I prayed about it, and god said 'no'".


Well, here's what I believe - as I haven't stated it before. I believe that right and wrong are as meaningfull as matter and energy. If you don't believe this - and clearly some of the posters don't - then on what are your moral philosophies based?

And if you do believe it - where do those moral values come from?
 
Well, here's what I believe - as I haven't stated it before. I believe that right and wrong are as meaningfull as matter and energy. If you don't believe this - and clearly some of the posters don't - then on what are your moral philosophies based?

And if you do believe it - where do those moral values come from?

Oh, I know the answer to this one!! Moral values come from an invisible sky daddy who no one has ever seen, except for sheepherders 3-4000 years ago, and is really real, unlike the invisible sky daddies of all the other ignorant tribes of ancient people!

Boy, when you put it that way... theists are sort of willfully stupid when it comes to religion. GIANT blind spot!
 
Complexity has taken materialism to its logical conclusion - acts have no objective significance. The idea that it is wrong to shoot your neighbour is meaningless.
The conclusion you've come to is stupid, and also dangerously close to dishonest. "Lack of objective significance" is not the same as "meaningless". When you start actually thinking about things with a little objectivity yourself, you might have a chance of understanding what people say to you.
 
I think we agree more than we disagree, here, really.


I think we do agree on a lot.


I think while questions like 'should we feed everyone' might not have a yes or no "proven" answer, there are many valid answers based on reasoning, stemming from tentatively accepted moral theories and philosophies.


Here I must disagree. It is precisely because they are based upon moral theories and philosophies that can have no foundation that they do not have valid answers - answers to these questions are contingent on assumptions that are not well founded.

Your reasoning flows like this: 'If X and Y are true, then Z is true.' Your statement may even be a true one. However, since X and Y can not be shown to be true, your statement is of limited use.

What you can do is say that you believe that X and Y are true, that you are going to act as though X and Y are true, and that you are going to tentatively admit Z to the things that you believe and will act upon.

This is an honest statement - you state your beliefs and your intent to act upon those beliefs.

Do not go beyond that, though - don't say that X and Y are true, don't expect anyone else to agree with your beliefs, and always be open to the possibility that your beliefs are wrong.

In short, there are no valid answers to these questions, there are only answers that are contingent upon your beliefs.


For instance, if we accept the notion that every human is entitled to a fundamental right to life, we may feel compelled to act when we see a nation is starving.

If, on the other hand, we have strong belief in self-determination, we might not feel a need to interfere.

The reality, for most of us, is somewhere in between.


You are making my point for me - "if we accept the notion...", "If, on the other hand, we have a strong belief in...".

The key, I think, is trying to understand the lack of foundation in our values judgements and being humble and open to the possibility that we are wrong.


The point I was trying to make is that I believe it is far better to acknowledge (and even acclaim, perhaps) our own reasoning in determination of our moral philosophies, which keeps them open to criticism and change, than it is to pretend (as some here do) that our morals have been determined by some other higher power, which leaves them static and less able to change to solve new problems we encounter in our society.


I absolutely agree with this statement.


When faced with a new situation in society, I have far more confidence in someone who will study the problem, think through the possible consequences and risks, and attempt to justify their beliefs about a possible solution than I do in someone who, when faced with a dilemma, just says "I prayed about it, and god said 'no'".


I absolutely agree with this statement.

I love what I understand of mathematics.

One of the things that I love about mathematics is the clarity which it demands.

There is no uncontingent truth in mathematics - there is nothing in mathematics that is true without requiring that other things be true.

Mathematics is the study of consequences. These consequences flow from the asserted core of a system - a set of statements that are assumed to be true. Without these axioms, there is no system, and there are no consequences.

Clarity and success in mathematics requires the clear identification and understanding of what is given, what is assumed to be true.

I think that the same is true with the rest of life. It is important to understand the assumptions that underlie our systems of thought, especially our moral and ethical systems, and to understand that their fruits can be no better than their roots.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom